p^s* - 3 ^V HUGH BLACK (QattteU Mniuerfiitji ffitbrarg 3tt)aia, Krm fork Kjey. P.U.Luce. Date Due ^ ' Cornell University Library " arW37589 Work, 3 1924 031 786 902 olin,anx Cornell University Library The original of tiiis book is in tine Cornell University Library. There are no known copyright restrictions in the United States on the use of the text. http://www.archive.org/cletails/cu31924031786902 By THE SAME AUTHOR FRIENDSHIP O O O CULTURE AND RESTRAINT IDLENESS AND WORK IN some moods there are few things more irritating than a panegyric of work and a denunciation of idleness ; for to workers it seems hke beating the air so far as they are concerned. They are inclined to think that those who speak most eloquently in praise of work, as if labor were a luxury, are usually people who know little of its burden. Still there is no subject which has more right to be considered, since there is no single subject which fills so large a space in the lives of most. We may object that we have no choice in the matter, and no need for encourage- ment or reproof. We at least have the spur of necessity, which would soon prick our side if we tried to dispense with what is our lot. It might seem also as if it 9 IDLENESS AND WORK A../^^e=a??^?=^ could be said with some truth that idle- ness is not a very glaring fault of our race, that our country compared with some others is a perfect hive of industry, and that many among us suffer from over- work rather than underwork. It may be worth while considering the subject, though all this be true, and though we ourselves be even desperately industrious ; for is it not the case that the false and foolish standard is set up in society which almost looks upon it as a disgrace to work, or at least makes idleness an ideal ? If we search for it we may find it in some corner of our own heart. Many work hard with little thought either of the nobility or the meaning of work, but only to get rich so that some fine day they too may be able to be idle. In spite of our activities we may hanker after what we conceive to be the paradise of idleness. The ultimate ambition in our minds is to be freed from the neces- sity of work, as if work and not idleness 10 IDLENESS AND WORK ■were the evil. We do not value work for its own sake, but think of it as a disa- greeable necessity. The common social ideal is certainly a life of ease and pleEisure, not a life of work and service. Society among us seems to be carefully graded in inverse proportion according to the amount of leisure enjoyed. We know how " Society '" looks down on trade and business, the industry which alone makes it possible for them to live at all ; and as for manual labor, that is another hemisphere ! If we do value business, it is for its returns, its profits, not for the honest employ- ment which trains body and mind and develops character. This is not just the ignorant contempt of a select class ; it has permeated all classes, so that to climb the social ladder means getting rid of work. Burton gives a chapter full of his quaint and pedantic learning about exercise, quoting the wisdom of the ancients as to the necessity of labor for 11 AND health of body and mind, citing Seneca and Xenophon, the practice of the Egyptians of old, Jews, Turks, and then he draws the contrast in irony : " But amongst us the badge of gentry is idle- ness, — - to be of no calling, not to labor, for that ^s derogatory to their birth ; to be a mere spectator, a drone." This ideal affects the whole social organism, and influences the thought and conduct of all. Some of us, who are very diligent and industrious, have the makings of pretty fair specimens of the sluggard in us, since our hearts are set on that as the great end of life. Certainly, one of the commonest modern ideals is that of no work, or as near that as possible. This does not refer to the demands of some sections to have more leisure, which will give at least op- portunities for fuller self-education. Some of these demands are just enough in a civilized community, and must be granted where practicable. The reference is to 12 IDLENESS AND WORK the ideal to be found in all classes, which looks upon toil as only an evil, and which has lost the old moral dignity of labor. This false ideal has cut deep. We find it in literature and in religion. A good many books have been written to show what Utopian life on this earth would be, and they are almost all spoiled by mak- ing work an evil thing, to be got rid of as much as possible. The objection is often made against any form of socialism that nobody would be found willing to do the necessary lower forms of work needed by society. It is a very poor objection. If that were the only objection to socialism, some of us would have little diificulty in believing in it. There are in our midst men and women cheerfully taking upon themselves burdens, and bending their necks to duties, from which they could easily escape. It is incredible that in any state of society the spirit of Christ will die out. Men are this day serving Him faithfully 13 ID LENESS AND WORK as hewers of wood and drawers of water, doing for their daily task what the world calls lower work, and who might well be envied for their content of mind and largeness of soul. A stronger objection to socialist ideals is precisely the opposite, that they make too much of the mere ex- ternals of life. It is assumed too often that man can live by bread alone. Most of the ideals for perfect human life and society have this flaw. The notion of happiness is like that described in such books as Lord Lytton's The Coming Race, where social and political felicity is made to consist of having all they need. The motto of their lives is, They were born ; they were happy ; they died. There is no stimulus of want, no goad of poverty, no fierce rivalry. We pray for the time when there will be no want and less rivalry, but never for the time when men will be above effort. Was there not a philosopher who thought that the earth was turning into a bun, and the sea into 14 DLENESS AND WORK lemonade, that mankind might be happy without effort ? Some kinds of work are evil because of unhealthy surroundings or fierce competi- tion, but work must have a place in all schemes to ameliorate the race. Work is needed to attain moral progress, and to conserve it when attained. There is noth- ing more astonishing on this earth of ours than the spectacle of some who do not know how to kill time — so long as there are thorns and thistles of various kinds to keep down. And there is nothing more pathetic than that of others, willing to work and unable to find a place where to use a spade or handle a tool. There is something wrong somewhere, which it behoves us to put right, when these two classes exist. The subject of this book is, however, not a discussion of economic problems, but the more personal one of our actual work, with its claims on us and its lessons for us. This subject of personal duty is 15 I DLENESS A ND WORK distinct from the larger question of social rearrangement and schemes for the reor- ganization of labor, by which fervent re- formers hope to bring in a condition of society in which labor will be more fairly apportioned and the fruits of labor be more equably distributed. We are here not concerned with criticising the present state of industry, or criticising the proj- ects of reformers. Such larger consider- ations do affect the subject, since we are all influenced for good and evil by the social .state in which we are placed. In- dustrial conditions immensely aflFect the individual worker. But our subject is a primary one, and simpler, if narrower, than such economic discussions. It is the personal duty incumbent on each in this or any other order of society. Here we have our feet on fact, and are not just treading the air vaguely, as is so often the case in dealing with the more gran- diose questions about an ideally perfect social reconstruction. We do not need 16 IDLENESS AND WORK ^f'J.W to wait till society has been transformed by social reformers before we can have a school for character. The school is here, and the door is open. The labor market, as we know it to-day, is some- times a rough and stern teacher, but it has valuable lessons to enforce, and it is a duty we owe to ourselves to submit our- selves to the discipline. A further instance of the prevalence of the false ideal is seen in the way it even colors religious thought. Many treat the work and service of life as a painful necessity in order to qualify for the Rest that rcmaincth, and look forward to a millennium of ease and not to a millen- nium of holiness. It is of a piece with the offence taken at Christ's birth and home and occupation. The Jews sneered at the Nazarite, and the Nazarites sneered at the Carpenter. Every class has its prejudices, and men could not easily rid their minds of a natural prejudice against 17 y^mff^ IDLENESS AND WORK a provincial tradesman as a teacher of re- ligion. Celsus, who wrote the first great polemic against Christianity, made it one of his objections that Christ had worked with His own hands. It was a natural objection to a learned philosopher, who did not enter into the heart of the faith, and who, therefore, could not see the bearing of the strange fact. Even many defenders of the faith have stumbled at the same thing, and seem to think it unworthy of their Lord to have ever appeared in such a humble guise. The Apochryphal gospels, for example, show Christ above work and worry, doing everything miraculously even when a child. The moral dignity and the spiritual power of the simple gospel story are lost in the stilted artificial divinity, which good men with the best will in the world attributed to the Master. The mediae- val stories and legends which gathered round Christ have many of them the same fatal misapprehension. In the 18 i t j>^ IDLENESS AND WORK miracle-play introduced into Longfellow's Golden Legend this is seen. In one scene the boy Jesus is at play with His school-mates by the river-side, where their game was to make sparrows out of clay. Jesus claps His hands, and the clay sparrows become real birds and fly away singing. These mistakes of friends and enemies of the faith are due to fail- ure to apprehend the deep bearing of what wc call Christ's humiliation. We fail utterly if we do not see that common work has been sanctified by Him, and common duty hallowed. He has taken away the curse from work by His life, as well as the curse of sin by His death. It is remarkable how St. Paul exalts the common duties of daily life — all the more remarkable because he was by nature open to the high enthusiasms which usually neglect, if not despise, the humbler things of practical life. He never lets his mystical raptures and religious fervor cut him off from the 19 DLENESS AND WO RK mm ordinary world of work and duty. Rather, he lifts this up to a plane where the highest motives rule. He links the humblesb life to the loftiest spiritual thoughts, and reinforces plain duty by unearthly sanctions. It shames us to see how he ennobles the meanest tasks, the work of a slave, for example, not content with calling it useful and necessary work, but exalting it as truly spiritual. He never despised manual labor, according to the social standard of his time, and even of our own time. He knew too well what it could do for a man, as he worked at his own trade in the intervals of other labors. Perhaps, too, he felt that it brought him into a great succes- sion when he remembered that his Lord had been a carpenter ! He knew the value of steady, honest work, and was never more severe in his judgments than when condemning those who neglected work on the plea of religion. The heathen world gave honor to certain 20 DLENESS kinds of work, that of government and war, intellectual work, and even the laborious training of the athletes to fit themselves for the great games, but man- ual labor was classed by them as servile, and that meant work fit only for slaves. They of course recognized that it was necessary in order to keep society going, but it had no honor on that account, but only contempt. It was looked upon as taking away from human dignity, un- worthy of a free man. St. Paul insisted that instead of a man being lowered by his work he was raised by it in manhood, growing in character and even in grace, if it were done honestly and faithfully. The common callings of humble life are taken as of God's appointment, a test of conscience and an open way to character. The false standard of life also widens the cleavase between different classes of the community. The foolish envy of idleness creates bitterness among the 21 'y> Idleness and work iiiM-i.-j-i-fii workers, and it has to be confessed that the frivolous work of idlers gives ground for the bitterness. The envy is foolish, whatever we may say about the worse than folly of selfish idleness. Richard Jefferies in one of his sketches tells of meeting three women field-workers. He en- vied them and thought their health ideal. What would he not give to be like them ? " There was that in their cheeks that all the wealth of London could not purchase, a superb health in their carriage prin- cesses could not obtain.^' But he could see plainly that they regarded him with bitter envy, jealousy, and hatred written in their eyes. They cursed him in their hearts, simply because they worked and he seemed to be idle. Because he did not appear to be doing any visible work, they hated and envied him ; and he who knew both lives would have gladly ex- changed places to get their unwearied step, and to be always in the open air and abroad upon the earth. 22 ^'>^;(^ :b..- >. THE MORAL NEED OF WORK open the eyes of outsiders if they knew. Motives such as ambition may come in, but behind it there is that need of work to make them and keep them strong and true men. All of us, at least theoretically, admit the value of work to redeem life. It gives purpose and meaning of a sort, if it does not give dignity. Even when work is selfish in its motive, or when it is forced by necessity and not by will, it still carries with it a certain purifying and steadying power. As Carlyle taught his generation : " Idleness alone is with- out hope. There is endless hope in work were it even work at making money." Amid all his lamentation he felt that the hope for England lay in the fact that it was peopled by a noble, silent, working people, who only needed to be wisely led to spend their busy practical genius on worthy objects. There is a moral danger of idleness even to good people, making them undis- 75 THE MORAL NEED OF WORK I f^ ciplined and fussy, easily taken up with petty things. St. Paul wrote in indigna- tion to the Thessalonians, when he heard that some of them had given up their ordinary employments in the intensity of their religious feelings, " When we were with you, this we commanded you that if any would not work neither should he eat." Even in the interests of so-called religion, to break off from the common task and lot of man meant disorder and unrest and all manner of evils. The express purpose of giving up work was to prepare by quiet contemplation for the coming of their Lord, but strangely enough the means taken for attaining that purpose defeated itself. It was found that those who gave up their ordinary occupations, instead of becom- ing more prayerful, and more peaceful in their faith, became busybodies, meddling with other people's business, flighty and unsettled in their ways, a public nuisance to their quiet neighbors who were doing 75 Ee THE MORAL NEED OF WORK' their own immediate duty. It is one of life's little ironies that this should be so, and yet we see how naturally it comes about. Having freed themselves from the restraint and discipline of common work, they only became more unsettled in their habits. Though their special de- sign was to have more opportunity to grow more truly quiet in heart and life, the practical result was that thev neither became quiet themselves nor would allow other people to be quiet. They became censorious of others, whose holiness was questioned since they went on with the customary fulfilment of duty. Apart from the subtle temptation which his- tory shows us awaits all such attempts to reach sanctity by retirement from daily common work, there are many pressing temptations from the mere idleness. St. Paul knew well that all sorts of moral disorders would arise from such a state of affairs ; as the old couplet which was instilled into us in our childhood has it 77 iTHE MORAL NEED OF WORK with more truth than poetry, " Satan finds some mischief still for idle hands to do " — to say nothing of idle tongues ! Idle- ness and fussiness indeed are commonly seen together. If we have not found how to possess our soul amid all the duties of life, we will never find the secret by merely resigning from the place of duty. It is not to be supposed that the chief moral value of work is a negative one in guarding against evil. It is a positive necessity also in developing good. Work is a great instrument for the discipline of character which we cannot afford to forego, and this discipline is not confined to some special sort of work such as that specially designated religious. It refers to the ordinary duties and common tasks of our daily occupation, the zeal and energy and alertness and honesty and uprightness of our business, the spirit in which we work, the manner in which we get through our days. Spiritually it 78 SEl MORAL NEED OF WORK makes little difference what our work is ; it is the manner of our doing it. A scav- enger may be a truer public servant than a cabinet minister. It is of course well to seek the most suitable spheres of action for our particu- lar capacities, and well that our work should be congenial and in keeping with the bent of our inclination, if only be- cause we will then do much better and lasting work. There is always a danger when men do not find pleasure in their everyday work ; for there arises a con- stant tendency to seek pleasure elsewhere, a pleasure which is not so pure and whole- some. But the moral value of work does not depend on pleasure. Even when it seems against the grain, if it be the fruit of an ennobling sense of duty it brings its own reward. There are men in busi- ness, whose tastes lie entirely in something else, who yet feel morally bound to it through responsibility for others; and it has been a discipline of character which 7.Q H^T^-j } THE MORAL NEED OF WORK has made men of them. After all, the important thing is not the kind of work a man does, but its effect on life and character. We often think that if we only had a more suitable sphere, if we were rid of some limitations with which we are ham- pered, our lives and our work would be better ; and sometimes we even fear that we have mistaken our vocation. This is often just a selfish longing or the craving of personal ambition. With other oppor- tunities we might make more of our lives for our profit, but it does not follow that we would make more of them for the higher ends of existence. " I have wasted my life in laboriously doing nothing at all," said Hugh Grotius, the great Dutch jurist, historian, and theologian. That was only the true soul of the man coming out, but even if by any chance he could have made more of his life in some other sphere it does not follow that it would be a better life. Any life which is spent 80 wii^dkm, laboriously in service cannot be wasted. To the very best and worthiest such a fear of having mistaken his vocation can come, Isaiah makes even the ideal ser- vant of God exclaim, "I have labored in vain ; I have spent my strength for nought and in vain." But in spite of that feeling, just because his work was done truly and sincerely he was able to continue, "yet surely my judgment is with the Lord, and my work with my God." When speaking of the moral duty of labor we are met with a further theo- retical difficulty which arises chiefly be- cause of the subdivision and specialization in all modern industry. Culture, we are assured, is only possible to those who are not dragged into the narrowing condition of being compelled to do a special kind of work. It is true that there is a cul- ture from which the ordinary worker is shut out, the sweetness and light which come from an extended knowledge of literature and art, the refinement of in- 6 81 1 THE MORAL NEED OF WORK« S^iiiir:MSiito'u.^iiiiii.wffy-"'f;ii tellect and taste. But that after all is only on the surface of life, the polishing of an instrument. The culture of char- acter and the culture of soul are not confined to any such select class, and indeed moral strength and true wisdom will be found among the unlettered as often as among the highly educated ; for character is produced from the ordinary materia] of life by the common tasks and the daily duties. God does not give us character, He gives us only time ; He does not give us results, but only opportunities. The yoke of work is not merely a moral preservative, but is also an occa- sion for growth in gracious life. Faith- lessness here not only opens the door to evils we would have avoided, but also deprives us of good. Sloth is one of the seven deadly sins labelled by the Church ; for it is recognized as one of the great sources of mischief — " the Devil's cush- ion," as an old writer calls it, inducing 82 y €^ WEEl THE MORAL NEED OF WORK rust of mind and depravity of soul to all who fall victims to it. Its danger lies in what we lose through it, as well as what we suffer. An aimless, useless life brings at the end poverty of soul, with no work of faith and patience of hope and labor of love meeting their harvest and their harvest joy. The slack hands tend to the empty heart, with enough sense of need to desire but nothing to .satisfy. "Have a lust for thine own work and thou shalt be safe," said St. Hermas, and many have been able to add their testimony to the safety given by a love of work. When ac- cepted as part of the moral law it does much more than offer safety from temp- tations ; for it brings new sanctions and a new motive. Industry from this point of view be- comes just another name for conscience. Without this moral sense we so easily fritter away our strength, and squander our time, and have nothing left for our 83 AL^^fStlii?^ ^jO 5''^C? j THE MORAL NEED OF WORK work but the dregs of our power. Con- science has been abused by being limited to speculative difficulties about right and wrong, the settling of questions of cas- uistry. It too often has lost its relation to actual and common life. We need more conscience put into our daily work, and in this connection conscience is sim- ply industry. Some men of delicate, re- fined conscience in matters of abstract morality are traitors to it in their every- day work. If we are not making our work a discipline for our character, if it has no moral contents to us, our dili- gence will be barren of real fruit. The true nobility of life is honest, earnest service, the strenuous exercise of our fac- ulties, with conscience in our work as in the sight of God who gives us our place and our tools and our work. 84 nnHE virtue of a man ought to he meas^i-red, not hy his extraordinary exertions, but by his everyday conduct. — Pascal. ^ THE DUTY OF WORK IT might seem unnecessary to speak of duty in this connection. We are held in the grip of a great physi- cal necessity, and to the great major- ity at least there is no reprieve. What is gained by proving that we ought to work from a sense of duty, since we do work, and some suffer from excessive labor .'' We have got to work, and that seems an end of it. This feeling is nat- ural, especially to those who carry a heavy load. But we might as well say, Why speak of life ? — we have got to live, and that is an end of it ; or of death .'' — we have got to die, and that is an end of it. True, we have got to live and to die, but everything depends on how we live and die. So, we have got to work (most of us), but everything 87 depends on how we work. There is vast difference between blindly doing a thing which is necessary and understanding the reasons why it is necessary. We surely should have some intelligent grasp of such a universal fact as work, and be able to bring to bear on it noble motives. Even though we imagine it will not make much difference to the work, it will make a difference to the worker if his motive and spirit be high or low. For example, if we work as a matter of rou- tine into which we were pushed when young and which we carry on mechani- cally, or if our only thought is to get a living or to make money, these are all different from working from a sense of duty or for the sake of love. It is true that the man who works even from a lower motive is better than the man who will not bestir himself, and who looks upon himself as unfortunate because the plums do not fall ripe into his open mouth, and who hopes to catch larks if 88 THE OF WORK the heavens will only oblige him by fall- ing. The one has some notion of cause and effect, and the other is living in a false world without a glimpse of moral law. So, in like manner the man who works from a high motive enters a region shut to him who may work as hard or harder, but who has no vision of the inner meaning of things. Further, there is another temptation which makes such a subject useful, the temptation to consider our work as out- side of our moral life. To many, work is looked on as just a means of gaining a livelihood, and the real life begins where that ends. The result is that men live in sections, with a compartment for religion, and one for business, and one for home and social relations. This is responsible for much false thinking and false living, and is responsible for many of the incon- sistencies in good men which puzzle the world and grieve the Church. It is not merely a failure of religion, failure to 89 THE DUTY OF WORK bring religion down to the details of busi- ness, but it is a failure to see that busi- ness and work are an essential sphere of religion. Work to many is done to get the wherewithal to live, instead of being, as it should be, itself an appointed man- ner of living, one of the activities of our inner life. How common, for example, it is for men to think that when they have made a living they can then devote them- selves to higher things ! Plato in the Republic has two lines of dialogue illus- trative of this. "Have you heard of the saying of Phocylides, that as soon as a man has a livelihood he should practise virtue ? " " Nay, he said, I think that he had better begin somewhat sooner." The true view of our livelihood is to use it as a .sphere for developing virtue. A man's character is often made or marred by how he approaches his daily work ; and his character is certainly revealed by the spirit in which his work is done. We 90 THE DUTY OF WORK are just the raw material out of which men are made. We have to undergo the process of making ; we have to submit to the discipHne that fashions us to higher ends ; and our daily work is an approved instrument for this purpose. It is an important part of the great moral train- ing, how important we can see by think- ing of the large place in our lives our ordinary work takes up. It is absurd to think that we can cut this out from the region of moral duty without serious loss. The first element then is the duty to ourselves, not merely to gain an honest subsistence and earn our living as we say, but to gain our moral character, and come under the sweep of the forces that help to make men. Thus we must ac- cept duty not for the sake of what we can get or even give, but what we can also become. To attain any great end men willingly submit to the discipline designed to achieve it. The athlete un- 91 liM THE DUTY OF WORK dergoes the long and strict regime ap- proved for his special training. The scholar can only become such by one way, and there is no royal road to learn- ing. The great end of character must also be pursued by submitting to daily discipline ; and work accepted as part of moral training lifts the whole life to a higher level. To achieve this, work must not be done perfunctorily as if it did not matter much how it was done, or as a disagreeable physical necessity, but must be looked on consistently as a means to a moral end. It is not possible to do justice to all the rich contents of such discipline. It has of course, as we have seen, a negative value in warding off many evils, clearing the mind of temptations, filling up an otherwise empty life with occupations and good habits. But there are posi- tive blessings in the building of a stead- fast character. By the very compulsion against which we often kick we learn 92 THE DUTY OF WORK Cl:: what obligation is, since we are brought face to face with the idea of must, which should also lead us to the idea of ou^ht : and that is a lesson which is cheaply got at almost any price. We learn our limi- tations and the limitations of our lot ; and the first important step in the mas- tery of life, as in the mastery of any art, is to accept the essential limitations. The discipline of our daily work should breed in us habits of self-restraint, pa- tience, faithfulness, obedience to law, an ordered life. Even in a lot of drudgery there are possible some valuable personal virtues, such as integrity of mind, a real independence in what seems a hopelessly dependent state, generosity, and helpful- ness. We cannot overlook the fact also that strength of character can be pro- duced by the untoward circumstances enforced on a man against his will and desire. A narrow corner of life, when possessed by a supreme sense of duty, may be an opportunity for a larger and 9S deeper moral achievement than would be likely in a spacious lot under the sun- shine of smiling fortune. Thus from this high point of view, our daily work is first of all a duty to self, for the sake of one's own character and the discipline of life. Another great and all-embracing prin- ciple which we cannot forget without hurting the best quality of our work is that it should be also a duty to our fellows. Our work must in some way be related to what St. Paul calls " brotherly love." In Thessalonica Paul was con- fronted by a section of his converts refusing to work through what they con- sidered spiritual exaltation, giving them- selves up to fervid expectations about our Lord's coming. It was not fit, they thought, that they should be wasting their time and strength on the trivial tasks by which they earned their bread when they might be devoting themselves to what seemed more religious duties. 94 ps'x ./^ THE DUTY OF WORK The results were as might be expected. For one thing, it meant that those who ceased working became a charge on the rest of the Church. They were a nuisance to their industrious brethren and a tax on their good nature and their faith. St. Paul sternly denounces their conduct, and at the same time states one of the principles by which he elevates the whole subject of marfs work. He points out bluntly that if they are not working they are living off others. It simply means that they are a burden on those who are humbly going on with their or- dinary duties. So, the principle he states as in itself sufficient to justify work is love of the brethren. It is a duty to them to take their share of the bur- dens of life and not to hamper others needlessly. His appeal for industry is : " Touching brotherly love, we beseech you that ye do your own business and work with your own hands, that ye may walk honestly towards them that are 95 THE DUTY OF WORK without and that ye may have lack of nothing." No amount of sanctity which might conceivably be attained by such abdication of the duty of work could make up for the selfishness of throwing the burden of their support on their fellows. This is the condemnation of the whole monastic system which grew to such proportions in the Roman Church. The holiness reached thus by casting an extra load on others is at bottom sel- fishness, however religiously disguised. Christian independence is the other side of Christian charity. Charity has rights as well as duties, and it is the right of charity to demand that it be not called on needlessly and wilfully. It is a shame for Christians to shut up their hearts against need ; but it is no less a shame to impose on others. True brotherly love is the cure for both of these sins. Love opens hand and heart ; and love will not cast a needless burden on the brethren. 96 THE DUTY OF WORK However laborious it be, there is no honor in merely selfish work, designed only to grasp and get and keep. Work needs to be touched by the romance of love to redeem it from ultimate barren- ness. There is a great deal of nonsense talked about the dignity of labor, often by men who have never worked hard enough to know the weariness and pain of too much labor. Work does carry with it the dignity of at least a measure of independence, and brings the satisfac- tion of a piece of work done to the best of one's ability, and is a safeguard from many an evil; but in itself it has no such intrinsic beauty as is sometimes claimed for it. It all depends on its motive and its spirit. The work which has no other end than to make money, for example, is not a thing of dignity, even although it brings some benefits in its train. The toil also, that is done in soulless stupefy- ing fashion from pure necessity, is not a thing to rejoice over as a tribute to the 7 97 nobility of humanity. We will never have right ideas of social duty tiU we recognize that work may be too hard and may bend hearts as well as backs too sorely, as in Burns's description of the cottars, Wha drudge and drive, thro' wet and dry Wi' never-ceasing toil. Labor which is only labor is vanity and vexation of spirit. In the last issue it is only love that gives labor worth. This is true even in the lowest and commonest spheres. To raise work above grossness, to take the sting out of its curse, the thought of working for othei's must come in. It must be done for love of others. Other- wise, it is only soulless drudgery, or grasp- ing materialism. Toil the most untiring is a poor thing, if it is only inspired by mammon worship, or some other form of self-aggrandizement. On the other hand many a life, which has had little 98 success and seemingly little joy, has won dignity because the inner source of all its activity has been love. The strong must bear the burdens of the weak, willingly, lovingly, joyfully. St. Paul's noble boast in his farewell address to the elders of Ephesus touches on this motive as an inevitable principle of Christian duty : " Ye yourselves know that these hands have ministered unto my necessities and to them that were with me. I have showed you how that so laboring ye ought to support the weak." After all, much of the world's work is done for love, for wife and children, for the aged, the frail, and the sick. It is the divine tax levied on strength. The true and only dignity of labor is that it be done for love. But this motive has not carried us far if it only takes us the length of enduring work for the sake of kith and kin. When we say that work is a duty for the sake of others, we mean a larger and wider re- 99 THE DUTY OF WORK lationshjp. The Christian motive tran- scends the ties of blood, and family, and friendship. So work is a duty to society, and not merely to a few individuals. We owe all we have and are to our fellows, and the only way we have of paying the debt is to take our share of the burden. An English statesman called the wealthy idlers the " dangerous classes," and it is true in every sense ; for they are the great argument for socialism ; they do more to unsettle the minds of workers than all socialist propagandists put to- gether ; and with their luxury and self- indulgence they lower the tone of the whole of society, and corrupt the life of the country, making it weak in the time of trial. The unemployed classes are the dangerous classes at both ends of the scale. Men cannot be idle with safety either to themselves or to the community. We want a higher ideal of social duty and social honor, till all will admit the dis- honor of offering no sort of service what- 100 t' THE DUTY OF WORK ever to the common weal. We need to accept the social obligation to take our share of the world's work. One element of the duty of work is simply the duty of sacrifice. It means making a contribution of some sort to the good of the whole body politic, giving a real service to others by bending to the burden of all. Work is a practical acceptance of the truth that no man liveth to himself, and that a self-centred life is a social offence. It applie.s also to the quality of our work, its faithfulness and honesty and trustworthiness. Shoddy work is not only a wrong to a man's own personal integrity, hurting his character ; but also it is a wrong to society. Truthfulness in work is as much demanded as truthfiilness in speech. False and sham work of every kind is a sin against brotherly love ; for somebody suffers for it somehow. We never can tell who must suffer, as when a ship springs a leak through badly 101 'f: THE DUTY OF WORK driven rivets, or when cheapness is got bj adulterating food. Truthfuhiess in work applies all round and in all sorts of work. Some men will steal their master's time who would never steal his money ; but perfect honesty has a wider sweep than the narrow limits of our common ethics. Carlyle was fond of the phrase the Chivalry of labor, by which he meant his vision of the time when the leaders of industry would be captains in the true sense, organizing labor to fight against need and poverty ; and the workers be joined to them by something stronger than cash-payment. What is this Chivalry of labor but just a restatement of the Christian motive of brotherly love ? Are there any problems in the industrial world which could not be solved by the patient application of that principle? Are there any difficulties so insuperable that they could not be removed by Christian brotherly love .'' 102 THE DUTY OF WORK This is not a counsel of perfection, a thing in the clouds which cannot concern us practically. All our lives come into touch with other lives at some point or other. There is no one who cannot ren- der some service or other to his fellows. It only needs that we each should consider that our conduct is ever affecting some. It only needs that we take our life seriously as a high opportunity, and that we should let the thought of service sink into our hearts, redeeming our lives from selfishness, and making them the service of God and of our brethren. Selfish labor is cursed with futility. It cannot even bring happi- ness when there is no love in it. Goethe makes Faust begin his researches in the magic which brought on the tragedy of his life, because he realized that all his previous labor and learning were useless and gave him no peace of mind. He had studied laboriously, explored philosophy and science and law and medicine, poured over deep theology, but all he knew or 103 THlT DUTYT>F WORK thought he knew seemed unmeaning to him, because he had lost the hope and the desire to instruct and elevate mankind. It is a true touch. Philosophy, and law, and medicine, and science, and theology, and all work whatsoever, are barren without this human relation. They must all be learned and practised for the sake of others. When they lose their contact with life, they grow false, and bring no saLisfaction even to the mind of the learner or worker. This thought of duty to others opens up the region in which work must be done if it is to be of any account. Brotherly love must be one of the motives : it must be done as service. That is the true dignity of labor and the Chivalry of labor, done with conscience because done as in the sight of God, and done with grace because done for others, and done with delight because done for love. When we look upon our daily tasks as playing a part, however humble, in the great common- 104 THE DUTY OF WORK r; wealth, as our contribution to the world, they are lighted up with a new light. Common household duties, the routine of shop or office or mill, the market-place, the student's desk, the physician's round, all cease to be meaningless drudgery, and are all turned into something passing rich and rare when they are transmuted into a labor of love. At the end of life we shall not be asked how much pleasure we had in it, but how much service we gave in it ; not how full it was of success, but how full it was of sacrifice ; not how happy we were, but how helpful we were ; not how ambition was gratified, but how love was served. Life is judged by love ; and love is known by her fruits. Further, we cannot overestimate the dynamic introduced by the thought of a vocation in life, when a man grasps the situation with both his hands. When duty inspires our ordinary occupations and business, we feel that we are called to 105 THE DUTY OF WORK do this as truly as ever prophet was called to preach ; and so our duty to self in this matter runs into our duty to God. This is the third strand in the lope. The Christian religion thus ennohles the whole subject of work, cames it higher and further as not only duty to our own best selves and as duty to others, but also as duty to God. It is this alone that introduces the element of vocation into our lives, something we are meant to do and to be. We hold our gifts and our capacities from God. Nothing but the power of Christian sentiment is sufficient to make us submit to the self-discipline which we know to be necessary for true working. It alone sets before us the highest motive for action. When con- duct is governed by love to God and to man it gets a force to which no other is comparable. Christian principle in these three lines of duty can alone control the self-inter- ested motives which otherwise would rule 106 The duty of work supreme in the actual conditions of life. When we come to see how faithfulness in duty relates us not only to our fellow- men but to God, we come to see that work is not just a physical necessity, not merely a part of the painful lot of man, but part of the privilege. And the idler, the selfish man, the man who thinks only of himself and lives only for himself, is self-condemned. As a duty which ^ve owe to God who gave us our opportunities, work is an obligation resting on every man. If we have no need to work for a living, there is all the more obligation to offer our service to the public good in other ways. Leism-e is an invalu- able gift to a man who accepts his life sacredly, and who is inspired with a sense of duty to God. What splendid examples we have had, and have, in our own country of men giving their energies to unrecompensed work in social, phil- anthropic, and religious activity. The mainspring of such devotion has been a ]07 THE DUTY OF WORK sense of duty to God, inspiring conse- crated service. To feel the full weight of this motive we need only compaie it with many of the ends which men set before themselves as the inspiring object of all their labor. The commonest of all motives of work in our commercial days is the making of money. That is a legitimate motive enough so far as it goes ; but we have to ask the question if it is adequate. In questioning its worth we are going deeper than merely reminding ourselves of the un- stable tenure by which we hold all riches, or of its powerlessness to buy love or cheat death, its impotence before the rude shocks that strike the heart of man. We are asking ourselves if it can be called an ade- quate motive for beings endowed as we are, if we can be satisfied with the net result of a life dignified by no higher purpose. The life itself can be poverty- stricken though the means of living abound. All other selfish motives of la- 108 ■$' 't THE DUTY OF WORK bor are cursed with the same vanity, whether it be the thirst for fame or repu- tation, or to found a family, the pathetic under-current of motive of some of Sir Walter Scott's abundant labors, or any other of the common aims of men. Many of these motives are intermixed with much good. Even the mere money-grubber may have visions of the supposed happi- ness the fruit of his toil will give to those he loves. But how futile it all is to give grace or beauty to life ! The spiritual light thrown by religious duty is needed to redeem work from meanness and from ultimate fatuity. The great moral education of life is open to us all, if we will put duty before pleasure, and if we will look upon our whole lot in life as a school of divine discipline. It is futile to attempt to live in sections, separating business from religion and work from faith. If, as we bow our neck to the yoke of duty, we are sure that it is appointed us of God, we 109 THE DUTY OF WORK will move towards high ends. What has been sown in the long years of labor is reaped in a gain to character. This high doctrine of duty is alone worthy of us, difficult though it be, and alone will make our lives noble. Even when achieved in weariness, when the tired soul would fain lay down the burden, nothing will so renew the strength like the thought of duty. We are perhaps complaining of the drudgery of our life, longing for a larger lot with more of the world's pleasure in it, with more of the uplifting of success, with more beauty and joy and freedom. We say — I am so tired, so tired of rigid duty. So tired of all my tired hands find to do, I yearn, I faint for some of life's free beauty. The loose beads with no straight string running through. Yet we know that to give our life mean- ing and value it needs that straight string of duty, and we know that to be false 110 ONE of the many Proverbs which inculcate industry does it by con- trast between actual labor and mere talk, between the man who works steadily, honestly, seriously, and the man of flighty and indolent nature copious of suggestions and criticisms, who will not put his hand to any definite task. " In all labor there is profit : but the talk of the lips tendeth only to penury." There is a talk which is work, when behind it is the toil of brain and heart. Indeed, the highest and the hardest kind of work in the world might be classed among that of talk, the work of teacher whether by speech or by writing. But we need very little experience of the world and of men to enable us to appreciate the irony of the contrast between the worker and the 115 THE FRUITS talker. We know the man with brilliant suggestions and acute criticisms and end- less projects, but with never an ounce of practical result. He spends all his en- ergy in talk, and always means to be doing but never does. The man of the- ories and promises and words is known to us all — theories without practice, prom- ises without fulfilment, words without work. The futility of this strikes us, as it struck the old proverb-maker. In- dustry of any kind he could honor, but this industry of the tongue merely tired him, as it tires us. Talk ! Talk will not plough fields and gather harvests, will not build houses and ships, will not carry on business and provide for the needs of life. When we say that in labor there is profit, we naturally think of the mate- rial return which labor earns, the gains it receives ; and this just as naturally is the chief thing in the mind of the prov- erb-maker. Industry leads to prosperity. It is good to assure ourselves what steady 116 THE FRUITS OF WORK ■J -t. 'i^ .- industry will do for us, to assure ourselves that in labor there is certain profit. We would not make too much of the nat- ural fruits of work, the temporal good it achieves, the material success we natu- rally expect from it. To lay too much emphasis on this is to put the emphasis on the wrong thing; but on the other hand it is stupid to despise such profit, as if all life did not have any sort of phys- ical basis. When we come to think of it, we realize that all the material good of the world is built on the profit of labor. There are no fiuits of any kind in all our civilization, which are not the fruits of work. The things which are needful in this life from a material point of view are added to us through industry, and only through industry. Neither talk, nor any- thing else but work, will feed and clothe and shelter. In the life of the individual also it is a silly affectation to rule out of account as a motive the natural success which 117 1^ \r^*^^h^Mi4^' THE FRUITS OF WO RK comes from industry. The world is built so that the idle and slothful cannot make anything of it ; and the hand of the diligent maketh rich. Still, this side of our subject as a rule is self-evident, and does not need to be elaborated. It is part of ordinary worldly prudence to direct the eyes of the young to such common fruits of work as its temporal good in at least affording a living. But there are other fruits even more important in the long run, other things got by the way, of more lasting worth than any material gains. The great value of work is not for what it earns, but for its education and training of body and mind and soul. It reacts on character, cutting deep into the nature virtues like patience and self-control and courage, establishing habits of concentra- tion and persistence and foresight. Even great mental gifts are rendered comparatively useless, if they are not tied down to definite tasks. There are 118 am Mrii many brilliant men who sparkle and shine with their lips, but who achieve nothing of permanent worth, because they have not bent to the daily discipline of strenuous labor. We cannot accept the famous definition of genius as an infinite capacity for taking pains ; for no amount of pains will itself accomplish the highest creative work of genius : but many a genius has brought no profit of aiiy kind either to himself or to the world, simply because he never submitted to the drudgery of work. There have been in England few men of such astound- ing genius as Coleridge. This is the testimony of all who knew him, and is our testimony also from the brilliant fragments of work he has left ; and yet his life is almost tragedy in its barrenness. Even the talk of his lips, though his words were as gold, tended only to moral penury. His plans, and schemes, and endless prospectuses of books he meant to write, his resolutions about the great 119 *«^\, THE FRUITS OF WORK work he intended always to begin, make a very pitiful story. It is like clouds and wind without rain, as another proverb has it, full of empty promise. His infirm- ity of purpose grew on him till he lost all power of decision and all capacity to work ; and he died as he had lived, a nerve- less soul. There had not perhaps been a man of greater mind since Shakespeare ; and yet in a prayer written by him near the end of his life he had to lament, as all the world has to lament, his unused talents and neglected opportunities. It is a common matter of observation that the successful man is not always the man with the most ability and the most brilliant powers. These often carry with them a disability, or at least a tempta- tion, to trust to them and make up by feverish haste what has been lost by slug- gishness. But every truly great man has in addition to his splendid gifts of mind the still more splendid gift of industry. It creates and strengthens the moral 120 c THE FRUITS OF WORK qualities necessary for sustained work of a high order. Method, perseverance, the self-criticism which can only be satisfied with the best, are only other names for the quality of industry. No true and lasting work can be done except as the result of a long training in the best methods of working. It does not mean that any methods can be a substitute for the original gift ; but it does mean that even the greatest gifts need the dis- cipline and development of hard work. Ruskin says on this point : " During such investigation as I have been able to give to the lives of the artists whose works are in all points noblest, no fact ever looms so large upon me, no law reniains so steadfast in the universality of its ap- plication, as the fact and law that they are all great workers ; nothing concern- ing them is matter of more astonishment than the quantity they have accomplished in the given length of their life ; and when I hear a young man spoken of as 121 ,-^ *t!S!0AslNMiii,'^' T THE FRUITS OF WORK giving promise of high genius, the first question I ask about him is always — Does he work ? " The ease with which greatness does its work often deceives. The orator masters his subject and his audience with ease ; the artist transfers to the canvas his vision of beauty without eiFort or seem- ing strain ; the musician pours out his melody spontaneous as a bird. Simplic- ity and ease are the marks of all great work, but behind it there are years of toil and arduous learning to do with ease what others cannot do at all. Capacity to toil is necessary for the highest work. This does not mean restless ambition, but steady peaceful labor along the line of his genius. The true reward of work- ing is not the material wage it earns in money or position or fame, but the in- creased and facile power of working. The fruits of labor can only be reaped by steady, well-directed, faithful labor ; and the fruits of work are capacity for 122 THE FRUITS OF WORK better work, but are also fruits of char- acter. The richest gains are not in any outward success, but in the result on the man himself, giving him the habit of ap- plic:atiori and discipline of thought, and stiffening his power of will. In all labor there is profit, though it cannot be put down in terms of cash. It is profitable to work though there should be no signs of success, no fruits that appear to the eye. 'r For one thing — to mention some actual benefits apart from this general training of character — one of the fruits of the habit of work is the independence of mind it induces. In work we are taken out of ourselves, removed from petty annoyances and all the small personali- ties that embitter life. No man can be thoroughly miserable who has work to do. Tlie direst misery is the result of a self-centred life. Unhappiness cannot exist in its keenest form where self is 123 THE FRUITS OF forgotten, and in all work worth doing there is concentration of all the powers, and a forgetfulness of everything except how to do it well. True work means independence of outside criticism and outside interference. A worker has not time to brood over fancied slights ; he can forget the world in doing his duty. Things done well. And with a care, exempt themselves from fear. We agitate ourselves with a host of petty worries and chagrins, so petty sometimes that we woxold be ashamed even to men- tion the things that annoy us. No true work was ever done in such a mood ; and such a mood cannot live in the atmos- phere of earnest, serious work. Forget self, and rest comes ; we get at once out into the calm. The heart's peace comes of the heart's own bringing ; and the way to bring it is to give ourselves to duty simply and humbly. And at the last there is nothing that gives such 124 THE FRUlfSOFWORKt satisfaction and independence as the sense of having honestly striven to perform duty. Sir Henry Lawrence, the hero of Lucknow, ever remembered as a savior of the British Empire at the Indian Mutiny, when he lay dying of a mortal wound at Lucknow, asked that his epitaph should be, " Here lies Henry Lawrence, who tried to do his duty."' The doing of duty teaches courage and patience and faith ; and these bring peace. It makes a man morally independent, strong and able to live his life to God and not to man. Firm adherence to duty can enable a man to do without praise, or encourage- ment, or adulation from men. It is a refuge from the strife of tongues, from the inept criticisms and evil-speaking of a censorious world. We read in the biography of Robertson of Brighton that at one period of his ministry his sensitive soul was bruised with the opposition and misrepresentation of detractors, and with the no less officiousness of admirers ; and 125 THE FRUITS OF WORK so, shrinking from the stings of a pub- licity he never sought, he gave himself up to quiet and continuous work as a refuge. He studied and preached and visited, and sought to find a hidden way of life, and by the very irksomeness of work tried to rid himself of what to his temperament was the worse irksomeness of fame. This over-sensitiveness was the great weakness of his character, and it could only be overcome by withdrawing into the region of duty. A touch of self-reliance is re- quired to make the character truly bal- anced ; and self-reliance is the result of self-forgetfulness. A confirmed habit of work gives an independence of mind which enables a man to dispense with many other supports, and enables him to disregard many criticisms which would distract the worker and weaken the work. The petty worries of life can always be at least mitigated thus. Emerson wrote in his Journal what was almost part of his faith : " To every reproach I know but 126 i* THE FRUITS OF WORK one answer, namely, to go again to my work. ' But you neglect your relations.' Too true, then I will work the harder. ' But you have no genius.' Yes, then I will work the harder. ' But you have detached yourself from people : you must regain some positive relation.' Yes, I will work the harder." Another of the fruits of this beneficent habit along the same line is that it brings habii for grief. Since it gives forgetful- ness of self, it can be and is an antidote to pain of heart. It often means the only chance of surcease of sorrow. The very routine and drudgery of daily work have often saved a life from despair. Adherence to duty is a way to attain some measure of peace. However great the sorrow, the needs of living and the duties of living press in, and demand attention. It is well that it should be so ; for the very necessity is a lesson in faith. When the cloud creeps over the 127 [EFRUITS OF WORK heart, when the way is obscured, when the future is unknown and the past seems a failure, when all else is dark, duty is still a light to the feet. It can be done meanwhile. When love itself seems dead, the service of love remains ; and to that we are called. Of course there may be cowardice in thus turning to work from the thought of grief. It may be used as an opiate to deaden pain and forget thought. We use it wrongfully, when we do so faith- lessly and bitterly. But when it is accepted humbly as the will of God, it gives peace to turn to something else, which is also the will of God, namely, daily duty. The very habit soothes and heals the bruised heart. In all labor there is this profit, that it gives patience to grief. This is a poor thing if it is taken as a means of forgetting, a narcotic to dull and numb pain ; but our whole path is transfigured if we see that we are walking in the way of God's appoint- 128 THE FRUITS OF WORK ment, simply and sweetly performing His will. There are many instances in life and literature of the power of work to assuage grief. A son-ow will either unman, or it will brace and nerve, and lift the life in a new access of courage. Sir Walter Scott used work to keep his mind from brood- ing on the downfall of his life's great scheme. His Journal is an unpretentious record of a noble life, revealing his brave true soul. The manner in which he buckled to his task (sometimes when the page he was writing waltzed before his eyes), the manly way in which he faced his trouble, and buried his grief, the pa- tience with intruding visitors when all the time he was aching to get back to work, move us with mingled pity and admira- tion. With pain of body and sorrow of heart and sickness of soul he battled on, and in his own conduct illustrated the words which long years before he had caused to be carved on his dial-stone at 9 129 Abbotsford, "I must work while it is called day ; for the night cometh when no man can work." It is in such a trial that a man's true character is revealed. He who has always put conscience into his work will not find the beneficent habit of work fail him at the pinch. Another of the assured fruits of work is happiness. It is the experience of all ages that to make happiness the end of life, the one definite purpose towards which a man strives, is infallibly to lose it. It is bound to result in frittering away life in trivialities, or swamping it in grossness. Yet we cannot leave it out of our scheme, since it is a demand of our very nature. Experience teaches that happiness is got by the way in pursuing other ends, and not by pursuing itself as an end ; and one of the accredited means of attaining some measure of hap- piness is by healthful activity of body and mind. In every well-ordered life there 130 THE FRUITS OF WORK must, be serious occupation for any sort of permanent happiness. The hajjpiest people one meets are always the busy people. The most miserable are those who have to invent frivolous substitutes for some serious employment. We are reminded of the satire of Burns\s poem, The Twa Dogs, where Luath, the poor man's dog, asks Caesar, the rich man's dog, if his master and his friends are not the happiest people on earth. It is a sly touch to put that question into the mouth of the poor man's dog. Caesar replies that he thinks they are not to be envied. A country fellow at the pleiigh. His acres tilled, he 's right eneugh ; A country girl at her wheel, Her dizzen 's dune, she 's unco weel ; But gentlemen, and ladies warst, Wi' ev'n-doon want o' wark are curst. The primal curse is felt by all, who accept it humbly, to be a blessing in disguise. Work is the very salt of life, not only 131 THE FRUITS OF WORK preserving it from decay, but also giving it tone and flavor. Carlyle never wearied in asserting this — it was one of liis best messages to his age — as in these words from his famous Inaugural Address, " Work is the grand cure of all maladies and miseries that beset mankind — • honest work which you intend getting done." Every man of knowledge and experience who writes on happiness gives work as one of the pure sources of enjoyment. This is partly because of its intimate connection with health of body ; and partly because industry brings peace of mind. We arc so easily led astray here, look- ing for happiness from getting, rather than from doing and being. Mere receptive happiness, which comes from possessions, from a present easy lot, from aesthetic en- joyment, cannot last. The taste palls on the jaded palate. It needs to be flicked with ever stronger spices. Its end is the hell of ennui, which is the inevitable dis- ease of idleness. This receptive happiness 132 T HE FR UITS OF WORK is the kind we mostly look for, and ex- plains why we are so sadly disappointed. Happiness can only come from obedience to the laws of life, and from the activity which is recognized to be the natural and healthy way of life. Perhaps the most pessimistic, and certainly the saddest, words Ruskin ever wrote are in his fine lecture on the Mystery of Life and the Arts, in which he shows how little real guidance in the great mystery of life we have received from even the wisest men, poets and teachers and statesmen and philosophers and the wise practical men ; but one thing he is sure of is that industry worthily followed gives peace. Other paths lead to disappointment, but sincere and honest labor means happiness. " Ask the laborer in the field, at the forge, or in the mine ; ask the patient, delicate-fiiigered artisan, or the strong-armed fiery-hearted worker in bronze and in marble and with the colors of light ; and none of these who are true workmen will ever tell you that 133 »»« THE FRUITS OF WORK ■■■-^ ^r-'i^:^"''%% THE IDEAL OF WORK habit of work, which has so blessed men, is but a makeshift without the ideal of work. To a spiritual being like man there is no detail of his life which has not spiritual significance; and the failure of our days is due to our neglect of the un- seen in dealing with the seen, our forget- fulness to live every common hour in the power of an endless life. Viewed practically, and put into simple language, the ideal of work iafaithfulness, work done according to a high standard which the worker himself sets up. We have such easy and elastic consciences, and sucli low selfish standards ! What will pass, what will do the turn, is often all that we aim at. We do not put con- science into our work. Speaking to a riveter once about piecework, I asked if the character of the work did not suffer from the haste to get as much money in as short a time as possible. He said that there was an inspector. " Does that 146 THE IDEAL OF WORK mean," I asked, " that the standard is to put in as many rivets as possible just in such a way that you will not need to come back and tighten them ? " " That 's about it," he said honestly. Our modern methods at least can'y the danger of taking away from moral stamina. Such work may be well enough done, be- cause it does not pay to come back and do it over again at the bidding of the inspector, but that is to put the inspec- tor in the place of conscience. No work ever lasted without conscience. How is it that Cremonese violins have had such a repute in the world ? We must accept Browning's explanation — Antonio Stradivari has an eye That winces at false worlc and loves the true. The man comes out in his work ; the character is revealed by conduct. We would be all the better if we had a little more fastidious taste about our own work. We should find it harder to please our- 147 THE IDEAL OF WORK selves than to please others. The self- respect which conies from a high standard will sometimes keep a man true, when he could satisfy the demands of others with less. A great preacher once said that his experience, after a considerable min- istry, was that the people appreciated most what cost him least. That would represent a strong temptation to him. It is true in everything that mere flashy surface work often for a time puts the genuine solid work out of the market. Hence the mere market standard is not sufficient. A man must never suifer him- self to be unfaithful to his better self. We have no safeguard if we have not conscience in our work. We may not be master of our daily work, but we are at least master of the spirit in which we do it. We can try to be faithful, even when we cannot be great, or when the work seems common- place. The Louvre in Paris has one of Murillo's pictures, which depicts the in- 148 THE IDEAL OF WORK terior of a convent kitchen, with angels doing the ordinary kitchen work, washing dishes, putting a kettle on the fire. The business of cooking is done with such grace that the menial tasks do not sug- gest any degradation, but seem the fit and proper work of angels, when they do it so beautifully. Kitchen work is refined by the dignity and sweet simplicity of such workers. " It is not thy works, which are all mortal, infinitely little, and the greatest no greater than the least, but only the spirit thou workest in, that can have worth or continuance.'' There are two opposite temptations which beset us all. On the one side there is the danger of the ideal, the temptation to look only for large is- sues, imposing duties, heroic enterprises, neglecting the opportunities at our hand. We can be unfaithful in the name of God, because of what seems a large ideal. We can seek what we conceive to be the better part and refuse the common duties 149 THE IDEAL OF WORK and tasks. But to mean anything, the ideal must be taken down into our lives, and fashion itself in every act. The danger of the ideal is to miss the detail. On tlie other hand, there is the clan- ger of detail, making life a thing of patchwork merely. However laboriously stitched together, it is only patchwork at the end. There are men to whom noth- ing is great, who have low-souled con- tentment wth the small. We can attend punctiliously to duty and be faithful in detail ; but never once have our hearts fired by the inspiration of a large love. " Thou art careful and troubled about many things, but one thing is needful." The danger of detail is to miss the ideal. The proper attitude is the small for the sake of the large, faithfulness in the little because of faith in the great. Life is of a piece, and before we can come to anything like a true estimate, it must be viewed as a whole. We cannot speak of 150 THE IDEAL OF WORK a man's character till it has gathered some sort of consistency. Every section of life must concur in our judgment before we can speak of a character as formed. This is why so many of our common divisions in the life of man are futile if not false, such as into the mor- ally great and the morally small. All life has spiritual significance. We are tempted to think that we are not being truly and fairly tested by the particular experiences through which we have passed and are passing, that this is only a day of small things unworthy of our real capacity. When we are forced to some measure of self-judgment and are sick at heart with a sense of the pettiness of our lives, we lay the blame on our surround- ings that we have never had a proper chance ; and we look forward to a future when some large opportunity will be given us, feeling sure that we will rise to the occasion when the occasion comes. But who are the men who are made by an 151 THE IDEAL OF WORK occasion ? If we knew all the facts we would see that they are the men who have been using what occasions were granted them before. The faults and selfishness which come out in us now would only be more apparent in the larger sphere, unless the larger sphere brought with it a larger ideal. Our character conditions our future, and our character is the fruit of all the past. Judgment of our life is going on cease- lessly, and records itself infallibly and in- delibly on character. It is a vain dream to think that any outside change would in itself make any difference, and that we can afford to neglect our small opportun- ities with the comfortable thought that nothing essential is altered, and that we are open to make a great success of some great opportunities that some day will come. A simple and plain fact of moral life is stated in the words, " He that is faithful in that which is least is faithful also in much." 152 ■i>wi-i>i»^«S