id sid tid token lemma pos istl-2455 1 1 on on ADP istl-2455 1 2 impact impact NOUN istl-2455 1 3 of of ADP istl-2455 1 4 oa oa NOUN istl-2455 1 5 , , PUNCT istl-2455 1 6 the the DET istl-2455 1 7 jury jury NOUN istl-2455 1 8 is be AUX istl-2455 1 9 still still ADV istl-2455 1 10 out out ADV istl-2455 1 11 previous previous ADJ istl-2455 1 12 contents content NOUN istl-2455 1 13 next next ADJ istl-2455 1 14 issues issue NOUN istl-2455 1 15 in in ADP istl-2455 1 16 science science NOUN istl-2455 1 17 and and CCONJ istl-2455 1 18 technology technology NOUN istl-2455 1 19 librarianship librarianship NOUN istl-2455 1 20 summer summer NOUN istl-2455 1 21 2008 2008 NUM istl-2455 1 22 doi:10.5062 doi:10.5062 PROPN istl-2455 1 23 / / SYM istl-2455 1 24 f4df6p53 f4df6p53 PROPN istl-2455 1 25 viewpoint viewpoint NOUN istl-2455 1 26 on on ADP istl-2455 1 27 impact impact NOUN istl-2455 1 28 of of ADP istl-2455 1 29 oa oa NOUN istl-2455 1 30 , , PUNCT istl-2455 1 31 the the DET istl-2455 1 32 jury jury NOUN istl-2455 1 33 is be AUX istl-2455 1 34 still still ADV istl-2455 1 35 out out ADV istl-2455 1 36 david david PROPN istl-2455 1 37 flaxbart flaxbart PROPN istl-2455 1 38 viewpoint viewpoint NOUN istl-2455 1 39 editor editor NOUN istl-2455 1 40 issues issue NOUN istl-2455 1 41 in in ADP istl-2455 1 42 science science NOUN istl-2455 1 43 and and CCONJ istl-2455 1 44 technology technology NOUN istl-2455 1 45 librarianship librarianship NOUN istl-2455 1 46 flaxbart@uts.cc.utexas.edu flaxbart@uts.cc.utexas.edu PROPN istl-2455 1 47 copyright copyright NOUN istl-2455 1 48 2008 2008 NUM istl-2455 1 49 , , PUNCT istl-2455 1 50 david david PROPN istl-2455 1 51 flaxbart flaxbart PROPN istl-2455 1 52 . . PUNCT istl-2455 2 1 used use VERB istl-2455 2 2 with with ADP istl-2455 2 3 permission permission NOUN istl-2455 2 4 . . PUNCT istl-2455 3 1 we we PRON istl-2455 3 2 have have VERB istl-2455 3 3 no no DET istl-2455 3 4 contributed contribute VERB istl-2455 3 5 viewpoint viewpoint NOUN istl-2455 3 6 to to PART istl-2455 3 7 share share VERB istl-2455 3 8 in in ADP istl-2455 3 9 this this DET istl-2455 3 10 issue issue NOUN istl-2455 3 11 , , PUNCT istl-2455 3 12 so so CCONJ istl-2455 3 13 i i PRON istl-2455 3 14 have have AUX istl-2455 3 15 taken take VERB istl-2455 3 16 the the DET istl-2455 3 17 liberty liberty NOUN istl-2455 3 18 of of ADP istl-2455 3 19 writing write VERB istl-2455 3 20 my my PRON istl-2455 3 21 own own ADJ istl-2455 3 22 . . PUNCT istl-2455 4 1 let let VERB istl-2455 4 2 this this PRON istl-2455 4 3 be be AUX istl-2455 4 4 a a DET istl-2455 4 5 reminder reminder NOUN istl-2455 4 6 to to ADP istl-2455 4 7 our our PRON istl-2455 4 8 readers reader NOUN istl-2455 4 9 : : PUNCT istl-2455 4 10 we we PRON istl-2455 4 11 want want VERB istl-2455 4 12 your your PRON istl-2455 4 13 opinions opinion NOUN istl-2455 4 14 ! ! PUNCT istl-2455 5 1 please please INTJ istl-2455 5 2 consider consider VERB istl-2455 5 3 submitting submit VERB istl-2455 5 4 a a DET istl-2455 5 5 viewpoint viewpoint NOUN istl-2455 5 6 for for ADP istl-2455 5 7 an an DET istl-2455 5 8 upcoming upcoming ADJ istl-2455 5 9 issue issue NOUN istl-2455 5 10 of of ADP istl-2455 5 11 istl istl PROPN istl-2455 5 12 . . PUNCT istl-2455 6 1 -df -df SPACE istl-2455 6 2 the the DET istl-2455 6 3 conventional conventional ADJ istl-2455 6 4 wisdom wisdom NOUN istl-2455 6 5 among among ADP istl-2455 6 6 open open ADJ istl-2455 6 7 access access NOUN istl-2455 6 8 advocates advocate NOUN istl-2455 6 9 and and CCONJ istl-2455 6 10 librarians librarians PROPN istl-2455 6 11 is be AUX istl-2455 6 12 that that SCONJ istl-2455 6 13 articles article NOUN istl-2455 6 14 that that PRON istl-2455 6 15 are be AUX istl-2455 6 16 freely freely ADV istl-2455 6 17 available available ADJ istl-2455 6 18 will will AUX istl-2455 6 19 be be AUX istl-2455 6 20 read read VERB istl-2455 6 21 more more ADV istl-2455 6 22 , , PUNCT istl-2455 6 23 downloaded download VERB istl-2455 6 24 more more ADJ istl-2455 6 25 , , PUNCT istl-2455 6 26 and and CCONJ istl-2455 6 27 by by ADP istl-2455 6 28 extension extension NOUN istl-2455 6 29 cited cite VERB istl-2455 6 30 more more ADV istl-2455 6 31 . . PUNCT istl-2455 7 1 it it PRON istl-2455 7 2 seems seem VERB istl-2455 7 3 like like ADP istl-2455 7 4 a a DET istl-2455 7 5 no no NOUN istl-2455 7 6 - - PUNCT istl-2455 7 7 brainer brainer NOUN istl-2455 7 8 : : PUNCT istl-2455 7 9 take take VERB istl-2455 7 10 down down ADP istl-2455 7 11 the the DET istl-2455 7 12 walls wall NOUN istl-2455 7 13 and and CCONJ istl-2455 7 14 people people NOUN istl-2455 7 15 will will AUX istl-2455 7 16 come come VERB istl-2455 7 17 in in ADP istl-2455 7 18 . . PUNCT istl-2455 8 1 indeed indeed ADV istl-2455 8 2 , , PUNCT istl-2455 8 3 a a DET istl-2455 8 4 number number NOUN istl-2455 8 5 of of ADP istl-2455 8 6 studies study NOUN istl-2455 8 7 published publish VERB istl-2455 8 8 in in ADP istl-2455 8 9 recent recent ADJ istl-2455 8 10 years year NOUN istl-2455 8 11 have have AUX istl-2455 8 12 claimed claim VERB istl-2455 8 13 to to PART istl-2455 8 14 confirm confirm VERB istl-2455 8 15 that that DET istl-2455 8 16 assumption assumption NOUN istl-2455 8 17 . . PUNCT istl-2455 9 1 but but CCONJ istl-2455 9 2 a a DET istl-2455 9 3 new new ADJ istl-2455 9 4 paper paper NOUN istl-2455 9 5 by by ADP istl-2455 9 6 philip philip PROPN istl-2455 9 7 davis davis PROPN istl-2455 9 8 and and CCONJ istl-2455 9 9 his his PRON istl-2455 9 10 colleagues colleague NOUN istl-2455 9 11 at at ADP istl-2455 9 12 cornell cornell PROPN istl-2455 9 13 university university PROPN istl-2455 9 14 suggests suggest VERB istl-2455 9 15 that that SCONJ istl-2455 9 16 the the DET istl-2455 9 17 citation citation NOUN istl-2455 9 18 effect effect NOUN istl-2455 9 19 may may AUX istl-2455 9 20 not not PART istl-2455 9 21 be be AUX istl-2455 9 22 there there ADV istl-2455 9 23 after after ADV istl-2455 9 24 all all ADV istl-2455 9 25 ( ( PUNCT istl-2455 9 26 davis davis PROPN istl-2455 9 27 et et PROPN istl-2455 9 28 al al PROPN istl-2455 9 29 . . PROPN istl-2455 9 30 2008 2008 NUM istl-2455 9 31 ) ) PUNCT istl-2455 9 32 . . PUNCT istl-2455 10 1 we we PRON istl-2455 10 2 desperately desperately ADV istl-2455 10 3 need need VERB istl-2455 10 4 objective objective NOUN istl-2455 10 5 , , PUNCT istl-2455 10 6 quantifiable quantifiable ADJ istl-2455 10 7 evidence evidence NOUN istl-2455 10 8 that that PRON istl-2455 10 9 oa oa VERB istl-2455 10 10 does do VERB istl-2455 10 11 what what PRON istl-2455 10 12 it it PRON istl-2455 10 13 claims claim VERB istl-2455 10 14 to to PART istl-2455 10 15 do do VERB istl-2455 10 16 , , PUNCT istl-2455 10 17 rather rather ADV istl-2455 10 18 than than ADP istl-2455 10 19 taking take VERB istl-2455 10 20 these these DET istl-2455 10 21 things thing NOUN istl-2455 10 22 as as ADP istl-2455 10 23 a a DET istl-2455 10 24 matter matter NOUN istl-2455 10 25 of of ADP istl-2455 10 26 near near ADJ istl-2455 10 27 - - PUNCT istl-2455 10 28 religious religious ADJ istl-2455 10 29 faith faith NOUN istl-2455 10 30 . . PUNCT istl-2455 11 1 only only ADV istl-2455 11 2 with with ADP istl-2455 11 3 hard hard ADJ istl-2455 11 4 evidence evidence NOUN istl-2455 11 5 can can AUX istl-2455 11 6 we we PRON istl-2455 11 7 refute refute VERB istl-2455 11 8 publisher publisher NOUN istl-2455 11 9 claims claim NOUN istl-2455 11 10 that that SCONJ istl-2455 11 11 oa oa PRON istl-2455 11 12 is be AUX istl-2455 11 13 evil evil ADJ istl-2455 11 14 , , PUNCT istl-2455 11 15 destructive destructive ADJ istl-2455 11 16 , , PUNCT istl-2455 11 17 and and CCONJ istl-2455 11 18 unnecessary unnecessary ADJ istl-2455 11 19 , , PUNCT istl-2455 11 20 and and CCONJ istl-2455 11 21 demonstrate demonstrate VERB istl-2455 11 22 to to ADP istl-2455 11 23 all all DET istl-2455 11 24 stakeholders stakeholder NOUN istl-2455 11 25 that that SCONJ istl-2455 11 26 oa oa PRON istl-2455 11 27 is be AUX istl-2455 11 28 worthy worthy ADJ istl-2455 11 29 of of ADP istl-2455 11 30 further further ADJ istl-2455 11 31 investment investment NOUN istl-2455 11 32 and and CCONJ istl-2455 11 33 advocacy advocacy NOUN istl-2455 11 34 . . PUNCT istl-2455 12 1 studies study NOUN istl-2455 12 2 of of ADP istl-2455 12 3 oa oa PROPN istl-2455 12 4 's 's PART istl-2455 12 5 effects effect NOUN istl-2455 12 6 , , PUNCT istl-2455 12 7 especially especially ADV istl-2455 12 8 those those PRON istl-2455 12 9 published publish VERB istl-2455 12 10 in in ADP istl-2455 12 11 journals journal NOUN istl-2455 12 12 that that SCONJ istl-2455 12 13 real real ADJ istl-2455 12 14 scientists scientist NOUN istl-2455 12 15 see see VERB istl-2455 12 16 ( ( PUNCT istl-2455 12 17 as as SCONJ istl-2455 12 18 opposed oppose VERB istl-2455 12 19 to to ADP istl-2455 12 20 the the DET istl-2455 12 21 " " PUNCT istl-2455 12 22 library library NOUN istl-2455 12 23 literature literature NOUN istl-2455 12 24 " " PUNCT istl-2455 12 25 ) ) PUNCT istl-2455 12 26 , , PUNCT istl-2455 12 27 help help VERB istl-2455 12 28 bring bring VERB istl-2455 12 29 the the DET istl-2455 12 30 debate debate NOUN istl-2455 12 31 into into ADP istl-2455 12 32 the the DET istl-2455 12 33 arena arena NOUN istl-2455 12 34 where where SCONJ istl-2455 12 35 it it PRON istl-2455 12 36 matters matter VERB istl-2455 12 37 most most ADV istl-2455 12 38 : : PUNCT istl-2455 12 39 among among ADP istl-2455 12 40 scientists scientist NOUN istl-2455 12 41 themselves themselves PRON istl-2455 12 42 . . PUNCT istl-2455 13 1 but but CCONJ istl-2455 13 2 what what PRON istl-2455 13 3 happens happen VERB istl-2455 13 4 when when SCONJ istl-2455 13 5 the the DET istl-2455 13 6 numbers number NOUN istl-2455 13 7 do do AUX istl-2455 13 8 n't not PART istl-2455 13 9 support support VERB istl-2455 13 10 the the DET istl-2455 13 11 claims claim NOUN istl-2455 13 12 ? ? PUNCT istl-2455 14 1 any any DET istl-2455 14 2 study study NOUN istl-2455 14 3 that that PRON istl-2455 14 4 calls call VERB istl-2455 14 5 into into ADP istl-2455 14 6 question question NOUN istl-2455 14 7 the the DET istl-2455 14 8 efficacy efficacy NOUN istl-2455 14 9 of of ADP istl-2455 14 10 oa oa PROPN istl-2455 14 11 will will AUX istl-2455 14 12 be be AUX istl-2455 14 13 eagerly eagerly ADV istl-2455 14 14 seized seize VERB istl-2455 14 15 upon upon SCONJ istl-2455 14 16 by by ADP istl-2455 14 17 the the DET istl-2455 14 18 opponents opponent NOUN istl-2455 14 19 of of ADP istl-2455 14 20 oa oa PRON istl-2455 14 21 and and CCONJ istl-2455 14 22 used use VERB istl-2455 14 23 to to PART istl-2455 14 24 attack attack VERB istl-2455 14 25 further further ADJ istl-2455 14 26 efforts effort NOUN istl-2455 14 27 and and CCONJ istl-2455 14 28 policies policy NOUN istl-2455 14 29 that that PRON istl-2455 14 30 are be AUX istl-2455 14 31 now now ADV istl-2455 14 32 , , PUNCT istl-2455 14 33 after after ADP istl-2455 14 34 many many ADJ istl-2455 14 35 years year NOUN istl-2455 14 36 , , PUNCT istl-2455 14 37 beginning begin VERB istl-2455 14 38 to to PART istl-2455 14 39 bear bear VERB istl-2455 14 40 fruit fruit NOUN istl-2455 14 41 . . PUNCT istl-2455 15 1 we we PRON istl-2455 15 2 have have AUX istl-2455 15 3 already already ADV istl-2455 15 4 seen see VERB istl-2455 15 5 some some DET istl-2455 15 6 publishers publisher NOUN istl-2455 15 7 set set VERB istl-2455 15 8 up up ADP istl-2455 15 9 little little ADV istl-2455 15 10 - - PUNCT istl-2455 15 11 used use VERB istl-2455 15 12 author author NOUN istl-2455 15 13 - - PUNCT istl-2455 15 14 pays pay VERB istl-2455 15 15 oa oa NOUN istl-2455 15 16 options option NOUN istl-2455 15 17 as as ADP istl-2455 15 18 a a DET istl-2455 15 19 straw straw NOUN istl-2455 15 20 man man NOUN istl-2455 15 21 to to PART istl-2455 15 22 " " PUNCT istl-2455 15 23 prove prove VERB istl-2455 15 24 " " PUNCT istl-2455 15 25 that that SCONJ istl-2455 15 26 authors author NOUN istl-2455 15 27 do do AUX istl-2455 15 28 n't not PART istl-2455 15 29 care care VERB istl-2455 15 30 about about ADP istl-2455 15 31 oa oa PRON istl-2455 15 32 and and CCONJ istl-2455 15 33 do do AUX istl-2455 15 34 n't not PART istl-2455 15 35 want want VERB istl-2455 15 36 to to PART istl-2455 15 37 pay pay VERB istl-2455 15 38 for for ADP istl-2455 15 39 it it PRON istl-2455 15 40 . . PUNCT istl-2455 16 1 the the DET istl-2455 16 2 last last ADJ istl-2455 16 3 thing thing NOUN istl-2455 16 4 we we PRON istl-2455 16 5 need need VERB istl-2455 16 6 is be AUX istl-2455 16 7 to to PART istl-2455 16 8 give give VERB istl-2455 16 9 the the DET istl-2455 16 10 naysayers naysayer NOUN istl-2455 16 11 more more ADJ istl-2455 16 12 ammunition ammunition NOUN istl-2455 16 13 . . PUNCT istl-2455 17 1 nevertheless nevertheless ADV istl-2455 17 2 , , PUNCT istl-2455 17 3 it it PRON istl-2455 17 4 probably probably ADV istl-2455 17 5 is be AUX istl-2455 17 6 accurate accurate ADJ istl-2455 17 7 to to PART istl-2455 17 8 say say VERB istl-2455 17 9 that that SCONJ istl-2455 17 10 most most ADJ istl-2455 17 11 authors author NOUN istl-2455 17 12 do do AUX istl-2455 17 13 n't not PART istl-2455 17 14 care care VERB istl-2455 17 15 about about ADP istl-2455 17 16 oa oa ADP istl-2455 17 17 -not -not NOUN istl-2455 17 18 because because SCONJ istl-2455 17 19 they they PRON istl-2455 17 20 think think VERB istl-2455 17 21 it it PRON istl-2455 17 22 's be AUX istl-2455 17 23 a a DET istl-2455 17 24 bad bad ADJ istl-2455 17 25 thing thing NOUN istl-2455 17 26 , , PUNCT istl-2455 17 27 but but CCONJ istl-2455 17 28 because because SCONJ istl-2455 17 29 they they PRON istl-2455 17 30 remain remain VERB istl-2455 17 31 wholly wholly ADV istl-2455 17 32 ignorant ignorant ADJ istl-2455 17 33 of of ADP istl-2455 17 34 its its PRON istl-2455 17 35 existence existence NOUN istl-2455 17 36 as as ADP istl-2455 17 37 a a DET istl-2455 17 38 matter matter NOUN istl-2455 17 39 of of ADP istl-2455 17 40 debate debate NOUN istl-2455 17 41 and and CCONJ istl-2455 17 42 because because SCONJ istl-2455 17 43 , , PUNCT istl-2455 17 44 for for ADP istl-2455 17 45 most most ADJ istl-2455 17 46 of of ADP istl-2455 17 47 them they PRON istl-2455 17 48 , , PUNCT istl-2455 17 49 it it PRON istl-2455 17 50 's be AUX istl-2455 17 51 irrelevant irrelevant ADJ istl-2455 17 52 since since SCONJ istl-2455 17 53 they they PRON istl-2455 17 54 already already ADV istl-2455 17 55 have have VERB istl-2455 17 56 subscription subscription NOUN istl-2455 17 57 access access NOUN istl-2455 17 58 paid pay VERB istl-2455 17 59 for for ADP istl-2455 17 60 by by ADP istl-2455 17 61 their their PRON istl-2455 17 62 institutions institution NOUN istl-2455 17 63 . . PUNCT istl-2455 18 1 studying study VERB istl-2455 18 2 the the DET istl-2455 18 3 effect effect NOUN istl-2455 18 4 of of ADP istl-2455 18 5 oa oa NOUN istl-2455 18 6 in in ADP istl-2455 18 7 the the DET istl-2455 18 8 scholarly scholarly ADJ istl-2455 18 9 communication communication NOUN istl-2455 18 10 environment environment NOUN istl-2455 18 11 is be AUX istl-2455 18 12 devilishly devilishly ADV istl-2455 18 13 tricky tricky ADJ istl-2455 18 14 . . PUNCT istl-2455 19 1 there there PRON istl-2455 19 2 are be VERB istl-2455 19 3 many many ADJ istl-2455 19 4 variables variable NOUN istl-2455 19 5 and and CCONJ istl-2455 19 6 unknowns unknown NOUN istl-2455 19 7 that that PRON istl-2455 19 8 ca can AUX istl-2455 19 9 n't not PART istl-2455 19 10 be be AUX istl-2455 19 11 quantified quantify VERB istl-2455 19 12 or or CCONJ istl-2455 19 13 controlled control VERB istl-2455 19 14 . . PUNCT istl-2455 20 1 davis davis PROPN istl-2455 20 2 et et PROPN istl-2455 20 3 al al PROPN istl-2455 20 4 . . PROPN istl-2455 20 5 have have AUX istl-2455 20 6 moved move VERB istl-2455 20 7 a a DET istl-2455 20 8 step step NOUN istl-2455 20 9 forward forward ADV istl-2455 20 10 by by ADP istl-2455 20 11 randomizing randomize VERB istl-2455 20 12 the the DET istl-2455 20 13 selection selection NOUN istl-2455 20 14 of of ADP istl-2455 20 15 articles article NOUN istl-2455 20 16 to to PART istl-2455 20 17 make make VERB istl-2455 20 18 freely freely ADV istl-2455 20 19 accessible accessible ADJ istl-2455 20 20 , , PUNCT istl-2455 20 21 and and CCONJ istl-2455 20 22 comparing compare VERB istl-2455 20 23 this this DET istl-2455 20 24 group group NOUN istl-2455 20 25 to to ADP istl-2455 20 26 a a DET istl-2455 20 27 larger large ADJ istl-2455 20 28 group group NOUN istl-2455 20 29 of of ADP istl-2455 20 30 subscription subscription NOUN istl-2455 20 31 - - PUNCT istl-2455 20 32 restricted restrict VERB istl-2455 20 33 articles article NOUN istl-2455 20 34 in in ADP istl-2455 20 35 the the DET istl-2455 20 36 same same ADJ istl-2455 20 37 set set NOUN istl-2455 20 38 of of ADP istl-2455 20 39 journals journal NOUN istl-2455 20 40 . . PUNCT istl-2455 21 1 this this PRON istl-2455 21 2 should should AUX istl-2455 21 3 cancel cancel VERB istl-2455 21 4 out out ADP istl-2455 21 5 the the DET istl-2455 21 6 " " PUNCT istl-2455 21 7 self self NOUN istl-2455 21 8 selection selection NOUN istl-2455 21 9 " " PUNCT istl-2455 21 10 bias bias NOUN istl-2455 21 11 , , PUNCT istl-2455 21 12 which which PRON istl-2455 21 13 postulates postulate VERB istl-2455 21 14 that that SCONJ istl-2455 21 15 articles article NOUN istl-2455 21 16 chosen choose VERB istl-2455 21 17 for for ADP istl-2455 21 18 oa oa PRON istl-2455 21 19 tend tend VERB istl-2455 21 20 to to PART istl-2455 21 21 be be AUX istl-2455 21 22 the the DET istl-2455 21 23 higher high ADJ istl-2455 21 24 quality quality NOUN istl-2455 21 25 papers paper NOUN istl-2455 21 26 that that PRON istl-2455 21 27 would would AUX istl-2455 21 28 garner garner VERB istl-2455 21 29 more more ADJ istl-2455 21 30 citations citation NOUN istl-2455 21 31 regardless regardless ADV istl-2455 21 32 . . PUNCT istl-2455 22 1 indeed indeed ADV istl-2455 22 2 , , PUNCT istl-2455 22 3 when when SCONJ istl-2455 22 4 this this DET istl-2455 22 5 variable variable NOUN istl-2455 22 6 was be AUX istl-2455 22 7 removed remove VERB istl-2455 22 8 , , PUNCT istl-2455 22 9 the the DET istl-2455 22 10 citation citation NOUN istl-2455 22 11 advantage advantage NOUN istl-2455 22 12 disappeared disappear VERB istl-2455 22 13 . . PUNCT istl-2455 23 1 critics critic NOUN istl-2455 23 2 have have AUX istl-2455 23 3 been be AUX istl-2455 23 4 quick quick ADJ istl-2455 23 5 to to PART istl-2455 23 6 point point VERB istl-2455 23 7 out out ADP istl-2455 23 8 that that SCONJ istl-2455 23 9 the the DET istl-2455 23 10 time time NOUN istl-2455 23 11 frame frame NOUN istl-2455 23 12 for for ADP istl-2455 23 13 davis davis PROPN istl-2455 23 14 ' ' PART istl-2455 23 15 study study NOUN istl-2455 23 16 was be AUX istl-2455 23 17 short short ADJ istl-2455 23 18 , , PUNCT istl-2455 23 19 and and CCONJ istl-2455 23 20 that that SCONJ istl-2455 23 21 the the DET istl-2455 23 22 articles article NOUN istl-2455 23 23 have have AUX istl-2455 23 24 not not PART istl-2455 23 25 been be AUX istl-2455 23 26 out out ADV istl-2455 23 27 long long ADV istl-2455 23 28 enough enough ADV istl-2455 23 29 for for SCONJ istl-2455 23 30 their their PRON istl-2455 23 31 full full ADJ istl-2455 23 32 citation citation NOUN istl-2455 23 33 impact impact NOUN istl-2455 23 34 to to PART istl-2455 23 35 be be AUX istl-2455 23 36 apparent apparent ADJ istl-2455 23 37 . . PUNCT istl-2455 24 1 davis davis PROPN istl-2455 24 2 has have AUX istl-2455 24 3 indicated indicate VERB istl-2455 24 4 that that SCONJ istl-2455 24 5 his his PRON istl-2455 24 6 team team NOUN istl-2455 24 7 will will AUX istl-2455 24 8 continue continue VERB istl-2455 24 9 to to PART istl-2455 24 10 track track VERB istl-2455 24 11 the the DET istl-2455 24 12 articles article NOUN istl-2455 24 13 for for ADP istl-2455 24 14 several several ADJ istl-2455 24 15 more more ADJ istl-2455 24 16 years year NOUN istl-2455 24 17 . . PUNCT istl-2455 25 1 but but CCONJ istl-2455 25 2 even even ADV istl-2455 25 3 in in ADP istl-2455 25 4 the the DET istl-2455 25 5 follow follow VERB istl-2455 25 6 - - PUNCT istl-2455 25 7 up up ADP istl-2455 25 8 interval interval NOUN istl-2455 25 9 since since SCONJ istl-2455 25 10 the the DET istl-2455 25 11 end end NOUN istl-2455 25 12 of of ADP istl-2455 25 13 the the DET istl-2455 25 14 study study NOUN istl-2455 25 15 , , PUNCT istl-2455 25 16 the the DET istl-2455 25 17 initial initial ADJ istl-2455 25 18 conclusion conclusion NOUN istl-2455 25 19 has have AUX istl-2455 25 20 n't not PART istl-2455 25 21 been be AUX istl-2455 25 22 changed change VERB istl-2455 25 23 ( ( PUNCT istl-2455 25 24 davis davis PROPN istl-2455 25 25 2008 2008 NUM istl-2455 25 26 ) ) PUNCT istl-2455 25 27 . . PUNCT istl-2455 26 1 in in ADP istl-2455 26 2 truth truth NOUN istl-2455 26 3 , , PUNCT istl-2455 26 4 this this DET istl-2455 26 5 kind kind NOUN istl-2455 26 6 of of ADP istl-2455 26 7 citation citation NOUN istl-2455 26 8 study study NOUN istl-2455 26 9 takes take VERB istl-2455 26 10 years year NOUN istl-2455 26 11 . . PUNCT istl-2455 27 1 ideally ideally ADV istl-2455 27 2 one one PRON istl-2455 27 3 would would AUX istl-2455 27 4 track track VERB istl-2455 27 5 articles article NOUN istl-2455 27 6 for for ADP istl-2455 27 7 at at ADP istl-2455 27 8 least least ADJ istl-2455 27 9 the the DET istl-2455 27 10 " " PUNCT istl-2455 27 11 cited cite VERB istl-2455 27 12 half half ADJ istl-2455 27 13 life life NOUN istl-2455 27 14 " " PUNCT istl-2455 27 15 horizon horizon NOUN istl-2455 27 16 of of ADP istl-2455 27 17 a a DET istl-2455 27 18 given give VERB istl-2455 27 19 discipline discipline NOUN istl-2455 27 20 , , PUNCT istl-2455 27 21 which which PRON istl-2455 27 22 is be AUX istl-2455 27 23 measured measure VERB istl-2455 27 24 in in ADP istl-2455 27 25 years year NOUN istl-2455 27 26 , , PUNCT istl-2455 27 27 before before ADP istl-2455 27 28 reaching reach VERB istl-2455 27 29 a a DET istl-2455 27 30 confident confident ADJ istl-2455 27 31 conclusion conclusion NOUN istl-2455 27 32 that that SCONJ istl-2455 27 33 oa oa PRON istl-2455 27 34 does do VERB istl-2455 27 35 or or CCONJ istl-2455 27 36 does do AUX istl-2455 27 37 not not PART istl-2455 27 38 , , PUNCT istl-2455 27 39 in in ADP istl-2455 27 40 fact fact NOUN istl-2455 27 41 , , PUNCT istl-2455 27 42 affect affect VERB istl-2455 27 43 the the DET istl-2455 27 44 citation citation NOUN istl-2455 27 45 rate rate NOUN istl-2455 27 46 . . PUNCT istl-2455 28 1 the the DET istl-2455 28 2 trouble trouble NOUN istl-2455 28 3 is be AUX istl-2455 28 4 , , PUNCT istl-2455 28 5 people people NOUN istl-2455 28 6 do do AUX istl-2455 28 7 n't not PART istl-2455 28 8 want want VERB istl-2455 28 9 to to PART istl-2455 28 10 wait wait VERB istl-2455 28 11 years year NOUN istl-2455 28 12 for for SCONJ istl-2455 28 13 an an DET istl-2455 28 14 answer answer NOUN istl-2455 28 15 -policy -policy NOUN istl-2455 28 16 decisions decision NOUN istl-2455 28 17 are be AUX istl-2455 28 18 being be AUX istl-2455 28 19 made make VERB istl-2455 28 20 in in ADP istl-2455 28 21 the the PRON istl-2455 28 22 here here ADV istl-2455 28 23 and and CCONJ istl-2455 28 24 now now ADV istl-2455 28 25 . . PUNCT istl-2455 29 1 what what PRON istl-2455 29 2 researchers researcher NOUN istl-2455 29 3 are be AUX istl-2455 29 4 really really ADV istl-2455 29 5 trying try VERB istl-2455 29 6 to to PART istl-2455 29 7 measure measure VERB istl-2455 29 8 is be AUX istl-2455 29 9 the the DET istl-2455 29 10 added add VERB istl-2455 29 11 audience audience NOUN istl-2455 29 12 of of ADP istl-2455 29 13 readers reader NOUN istl-2455 29 14 that that PRON istl-2455 29 15 would would AUX istl-2455 29 16 not not PART istl-2455 29 17 otherwise otherwise ADV istl-2455 29 18 see see VERB istl-2455 29 19 these these DET istl-2455 29 20 articles article NOUN istl-2455 29 21 . . PUNCT istl-2455 30 1 the the DET istl-2455 30 2 core core ADJ istl-2455 30 3 audience audience NOUN istl-2455 30 4 for for ADP istl-2455 30 5 the the DET istl-2455 30 6 articles article NOUN istl-2455 30 7 , , PUNCT istl-2455 30 8 as as ADP istl-2455 30 9 davis davis PROPN istl-2455 30 10 notes notes PROPN istl-2455 30 11 , , PUNCT istl-2455 30 12 is be AUX istl-2455 30 13 " " PUNCT istl-2455 30 14 highly highly ADV istl-2455 30 15 associated associated ADJ istl-2455 30 16 and and CCONJ istl-2455 30 17 concentrated concentrate VERB istl-2455 30 18 among among ADP istl-2455 30 19 the the DET istl-2455 30 20 elite elite ADJ istl-2455 30 21 research research NOUN istl-2455 30 22 institutions institution NOUN istl-2455 30 23 around around ADP istl-2455 30 24 the the DET istl-2455 30 25 world world NOUN istl-2455 30 26 . . PUNCT istl-2455 30 27 " " PUNCT istl-2455 31 1 these these DET istl-2455 31 2 people people NOUN istl-2455 31 3 already already ADV istl-2455 31 4 have have VERB istl-2455 31 5 access access NOUN istl-2455 31 6 to to ADP istl-2455 31 7 the the DET istl-2455 31 8 articles article NOUN istl-2455 31 9 anyway anyway ADV istl-2455 31 10 , , PUNCT istl-2455 31 11 so so CCONJ istl-2455 31 12 the the DET istl-2455 31 13 oa oa ADJ istl-2455 31 14 variable variable NOUN istl-2455 31 15 is be AUX istl-2455 31 16 meaningless meaningless ADJ istl-2455 31 17 to to ADP istl-2455 31 18 them they PRON istl-2455 31 19 . . PUNCT istl-2455 32 1 those those PRON istl-2455 32 2 outside outside ADP istl-2455 32 3 this this DET istl-2455 32 4 core core ADJ istl-2455 32 5 audience audience NOUN istl-2455 32 6 of of ADP istl-2455 32 7 readers reader NOUN istl-2455 32 8 and and CCONJ istl-2455 32 9 authors author NOUN istl-2455 32 10 are be AUX istl-2455 32 11 an an DET istl-2455 32 12 unknown unknown ADJ istl-2455 32 13 quantity quantity NOUN istl-2455 32 14 , , PUNCT istl-2455 32 15 and and CCONJ istl-2455 32 16 may may AUX istl-2455 32 17 not not PART istl-2455 32 18 be be AUX istl-2455 32 19 publishing publish VERB istl-2455 32 20 much much ADJ istl-2455 32 21 of of ADP istl-2455 32 22 their their PRON istl-2455 32 23 own own ADJ istl-2455 32 24 , , PUNCT istl-2455 32 25 hence hence ADV istl-2455 32 26 they they PRON istl-2455 32 27 are be AUX istl-2455 32 28 not not PART istl-2455 32 29 showing show VERB istl-2455 32 30 up up ADP istl-2455 32 31 as as ADP istl-2455 32 32 additional additional ADJ istl-2455 32 33 citations citation NOUN istl-2455 32 34 in in ADP istl-2455 32 35 isi isi NOUN istl-2455 32 36 - - PUNCT istl-2455 32 37 covered cover VERB istl-2455 32 38 journals journal NOUN istl-2455 32 39 . . PUNCT istl-2455 33 1 their their PRON istl-2455 33 2 presence presence NOUN istl-2455 33 3 is be AUX istl-2455 33 4 however however ADV istl-2455 33 5 clearly clearly ADV istl-2455 33 6 evident evident ADJ istl-2455 33 7 in in ADP istl-2455 33 8 significantly significantly ADV istl-2455 33 9 higher high ADJ istl-2455 33 10 browsing browsing NOUN istl-2455 33 11 and and CCONJ istl-2455 33 12 download download NOUN istl-2455 33 13 statistics statistic NOUN istl-2455 33 14 . . PUNCT istl-2455 34 1 and and CCONJ istl-2455 34 2 to to ADP istl-2455 34 3 many many ADJ istl-2455 34 4 oa oa ADP istl-2455 34 5 advocates advocate NOUN istl-2455 34 6 , , PUNCT istl-2455 34 7 that that PRON istl-2455 34 8 is be AUX istl-2455 34 9 precisely precisely ADV istl-2455 34 10 the the DET istl-2455 34 11 point point NOUN istl-2455 34 12 : : PUNCT istl-2455 34 13 to to PART istl-2455 34 14 widen widen VERB istl-2455 34 15 the the DET istl-2455 34 16 audience audience NOUN istl-2455 34 17 for for ADP istl-2455 34 18 scholarly scholarly ADJ istl-2455 34 19 literature literature NOUN istl-2455 34 20 beyond beyond ADP istl-2455 34 21 the the DET istl-2455 34 22 traditional traditional ADJ istl-2455 34 23 confines confine NOUN istl-2455 34 24 of of ADP istl-2455 34 25 top top ADJ istl-2455 34 26 universities university NOUN istl-2455 34 27 and and CCONJ istl-2455 34 28 institutes institute NOUN istl-2455 34 29 to to PART istl-2455 34 30 include include VERB istl-2455 34 31 laypeople laypeople NOUN istl-2455 34 32 , , PUNCT istl-2455 34 33 patients patient NOUN istl-2455 34 34 , , PUNCT istl-2455 34 35 taxpayers taxpayer NOUN istl-2455 34 36 , , PUNCT istl-2455 34 37 and and CCONJ istl-2455 34 38 students student NOUN istl-2455 34 39 all all ADV istl-2455 34 40 over over ADP istl-2455 34 41 the the DET istl-2455 34 42 world world NOUN istl-2455 34 43 . . PUNCT istl-2455 35 1 counting count VERB istl-2455 35 2 citations citation NOUN istl-2455 35 3 is be AUX istl-2455 35 4 not not PART istl-2455 35 5 the the DET istl-2455 35 6 best good ADJ istl-2455 35 7 way way NOUN istl-2455 35 8 to to PART istl-2455 35 9 measure measure VERB istl-2455 35 10 this this DET istl-2455 35 11 latter latter ADJ istl-2455 35 12 impact impact NOUN istl-2455 35 13 of of ADP istl-2455 35 14 open open ADJ istl-2455 35 15 access access NOUN istl-2455 35 16 . . PUNCT istl-2455 36 1 davis davis PROPN istl-2455 36 2 and and CCONJ istl-2455 36 3 his his PRON istl-2455 36 4 colleagues colleague NOUN istl-2455 36 5 are be AUX istl-2455 36 6 to to PART istl-2455 36 7 be be AUX istl-2455 36 8 commended commend VERB istl-2455 36 9 for for ADP istl-2455 36 10 applying apply VERB istl-2455 36 11 statistical statistical ADJ istl-2455 36 12 rigor rigor NOUN istl-2455 36 13 to to ADP istl-2455 36 14 these these DET istl-2455 36 15 arguments argument NOUN istl-2455 36 16 , , PUNCT istl-2455 36 17 and and CCONJ istl-2455 36 18 letting let VERB istl-2455 36 19 the the DET istl-2455 36 20 chips chip NOUN istl-2455 36 21 fall fall VERB istl-2455 36 22 where where SCONJ istl-2455 36 23 they they PRON istl-2455 36 24 may may AUX istl-2455 36 25 . . PUNCT istl-2455 37 1 we we PRON istl-2455 37 2 may may AUX istl-2455 37 3 not not PART istl-2455 37 4 always always ADV istl-2455 37 5 like like VERB istl-2455 37 6 the the DET istl-2455 37 7 answers answer NOUN istl-2455 37 8 , , PUNCT istl-2455 37 9 but but CCONJ istl-2455 37 10 it it PRON istl-2455 37 11 is be AUX istl-2455 37 12 vital vital ADJ istl-2455 37 13 that that SCONJ istl-2455 37 14 the the DET istl-2455 37 15 questions question NOUN istl-2455 37 16 be be AUX istl-2455 37 17 asked ask VERB istl-2455 37 18 . . PUNCT istl-2455 38 1 references reference NOUN istl-2455 38 2 davis davis PROPN istl-2455 38 3 , , PUNCT istl-2455 38 4 philip philip PROPN istl-2455 38 5 m. m. PROPN istl-2455 38 6 , , PUNCT istl-2455 38 7 lewenstein lewenstein PROPN istl-2455 38 8 , , PUNCT istl-2455 38 9 bruce bruce PROPN istl-2455 38 10 v. v. PROPN istl-2455 38 11 , , PUNCT istl-2455 38 12 simon simon PROPN istl-2455 38 13 , , PUNCT istl-2455 38 14 daniel daniel PROPN istl-2455 38 15 h. h. PROPN istl-2455 38 16 , , PUNCT istl-2455 38 17 booth booth PROPN istl-2455 38 18 , , PUNCT istl-2455 38 19 james james PROPN istl-2455 38 20 g. g. PROPN istl-2455 38 21 booth booth PROPN istl-2455 38 22 , , PUNCT istl-2455 38 23 and and CCONJ istl-2455 38 24 connolly connolly ADV istl-2455 38 25 , , PUNCT istl-2455 38 26 mathew mathew PROPN istl-2455 38 27 j.l j.l PROPN istl-2455 38 28 . . PROPN istl-2455 38 29 2008 2008 NUM istl-2455 38 30 . . PUNCT istl-2455 39 1 open open ADJ istl-2455 39 2 access access NOUN istl-2455 39 3 publishing publishing NOUN istl-2455 39 4 , , PUNCT istl-2455 39 5 article article NOUN istl-2455 39 6 downloads download NOUN istl-2455 39 7 , , PUNCT istl-2455 39 8 and and CCONJ istl-2455 39 9 citations citation NOUN istl-2455 39 10 : : PUNCT istl-2455 39 11 randomised randomise VERB istl-2455 39 12 controlled control VERB istl-2455 39 13 trial trial NOUN istl-2455 39 14 . . PUNCT istl-2455 40 1 bmj bmj NOUN istl-2455 40 2 337 337 NUM istl-2455 40 3 , , PUNCT istl-2455 40 4 a568 a568 PROPN istl-2455 40 5 . . PUNCT istl-2455 41 1 [ [ X istl-2455 41 2 online online X istl-2455 41 3 ] ] PUNCT istl-2455 41 4 . . PUNCT istl-2455 42 1 available available ADJ istl-2455 42 2 : : PUNCT istl-2455 42 3 http://www.bmj.com/cgi/content/full/337/jul31_1/a568 http://www.bmj.com/cgi/content/full/337/jul31_1/a568 NOUN istl-2455 42 4 [ [ X istl-2455 42 5 accessed access VERB istl-2455 42 6 august august PROPN istl-2455 42 7 11 11 NUM istl-2455 42 8 , , PUNCT istl-2455 42 9 2008 2008 NUM istl-2455 42 10 ] ] PUNCT istl-2455 42 11 . . PUNCT istl-2455 43 1 davis davis PROPN istl-2455 43 2 , , PUNCT istl-2455 43 3 philip philip PROPN istl-2455 43 4 . . PUNCT istl-2455 43 5 2008 2008 NUM istl-2455 43 6 . . PUNCT istl-2455 44 1 comment comment NOUN istl-2455 44 2 in in ADP istl-2455 44 3 response response NOUN istl-2455 44 4 to to ADP istl-2455 44 5 kent kent PROPN istl-2455 44 6 andersen andersen PROPN istl-2455 44 7 , , PUNCT istl-2455 44 8 " " PUNCT istl-2455 44 9 open open ADJ istl-2455 44 10 access access NOUN istl-2455 44 11 does do AUX istl-2455 44 12 n't not PART istl-2455 44 13 drive drive VERB istl-2455 44 14 citations citation NOUN istl-2455 44 15 , , PUNCT istl-2455 44 16 " " PUNCT istl-2455 44 17 posted post VERB istl-2455 44 18 august august PROPN istl-2455 44 19 6 6 NUM istl-2455 44 20 , , PUNCT istl-2455 44 21 2008 2008 NUM istl-2455 44 22 , , PUNCT istl-2455 44 23 [ [ X istl-2455 44 24 online online NOUN istl-2455 44 25 ] ] PUNCT istl-2455 44 26 . . PUNCT istl-2455 45 1 available available ADJ istl-2455 45 2 : : PUNCT istl-2455 45 3 http://scholarlykitchen.sspnet.org/2008/07/31/open-access-doesnt-drive-citations/ http://scholarlykitchen.sspnet.org/2008/07/31/open-access-doesnt-drive-citations/ PROPN istl-2455 45 4 [ [ X istl-2455 45 5 accessed access VERB istl-2455 45 6 august august PROPN istl-2455 45 7 7 7 NUM istl-2455 45 8 , , PUNCT istl-2455 45 9 2008 2008 NUM istl-2455 45 10 ] ] PUNCT istl-2455 45 11 . . PUNCT istl-2455 46 1 previous previous ADJ istl-2455 46 2 contents content NOUN istl-2455 46 3 next next ADV