id sid tid token lemma pos istl-2446 1 1 the the DET istl-2446 1 2 american american PROPN istl-2446 1 3 chemical chemical PROPN istl-2446 1 4 society society NOUN istl-2446 1 5 and and CCONJ istl-2446 1 6 open open ADJ istl-2446 1 7 access access NOUN istl-2446 1 8 previous previous ADJ istl-2446 1 9     SPACE istl-2446 1 10 contents content NOUN istl-2446 1 11     SPACE istl-2446 1 12 next next ADJ istl-2446 1 13 issues issue NOUN istl-2446 1 14 in in ADP istl-2446 1 15 science science NOUN istl-2446 1 16 and and CCONJ istl-2446 1 17 technology technology NOUN istl-2446 1 18 librarianship librarianship NOUN istl-2446 1 19 winter winter NOUN istl-2446 1 20 2008 2008 NUM istl-2446 1 21 doi:10.5062 doi:10.5062 NOUN istl-2446 1 22 / / SYM istl-2446 1 23 f4h70crk f4h70crk SPACE istl-2446 2 1 urls url NOUN istl-2446 2 2 in in ADP istl-2446 2 3 this this DET istl-2446 2 4 document document NOUN istl-2446 2 5 have have AUX istl-2446 2 6 been be AUX istl-2446 2 7 updated update VERB istl-2446 2 8 . . PUNCT istl-2446 3 1 links link NOUN istl-2446 3 2 enclosed enclose VERB istl-2446 3 3 in in ADP istl-2446 3 4 { { PUNCT istl-2446 3 5 curly curly ADJ istl-2446 3 6 brackets bracket NOUN istl-2446 3 7 } } PUNCT istl-2446 3 8 have have AUX istl-2446 3 9 been be AUX istl-2446 3 10 changed change VERB istl-2446 3 11 . . PUNCT istl-2446 4 1 if if SCONJ istl-2446 4 2 a a DET istl-2446 4 3 replacement replacement NOUN istl-2446 4 4 link link NOUN istl-2446 4 5 was be AUX istl-2446 4 6 located locate VERB istl-2446 4 7 , , PUNCT istl-2446 4 8 the the DET istl-2446 4 9 new new ADJ istl-2446 4 10 url url NOUN istl-2446 4 11 was be AUX istl-2446 4 12 added add VERB istl-2446 4 13 and and CCONJ istl-2446 4 14 the the DET istl-2446 4 15 link link NOUN istl-2446 4 16 is be AUX istl-2446 4 17 active active ADJ istl-2446 4 18 ; ; PUNCT istl-2446 4 19 if if SCONJ istl-2446 4 20 a a DET istl-2446 4 21 new new ADJ istl-2446 4 22 site site NOUN istl-2446 4 23 could could AUX istl-2446 4 24 not not PART istl-2446 4 25 be be AUX istl-2446 4 26 identified identify VERB istl-2446 4 27 , , PUNCT istl-2446 4 28 the the DET istl-2446 4 29 broken broken ADJ istl-2446 4 30 link link NOUN istl-2446 4 31 was be AUX istl-2446 4 32 removed remove VERB istl-2446 4 33 . . PUNCT istl-2446 5 1 viewpoints viewpoint VERB istl-2446 5 2 the the DET istl-2446 5 3 american american PROPN istl-2446 5 4 chemical chemical PROPN istl-2446 5 5 society society NOUN istl-2446 5 6 and and CCONJ istl-2446 5 7 open open ADJ istl-2446 5 8 access access NOUN istl-2446 5 9 bob bob PROPN istl-2446 5 10 michaelson michaelson PROPN istl-2446 5 11 seeley seeley PROPN istl-2446 5 12 g. g. PROPN istl-2446 5 13 mudd mudd PROPN istl-2446 5 14 library library PROPN istl-2446 5 15 for for ADP istl-2446 5 16 science science NOUN istl-2446 5 17 and and CCONJ istl-2446 5 18 engineering engineering NOUN istl-2446 5 19 northwestern northwestern ADJ istl-2446 5 20 university university NOUN istl-2446 5 21 rmichael@northwestern.edu rmichael@northwestern.edu VERB istl-2446 5 22 copyright copyright NOUN istl-2446 5 23 2008 2008 NUM istl-2446 5 24 , , PUNCT istl-2446 5 25 bob bob PROPN istl-2446 5 26 michaelson michaelson PROPN istl-2446 5 27 . . PUNCT istl-2446 6 1 used use VERB istl-2446 6 2 with with ADP istl-2446 6 3 permission permission NOUN istl-2446 6 4 . . PUNCT istl-2446 7 1 " " PUNCT istl-2446 7 2 open open ADJ istl-2446 7 3 access access NOUN istl-2446 7 4 publishing publishing NOUN istl-2446 7 5 " " PUNCT istl-2446 7 6 can can AUX istl-2446 7 7 mean mean VERB istl-2446 7 8 many many ADJ istl-2446 7 9 things thing NOUN istl-2446 7 10 ( ( PUNCT istl-2446 7 11 see see VERB istl-2446 7 12 e.g. e.g. ADV istl-2446 7 13 { { PUNCT istl-2446 7 14 http://web.archive.org/web/20110718164239/http://www.escholarlypub.com/oab/oab.pdf http://web.archive.org/web/20110718164239/http://www.escholarlypub.com/oab/oab.pdf ADJ istl-2446 7 15 } } PUNCT istl-2446 7 16 pp pp PROPN istl-2446 7 17 . . PUNCT istl-2446 8 1 xi xi PROPN istl-2446 8 2 - - PUNCT istl-2446 8 3 xii xii PROPN istl-2446 8 4 ) ) PUNCT istl-2446 9 1 and and CCONJ istl-2446 9 2 it it PRON istl-2446 9 3 is be AUX istl-2446 9 4 not not PART istl-2446 9 5 yet yet ADV istl-2446 9 6 clear clear ADJ istl-2446 9 7 how how SCONJ istl-2446 9 8 open open ADJ istl-2446 9 9 access access NOUN istl-2446 9 10 ( ( PUNCT istl-2446 9 11 oa oa NOUN istl-2446 9 12 ) ) PUNCT istl-2446 9 13 publishing publishing NOUN istl-2446 9 14 may may AUX istl-2446 9 15 find find VERB istl-2446 9 16 a a DET istl-2446 9 17 sustainable sustainable ADJ istl-2446 9 18 business business NOUN istl-2446 9 19 model model NOUN istl-2446 9 20 . . PUNCT istl-2446 9 21     SPACE istl-2446 10 1 nonetheless nonetheless ADV istl-2446 10 2 , , PUNCT istl-2446 10 3 oa oa PRON istl-2446 10 4 is be AUX istl-2446 10 5 already already ADV istl-2446 10 6 important important ADJ istl-2446 10 7 for for ADP istl-2446 10 8 scholarly scholarly ADJ istl-2446 10 9 communication communication NOUN istl-2446 10 10 , , PUNCT istl-2446 10 11 and and CCONJ istl-2446 10 12 seems seem VERB istl-2446 10 13 certain certain ADJ istl-2446 10 14 to to PART istl-2446 10 15 become become VERB istl-2446 10 16 more more ADV istl-2446 10 17 so so ADV istl-2446 10 18 , , PUNCT istl-2446 10 19 as as SCONJ istl-2446 10 20 demonstrated demonstrate VERB istl-2446 10 21 for for ADP istl-2446 10 22 example example NOUN istl-2446 10 23 by by ADP istl-2446 10 24 the the DET istl-2446 10 25 recent recent ADJ istl-2446 10 26 vote vote NOUN istl-2446 10 27 of of ADP istl-2446 10 28 the the DET istl-2446 10 29 harvard harvard PROPN istl-2446 10 30 faculty faculty NOUN istl-2446 10 31 . . PUNCT istl-2446 11 1 we we PRON istl-2446 11 2 must must AUX istl-2446 11 3 therefore therefore ADV istl-2446 11 4 sustain sustain VERB istl-2446 11 5 a a DET istl-2446 11 6 serious serious ADJ istl-2446 11 7 conversation conversation NOUN istl-2446 11 8 among among ADP istl-2446 11 9 all all DET istl-2446 11 10 players player NOUN istl-2446 11 11 – – PUNCT istl-2446 11 12 researchers researcher NOUN istl-2446 11 13 , , PUNCT istl-2446 11 14 funding funding NOUN istl-2446 11 15 agencies agency NOUN istl-2446 11 16 , , PUNCT istl-2446 11 17 libraries library NOUN istl-2446 11 18 , , PUNCT istl-2446 11 19 and and CCONJ istl-2446 11 20 publishers publisher NOUN istl-2446 11 21 – – PUNCT istl-2446 11 22 about about ADP istl-2446 11 23 potential potential ADJ istl-2446 11 24 implications implication NOUN istl-2446 11 25 , , PUNCT istl-2446 11 26 both both CCONJ istl-2446 11 27 beneficial beneficial ADJ istl-2446 11 28 and and CCONJ istl-2446 11 29 detrimental detrimental ADJ istl-2446 11 30 , , PUNCT istl-2446 11 31 of of ADP istl-2446 11 32 various various ADJ istl-2446 11 33 sorts sort NOUN istl-2446 11 34 of of ADP istl-2446 11 35 oa oa NOUN istl-2446 11 36 . . PUNCT istl-2446 12 1 unfortunately unfortunately ADV istl-2446 12 2 , , PUNCT istl-2446 12 3 serious serious ADJ istl-2446 12 4 conversation conversation NOUN istl-2446 12 5 is be AUX istl-2446 12 6 ill ill ADV istl-2446 12 7 - - PUNCT istl-2446 12 8 served serve VERB istl-2446 12 9 by by ADP istl-2446 12 10 some some DET istl-2446 12 11 publishers publisher NOUN istl-2446 12 12 ’ ' PUNCT istl-2446 12 13 strategies strategy NOUN istl-2446 12 14 , , PUNCT istl-2446 12 15 including include VERB istl-2446 12 16 , , PUNCT istl-2446 12 17 regrettably regrettably ADV istl-2446 12 18 , , PUNCT istl-2446 12 19 those those PRON istl-2446 12 20 pursued pursue VERB istl-2446 12 21 by by ADP istl-2446 12 22 the the DET istl-2446 12 23 american american PROPN istl-2446 12 24 chemical chemical PROPN istl-2446 12 25 society society PROPN istl-2446 12 26 . . PUNCT istl-2446 13 1 editorials editorial NOUN istl-2446 13 2 in in ADP istl-2446 13 3 chemical chemical PROPN istl-2446 13 4 & & CCONJ istl-2446 13 5 engineering engineering PROPN istl-2446 13 6 news news NOUN istl-2446 13 7 as as ADV istl-2446 13 8 far far ADV istl-2446 13 9 back back ADV istl-2446 13 10 as as ADP istl-2446 13 11 2004 2004 NUM istl-2446 13 12 denounced denounce VERB istl-2446 13 13 oa oa PRON istl-2446 13 14 as as ADP istl-2446 13 15 " " PUNCT istl-2446 13 16 socialized socialize VERB istl-2446 13 17 science science NOUN istl-2446 13 18 " " PUNCT istl-2446 13 19 -whatever -whatever ADV istl-2446 13 20 that that PRON istl-2446 13 21 is be AUX istl-2446 13 22 supposed suppose VERB istl-2446 13 23 to to PART istl-2446 13 24 mean mean VERB istl-2446 13 25 . . PUNCT istl-2446 14 1 in in ADP istl-2446 14 2 2005 2005 NUM istl-2446 14 3 nobel nobel PROPN istl-2446 14 4 laureate laureate PROPN istl-2446 14 5 richard richard PROPN istl-2446 14 6 j. j. PROPN istl-2446 14 7 roberts roberts PROPN istl-2446 14 8 published publish VERB istl-2446 14 9 an an DET istl-2446 14 10 open open ADJ istl-2446 14 11 letter letter NOUN istl-2446 14 12 announcing announce VERB istl-2446 14 13 his his PRON istl-2446 14 14 resignation resignation NOUN istl-2446 14 15 from from ADP istl-2446 14 16 acs acs PROPN istl-2446 14 17 out out ADP istl-2446 14 18 of of ADP istl-2446 14 19 disgust disgust NOUN istl-2446 14 20 at at ADP istl-2446 14 21 the the DET istl-2446 14 22 society society NOUN istl-2446 14 23 's 's PART istl-2446 14 24 opposition opposition NOUN istl-2446 14 25 to to ADP istl-2446 14 26 oa oa NOUN istl-2446 14 27 . . PUNCT istl-2446 15 1 in in ADP istl-2446 15 2 january january PROPN istl-2446 15 3 2007 2007 NUM istl-2446 15 4 nature nature NOUN istl-2446 15 5 ( ( PUNCT istl-2446 15 6 445 445 NUM istl-2446 15 7 , , PUNCT istl-2446 15 8 25 25 NUM istl-2446 15 9 january january PROPN istl-2446 15 10 2007 2007 NUM istl-2446 15 11 , , PUNCT istl-2446 15 12 347 347 NUM istl-2446 15 13 ) ) PUNCT istl-2446 15 14 reported report VERB istl-2446 15 15 that that SCONJ istl-2446 15 16 acs acs PROPN istl-2446 15 17 was be AUX istl-2446 15 18 among among ADP istl-2446 15 19 a a DET istl-2446 15 20 group group NOUN istl-2446 15 21 of of ADP istl-2446 15 22 members member NOUN istl-2446 15 23 of of ADP istl-2446 15 24 the the DET istl-2446 15 25 association association NOUN istl-2446 15 26 of of ADP istl-2446 15 27 american american ADJ istl-2446 15 28 publishers publisher NOUN istl-2446 15 29 ( ( PUNCT istl-2446 15 30 aap aap NOUN istl-2446 15 31 ) ) PUNCT istl-2446 15 32 that that PRON istl-2446 15 33 hired hire VERB istl-2446 15 34 " " PUNCT istl-2446 15 35 pit pit NOUN istl-2446 15 36 bull bull NOUN istl-2446 15 37 " " PUNCT istl-2446 15 38 eric eric PROPN istl-2446 15 39 dezenhall dezenhall PROPN istl-2446 15 40 to to PART istl-2446 15 41 attack attack VERB istl-2446 15 42 the the DET istl-2446 15 43 open open ADJ istl-2446 15 44 access access NOUN istl-2446 15 45 movement movement NOUN istl-2446 15 46 . . PUNCT istl-2446 16 1 dezenhall dezenhall PROPN istl-2446 16 2 advised advise VERB istl-2446 16 3 the the DET istl-2446 16 4 publishers publisher NOUN istl-2446 16 5 to to PART istl-2446 16 6 focus focus VERB istl-2446 16 7 on on ADP istl-2446 16 8 simple simple ADJ istl-2446 16 9 messages message NOUN istl-2446 16 10 ( ( PUNCT istl-2446 16 11 more more ADV istl-2446 16 12 honestly honestly ADV istl-2446 16 13 : : PUNCT istl-2446 16 14 simple simple ADJ istl-2446 16 15 - - PUNCT istl-2446 16 16 minded minded ADJ istl-2446 16 17 dissembling dissemble VERB istl-2446 16 18 slogans slogan NOUN istl-2446 16 19 ) ) PUNCT istl-2446 16 20 , , PUNCT istl-2446 16 21 such such ADJ istl-2446 16 22 as as ADP istl-2446 16 23 " " PUNCT istl-2446 16 24 public public ADJ istl-2446 16 25 access access NOUN istl-2446 16 26 equals equal VERB istl-2446 16 27 government government NOUN istl-2446 16 28 censorship censorship NOUN istl-2446 16 29 . . PUNCT istl-2446 16 30 " " PUNCT istl-2446 17 1 indeed indeed ADV istl-2446 17 2 , , PUNCT istl-2446 17 3 acs acs PROPN istl-2446 17 4 senior senior ADJ istl-2446 17 5 vice vice NOUN istl-2446 17 6 president president PROPN istl-2446 17 7 brian brian PROPN istl-2446 17 8 crawford crawford PROPN istl-2446 17 9 told tell VERB istl-2446 17 10 nature,"[w]hen nature,"[w]hen PRON istl-2446 17 11 any any DET istl-2446 17 12 government government NOUN istl-2446 17 13 or or CCONJ istl-2446 17 14 funding funding NOUN istl-2446 17 15 agency agency NOUN istl-2446 17 16 houses house NOUN istl-2446 17 17 and and CCONJ istl-2446 17 18 disseminates disseminate NOUN istl-2446 17 19 for for ADP istl-2446 17 20 public public ADJ istl-2446 17 21 consumption consumption NOUN istl-2446 17 22 only only ADV istl-2446 17 23 the the DET istl-2446 17 24 work work NOUN istl-2446 17 25 it it PRON istl-2446 17 26 itself itself PRON istl-2446 17 27 funds fund NOUN istl-2446 17 28 , , PUNCT istl-2446 17 29 that that PRON istl-2446 17 30 constitutes constitute VERB istl-2446 17 31 a a DET istl-2446 17 32 form form NOUN istl-2446 17 33 of of ADP istl-2446 17 34 selection selection NOUN istl-2446 17 35 and and CCONJ istl-2446 17 36 self self NOUN istl-2446 17 37 - - PUNCT istl-2446 17 38 promotion promotion NOUN istl-2446 17 39 of of ADP istl-2446 17 40 that that DET istl-2446 17 41 entity entity NOUN istl-2446 17 42 's 's PART istl-2446 17 43 interests interest NOUN istl-2446 17 44 . . PUNCT istl-2446 18 1 " " PUNCT istl-2446 18 2     SPACE istl-2446 18 3 by by ADP istl-2446 18 4 mid-2007 mid-2007 NOUN istl-2446 18 5 dezenhall dezenhall PROPN istl-2446 18 6 had have AUX istl-2446 18 7 founded found VERB istl-2446 18 8 prism prism NOUN istl-2446 18 9 ( ( PUNCT istl-2446 18 10 " " PUNCT istl-2446 18 11 partnership partnership NOUN istl-2446 18 12 for for ADP istl-2446 18 13 research research NOUN istl-2446 18 14 integrity integrity NOUN istl-2446 18 15 in in ADP istl-2446 18 16 science science NOUN istl-2446 18 17 and and CCONJ istl-2446 18 18 medicine medicine NOUN istl-2446 18 19 " " PUNCT istl-2446 18 20 – – PUNCT istl-2446 18 21 " " PUNCT istl-2446 18 22 integrity integrity NOUN istl-2446 18 23 " " PUNCT istl-2446 18 24 is be AUX istl-2446 18 25 presumably presumably ADV istl-2446 18 26 used use VERB istl-2446 18 27 in in ADP istl-2446 18 28 the the DET istl-2446 18 29 rovian rovian ADJ istl-2446 18 30 sense sense NOUN istl-2446 18 31 ) ) PUNCT istl-2446 18 32 , , PUNCT istl-2446 18 33 launched launch VERB istl-2446 18 34 by by ADP istl-2446 18 35 the the DET istl-2446 18 36 executive executive ADJ istl-2446 18 37 council council NOUN istl-2446 18 38 of of ADP istl-2446 18 39 the the DET istl-2446 18 40 professional professional ADJ istl-2446 18 41 and and CCONJ istl-2446 18 42 scholarly scholarly ADJ istl-2446 18 43 publishing publishing NOUN istl-2446 18 44 division division NOUN istl-2446 18 45 of of ADP istl-2446 18 46 the the DET istl-2446 18 47 aap aap NOUN istl-2446 18 48 . . PUNCT istl-2446 19 1 this this DET istl-2446 19 2 organization organization NOUN istl-2446 19 3 proceeded proceed VERB istl-2446 19 4 to to PART istl-2446 19 5 make make VERB istl-2446 19 6 , , PUNCT istl-2446 19 7 without without ADP istl-2446 19 8 evidence evidence NOUN istl-2446 19 9 or or CCONJ istl-2446 19 10 plausibility plausibility NOUN istl-2446 19 11 , , PUNCT istl-2446 19 12 claims claim VERB istl-2446 19 13 about about ADP istl-2446 19 14 oa oa PRON istl-2446 19 15 presaged presage VERB istl-2446 19 16 in in ADP istl-2446 19 17 the the DET istl-2446 19 18 nature nature NOUN istl-2446 19 19 account account NOUN istl-2446 19 20 : : PUNCT istl-2446 19 21     SPACE istl-2446 19 22 that that SCONJ istl-2446 19 23 it it PRON istl-2446 19 24 could could AUX istl-2446 19 25 " " PUNCT istl-2446 19 26 undermine undermine VERB istl-2446 19 27 the the DET istl-2446 19 28 peer peer NOUN istl-2446 19 29 review review NOUN istl-2446 19 30 process process NOUN istl-2446 19 31 " " PUNCT istl-2446 19 32 and and CCONJ istl-2446 19 33 even even ADV istl-2446 19 34 " " PUNCT istl-2446 19 35 open open VERB istl-2446 19 36 the the DET istl-2446 19 37 door door NOUN istl-2446 19 38 to to ADP istl-2446 19 39 scientific scientific ADJ istl-2446 19 40 censorship censorship NOUN istl-2446 19 41 in in ADP istl-2446 19 42 the the DET istl-2446 19 43 form form NOUN istl-2446 19 44 of of ADP istl-2446 19 45 selective selective ADJ istl-2446 19 46 additions addition NOUN istl-2446 19 47 to to ADP istl-2446 19 48 or or CCONJ istl-2446 19 49 omissions omission NOUN istl-2446 19 50 from from ADP istl-2446 19 51 the the DET istl-2446 19 52 scientific scientific ADJ istl-2446 19 53 record record NOUN istl-2446 19 54 . . PUNCT istl-2446 19 55 " " PUNCT istl-2446 20 1 such such ADJ istl-2446 20 2 ludicrous ludicrous ADJ istl-2446 20 3 claims claim NOUN istl-2446 20 4 led lead VERB istl-2446 20 5 a a DET istl-2446 20 6 number number NOUN istl-2446 20 7 of of ADP istl-2446 20 8 publishers publisher NOUN istl-2446 20 9 , , PUNCT istl-2446 20 10 including include VERB istl-2446 20 11 cambridge cambridge PROPN istl-2446 20 12 university university PROPN istl-2446 20 13 press press NOUN istl-2446 20 14 , , PUNCT istl-2446 20 15 oxford oxford PROPN istl-2446 20 16 university university PROPN istl-2446 20 17 press press PROPN istl-2446 20 18 , , PUNCT istl-2446 20 19 columbia columbia PROPN istl-2446 20 20 university university PROPN istl-2446 20 21 press press NOUN istl-2446 20 22 , , PUNCT istl-2446 20 23 and and CCONJ istl-2446 20 24 university university PROPN istl-2446 20 25 of of ADP istl-2446 20 26 chicago chicago PROPN istl-2446 20 27 press press PROPN istl-2446 20 28 , , PUNCT istl-2446 20 29 to to ADP istl-2446 20 30 disavow disavow NOUN istl-2446 20 31 prism prism NOUN istl-2446 20 32 ( ( PUNCT istl-2446 20 33 see see VERB istl-2446 20 34 e.g. e.g. PROPN istl-2446 20 35 http://www.eurekajournalwatch.org/index.php/prism http://www.eurekajournalwatch.org/index.php/prism PROPN istl-2446 20 36 ) ) PUNCT istl-2446 20 37 . . PUNCT istl-2446 21 1 if if SCONJ istl-2446 21 2 the the DET istl-2446 21 3 acs acs PROPN istl-2446 21 4 regrets regret VERB istl-2446 21 5 its its PRON istl-2446 21 6 association association NOUN istl-2446 21 7 with with ADP istl-2446 21 8 prism prism PROPN istl-2446 21 9 's 's PART istl-2446 21 10 misstatements misstatement NOUN istl-2446 21 11 , , PUNCT istl-2446 21 12 they they PRON istl-2446 21 13 do do AUX istl-2446 21 14 n’t not PART istl-2446 21 15 show show VERB istl-2446 21 16 it it PRON istl-2446 21 17 . . PUNCT istl-2446 22 1 after after ADP istl-2446 22 2 a a DET istl-2446 22 3 long long ADJ istl-2446 22 4 legislative legislative ADJ istl-2446 22 5 fight fight NOUN istl-2446 22 6 , , PUNCT istl-2446 22 7 the the DET istl-2446 22 8 national national ADJ istl-2446 22 9 institutes institutes PROPN istl-2446 22 10 of of ADP istl-2446 22 11 health health NOUN istl-2446 22 12 ( ( PUNCT istl-2446 22 13 nih nih PROPN istl-2446 22 14 ) ) PUNCT istl-2446 22 15 was be AUX istl-2446 22 16 able able ADJ istl-2446 22 17 to to PART istl-2446 22 18 secure secure VERB istl-2446 22 19 passage passage NOUN istl-2446 22 20 of of ADP istl-2446 22 21 a a DET istl-2446 22 22 mandate mandate NOUN istl-2446 22 23 on on ADP istl-2446 22 24 open open ADJ istl-2446 22 25 access access NOUN istl-2446 22 26 for for ADP istl-2446 22 27 nih nih PROPN istl-2446 22 28 - - PUNCT istl-2446 22 29 funded fund VERB istl-2446 22 30 research research NOUN istl-2446 22 31 within within ADP istl-2446 22 32 a a DET istl-2446 22 33 year year NOUN istl-2446 22 34 of of ADP istl-2446 22 35 publication publication NOUN istl-2446 22 36 . . PUNCT istl-2446 23 1 ( ( PUNCT istl-2446 23 2 compare compare VERB istl-2446 23 3 the the DET istl-2446 23 4 six six NUM istl-2446 23 5 - - PUNCT istl-2446 23 6 month month NOUN istl-2446 23 7 requirement requirement NOUN istl-2446 23 8 of of ADP istl-2446 23 9 other other ADJ istl-2446 23 10 funding funding NOUN istl-2446 23 11 sources source NOUN istl-2446 23 12 such such ADJ istl-2446 23 13 as as ADP istl-2446 23 14 the the DET istl-2446 23 15 wellcome wellcome ADJ istl-2446 23 16 trust trust NOUN istl-2446 23 17 , , PUNCT istl-2446 23 18 australian australian ADJ istl-2446 23 19 research research NOUN istl-2446 23 20 council council PROPN istl-2446 23 21 , , PUNCT istl-2446 23 22 and and CCONJ istl-2446 23 23 medical medical ADJ istl-2446 23 24 research research NOUN istl-2446 23 25 council council NOUN istl-2446 23 26 . . PUNCT istl-2446 23 27 ) ) PUNCT istl-2446 24 1 but but CCONJ istl-2446 24 2 as as SCONJ istl-2446 24 3 reported report VERB istl-2446 24 4 in in ADP istl-2446 24 5 lj lj PROPN istl-2446 24 6 academic academic ADJ istl-2446 24 7 newswire newswire NOUN istl-2446 24 8 , , PUNCT istl-2446 24 9 { { PUNCT istl-2446 24 10 the the DET istl-2446 24 11 acs acs PROPN istl-2446 24 12 threatens threaten VERB istl-2446 24 13 a a DET istl-2446 24 14 legal legal ADJ istl-2446 24 15 battle battle NOUN istl-2446 24 16 } } PUNCT istl-2446 24 17 . . PUNCT istl-2446 25 1 executive executive ADJ istl-2446 25 2 director director NOUN istl-2446 25 3 madeleine madeleine PROPN istl-2446 25 4 jacobs jacobs PROPN istl-2446 25 5 makes make VERB istl-2446 25 6 the the DET istl-2446 25 7 claim claim NOUN istl-2446 25 8 , , PUNCT istl-2446 25 9 according accord VERB istl-2446 25 10 to to ADP istl-2446 25 11 chemistry chemistry NOUN istl-2446 25 12 world world NOUN istl-2446 25 13 , , PUNCT istl-2446 25 14 that that SCONJ istl-2446 25 15 " " PUNCT istl-2446 25 16 the the DET istl-2446 25 17 policy policy NOUN istl-2446 25 18 would would AUX istl-2446 25 19 result result VERB istl-2446 25 20 in in ADP istl-2446 25 21 conflicts conflict NOUN istl-2446 25 22 with with ADP istl-2446 25 23 copyright copyright NOUN istl-2446 25 24 law law NOUN istl-2446 25 25 and and CCONJ istl-2446 25 26 intellectual intellectual ADJ istl-2446 25 27 property property NOUN istl-2446 25 28 rights right NOUN istl-2446 25 29 , , PUNCT istl-2446 25 30 " " PUNCT istl-2446 25 31 resurrecting resurrect VERB istl-2446 25 32 the the DET istl-2446 25 33 claim claim NOUN istl-2446 25 34 that that SCONJ istl-2446 25 35 it it PRON istl-2446 25 36 could could AUX istl-2446 25 37 " " PUNCT istl-2446 25 38 interfere interfere VERB istl-2446 25 39 with with ADP istl-2446 25 40 scientific scientific ADJ istl-2446 25 41 peer peer NOUN istl-2446 25 42 review review NOUN istl-2446 25 43 " " PUNCT istl-2446 25 44 and and CCONJ istl-2446 25 45 adding add VERB istl-2446 25 46 that that SCONJ istl-2446 25 47 it it PRON istl-2446 25 48 would would AUX istl-2446 25 49 " " PUNCT istl-2446 25 50 adversely adversely ADV istl-2446 25 51 affect affect VERB istl-2446 25 52 the the DET istl-2446 25 53 sustainability sustainability NOUN istl-2446 25 54 of of ADP istl-2446 25 55 scientific scientific ADJ istl-2446 25 56 journals journal NOUN istl-2446 25 57 . . PUNCT istl-2446 25 58 " " PUNCT istl-2446 26 1 it it PRON istl-2446 26 2 seems seem VERB istl-2446 26 3 to to ADP istl-2446 26 4 me i PRON istl-2446 26 5 that that SCONJ istl-2446 26 6 all all PRON istl-2446 26 7 of of ADP istl-2446 26 8 these these DET istl-2446 26 9 claims claim NOUN istl-2446 26 10 are be AUX istl-2446 26 11 nonsense nonsense NOUN istl-2446 26 12 . . PUNCT istl-2446 27 1 lj lj PROPN istl-2446 27 2 academic academic ADJ istl-2446 27 3 newswire newswire NOUN istl-2446 27 4 notes note VERB istl-2446 27 5 that that SCONJ istl-2446 27 6 the the DET istl-2446 27 7 library library NOUN istl-2446 27 8 community community NOUN istl-2446 27 9 refuted refute VERB istl-2446 27 10 acs acs PROPN istl-2446 27 11 's 's PART istl-2446 27 12 copyright copyright NOUN istl-2446 27 13 claim claim NOUN istl-2446 27 14 in in ADP istl-2446 27 15 july july PROPN istl-2446 27 16 2007 2007 NUM istl-2446 27 17 . . PUNCT istl-2446 28 1 as as SCONJ istl-2446 28 2 peter peter PROPN istl-2446 28 3 suber suber PROPN istl-2446 28 4 has have AUX istl-2446 28 5 repeatedly repeatedly ADV istl-2446 28 6 discussed discuss VERB istl-2446 28 7 , , PUNCT istl-2446 28 8 peer peer NOUN istl-2446 28 9 review review NOUN istl-2446 28 10 is be AUX istl-2446 28 11 entirely entirely ADV istl-2446 28 12 compatible compatible ADJ istl-2446 28 13 with with ADP istl-2446 28 14 open open ADJ istl-2446 28 15 access access NOUN istl-2446 28 16 . . PUNCT istl-2446 29 1 if if SCONJ istl-2446 29 2 the the DET istl-2446 29 3 acs acs NOUN istl-2446 29 4 is be AUX istl-2446 29 5 to to PART istl-2446 29 6 be be AUX istl-2446 29 7 a a DET istl-2446 29 8 party party NOUN istl-2446 29 9 to to ADP istl-2446 29 10 discussions discussion NOUN istl-2446 29 11 of of ADP istl-2446 29 12 oa oa NOUN istl-2446 29 13 , , PUNCT istl-2446 29 14 they they PRON istl-2446 29 15 must must AUX istl-2446 29 16 stop stop VERB istl-2446 29 17 getting get VERB istl-2446 29 18 their their PRON istl-2446 29 19 policy policy NOUN istl-2446 29 20 advice advice NOUN istl-2446 29 21 from from ADP istl-2446 29 22 pr pr ADP istl-2446 29 23 flacks flack NOUN istl-2446 29 24 and and CCONJ istl-2446 29 25 start start VERB istl-2446 29 26 making make VERB istl-2446 29 27 rational rational ADJ istl-2446 29 28 contributions contribution NOUN istl-2446 29 29 to to ADP istl-2446 29 30 the the DET istl-2446 29 31 discourse discourse NOUN istl-2446 29 32 . . PUNCT istl-2446 30 1 otherwise otherwise ADV istl-2446 30 2 they they PRON istl-2446 30 3 will will AUX istl-2446 30 4 continue continue VERB istl-2446 30 5 to to PART istl-2446 30 6 poison poison VERB istl-2446 30 7 the the DET istl-2446 30 8 waters water NOUN istl-2446 30 9 , , PUNCT istl-2446 30 10 and and CCONJ istl-2446 30 11 deservedly deservedly ADV istl-2446 30 12 will will AUX istl-2446 30 13 be be AUX istl-2446 30 14 accorded accord VERB istl-2446 30 15 no no DET istl-2446 30 16 credence credence NOUN istl-2446 30 17 . . PUNCT istl-2446 31 1 previous previous ADJ istl-2446 31 2     SPACE istl-2446 31 3 contents content NOUN istl-2446 31 4     SPACE istl-2446 31 5 next next ADJ