George Washington Flowers Memorial Collection DUKE UNIVERSITY LIBRARY ESTABLISHED BY THE FAMILY OF COLONEL FLOWERS Digitized by the Internet Archive in 2014 https://archive.org/details/nationalsinsfastOOthor THE FLOWERS COLIECTIOM Itational §m. FAST-DAT SERMON: PREACHED IN THE PRESBYTERIAN CHURCH, COLUMBIi, S. C, WEDNESDAY, NOVEMBER 21, 1860, By Rev. J. H. THORNWELL, D. D COLUMBIA, S. C: SOUTHERN GUARDIAN STEAM-POWER PRESS. 1860. S E R M O N And it came to pass, when King Hezekiah heard it, that he rent his clothes, and covered himself with sackcloth, and went into the house of the Lord." — Isaiah 37 : 1. I have no design, in the selection of these words, to inti- mate that there is a parallel between Jerusalem and our own Commonwealth in relation to the Covenant of God. I am far from believing that we alone, of all the people of the earth, are possessed of the true religion, and far from en- couraging the narrow and exclusive spirit which, with the ancient hypocrites denounced by the Prophet, can com- placently exclaim, the temple of the Lord, the temple of the Lord, are we. Such arrogance and bigotry are utterly inconsistent with the penitential confessions which this day has been set apart to evoke. We are here, not like the Pharisee, to boast of our own righteousness, and to thank God that we are not like other men ; but we are here like the poor publican, to smite upon our breasts, and to say, God be merciful to us, sinners. My design, in the choice of these words, is to illustrate the spirit and temper with which a Christian people should deport themselves in times of public calamity and distress. Jerusalem was in great straits. The whole country had been ravaged by a proud and insolent foe. The Sacred City remained as the last hold of the State, and a large army lay encamped before its walls. Ruin seemed to be inevitable. It teas a day of trouble, and of rebuke^ and of blasphemij. The children had come to the birth, and there was not strength to bring forth. In 4 FAST-DAY SERMON. the extremity of the danger, the sovereign betakes himself to God. Kenouncing all human confidence, and all human alliances, he rent his clothes, and covered himself with sackcloth, and went into the house of the Lord. In applying the text to our own circumstances, widely different in many respects from those of Jerusalem at the time referred to, I am oppressed with a difficulty, which you that are acquainted w^ith my views of the nature and functions of the Christian ministry can readily under- stand. During the twenty-five years in which I have fulfilled my course as a preacher — all of which have been spent in my native State, and nearly all in this city — I have never introduced secular politics into the instruc- tions of the pulpit. It has been a point of conscience with me to know no party in the State. Questions of law and public administration I have left to the tribunals appointed to settle them, and have confined my exhortations to those greatmattersthat pertain immediately to thekingdom of God I have left it to Ci^sar to take care of his own rights, and have insisted only upon the supreme rights of the Almighty. The angry disputes of the forum I have excluded from the house of the Lord. And while all classes have been ex- horted to the discharge of their common duties, as men, as citizens, as members of the family — while the sanctions of religion have, without scruple, been applied to all the re- lations of life, whether public or private, civil or domestic — the grounds of dissension which divide the community into parties, and range its members under difierent banners, have not been permitted to intrude into the sanctuary. The business of a preacher, as such, is to expound the Word of God. He has no commission to go beyond the teaching of the Scriptures. He has no authority to expound to sena- tors the Constitution of the State, nor to interpret for judges the law of the land. In the civil and political sphere, the dead must bury their dead. It is obvious, however, that religious sanctions cannot be applied to civil and FAST-DAY SERMON. 5 political duties without taking for granted the relations out of wliieh these duties spring. Religion cannot exact sub- mission to the powers that be, without implying that these powers are known and confessed. It cannot enjoin obe- dience to C^^sar, without taking it for granted that the authority of Caesar is acknowledged. When the Constitu- tion of the State is fixed and settled, the general reference to it which religion implies, in the inculcation of civil and political duties, may be made without intruding into the functions of the magistrate, or taking sides with any par- ticular pRrty in the Commonwealth. The relations which condition duty are admitted, and the conscience instantly recognizes the grounds on which the minister of the Gospel exhorts to fidelity. The duties belong to the department of religion ; the relations out of which they spring belong- to the department of political science ; and must be deter- mined apart from the Word of God. The concrete cases, to which the law of God is to be applied, must always be given ; the law itself is all that the preacher can enforce as of Divine authority. As the law, without the facts, how- ever, is a shadow without substance ; as the duty is un- meaning which is determined b}^ no definite relations ; the preacher cannot inculcate civil obedience, or convict of national sin, without allusions, more or less precise, to the theory and structure of the government. He avoids pre- sumption, b}^ having it distinctly understood, that the theory which he assumes is not announced as the Word of God, but is to be proved, as any other facts of history and expe- rience. He speaks here only in his own name, as a man, and proniulges a matter of opinion, and not an article of faith. If the assumptions which he makes are true, the duties which he enjoins must be accepted as Divine com- mands. The specuhitive antecedents being admitted, the practical consequents cannot be avoided. There are cases in which the question relates to a change in the govern- ment, in which the question of duty is simply a question of 6 FAST-DAY SEEMON. revolution. In such cases the minister has no commission from God to recommend or resist a change, unless some moral principle is immediately involved. He can explain and enforce the spirit and temper in which revolution should be contemplated and carried forward or abandoned. He can expound the doctrine of the Scriptures in relation to the nature, the grounds, the extent and limitations of civil obedience ; but it is not for him, as a preacher, to say wdien evils are intolerable, nor to prescribe the mode and measure of redress. These points he must leave to the State itself. When a revolution has once been achieved, he can enforce the duties which spring from the new con- dition of aifairs. Thus much I have felt bound to say, as to my views of the duty of a minister in relation to matters of State. As a citizen, a man, a member of the Commonwealth, he has a right to form and express his opinions upon every subject, to whatever department it belongs, which affects the interests of his race. As a man, he is as free as any other man ; but the citizen must not be confounded with the preacher, nor private opinions with the oracles of God. Entertaining these sentiments concerning the relations of the sacred office to political affairs, I am oppressed with the apprehension, that in attempting to fulfil the requi- sitions of the present occasion, I may transgress the limits of propriety, and merge the pulpit into the rostrum. I am anxious to avoid this error, and would, therefore, have it "understood, in advance, that whatever theory may be assumed of the nature and structure of our Government, is assumed upon the common grounds of historical knowledge, and is assumed mainly as fixing the points from which I would survey the sins of the country. If true — and no man has a right to reject them, without being able to disprove them — my conclusions in reference to our national guilt are irrefragably established. If not true, we must either deny that we are sinners, or must seek some other relations in FAST-DAY SERMON. 7 which to ground the consciousness of sin. If that conscious- ness should be thoroughly grounded, the services of this day will not be in vain. I can trul}^ say that niy great aim is not to expound our complex institutions, but to awaken the national conscience to a sense of its responsibility be- fore God. It is not to enlighten your minds, but to touch your hearts ; not to plead the cause of States rights or Federal authority, but to bring you as penitents before the Supreme Judge. This is no common solemnity. The day has been set apart by the constituted authorities of this Commonwealth, by joint resolution of both branches of the Legislature, and proclaimed by the Chief Magistrate of the State, as a day of fasting, humiliation and prayer. South Carolina, therefore, as an organized political community, prostrates herself this day before God. It is a time of danger, of blasphemy and rebuke, and, imitating the exam- ple of Hezekiah, she rends her clothes, covers herself with sackcloth, and comes into the House of the Lord. The question is, how she should demean herself under these solemn circumstances. Every minister, this day, becomes her organ, and he should instruct the people as to the attitude which we should all assume in the presence of Jehovah. It is a day of solemn worship, in which the State appears as a penitent, and lays her case before the Judge of all the earth. The points to which I shall direct your attention, are, first, the spirit in which we should approach God, and second, the errand on which we should go. I. As the individual, in coming to God, must believe that He is, and that He is the rewarder of them that dili- gently seek Him, so the State must be impressed with a profound sense of His all-pervading providence, and of its responsibility to Him, as the moral Ruler of the world. The powers that be are ordained of Him. From Him the magistrate receives his commission, and in His fear, he must use the sword as a terror to evil doers and a praise to them 8 FAST-DAY SERMON. that do well. Civil government is an institute of Heaven, founded in the character of man as social and moral, and is designed to realize the idea of justice. Take away the notion of mutual rights and the corresponding notions of duty and ohligation, and a commonwealth is no more con- ceivable among men than among brutes. As the State is essentially moral in its idea, it connects itself directly with the government of God. It is, indeed, the organ through which that government is administered in its relations to the highest interests of earth. A State, therefore, which does not recognize its dependence upon God, or which fails to apprehend, in its functions and offices, a commission from heaven, is false to the law of its own being. The moral finds its source and centre only in God. There can be no rights without responsibility, and responsibility is incom- plete until it terminates in a supreme will. The earthly sanctions of the State, its rewards and punishments, are insufficient either for the punishment of vice or the encour- agement of virtue, unless they connect themselves with the higher sanctions which religion discloses. If the State had to deal only with natures confessedly mortal; if its subjects were conscious of no other life than that which they bear from the cradle to the grave ; if their prospect terminated at death ; if they were only brutes of a more finished make, but equally destined to everlasting extinction, who does not see that the law would lose its terror, and obedience be stripped of its dignity. The moral nature of man is insep- arably linked with immortality, and immortality as insep- arably linked with religion. Among Pagan idolaters, the instinct of immortality, though not developed into a doc- trine, nor realized as a fact in reflection, is yet the secret power which, in the spontaneous workings of the soul, gives efficacy to punishment, and energy to rewards. Man feels himself immortal, and this feeling, though operating blind- ly, colors his hopes and his fears. The State, therefore, which should undertake to accomplish the ends of its being, FAST-DAY SERMON. 9 without taking into account the religious element in man, palsies its own arm. Subjects that have no religion are incapable of law. Eules of prudence they may institute ; measures of precaution they may adopt; a routine of coercion and constraint they may establish ; but laAvs they cannot have. They may be governed like a lunatic asylum ; but where there is no nature which responds to the sentiment of duty, there is no nature which confesses the majesty of law. Every State, therefore, must have a religion, or it must cease to be a government of men. Hence no Com- monwealth has ever existed without religious sanctions. ^'Whether true or false, sublime or ridiculous," says the author of the Consulate and the Empire, "man must have a religion. Every where, in all ages, in all countries, in ancient as in modern times, in civilized as well as in barba- rian nations, we find him a worshipper at some altar, be it venerable, degraded, or blood-stained." It is not only necessary that the State should have a religion ; it is equally necessary, in order to an adequate ful- filment of its own idea, that it have the true religion. Truth is the only proper food of the soul, and though superstition and error may avail for a time as external restraints, they never generate an inward principle of obedience. They serve as outward motives, but never become an inward life, and when the falsehood comes to be detected, the mind is apt to abandon itself to unrestrained licentiousness. The reaction is violent in proportion to the intensity of the pre- vious delusion. The most formidable convulsions in States are those which have been consequent upon the detection of religious imposture. " When a religion," says McCosh, " waxes old in a country — when the circumstances which at first favored its formation or introduction have changed — when in an age of reason it is tried and found unreason- able — when in an age of learning it is discovered to be the product of the grossest ignorance — when in an age of levity it is felt to be too stern — then the infidel spirit takes cour- 2 10 FAST-DAY SERMON. age, and, witli a zeal in whicli there is a strange mixture of scowling revenge and liglit-hearted wantonness, of deep- set hatred and laughing levity, it proceeds to level all exist- ing temples and altars, and erects no others in their room." The void which is created is soon filled with w^antonness and violence. The State cannot be restored to order until it settles down upon some form of religion again. As the subjects of a State must have a religion in order to be truly obedient, and as it is the true religion alone which converts obedience into a living principle, it is obvious that a Com- monwealth can no more be organized, which shall recog- nize all religions, than one which shall recognize none. The sanctions of its laws must have a centre of unity some where. To combine in the same government contra- dictory systems of faith, is as hopelessly impossible as to con- stitute into one State men of different races and languages. The Christian, the Pagan, Mohammedan ; Jews, Infidels and Turks, cannot coalesce as organic elements in one body politic. The State must take its religious type from the doctrines, the precepts, and the institutions of one or the other of these parties. When we insist upon the religious character of the State, we are not to be understood as recommending or favoring a Church Establishment, To have a religion is one thing — to have a Church Establishment is another ; and perhaps the most efiectual way of extinguishing the religious life of a State is to confine the expression of it to the forms and peculiarities of a single sect. The Church and the State, as visible institutions, are entirely distinct, and neither can usurp the province of the other without injury to both. But religion, as a life, as an inward principle, though specially developed and fostered by the Church, extends its domain beyond the sphere of technical worship, touches all the relations of man, and constitutes the inspi- ration of every duty. The service of the Commonwealth becomes an act of piety to Grod. The State realizes its FAST-DAY SERMON. 11 religious character through the religious character of its subjects ; and a State is and ought to be Christian, because all its subjects are and ought to be determined by the prin- ciples of the Gospel. As every legislator is bound to be a Christian man, he has no right to vote for any laws which are inconsistent with the teachings of the Scriptures. He must carry his Christian conscience into the halls of leg- islation. In conformity with these principles, we recognize Chris- tianity to-day as the religion of our Commonwealth. Our standard of right is that eternal law which God proclaimed from Sinai, and which Jesus expounded on the Mount. "We recognize our responsibility to Jesus Christ. He is head over all things to the Church, and the nation that will not serve Him is doomed to perish. Before men we are a free and sovereign State ; before God we are dependent subjects ; and one of the most cheering omens of the times is the heartiness with which this truth has been received. "VYe are a Christian people, and a Christian Commonwealth. As on the one hand we are not Jews, Infidels or Turks, so on the other, we are not Presbyterians, Baptists, Episcopa- lians, or Methodists. Christianity, without distinction of sects, is the fountain of our national life. We accept the Bible as the great moral charter by which our laws must be measured, and the Incarnate Redeemer as the Judge to whom we are responsible. In contending that Christianity is the organic life of the State, we of course do not exclude from the privileges of citizens, nor from the protection of the laws, those who do not acknowledge the authority of Jesus. They do not cease to be men, because they are not Christians, and Christian principle exacts that their rights should be sacredly main- tained by an institute which is founded in the idea of justice. As, moreover, the religion of the State realizes itself through the religious life of its subjects, it is not to be supported by arbitrary tests or by civil pains and disa- 12 FAST-DAY SERMON. bilities. Religion is essentially free and spontaneous. It cannot be enacted as a law, nor enforced by authority. When the State protects its outward institutions, such as the sanctity of the Sabbath, it enjoins nothiug which does violence to any man's conscience. It is only giving vent to the religious life of the people, without exacting from others what they feel it sinful to perform ; and so long as freedom of conscience and the protection of their rights are secured to men, they have no reason to complain that they are not permitted to unsettle the principles upon which all law and order ultimately rest. As long as they are not required to profess what they do not believe, nor to do what their consciences condemn ; as long as they are excluded from no privilege and deprived of no right, they cannot complain that the spirit and sanction of the laws are a standing protest against their want of sympathy with the prevailing type of national life. If Christianity be true, they ought certainly to be Christians. The claim of this religion, in contradistinction from every other, or from none at all, is founded only in its truth. If true, it must be authoritative, and the people who accept it as true would be traitors to their faith if they did not mould their institutions in conformity with its spirit. It is only as a sanction, and not as a law, that we plead for its influence ; and how a Christian people can have any other than Chris- tian institutions, it surpasses our intelligence to compass. That the State should treat all religions w^ith equal indif- ference, is to suppose that the subjects of the State can have a double life, flowing in parallel streams, which never approach nor touch — a life as citizens, and a life as men. It is to forget the essential unity of man, and the convergence of all the energies of his being to a religious centre. It is to forget that religion is the perfection of his nature, and that he realizes the idea of humanity in proportion as reli- gion pervades his whole being. A godless State is, in fact, a contradiction in terms; and if we must have some god, or FAST-DAY SERMON. 13 cease to be citizens because we have ceased to be men, who will hesitate between the God of the Bible and the absurd devices of human superstition and depravity ? It is, then, before the Supreme Jehovah that we prostrate ourselves to-day. We come as a Commonwealth ordained bv Him. We come as His creatures and His subjects. The sword by which we have executed justice, we received from His hands. We believe that He is — that He is our God ; that His favor is life, and His loving kindness better than life. We ascribe to His grace the institutions under which we have flourished. We trace to His hands the blessings which have distinguished our lot. Under Him the foundations of the State were laid, and to Him we owe whatsoever is valuable in our laws, healthful in our customs, or precious in our history. We come this day to acknowl- edge our dependence, swear our allegiance, and confess our responsibility. By Him we exist as a State, and to Him we must answer for the manner in which we have discharged our trust. " God standeth in the congregation of the mighty. He judgeth among the gods.'' n. Having explained the spirit in which we should approach God, let me call your attention, in the next place, to the ERRAND which brings us before Him this day — fast- ing, humiliation, and prayer. These terms define the worship which we are expected to present. Fasting is the outward sign ; penitence and prayer are the inward graces. In fasting, we relinquish for a season the bounties of Provi- dence, in token our conviction, that we have forfeited all claim to our daily bread. It is a symbolical confession that we deserve to be stripped of every gift, and left to perish in hunger, nakedness, and want. On occasions of solemn moment, and particularly when "manifestations of the Divine anger appear, as pestilence, war, and famine, the salutary custom of all ages has been for pastors to exhort the people to public fasting and extraordinary prayer." Through such a solemnity Nineveh was saved; 14 FAST-DAY SERMON. and if we are equally penitent, who shall say that we may not also be delivered from the judgments which our sins have provoked ? Fasting, apart from inward penitence, is an idle mockery. Is it such a fast as 1 have chosen ? a day for a man to afflict his soul ? is it to how down his head as a bulrush, and to spread sackcloth and ashes under him? wilt thou call this a fast and an acceptahle day to the Lord ? Is not this the fast that I have chosen f to loose the hands of wick- edness, to undo the heavy hardens, and to let the oppressed go free, and that ye hreak every yoke f Is it not to deal thy hread to the hungry, and that thou hring the poor that are cast out to thy house f when thou seest the naked that thou cover him ; and that thou hide not thyself from thine own flesh ? The great thing with us to-day is, to be impressed with a sense of our sins as a people; to confess them humbly before God; to deprecate His judgments, and to supplicate His favor. "We are too apt to restrict the notion of sin in its proper sense to the sphere of the individual ; to regard it as alto- gether private and personal, and not capable of being- predicated of the mal-administration of the State. But if the State is a moral institute, responsible to God, and exist- ing for moral and spiritual ends, it is certainly a subject capable of sin. It may endure, too, the penalty of sin, either in its organic capacity, by national judgments, by war, pestilence, weakness, and dissolution, or in its indi- vidual subjects, whose offences as citizens are as distinctly transgressions as any other forms of iniquity, and enter into the grounds of the Divine dispensation^ towards them. The State exists under a law which defines its duty. It is a means to an end, which limits its powers and determines its functions. It is the realization of an idea. Like an indi- vidual, it may sin by defect in coming short of its duty, and sin by positive contradiction to it. It may fail to com- prehend its vocation ; it may arrogate too much, or claim too little. It may be wanting in public spirit, or it may give public spirit a wrong direction. It may subordinate FAST-DAY SERMON. 15 the spiritual to the material, and, in encouraging the in- crease of national wealth, neglect to foster national great- ness. In aspiring to be rich and increased in goods, it may forget that the real glory of a nation is to be free, intelli- gent, and virtuous. The power which it has received as an instrument of good, it may pervert into an engine of tyranny. It may disregard the welfare and prosperity of its subjects, and degenerate into a tool for the selfish pur- poses of unscrupulous rulers. It may seek to aggrandize factions, instead of promoting the well-being of the people. The State, too, as a moral person, stands in rela- tions to other States, in consequence of which it may be guilty of bad faith, of inordinate ambition, of covetousness, rapacity, and selfishness. The same vices which degrade the individual among his fellows, may degrade a common- wealth among surrounding nations. It may be mean, vora- cious, insolent, extortionary. It may cringe to the strong, and oppress the weak. It may take unworthy advantages of the necessities of its neighbors, or make unworthy con- cessions for temporary purposes. The same laws regulate, and the same crimes disfigure, the intercourse of States with one another, which obtain in the case of individuals. The political relations of the one are precisely analogous to the social relations of the other. The same standard of honor, of integrity and magnanimity which is incumbent upon their subjects, is equally binding upon the States them- selves, and character ought to be as sacred among sovereign States as among private individuals. The true light, therfore, in which national defects and transgressions should be contemplated, is formally that of sin against God. Their injustice to their people is treach- ery to Him, and their failure to comprehend or to seek to fulfil the end of their being, is contempt of the Divine authority. We take too low a view, when we regard their errors simply as impolitic ; their real magnitude and enor- 16 FAST-DAY SERMON. mity we can never apprehend until we see them in the light of sins. It is to be feared that this notion of sin has not the hold which it should have of the public conscience. We are not accustomed to judge of the State by the same canons of responsibility which we apply to individuals. In some way or other, the notion of sovereignty, which only defines the relation of a State to earthly tribunals, affects our views of its relations to God ; and, whilst we charge it with errors, with blunders, with unfaithfulness to its trust, and deplore the calamities which its misconduct brings upon its subjects as public evils, we lose sight of the still more solemn truth, that these aberrations are the actions of a moral agent, and must be answered for at the bar of God. The moral law is one, and the State is bound to do its duty, under the same sanctions which pertain to the individual. When the State fails, or transgresses, its offences are equally abomina- tions in the sight of God. It is clearly idle to talk of national repentance, without the consciousness of national sin. This doctrine, therefore, I would impress upon you in every form of statement, that the misconduct of the State is rebellion against God, and that a nation which comes short of its destination, and is faithless to its trust, is stained with sin of the most malignant dye. God may endure it in patience for a season, but it is loathsome and abominable in His eyes, and the day of reckoning will at last come. Sin must either be pardoned or punished, confessed and forsaken, or it will work death. Sin has been the ruin of every Em- pire that ever flourished and fell. Assyria, Persia, Greece, and Rome, have paid the penalties to the Divine law. The only alternative with States, as with their subjects, is, repent or perish. The first duty, therefore, which, as a Christian people, we should endeavor to discharge this day, is to con- fess our national sins with humility and penitence. We should endeavor to feel their magnitude and enormity, not as injuries to man, but as offences against the majesty of FAST-DAY SERMON. 17 God. Our language should be that of David: Against Thee, Thee onI