PERKINS LIBRARY Duke University Rare Dooks /O V ^^ p» v aS^ m Digitized by the Internet Archive in 2012 with funding from Duke University Libraries http://archive.org/details/queenmabphilosop02shel QUEEN MAB; PHILOSOPHICAL POEM WITH NOTES. BY Verts i&Q&%fyt gfotlltQ. ECRASEZ L'INFAME! CORRESPONDANCE DE VOLTAIRE. Avia Pieridum peragro Ioca, nullius ante Trita solo ; juvat integros accedere fonteis ; Atque haurire ; juratque novos decerpere flores. Unde prius nulli velarint tempora iuusae. Primum quod magnis doceo de rebus ; et arctis Religionum animos nodis exsolvere pergo. Lucret. lib. iv. Aog 7TOV QTU), KCU KOfffiOV IClVTJffW. Archimedes Honfron: PRINTED & PUBLISHED BY R. CARLILE, 55, FLEET STREET. 1823. 4Huwn iWatu i. How wonderful is Death, Death and his brother Sleep ! One, pale as yonder waning moon With lips of lurid blue ; I The other, rosy as the morn % When throned on ocean's wave It blushes o'er the world : Yet both so passing wonderful! Hath then the gloomy Power Whose reign is in the tainted sepulchres Seized on her sinless soul ? Must then that peerless form Which love and admiration cannot view Without a beating heart, those azure veins Which steal like streams along a field of snow, That lovely outline, which is fair As breathing marble, perish ? Must putrefaction's breath 4 QUEEN MAB. Leave nothing of this heavenly sight But loathsomeness and ruin? Spare nothing but a gloomy theme, On which the lightest heart might moralize? Or is it only a sweet slumber Stealing o'er sensation, Which the breath of roseate morning Chaseth into darkness? Will Ianthe wake again, And give that faithful bosom joy Whose sleepless spirit waits to catch Light, life, and rapture from her smile?. Yes ! she will wake again, Although her glowing limbs are motionless, And silent those sweet lips, Once breathing eloquence That might have soothed a tyger's rage, Or thawed the cold heart of a conqueror. Her dewy e^es are closed, And oh ■■their lids, whbse texture fine Scarce hides the dark blue orbs beneath, The baby Sleep is pillowed : Her golden tresses shade r The bosom's stainless' pride, Curling like tendrils of the parasite Around a marble column. Hark! whence that rushing sound? 'Tis like the wondrous strain That round a lonely ruin swells, I. QUEEN MAB. 5 Which, wandering on the echoing shore, The enthusiast hears at evening : 'Tis softer than the west wind's sigh ; s 'Tis wilder than the unmeasured notes Of that strange lyre whose strings The genii of the breezes sweep : • Those lines of rainbow light Are like the moonbeams when they fall Through some cathedral window, but the teints Are such as may not find Comparison on earth. Behold the chariot of the Fairy Queen! Celestial coursers paw the unyielding air ; Their filmy pennons at her word they furl, And stop obedient to the reins of light: These the Queen of Spells drew in, She spread a charm around the spot, And leaning graceful from the ethereal car^ Long did she gaze, and silently, Upon the slumbering maid. Oh ! not the visioned poet in his dreams, When silvery clouds float through the wildered brain, When every sight of lovely, wild, and grand, Astonishes, enraptures, elevates, When fancy, at a glance, combines The wondrous and the beautiful, — . , So bright, so fair, so wild a shape Hath ever yet beheld, <"* e% 6 QUEEN MAB. I. As that which reined the coursers of the air, And poured the magic of her gaze Upon the maiden's sleep. The broad and yellow moon Shone dimly through her form — That form of faultless symmetry ; The pearly and pellucid car Moved not the moonlight's line ; 'Twas not an earthly pageant : Those who had looked upon the sight, Passing all human glory, Saw not the yellow moon, Saw not the mortal scene!, Heard not the night-wind's rush, Heard not an earthly sound, Saw but the fairy pageant, Heard but the heavenly strains That filled the lonely dwelling. The Fairy's frame was slight, yon fibrous cloud, That catches but the palest tinge of eveo, And which the straining eye can hardly seize When melting into eastern twilight's shadow, Were scarce so thin, so slight ; but the fair star That gems the glittering coronet of mom, Sheds not a light so mild, so powerful, As that which, bursting from the Fairy's form, Spread a purpureal halo round the scene, Yet with an undulating motion, Swayed to her outline gracefully. I. QUEEN MAB. i From her celestial car The Fairy Queen descended, And thrice she waved her wand Circled with wreaths of amaranth : Her thin and misty form Moved with the moving air, And the clear silver tones, As thus she spoke, were such As are unheard by all but gifted ear. FAIRY. Stars ! your balmiest influence shed ! Elements ! your wrath suspend ! Sleep, Ocean, in the rocky bounds That circle thy domain ! Let not a breath be seen to stir Around yon grass-grown ruin's height, Let even the restless gossamer Sleep on the moveless air ! Soul of Ianthe ! thou, Judged alone worthy of the envied boon, That waits the good and the sincere ; that waits Those who have struggled, and with resolute will Vanquished earth's pride and meanness,bursts the chains, The icy chains of custom, and have shone The day-stars of their age; — Soul of Ianthe ! Awake! arise! Sudden arose Ianthe's Soul ; it stood 8 QUEEN MAB. All beautiful in naked purity, The perfect semblance of its bodily frame. Instinct with inexpressible beauty and grace, Each stain of earthliness Had passed away, it reassumed Its native dignity, and stood Immortal amid ruin. Upon the couch the body lay Wrapt in the depth of slumber : Its features were fixed and meaningless, Yet animal life was there, And every organ yet performed Its natural functions: 'twas a sight Of wonder to behold the body and soul. The self-same lineaments, the same Marks of identity were there : Yet, oh, how different! One aspires to Heaven, Pants for its sempiternal heritage, And ever-changing, ever-rising still, Wantons in endless being. The other, for a time the unwilling sport Of circumstance and passion, struggles on; Fleets through its sad duration rapidly : Then like an useless and worn-out machine, Rots, perishes, and passes. FATRY. Spirit ! who hast dived so deep ; Spirit ! who hast soared so high ; I. QUEEN MAB. Thou the fearless, thou the mild, Accept the boon thy worth hath earned, Ascend the car with me. SPIRIT. Do I dream? Is this new feeling But a visioned ghost of slumber? If indeed I am a soul, A free, a disembodied soul, Speak again to me. FAIRY. I am the Fairy Mab : to me 'tis given The wonders of the human world to keep: The secrets of the immeasurable past, In the unfailing consciences of men, Those stern, unflattering chroniclers, I find : The future, from the causes which arise In each event, I gather: not the sting Which retributive memory implants In the hard bosom of the selfish man ; Nor that extatic and exulting throb Which virtue's votary feels when he sums up The thoughts and actions of a well-spent day, Are unforeseen, unregistered by me: And it is yet permitted me, to rend The veil of mortal frailty, that the spirit Clothed in its changeless purity, may know How soonest to accomplish the great end 10 QUEEN MAB. For which it hath its being, and may taste That peace, which in the end all life will share. This is the meed of virtue ; happy Soul, Ascend the car with me! The chains of earth's immurement Fell from Ianthe's spirit ; They shrank and break like bandages of straw Beneath a wakened giant's strength. She knew her glorious change, And felt in apprehension uncontrolled New raptures opening round : Each day-dream of her mortal life, Each frenzied vision of the slumbers That closed, each well-spent day, Seemed now to meet reality. The Fairy and the Soul proceeded ; The silver clouds disparted ; And as the car of magic they ascended, Again the speechless music swelled, Again the coursers of the air Unfurled their azure pennons, and the Queen Shaking the beamy reins Bade them pursue their way. The magic car moved on. The night was fair, and countless stars Studded heaven's dark blue vault, — Just o'er the eastern wave Peeped the first faint smile of morn : — I. QUEEN MAB. 11 The magic car moved on — From the celestial hoofs The atmosphere in naming sparkles flew, And where the burning wheels Eddied above the mountain's loftiest peak, Was traced a line of lightning. Now it flew far above a rock, The utmost verge of earth, The rival of the Andes, whose dark brow Lowered o'er the silver sea. Far, far below the chariot's path, Calm as a slumbering babe, Tremendous Ocean lay. The mirror of its stillness shewed The pale and waning stars, The chariot's fiery track, And the grey light of morn Tinging those fleecy clouds That canopied the dawn. Seemed it, that the chariot's way Lay through the midst of an immense concave, Radiant with million constellations, tinged With shades of infinite colour, And semicircled with a belt FlashiDg incessant meteors. The magic car moved on. As they approached their goal The coursers seemed to gather speed ; The sea no longer was distinguished ; earth M QUEEN MAB. Appeared a vast and shadowy sphere ; The sun's unclouded orb Rolled through the black concave; Its rays of rapid light Parted around the chariot's swifter course, And fell, like ocean's feathery spray Dashed from the boiling surge Before a vessel's prow. The magic car moved on. Earth's distant orb appeared The smallest light that twinkles in the heaven ; Whilst round the chariot's way Innumerable systems rolled, And countless spheres diffused An ever- varying glory. It was a sight of wonder : some Were horned like the crescent moon ; Some shed a mild and silver beam Like Hesperus o'er the western sea ; Some dash'd athwart with trains of flame, Like worlds to death and ruin driven ; Some shone like suns, and as the chariot passed, Eclipsed all other light. Spirit of Nature ! here ! In this interminable wilderness Of worlds, at whose immensity Even soaring fancy staggers, Here is thy fitting temple. Yet not the lightest leaf I. QUEEN MAB. 13 That quivers to the passing breeze Is less instinct with thee : Yet not the meanest worm That lurks in graves and fattens on the dead Less shares thy eternal breath. Spirit of Nature ! thou ! Imperishable as this scene, Here is thy fitting temple. 14 QUEEN MA.B. II. II. —►►►•••«<— If solitude hath ever led thy steps To the wild ocean's echoing shore, And thou hast lingered there, Until the sun's broad orb Seemed resting on the burnished wave, Thou must have marked the lines Of purple gold, that motionless Hung o'er the sinking sphere : Thou must have marked the billowy clouds Edged with intolerable radiancy Towering like rocks of jet Crowned with a diamond wreath. And yet there is a moment, When the sun's highest point Peeps like a star o'er ocean's western edge, When those far clouds of feathery gold, Shaded with deepest purple, gleam Like islands on a dark blue sea ; Then has thy fancy soared above the earth, And furled its wearied wing Within the Fairy's fane. Yet not the golden islands Gleaming in yon flood of light, II. QUEEN MAB. 15 Nor the feathery curtains Stretching o'er the sun's bright couch, Nor the burnished ocean waves Paving that gorgeous dome, So fair, so wonderful a sight As Mab's ethereal palace could afford. Yet likest evening's vault, that faery Hall ! As Heaven, low resting on the wave, it spread Its floors of flashing light, Its vast and azure dome, Its fertile golden islands Floating on a silver sea ; Whilst suns their mingling beamings darted Through clouds of circumambient darkness, And pearly battlements around Looked o'er the immense of Heaven. The magic car no longer moved. The Fairy and the Spirit Entered the Hall of Spells : Those golden clouds That rolled in glittering billows Beneath the azure canopy With the ethereal footsteps, trembled not : The light and crimson mists, Floating to strains of thrilling melody Through that unearthly dwelling, Yielded to every movement of the will. Upon their passive swell the Spirit leaned, And, for the varied bliss that pressed around, Used not the glorious privilege Of virtue and of wisdom. 16 QUEEN MAB, IT. Spirit ! the Fairy said, And pointed to the gorgeous dome, This is a wondrous sight And mocks all human grandeur ; But, were it virtue's only meed, to dwell In a celestial palace, all resigned To pleasurable impulses, immured Within the prison of itself, the will Of changeless nature would be unfulfilled. Learn to make others happy. Spirit, come ! This is thine high reward : — the past shall rise ; Thou shalt behold the present ; I will teach The secrets of the future. The Fairy and the Spirit Approached the overhanging battlement. — Below lay stretched the universe ! There, far as the remotest line That bounds imagination's flight, Countless and unending orbs In mazy motion intermingled, Yet still fulfilled immutably Eternal nature's law. Above, below, around The circling systems formed A wilderness of harmony ; Each with undeviating aim, In eloquent silence, through the depths of space Pursued its wondrous way. II. QUEEN MAB. 17 There was a little light That twinkled in the misty distance : None but a spirit's eye Might ken that rolling orb ; None but a spirit's eye, And in no other place But that celestial dwelling, might behold Each action of this earth's inhabitants. But matter, space, and time In those aerial mansions cease to act ; And all-prevailing wisdom, when it reaps The harvest of its excellence, o'erbounds Those obstacles, of which an earthly soul Fears to attempt the conquest. The Fairy pointed to the earth. The Spirit's intellectual eye Its kindred beings recognized. The thronging thousands, to a passing view, Seemed like an anthill's citizens. How wonderful ! that even The passions, prejudices, interests, That sway the meanest being, the weak touch That moves the finest nerve, And in one human brain Causes the faintest thought, becomes a link In the great chain of nature. Behold, the Fairy cried. Palmyra's ruined palaces !— Behold ! where grandeur frowned ; 2 18 QUEEN MAB. II. Behold ! where pleasure smiled ; What now remains? — the memory Of senselessness and shame — What is immortal there ? Nothing — it stands to tell A melancholy tale, to give An awful warning: soon Oblivion will steal silently The remnant of its fame. Monarchs and conquerors there Proud o'er prostrate millions trod — The earthquakes of the human race ; Like them, forgotten when the ruin That marks their shock is past. Beside the eternal Nile, The Pyramids have risen. Nile shall pursue his changeless way : Those pyramids shall fall ; Yea ! not a stone shall stand to tell The spot whereon they stood ; Their very scite shall be forgotten, As is their builder's name! Behold yon sterile spot ; Where now the wandering Arab's tent Flaps in the desert blast. There once old Salem's haughty fane Reared high to heaven its thousand golden domes, And in the blushing face of day Exposed its shameful glory.* II. QUEEN MAB. 19 Oh! many a widow, many an orphan cursed The building of that fane ; and many a father, Worn out with toil and slavery, implored The poor man's God to sweep it from the earth, » And spare his children the detested task Of piling stone on stone, and poisoning The choicest days of life, To soothe a dotard's vanity. Their an inhuman and uncultured race Howled hideous praises to their Demon-God; They rushed to war, tore from the mother's womb The unborn child, — old age and infancy Promiscuous perished ; their victorious arras Left not a soul to breathe. Oh ! they were fiends : But what was he who taught them that the God Of nature and benevolence had given A special sanction to the trade of blood ? His name and theirs are fading, and the tales Of this barbarian nation, which imposture Recites till terror credits, are pursuing Itself into forgetfulness. Where Athens, Rome, and Sparta stood, There is a moral desart now : The mean and miserable huts, The yet more wretched palaces, Contrasted with those ancient fanes, Now crumbling to oblivion ; The long and lonely colonnades, Through which the ghost of Freedom stalks, Seem like a well-known tune, 20 QUEEN MAB- II. Which, in some dear scene we have loved to hear, Remembered now in sadness. But, oh! how much more changed, How gloomier is the contrast Of human nature there ! Where Socrates expired, a tyrant's slave, A coward and a fool, spreads death around — Then, shuddering, meets his own. Where Cicero and Antoninus lived, A cowled and hypocritical monk Prays, curses, and deceives. Spirit! ten thousand years Have scarcely past away, Since, in the w T aste where now the savage drinks His enemy's blood, and aping Europe's sons, Wakes the unholy song of war, Arose a stately city, Metropolis of the western continent : There, now, the mossy column-stone, Indented by time's unrelaxing grasp, Which once appeared to brave All, save its country's ruin ; There the wide forest scene, Rude in the uncultivated loveliness Of gardens long run wild, Seems, to the unwilling sojourner, whose steps Chance in that desart has delayed, Thus to have stood since earth was what it is. Yet once it was the busiest haunt, Whither, as to a common centre, flocked II. QUEEN MA.B. 21 Strangers, and ships, and merchandize : Once peace and freedom blest The cultivated plain : But wealth, that curse of man, Blighted the bud of its prosperity: Virtue and wisdom, truth and liberty^ Fled, to return not, until man shall know That they alone can give the bliss Worthy a soul that claims Its kindred with eternity. There's not one atom of yon earth But once was living man ; Nor the minutest drop of rain, That hangeth in its thinnest cloud, But flowed in human veins: And from the burning plains Where Lybian monsters yell, From the most gloomy glens Of Greenland's sunless clime, To where the golden fields Of fertile England spread Their harvest to the day, Thou canst not find one spot Whereon no city stood. How strange is human pride! I tell thee that those living things, To whom the fragile blade of grass, That springeth iu the morn And perisheth ere noon, 22 QUEEN MAB, II. Is an unbounded world ; I tell thee that those viewless beings,. Whose mansion is the smallest particle Of the impassive atmosphere, Think, feel, and live like man; .„ That their affections and antipathies, Like his, produce the laws Ruling their moral state; And the minutest throb That through their frame diffuses The slightest, faintest motion, Is fixed and indispensable As the majestic laws That rule yon rolling orbs. The Fairy paused. The Spirit, In extacy of admiration, felt All knowledge of the past revived ; the events Of old and wondrous times. Which dim tradition interruptedly Teaches the credulous vulgar, were unfolded In just perspective to the view ; Yet dim from their infinitude. The Spirit seemed to stand High on an isolated pinnacle ; The flood of ages combating below, The depth of the unbounded universe Above, and all around Nature's unchanging harmony. III. QUEEN MAB. III. Fairy! the Spirit said, And on the Queen of Spells Fixed her ethereal eyes, I thank thee. Thou hast given A boon which I will not resign, and taught A lesson not to be unlearned. I know The past, and thence I will essay to glean A warning for the future, so that man May profit by his errors, and derive Experience from his folly : For, when the power of imparting joy Is equal to the will, the human soul Requires no other heaven. MAB. Turn thee, surpassing Spirit! Much yet remains unscanned. Thou knowest how great is man, Thou knowest his imbecility : Yet learn thou what he is ; Yet learn the lofty destiny Which* restless time prepares For every living soul. 24 QUEEN MAB. III. Behold a gorgeous palace, that, amid Yon populous city, rears its thousand towers And seems itself a city. Gloomy troops Of centinels, in stern and silent ranks, Encompass it around : the dweller there Cannot be free and happy ; hearest thou not The curses of the fatherless, the groans Of those who have no friend ? He passes on : The King, the wearer of a gilded chain That binds his soul to abjectness, the fool Whom courtiers nickname monarch, whilst a slave Even to the basest appetites — that man Heeds not the shriek of penury ; he smiles At the deep curses which the destitute Mutter in secret, and a sullen joy Pervades his bloodless heart when thousands groan But for those morsels which his wantonness Wastes in unjoyous revelry, to save All that they love from famine: when he hears The tale of horror, to some ready-made face Of hypocritical assent he turns, Smothering the glow of shame, that, spite of him. Flushes his bloated cheek. Now to the meal Of silence, grandeur, and excess, he drags His palled unwilling appetite. If gold, Gleaming around, and numerous viands culled From every clime, could force the loathing sense To overcome satiety, — if wealth The spring it draws from poisons not, — or vice, III. QUEEN MAB. 25 Unfeeling, stubborn vice, converteth not Its food to deadliest venom; then that king - Is happy; and the peasant who fulfils His unforced task, when he returns at even, And by the blazing faggot meets again Her welcome for whom all his toil is sped, Tastes not a sweeter meal. Behold him now Stretched on the gorgeous couch; his fevered brain Reels dizzily awhile: But, ah ! too soon The slumber of intemperance subsides, And conscience, that undying serpent, calls Her venomous brood to their nocturnal task. Listen ! he'speaks ! oh ! mark that frenzied eye — Oh ! mark that deadly visage. KING. No cessation ! Oh ! must this last for ever! Awful death, I wish, yet fear to clasp thee ! — Not one moment Of dreamless sleep ! O dear and blessed peace! Why dost thou shroud thy vestal purity In penury and dungeons? wherefore lurkest With danger, death, and solitude; yet shunn'st The palace I have built thee ? Sacred peace ! Oh visit me but once, but pitying shed One drop of balm upon my withered soul. Vain man! that palace is the virtuous heart, And peace defileth not her snowy robes 26 QUEEN MAB. III. In such a shed as thine. Hark ! yet he mutters ; His slumbers are but varied agonies, They prey like scorpions on the springs of life. There needeth not the bell that bigots frame To punish those who err : earth in itself Contains at once the evil and the cure; And all-sufficing nature can chastise Those who transgress her law, — she only knows How justly to proportion to the fault The punishment it merits. Is it strange That this poor wretch should pride him in his woe? Take pleasure in his abjectness, and hug The scorpion that consumes him ? Is it strange That, placed on a conspicuous throne of thorns, Grasping an iron sceptre, and immured Within a splendid prison, whose stern bounds Shut him from all that's good or dear on earth, His soul asserts not its humanity? That man's mild nature rises not in war Against a king's employ? No — 'tis not strange. He, like the vulgar, thinks, feels, acts and lives Just as his father did; the un.couquered powers Of precedent and custom interpose Between a king and virtue. Stranger yet, To those who know not nature, nor deduce The future from the present, it may seem, That not one slave, who suffers from the crimes Of this unnatural being ; not one wretch, Whose children famish, and whose nuptial bed III. QUEEN MAB. 27 In earth's unpitying bosom, rears an arm To dash him from his throne! Those gilded flies That, basking in the sunshine of a court, Fatten on its corruption ! — what are they ? ■ — The drones of the community ; they feed On the mechanic's labour : the starved hind For them compels the stubborn glebe to yield Its unshared harvests ; and yon squalid form, Leaner than fleshless misery, that wastes A sunless life in the unwholesome mine, Drags out in labour a protracted death, To glut their grandeur; many faint with toil, That few may know the cares and woe of sloth. Whence, thinkest thou, kings and parasites arose? Whence that unnatural line of drones, who heap Toil and unvanquishable penury On those who build their palaces, and bring Their daily bread ? — From vice, black loathsome vice; From rapine, madness, treachery, and wrong ; From all that genders misery, and makes Of earth this thorny wilderness ; from lust, Revenge, and murder And when reason's voice, Loud as the voice of nature, shall have waked The nations ; and mankind perceive that vice Is discord, war, and misery ; that virtue Is peace, and happiness, and harmony ; When man's maturer nature shall disdain The playthings of its childhood ; — kingly glare 28 QUEEN MAB. III. Will lose its power to dazzle; its authority Will silently pass by ; the gorgeous throne Shall stand unnoticed in the regal hall, Fast falling to decay ; whilst falsehood's trade Shall be as hateful and unprofitable As that of truth is now. Where is the fame Which the vain-glorious mighty of the earth Seek to eternize? Oh! the faintest sound From time's light footfall, the minutest wave That swells the flood of ages, whelms in nothing The unsubstantial bubble. Aye ! to-day Stern is the tyrant's mandate, red the gaze That flashes desolation, strong the arm That scatters multitudes. To-morrow comes ! That mandate is a thunder-peal that died In ages past; that gaze, a transient flash On which the midnight closed, and on that arm The worm has made his meal. The virtuous man, Who, great in his humility, as kings Are little in their grandeur; he who leads Invincibly a life of resolute good, And stands amid the silent dungeon-depths More free and fearless than the trembling judge, Who, clothed in venal power, vainly strove To bind the impassive spirit; — when he falls, His mild eye beams benevolence no more : Withered the hand outstretched but to relieve ; III. QUEEN MAB. 29 Sunk reason's simple eloquence that rolled But to appal the guilty. Yes ! the grave Hath quenched that eye, and death's relentless frost Withered that arm : but the unfading fame Which virtue hangs upon its votary's tomb ; The deathless memory of that man, whom kings Call to their mind and tremble; the remembrance With which the happy spirit contemplates i/ Its well-spent pilgrimage on earth, Shall never pass away. Nature rejects the monarch, not the man; The subject not the citizen : for kings And subjects, mutual foes, for ever play A losing game into each other's hands, Whose stakes are vice and misery. The man Of virtuous soul commands not, nor obeys. Power, like a desolating pestilence, Pollutes whate'er it touches; and obedience, Bane of all genius, virtue, freedom, truth, Makes slaves of men, and, of the human frame, A mechanized automaton. When Nero, High over flaming Rome, with savage joy Lowered like a fiend, drank with enraptured ear The shrieks of agonizing death, beheld The frightful desolation spread, and felt A new created sense within his soul Thrill to the sight, and vibrate to the sound ; Thinkest thou his grandeur had not overcome 30 QUEEN MAB. III. The force of human kindness ? and, when Rome, With one stern blow, hurled not the tyrant down, Crushed not the arm red with her dearest blood, Had not submissive abjectness destroyed Nature's suggestions? Look on yonder earth : The golden harvests spring ; the unfailing sun Sheds light and life ; the fruits, the flowers, the trees, Arise in due succession ; all things speak Peace, harmony, and love. The universe, In nature's silent eloquence, declares That all fulfil the works of love and joy, — All but the outcast man. He fabricates The sword which stabs his peace ; he cherisheth The snakes that gnaw his heart; he raiseth up The tyrant, whose delight is in his woe, Whose sport is in his agony. Yon sun, Lights it the great alone ? Yon silver beams, Sleep they less sweetly on the cottage thatch, Than on the dome of kings? Is mother earth A step-dame to her numerous sons, who earn Her unshared gifts with unremitting toil ; A mother only to those puling babes Who, nursed in ease and luxury, make men The playthings of their babyhood, and mar, In self-important childishness, that peace Which men alone appreciate ? Spirit of Nature! no. The pure diffusion of thy essence throbs III. QUEEN MAB. 31 Alike in every human heart. Thou, aye, erectest there Thy throne of power unappealable : Thou art the judge beneath whose nod Man's brief and frail authority Is powerless as the wind That passeth idly by. Thine the tribunal which surpasseth The shew of human justice, As God surpasses man. Spirit of Nature ! thou Life of interminable multitudes ; Soul of those mighty spheres Whose changeless paths thro' Heaven's deep silence lie; Soul of that smallest being, The dwelling of whose life Is one faint April sun-gleam ; — Man, like these passive things, Thy will unconsciously fulfilleth : Like theirs, his age of endless peace, Which time is fast maturing, Will swiftly, surely come ; And the unbounded frame, which thou pervadest, Will be without a flaw Marring its perfect symmetry. QUEEN MAB. IV. IV. How beautiful this night ! the balmiest sigh, Which vernal zephyrs breathe in evening's ear, Were discord to the speaking quietude That wrav£i, eapog ^ETriylyverai dipt]' "He avhpwv ysi'Er), ?/ p.kv vei >/^' awoXijyEi.^ IAIAA. Z\ 1. 146. a Like leaves on trees the race of man is found, Now green in youth, now withering on the ground ; Another race the following spring supplies ; They fall successive, and successive rise : So generations in their course decay ; So flourish these, when those are past away. Pope's Homer. 102 NOTES. V. Page 44. The mob of peasants, nobles, priests, and kings. Suave mari magno turbantibus aequora ventis E terra magnum alter ius spectare laborem ; Non quia vexari quemquam 'st jucunda voluptas, Sed quibns ipse malis careas quia cernere suave 'st. Suave etiam belli certamina magna tueri, Per campos instructa, tua sine parte pericli ; Sed nil dulcius est bene quam munita tenere Edita doctrina sapientum templa serena; Despicere unde queas alios, passim que videre Errare atque viam palanteis quserere vitse ; Certare ingenio ; contendere nobilitate ; Nocteis atque dies niti prastante labore Ad summas emergere opes, rerum que potiri. O miseras hominum menteis! O pectora caeca 3 ! Luc. lib. ii. a When the wide ocean maddening whirlwinds sweep, And heave the billows of the boiling deep, Pleased we from land the reeling bark survey, And rolling mountains of the watery way. Not that we joy another's woes to see, But to reflect that we ourselves are free. So, the dread battle ranged in distant fields, Ourselves secure, a secret pleasure yields. But what more charming than to gain the height Of true philosophy ? What pure delight From Wisdom's citadel to view below, Deluded mortals, as they wandering go In quest of happiness ! ah, blindly weak ! For fame, for vain nobility they seek ; NOTES. 103 V. Page 45. And statesmen boast Of wealth ! There is no real wealth but the labour of man. Were the mountains of gold, and the vallies of silver, the world would uot be one grain of corn the richer ; no one comfort would be added to the human race. In consequence of our consideration for the precious metals, one man is enabled to heap to himself luxuries at the expence of the necessaries of his neighbour ; a system admirably fitted to produce all the varieties of disease and crime, which never fail to characterise the two extremes of opulence and penury. A speculator takes pride to himself as the promoter of his country's prosperity, who employs a number of hands in the manufacture of articles avowedly destitute of use, or subservient only to the unhallowed cravings of luxury and ostentation. The nobleman, who employs the peasants of his neighbourhood in building his palaces, until " jam pauca aratro jugera, regies moles relin- quunt*" flatters himself that he has gained the title of a patriot by yielding to the impulses of vanity. The shew and pomp of courts adduces the same apology for Labour for heapy treasures, night and day, And pant for power and magisterial sway. Oh, wretched mortals ! souls devoid of light, Lost in the shades of intellectual night ! Dr. Busby's Lucretius. a These piles of royal structure, will soon leave but few acres for the plough. 1 01 NOTES. its continuance; and many a fete has been given, many a woman has eclipsed her beauty by her dress, to benefit the labouring poor and to encourage trade. Who does not see that this is a remedy which aggra- vates, whilst it palliates the countless diseases of so- ciety? The poor are set to labour, — for what? Not the food for which they famish : not the blankets for want of which their babes are frozen by the cold of their miserable hovels : not those comfors of civiliza- tion without which civilized man is far more miserable than the meanest savage ; oppressed as he is by all its insidious evils, within the daily and taunting prospect of its innumerable benefits assiduously exhibited before him: — no; for the pride of power, for the miserable isolation of pride, for the false pleasures of the hun- dredth part of society. No greater evidence is afforded of the wide extended and radical mistakes of civilized man than this fact : those arts which are essential to his very being are held in the greatest contempt ; em- ployments are lucrative in an inverse ratio to their usefulness a : the jeweller, the toyman, the actor gains fame and wealth by the exercise of his useless and ridiculous art; whilst the cultivator of the earth, he without whom society must cease to subsist, struggles through contempt and penury, and perishes by that famine which, but for his unceasing exertions, would annihilate the rest of mankind. I will not insult common sense by insisting on the doctrine of the natural equality of man. The question a See Rousseau, " De l'lnegalite parrai les Hommes," note 7. NOTES. 105 is not concerning its desirableness, but its practicabi- lity : so far as it is practicable, it is desirable. That state of human society which approaches nearer to an equal partition of its benefits and evils should, cceteris paribus*, be preferred: but so long as we conceive that a wanton expenditure of human labour, not for the necessities, not even for the luxuries of the ma?s of society, but for the egotism and ostentation of a few of its members, is defensible on the ground of public justice, so long we neglect to approximate to the re- demption of the human race. Labour is required for physical, and leisure for mo- ral improvement: from the former of these advantages the rich, and from the latter the poor, by the inevitable condition of their respective situations, are precluded. A state which should combine the advantages of both, would be subjected to the evils of neither. He that is deficient in firm health, or vigorous intellect, is but half a man : hence it follows, that, to subject the labouring classes to unnecessary labour, is wantonly depriving them of any opportunities of intellectual improvement; and that the rich are heaping up for their own mischief the disease, lassitude and ennui by which their exist- ence is rendered an intolerable burthen. English reformers exclaim against sinecures, — but the true pension-list is the rent-roll of the landed pro- prietors: wealth is a power usurped by the few, to compel the many to labour for their benefit. The laws which support this system derive their force from the a Making allowances on both sides. 106 NOTES. ignorance and credulity of its victims: they are the result of a conspiracy of the few against the many, who are themselves obliged to purchase this pre-emi- nence by the loss of all real comfort. $t3= The commodities that substantially contribute to the subsistence of the human species form a very short catalogue : they demand from us but a slender portion of industry. If these only were produced, and suffi- ciently produced, the species of man would be conti- nued. If the labour necessarily required to produce them were equitably divided among the poor, and, still more, if it were equitably divided among all, each man's share of labour would be light, and his portion of leisure would be ample. There was a time when this leisure would have been of small compara- tive value: it is to be hoped that the time will come, when it will be applied to the most important pur- poses. Those hours which are not required for the production of the necessaries of life, may be devoted to the cultivation of the understanding, the eularging our stock of knowledge, the refining our taste, and thus opening to us new and more exquisite sources of enjoyment. It was perhaps necessary that a period of monopoly and oppression should subsist, before a period of cul- tivated equality could subsist. Savages perhaps would never have been excited to the discovery of truth and the invention of art, but by the narrow motives which such a period affords. But, surely, after the savage NOTES. 107 state has ceased, and men have set out in the glorious career of discovery and invention, monopoly and op- pression cannot be necessary to prevent them from returning to a state of barbarism. — Godwin's En- quirer, Essay II. See also Pol. Jus., Book VIII. chap. 1 1 . It is a calculation of this admirable author, that all the conveniences of civilized life might be produced, if society would divide the labour equally among its members, by each individual being employed in labour two hours during the day. V. Page 46. Or religion Drives his wife raving mad, I am acquainted with a lady of considerable accom- plishments, and the mother of a numerous family, whom the Christian religion has goaded to incurable insanity. A parallel case is, I believe, within the ex- perience of every physician. Nam jam ssepe homines patriam, carosque parentes Prodiderunt, vitare Acherusia templa petentes a . Lucretius. ■ a For some, the approach of Death and Hell to stay, Their parents, friends, and country, will betray. Dr. Busby's Lucretius. 108 NOTES. V. Page 48. Even love is sold. Not even the intercourse of the sexes is exempt from the despotism of positive institution. Law pre- tends even to govern the indisciplinable wanderings of passion, to put fetters on the clearest deductions of reason, and, by appeals to the will, to subdue the in- voluntary affections of our nature. Love is inevitably consequent upon the perception of loveliness. Love withers under constraint: its very essence is liberty : it is compatible neither with obedience, jealousy, nor fear : it is there most pure, perfect, and unlimited, where its votaries live in confidence, equality, and un- reserve. How long then ought the sexual connection to last? what law ought to specify the extent of the grievances which should limit its duration? A husband and wife ought to continue so long united as they love each other : any law which should bind them to cohabita- tion for one moment after the decay of their affection, would be a most intolerable tyranny, and the most unworthy of toleration. How odious an usurpation of the right of private judgment should that law be considered, which should make the ties of friendship indissoluble, in spite of the caprices, the inconstancy, the fallibility, and capacity for improvement of the human mind. And by so much would the fetters of love be heavier and more unendurable than those of friendship, as love is more vehement and capricious, NOTES. 109 more dependent on those delicate peculiarities of ima- gination, and less capable of reduction to the ostensi- ble merits of the object. The state of society in which Ave exist is a mixture of feudal savageness and imperfect civilization. The narrow and unenlightened morality of the Christian religion is an aggravation of these evils. It is not even until lately that mankind have admitted that happiness is the sole end of the science of ethics, as of all other sciences; and that the fanatical idea of mortifying the flesh for the love of God has been discarded. I have heard, indeed, an ignorant collegian adduce, in favour of Christianity, its hostility to every worldly feeling a ! But if happiness be the object of morality, of all hu- man unions and disunions ; if the worthiness of every action is to be estimated by the quantity of pleasurable sensation it is calculated to produce, then the connec- tion of the sexes is so long sacred as it contributes to the comfort of the parties, and is naturally dissolved when its evils are greater than its benefits. There is nothing immoral in this separation. Constancy has nothing virtuous in itself, independently of the pleasure it confers, and partakes of the temporizing spirit of a The first Christian emperor made a law by which seduction was punished with death ; if the female pleaded her own consent, she also was punished with death ; if the parents endeavoured to screen the criminals, they were banished, and their estates were confiscated ; the slaves who might be accessary were burned alive, or forced to swallow melted lead. The very offspring of an illegal love were involved in the consequences of the sentence. — Gibbon's Decline and Fall, &c. vol, ii. page 210. See also, for the hatred of the primitive Christians to love, and even marriage, page 269. 110 NOTES. vice in proportion as it endures tamely moral defects of magnitude in the object of its indiscreet choice. Love is free: to promise for ever to love the same woman, is not less absurd than to promise to believe the same creed : such a vow, in both cases, excludes us from all enquiry. The language of the votarist is this: The woman I now love may be infinitely inferior to many others ; the creed I now profess may be a mass of errors and absurdities ; but I exclude myself from all future information as to the amiability of the one, and the truth of the other, resolving blindly, and in spite of conviction, to adhere to them. — Is this the language of delicacy and reason ? Is the love of such a frigid heart of more worth than its belief? The present system of constraint does no more, in the majority of instances, than make hypocrites or open enemies. Persons of delicacy and virtue, unhap- pily united to one whom they find it impossible to love, spend the loveliest season of their life in unpro- ductive efforts to appear otherwise than they are, for the sake of the feelings of their partner or the welfare of their mutual offspring : those of less generosity and refinement openly avow their disappointment, and lin- ger out the remnant of that union, which only death can dissolve, in a state of incurable bickering and hostility. The early education of their children takes its colour from the squabbles of the parents ; they are nursed in a systematic school of ill-humour, violence, and falsehood. Had they been suffered to part at the moment when indifference rendered their union irk- some, they would have been spared many years of NOTES. 1 1 1 misery: they would have connected themselves more suitably, and would have found that happiness in the society of more congenial partners which is for ever denied them by the despotism of marriage. They w r ould have been separately useful and happy mem- bers of society, who, whilst united, were miserable, and rendered misanthropical by misery. The convic- tion that wedlock is indissoluble holds out the strong- est of all temptations to the perverse : they indulge without restraint in acrimony, and all the little tyran- nies of domestic life, when they know that their vic- tim is without appeal. If this connection were put on a rational basis, each would be assured that habitual ill temper would terminate in separation, and would check this vicious and dangerous propensity. Prostitution is the legitimate offspring of marriage and its accompanying errors. Women, for no other crime than having followed the dictates of a natural appetite, are driven with fury from the comforts and sympathies of society. It is less venial than murder ; and the punishment which is inflicted on her who de- stroys her child to escape reproach, is lighter than the life of agony and disease to which the prostitute is irrecoverably doomed. Has a woman obeyed the im- pulse of unerring nature ; — society declares war against her, pityless and eternal war : she must be the tame slave, she must make no reprisals; theirs is the right of persecution, hers the duty of endurance. She lives a life of infamy : the loud and bitter laugh of scorn scares her from all return. She dies of long and lin- gering disease : yet she is in fault, she is the criminal, 112 NOTES. she the froward and untameable child, — and society, forsooth, the pure and virtuous matron, who casts her as an abortion from her undefiled bosom ! Society avenges herself on the criminals of her own creation; she is employed in anathematizing the vice to-day, which yesterday she was the most zealous to teach. Thus is formed one-tenth of the population of London, meanwhile the evil is twofold. Young men, excluded by the fanatical idea of chastity from the society of modest and accomplished women, associate with these vicious and miserable beings, destroying thereby all those exquisite and delicate sensibilities whose exist- ence cold-hearted worldlings have denied ; annihilat- ing all genuine passion, and debasing that to a selfish feeling which is the excess of generosity and devoted- ness. Their body and mind alike crumble into a hideous wreck of humanity ; idiotcy and disease be- come perpetuated in their miserable offspring, and distant generations suffer for the bigotted morality of their forefathers. Chastity is a monkish and evange- lical superstition, a greater foe to natural temperance even than uninteliectual sensuality; it strikes at the root of all domestic happiness, and consigns more than half of the human race to misery, that some few may monopolize according to law. A system could not well have been devised more studiously hostile to human happiness than marriage. I conceive that, from the abolition of marriage, the fit and natural arrangement of sexual connection would result. I by no means assert that the intercourse would be promiscuous: on the contrary; it appears, NOTES. 113 from the relation of parent to child, that this union is generally of long duration, and marked above al others with generosity and self-devotion. But this i a subject which it is perhaps premature to discuss. That which will result from the abolition of marriage, will be natural and right, because choice and change will be exempted from restraint. In fact, religion and morality, as they now stand, compose a practical code of misery and servitude: the genius of human happiness must tear every leaf from the accursed book of God, ere man can read the inscription on his heart. How would morality, dressed up in stiff stays and finery, start from her own disgusting image, should she look in the mirror of nature ! VI. Page 53. To the red and baleful sun That faintly twinkles there. The north polar star, to which the axis of the earth, in its present state of obliquity, points. It is exceed- ingly probable, from many considerations, that this obliquity will gradually diminish, until the equator coincides with the ecliptic : the nights and days will then become equal on the earth throughout the year, and probably the seasons also. There is no great ex- travagance in presuming that the progress of the per- pendicularity of the poles may be as rapid as the pro- gress of intellect; or that there should be a perfect identity between the moral and physical improvement 8 114 NOTES. of the human species. It is certain that wisdom is not compatible with disease, and that, in the present state of the climates of the earth, health, in the true and comprehensive sense of the word, is out of the reach of civilized man. Astronomy teaches us that the earth is now in its progress, and that the poles are every year becoming more and more perpendicular to the ecliptic. The strong evidence afforded by the history of mythology, and geological researches, that some event of this nature has taken place already, affords a strong presumption that this progress is not merely an oscillation, as has been surmised by some late astro- nomers 3 . Bones of animals peculiar to the torrid zone have been found in the north of Siberia, and on the banks of the river Ohio. Plants have been found in the fossil state in the interior of Germany, which de- mand the present climate of Hindostan for their pro- duction 1 '. The researches of M. Bailly c establish the existence of a people who inhabit a tract of land in Tartary, 49° north latitude, of greater antiquity than either the Indians, the Chinese, or the Chaldeans, from whom these nations derived their sciences and theo- logy. We find, from the testimony of ancient writers, that Britain, Germany, and France, were much colder than at present, and that their great rivers were an- nually frozen over. Astronomy teaches us also, that since this period the obliquity of the earth's position has been considerably diminished. gQh a Laplace, Syst£me du Monde. b Cabanis, Hapports du Physique et du Moral de l'Horome, vol. ii. p 406. c Lettres sur les Sciences, a Voltaire. Bailly. NOTES. 115 VI. Page 57. No atom of this turbulence fulfils A vague and unnecessitated task, Or acts but as it must and ought to act. Deux exemples serviront a nous rendre plus sensible le principe qui vient d'etre pose; nous emprunterons l'une du physique et l'autre du moral. Dans un tour- billon de poussiere qu'eleve un vent impetueux, quel- que confus qu'il paroisse a nos yeux ; dans la plus affreuse tempete excite par des vents opposes qui sou- levent les flots, il n'y a pas une seule molecule de poussiere ou d'eau qui soit place au hazard, qui n'ait sa cause suffisante pour occuper le lieu ou elie se trouve, et qui n'agisse rigoureussement de la maniere dont elle doit agir. Une geometre qui connoitroit exactement les differentes forces qui agissent dans ces deux eas, et les proprietes des molecules qui sont mues, demontreroit que d'apres des causes donnes, chaque molecule agit precisement comme elle doit agir, et ne peut agir autrement qu'elle ne fait. Dans les convulsions terribles qui agitent quelque- fois les soci^tes politiques, et qui produisent souvent le renversement d'un empire, il n'y a pas une seule action, une seule parole, une seule pensee, une seule volont6, une seule passion dans les agens qui concourent a la revolution comme destructeurs ou comme victimes, qui ne soit necessaire, qui n'agisse comme elle doit agir, qui n'opere infalliblement les effets qu'elle doit operer, suivant la place qu'occupent ces agens dans ce tourbillon moral. Cela paroitroit evident pour une 116 NOTES. intelligence qui sera en etat de saisir et d'appr^cier toutes les actions et re-actions des esprits et des corps de ceux qui contribuent a cette revolution a . Systeme de la Nature, vol. i. p. 44. VI. Page 58. Necessity ! thou mother of the world ! He who asserts the doctrine of Necessity, means that, contemplating the events which compose the moral and material universe, he beholds only an im- mense and uninterrupted chain of causes and effects, no one of which could occupy any other place than it a Two instances will serve to render more sensible to us the principle here laid down ; we will borrow one from natural the other from moral philosophy. In a whirlwind of dust raised by an impetuous wind, how- ever confused it may appear to our eyes ; in the most dreadful tempest excited by opposing winds, which convulse the waves, there is not a single particle of dust or of water that is placed by chance that has not its sufficient cause for occupying the situation in which it is, and which does not rigororously act in the mode it should act. A geometrician who knew equally the different powers which operate in both cases, and the properties of the particles which are propelled, would shew that according to the given causes, each particle acts precisely as it should act, and can- not act otherwise than it does. In those terrible convulsions which sometimes agitate political societies, and which frequently bring on the overthrow of an empire, there is not a single action, a single word, a single thought, a single volition, a single passion in the agents, which concur in the revolution as destroyers, or as victims, which is not necessary, which does not act as it should act, which does not infallibly produce the effects which it should produce, according to the place occupied by these agents in the moral whirlwind. This would appear evident to an intelligence which would be in a state to seize and appreciate all the actions and re-actions of the minds and bodies of those who contribute to this revolution. System of Nature, vol. i. NOTES, 117 does occupy, or act in any other place than it does act. The idea of necessity is obtained by our ex- perience of the connection between objects, the uni- formity of the operations of nature, the constant con- junction of similar events, and the consequent inference of one from the other. Mankind are therefore agreed in the admission of necessity, if they admit that these two circumstances take place in voluntary action. Motive is, to voluntary action in the human mind, what cause is to effect in the material universe. The word liberty, as applied to mind, is analogous to the word chance, as applied to matter: they spring from an ignorance of the certainty of the conjunction of antecedents and consequents. Every human being is irresistibly impelled to act precisely as he does act: in the eternity which preceded his birth, a chain of causes was generated, which, ope- rating under the name of motives, make it impossible that any thought of his mind, or any action of his life, should be otherwise than it is. Were the doctrine of Necessity false, the human mind would no longer be a legitimate object of science; from like causes it would be in vain that we should expect like effects ; the strongest motive would no longer be paramount over the conduct; all knowledge would be vague and undeterminate ; we could not predict with any cer- tainty, that we might not meet as an enemy to-morrow, him with whom we have parted in friendship to-night; the most probable inducements and the clearest rea- sonings would lose the invariable influence they pos- sess. The contrary of this is demonstrably the fact. 118 NOTES. Similar circumstances produce the same unvariable effects. The precise character and motives of any man on any occasion being given, the moral philoso- pher could predict his actions with as much certainty as the natural philosopher could predict the effects of the mixture of any particular chemical substances. Why is the aged husbandman more experienced than the young beginner? Because there is an uniform, un- deniable necessity in the operations of the material universe. Why is the old statesman more skilful than the raw politician? Because, relying on the necessary conjunction of motive and action, he proceeds to pro- duce moral effects, by the application of those moral causes which experience has shewn to be effectual. Some actions may be found to which we can attach no motives, but these are the effects of causes with which we are unacquainted. Hence the relation which motive bears to voluntary action is that of cause to effect ; nor, placed in this point of view, is it, or ever has it been the subject of popular or philosophical dis- pute. None but the few fanatics who are engaged in the Herculean task of reconciling the justice of their God with the misery of man, will longer outrage common sense by the supposition of an event without a cause, a voluntary action without a motive. History, politics, morals, criticism, all grounds of reasoning, all principles of science, alike assume the truth of the doctrine of Necessity. No farmer carrying his corn to market doubts' the sale of it at the market price. The master of a manufactory no more doubts that he can purchase the human labour necessary for his pur- NOTES. 1 1 9 poses, than that his machinery will act as they have been accustomed to act. But, whilst none have scrupled to admit necessity as influencing matter, many have disputed its domi- nion over mind. Independently of its militating with the received ideas of the justice of God, it is by no means obvious io a superficial enquiry. When the mind observes its own operations, it feels no connec- tion of motive and action : but as we know " nothing more of causation than the constant conjunction of objects and the consequent inference of one from the other, as we find that these two circumstances are uni- versally allowed to have place in voluntary action, we may be easily led to own that they are subjected to the necessity common to all causes." The actions of the will have a regular conjunction with circum- stances and characters; motive is, to voluntary action, what cause is to effect. But the only idea we can form of causation is a constant conjunction of similar objects, and the consequent inference of one from the other: wherever this is the case necessity is clearly established. The idea of liberty, applied metaphorically to the will, has sprung from a misconception of the meaning of the word power. What is power ? — id quod potest*, that which can produce any given effect. To deny power, is to say that nothing can or has the power to be or act. In the only true sense of the word power, it applies with equal force to the loadstone as to the a That which can do any thing. 120 NOTES. human will. Do you think these motives, which I shall present, are powerful enough to rouse him? is a question just as common as, Do you think this lever has the power of raising this weight? The advocates of free-will assert that the will has the power of refus- ing to be determined by the strongest motive: but the strongest motive is that which, overcoming all others, ultimately prevails ; this assertion therefore amounts to a denial of the will being ultimately determined by that motive which does determine it, which is absurd. But it is equally certain that a man cannot resist the strongest motive, as that he cannot overcome a physi- cal impossibility. The doctrine of Necessity tends to introduce a great change into the established notions of morality, and utterly to destroy religion. Reward and punishment must be considered, by the Necessarian, merely as motives which he would employ in order to procure the adoption or abandonment of any given line of con- duct. Desert, in the present sense of the word, would no longer have any meaning; and he, who should inflict pain upon another for no better reason than that he deserved it, would only gratify his revenge under pretence of satisfying justice. It is not enough, says the advocate of free-will, that a criminal should be prevented from a repetition of his crime: he should feel pain, and his torments, when justly inflicted, ought precisely to be proportioned to his fault. But utility is morality; that which is incapable of producing hap- piness is useless ; and though the crime of Damiens must be condemned, yet the frightful torments which NOTES, 121 revenge, under the name of justice, inflicted on this unhappy man, cannot be supposed to have augmented, even at the long run, the stock of pleasurable sensation in the world. At the same time the doctrine of Ne- cessity does not in the least diminish our disapproba- tion of vice. The conviction which all feel, that a viper is a poisonous animal, and that a tyger is con- strained, by the inevitable condition of his existence, to devour men, does not induce us to avoid them less sedulously, or, even more, to hesitate in destroying them: but he would surely be of a hard heart, who, meeting with a serpent on a desart island, or in a situ- ation where it was incapable of injury, should wan- tonly deprive it of existence. A Necessarian is in-> consequent to his own principles, if he indulges in hatred or contempt; the compassion which he feels for the criminal is unmixed with a desire of injuring him: he looks with an elevated and dreadless compo- sure upon the links of the universal chain as they pass before his eyes; whilst cowardice, curiosity and in- consistency only assail him in proportion to the fee- bleness and indistinctness with which he has perceived and rejected the delusions of free-will. Religion is the perception of the relation in which we stand to the principle of the universe. But if the principle of the universe be not an organic being, the model and prototype of man, the relation between it and human beings is absolutely none. Without some insight into its will respecting our actions, religion is nugatory and vain. But will is only a mode of ani- mal mind ; moral qualities also are such as only a 122 NOTES. human being can possess; to attribute them to the principle of the universe, is to annex to it properties incompatible with any possible definition of its nature. It is probable that the word God was originally only an expression denoting the unknown cause of the known events which men perceived in the universe. By the vulgar mistake of a metaphor for a real being, of a word for a thing, it became a man, endowed with human qualities and governing the universe as an earthly monarch governs his kingdom. Their ad- dresses to this imaginary being, indeed, are much in the same style as those of subjects to a king. They acknowledge his benevolence, deprecate his anger, and supplicate his favour. But the doctrine of Necessity teaches us, that in no case could any event have happened otherwise than it did happen, and that, if God is the author of good, he is also the author of evil ; that, if he is entitled to our gratitude for the one, he is entitled to our hatred for the other; that, admitting the existence of this hypo- thetic being, he is also subjected to the dominion of an immutable necessity. It is plain that the same arguments which prove that God is the author of food, light, and life, prove him also to be the author of poison, darkness, and death. The wide-wasting earth- quake, the storm, the battle, and the tyranny, are attri- butable to this hypothetic being in the same degree as the fairest forms of nature, sunshine, liberty, and peace. But we are taught, by the doctrine of Necessity, that there is neither good nor evil in the universe, otherwise than as the events to which we apply these NOTES. 123 epithets have relation to our own peculiar mode of being. Still less than with the hypothesis of a God, will the doctrine of Necessity accord with the belief of a future state of punishment. God made man such as he is, and then damned him for being so: for to say that God was the author of all good, and man the author of all evil, is to say that one man made a straight line and a crooked one, and another man made the incongruity. gi3= A Mahometan story, much to the present purpose, is recorded, wherein Adam and Moses are introduced disputing before God in the following manner. Thou, says Moses, art Adam, whom God created, and ani- mated with the breath of life, and caused to be wor- shipped by the angels, and placed in Paradise, from whence mankind have been expelled for thy fault. Whereto Adam answered, Thou art Moses, whom God chose for his apostle, and entrusted with his word, by giving thee the tables of the law, and whom he vouchsafed to admit to discourse with himself. How many years dost thou find the law was written before I was created? Says Moses, Forty. And dost thou not find, replied Adam, these words therein, And Adam rebelled against his Lord and transgressed? Which Moses confessing, Dost thou therefore blame me, continued he, for doing that which God wrote of me that I should do, forty years before I was created, nay, for what was decreed concerning me fifty thousand years before the creation of heaven and earth? Sales Prelim. Disc, to the Koran, p. 164. 124 NOTES, VII. Page 61. There is no God ! This negation must be understood solely to affect a creative Deity. The hypothesis of a pervading Spirit coeternal with the universe, remains UDshaken. A close examination of the validity of the proofs adduced to support any proposition, is the only secure way of attaining truth, on the advantages of which it is unnecessary to descant: our knowiedge of the exist- ence of a Deity is a subject of such importance, that it cannot be too minutely investigated; in consequence of this conviction we proceed briefly and impartially to examine the proofs which have been adduced. It is necessary first to consider the nature of belief. When a proposition is offered to the mind, it per- ceives the agreement or disagreement of the ideas of which it is composed. A perception of their agree- ment is termed belief. Many obstacles frequently prevent this perception from being immediate; these the mind attempts to remove, in order that the percep- tion may be distinct. The mind is active in the inves- tigation, in order to perfect the state of perception of the relation which the component ideas of the proposi- tion bear to each, which is passive: the investigation being confused with the perception, has induced many falsely to imagine that the mind is active in belief, — that belief is an act of volition, — in consequence of which it may be regulated by the mind. Pursuing, continuing this mistake, they have attached a degree of NOTES. 125 criminality to disbelief; of which, in its nature, it is incapable: it is equally incapable of merit. Belief, then, is a passion, the strength of which, like every other passion, is in precise proportion to the de- grees of excitement. The degrees of excitement are three. The senses are the sources of all knowledge to the mind ; consequently their evidence claims the strongest assent. The decision of the mind, founded upon our own experience, derived from these sources, claims the next degree. The experience of others, which addresses itself to the former one, occupies the lowest degree. (A graduated scale, on which should be marked the capabilities of propositions to approach to the test of the senses, would be a just barometer of the belief which ought to be attached to them.) Consequently no testimony can be admitted which is contrary to reason ; reason is founded on the evidence of our senses. Every proof may be referred to one of these three divisions: it is to be considered what arguments we receive from each of them, which should convince us of the existence of a Deity. 1st. The evidence of the senses* If the Deity should appear to us, if he should convince our senses, of his existence, this revelation would necessarily command belief. Those to whom the Deity has thus appeared have the strongest possible conviction of his existence. 126 NOTES. But the God of Theologians is incapable of local visi- bility. 2d. Reason. It is urged that man knows that what- ever is, must either have had a beginning, or have ex- isted from all eternity: he also knows, that whatever is not eternal must have had a cause. When this rea- soning is applied to the universe, it is necessary to prove that it was created: until that is clearly demon- strated, we may reasonably suppose that it has endur- ed from all eternity. We must prove design before we can infer a designer. The only idea which we can form of causation is derivable from the constant con- junction of objects, and the consequent inference of one from the other. In a case where two propositions are diametrically opposite, the mind believes that which is least incomprehensible; — it is easier to suppose that the universe has existed from all eternity, than to con- ceive a being beyond its limits capable of creating it: if the mind sinks beneath the weight of one, is it an alleviation to increase the intolerability of the burthen? The other argument, which is founded on a man's knowledge of his own existence, stands thus. A man knows not only that he now is, but that once he was not ; consequently there must have been a cause. But our idea of causation is alone derivable from the con- stant conjunction of objects and the consequent! nfer- ence of one from the other; and, reasoning experimen- tally, we can only infer from effects, causes exactly adequate to those effects. But there certainly is a generative power which is effected by certain instru- NOTES. 127 ments: we cannot prove that it is inherent in these instruments; nor is the contrary hypothesis capable of demonstration: we admit that the generative power is incomprehensible; but to suppose that the same effect is produced by an eternal, omniscient, omnipotent being, leaves the cause in the same obscurity, but ren- ders it more incomprehensible. 3d. Testimony. It is required that testimony should not be contrary to reason. The testimony that the Deity convinces the senses of men of his existence, can only be admitted by us, if our mind considers it less probable that these men should have been deceived, than that the Deity should have appeared to them. Our reason can never admit the testimony of men, who not only declare that they were eye-witnesses of mira- cles, but that the Deity was irrational; for he com- manded that he should be believed, he proposed the highest rewards for faith, eternal punishments for dis- belief. We can only command voluntary actions; belief is not an act of volition ; the mind is even pas- sive, or involuntarily active: from this it is evident that we have no sufficient testimony, or rather that testi- mony is insufficient to prove the being of a God. It has been before shewn that it cannot be deduced from reason. They alone, then, who have been convinced by the evidence of the senses, can believe it. Hence it is evident that, having no proofs from either of the three sources of conviction, the mind cannot believe the existence of a creative God: it is also evi- dent, that, as belief is a passion of the mind, no degree of criminality is attachable to disbelief; and that they 128 NOTES. only are reprehensible who neglect to remove the false medium through which their mind views any subject of discussion. Every reflecting mind must acknowledge that there is no proof of the existence of a Deity. God is an hypothesis, and, as such, stands in need of proof : the onus probandi* rests on the theist. Sir Isaac Newton says: Hypotheses non jingo, quicquid enim ex phcenomenis non deducitur, hypothesis vocan- da est, et hypothesis vel metaphysiccB, Del physicce, vel qualitatum occultarum, seu mechanicce, in philosophid locum non habent b . To all proofs of the existence of a creative God apply this valuable rule. We see a vari- ety of bodies possessing a variety of powers : we merely know their effects ; we are in a state of ignorance with respect to their essences and caused. These Newton calls the phenomena of things; but the pride of philo- sophy is unwilling to admit its ignorance of their causes. From the phenomena, which are the objects of our senses, we attempt to infer a cause, which we call God, and gratuitously endow it with all negative and con- tradictory qualities. From this hypothesis we invent this general name, to conceal our ignorance of causes and essences. The being called God by no means answers with the conditions prescribed by Newton ; it bears every mark of a veil woven by philosophical con- a The burthen of proof. b I do not invent hypothesis ; for whatever is not deduced from phoeno- mena, is to be called an hypothesis ; and hypotheses, either metaphysical or physical, or grounded on occult qualities, should not be allowed any room in philosophy. NOTES. 129 ceit, to hide the ignorance of philosophers even from themselves. They borrow the threads of its texture from the anthropomorphism of the vulgar. Words have been used by sophists for the same purposes, from the occult qualities of the peripatetics to the effluvium of Boyle and the crinities or nebulae of Herschel. God. is represented as infinite, eternal, incomprehensible; he is contained under every praedicate in non that the logic of ignorance could fabricate. Even his worship- pers allow that it is impossible to form any idea of him: they exclaim with the French poet, Pour dire ce quHl est, ilfaut etre lui-meme.* Lord Bacon says, that " Atheism leaves a man to sense, to philosophy, to natural piety, to laws, to repu- tation: all which may be guides to an outward moral virtue, though religion were not ; but superstition dis- mounts all these, and erecteth an absolute monarchy in the minds of men: therefore atheism did never perturb states; for it makes men wary of themselves, as looking no farther, and we seethe times inclined to atheism (as the time of Augustus Caesar) were civil times : but superstition hath been the confusion of many states, and bringeth in a new primum mobile, that ravisheth all the spheres of government. Bacon's Moral Essay on Superstition. a To tell what he is, you must be himself. 9 130 NOTES. a La premiere theologie de l'homme lui fit d'abord craindre et adorer les elemens meme, des objets mate- riels et grossiers; il rendit ensuite ses hommages a des agens presidens aux elemens, a des genies inferieurs, a des heros, ou a des homraes doues de grands qualites. A force de re'fleehir il crut simplifier les choses ensou- mettant la nature entiere a un seul agent, a un esprit, a une ame universelle, qui mettoit cette nature et ses parties en mouvement. En remontant des causes en causes, les mortels ont fini par ne rien voir ; et c'est dans cette obscurite qu'ils ont place leur Dieu; c'est dans cette abime tenebreux que leur imagination in- quiete travaille toujours a se fabriquer des chimeres, que les affligeront jusqu'a ce que la connoissance de la nature less detrompe des phantomes qu'ils ont toujours si vainement adores. Si nous voulons nous rendre compte de nos idees sur ■ The primary theology of man made him first fear and worship even the elements gross and material objects, he then paid his adorations to the pre- siding agents of the elements, to inferior genii, to heroes, or to men en- dowed with great qualities. By continuing to reflect he thought to sim- plify things, by submitting all nature to a single agent, to a spirit, to an universal soul, which put this nature, and its parts into motion. In ascending from cause, to cause, mankind have ended, by seeing nothing, and it is in the midst of this obscurity, that they have placed their God; it is in this dark abyss, that their restless imagination is always labouring to form chimeras, which will afflict them, until a knowledge of nature shall dissipate the phantoms which they have always so vainly adored. If we wish to render an account to ourselves, of our ideas respecting the Deity, we shall be obliged to confess that by the word God, men have never been able to designate any thing else but the most hidden, the most remote, the most unknown cause of the effects which they perceive; they only make use of this word, when the springs of natural and known causes cease to be visible to them ; the instant they lose the thread, or their un- NOTES. 131 la Divinite, nous serons obliges de convenir que, par le mot Dieu, les hommes n'ont jamais pu designer que la cause la plus cachee, la plus eloiguee, la plus incon- nue des effets qu'ils voyoient: ils ne font usage de ce mot, que lorsque le jeu des causes naturelles et con- nues cesse d'etre visible pour eux; des qu'ils perdent le fit de ces causes, ou des que leur esprit ne peut plus en suivre la chaine, ils tranchent leur difficulty, et ter- minent leur recherches en apellent Dieu la deraiere des causes, c'est-a-dire celle qui est au-dela de toutes les causes qu'ils connoisseut; ainsi ils ne font qu'assi- gner une denomination vague a une cause ignoree, a laquelle leur paresse ou les bornes de leurs connois- sances les forcent de s'arreter. Toutes les fois qu'on nous dit que Dieu est l'auteur de quelque phenomene, cela signifie qu'on ignore comment un tel phenomene a pu s'operer par le secours des forces ou des causes que derstanding can no longer follow the chain of these causes, they cut the knot of their difficulty and terminate their researches by calling God the last of these causes, that is to say, that which is beyond all the causes' with which they are acquainted. Thus they merely assign a vague denomina- tion to an unknown cause, at which their indolence or the limits of their in- formation compels them to stop. Whenever we are told, that God is the author of any phenomenon, that signifies that we are ignorant how such a phenomenon can be produced, with the assistance only of the natural pow- ers or causes with which we are acquainted. It is thus that the generality of mankind, whose lot is ignorance, attribute to the Deity, not only the uncommon effects which strike them, but even the most simple events, whose causes are the most easily discoverable, to all who have had the op- portunity of reflecting on them. In a word man has always respected the unknown causes of those surprising effects, which his ignorance prevented him from unravelling. It was upon the ruins of nature that men first raised the imaginary colossus of a Deity. 132 NOTES. nous connoissons dans la nature. C'est aiusi que le commun des homines, dont Fignorance est la partage, attribue a la Divinite non seulement les effets inusites que les frappent, mais encore les evenemens les plus simples, dont les causes sont les plus faciles a connoitre pour quiconque a pu les mediter. En un mot, l'homme a toujours respecte les causes inconnues des effets sur- prenans, que son ignorance Fempechoit de demeler. Ce fut sur les debris de la nature que les homines Re- verent le colosse imaginaire de la Divinite. Si Fignorance de la nature donna la naissance aux dieux, la connoissance de la nature est faite pour les detruire. A mesure que l'homme s'instruit, ses forces et ses ressources augmentent avec ses lumieres ; les sci- ences, les arts conservateurs, Findustrie, lui fournissent des secours ; l'experience le rassure, ou lui procure des moyens de resister aux efforts de bien des causes qui If the ignorance of nature gave birth to gods, a knowledge of nature is calculated to destroy them. In proportion as man becomes informed, his powers and resources in- crease with his knowledge, the sciences, the conservative arts, and industry furnish him with assistance, experience inspires him with confidence, or procures him the means of resisting the efforts of many causes, which cease to alarm him, as soon as he becomes acquainted with them. In a word, his terrors are dissipated in the same proportion as his mind is enlightened. A well informed man ceases to be superstitious. It is never but on trust, that whole nations worship the God of their fa- thers, and their priests ; authority, confidence, submission, and custom, to them supply the place of proofs and conviction ; they prostrate themselves and pray, because their fathers have taught them to prostrate themselves and pray, but wherefore did the latter kneel ? Because in remote periods, their guides and regulators, taught them it was a duty. " Worship and believe," said they " gods which you cannot comprehend, rely on our pro- found wisdom, we know more than you concerning the Deity." " But why NOTES. 1 33 cessent de l'alarmer des qu'il les a connues. En un mot, ses terreurs se dissipent dans la meme proportion que son esprit s'eclaire. L'homme instruit cesse d'etre superstitieux. Ce n'est jamais que sur parole que dps peu pies en- tiers adorent le Dieu de leurs peres et de leurs pretres: l'autorite, la confiance, la soumission, et l'habitude, leur tiennent lieu de conviction et de preuves; ils se prosternent et prient, parce que leurs peres leur ont ap- pris a se prosterner et prier: mais pourquoi ceux-ci se sont-ils mis a genoux? C'est que dans les temps eloi- gnes leurs legislateurs et leurs guides leur en ont fait un devoir. " Adorez et croyez," ont-ils dit, " des dieux que vous ne pouvez comprendre; rapportez-vous en a notre sagesse profonde; nous en savons plus que vous sur la Divinite." " Mais pourquoi m'en rapporterois-je a vous?" " C'est que Dieu le veut ainsi, c'est que Dieu vous punira si vous osez resister." " Mais ce Dieu n'est- il done pas la chose en question?" Cependant les hom- should I rely on you ?" " Because it is the will of God, because he will pun- ish you if you dare to resist." " But is not this God the thing in question?" Thus men have always been satisfied with this vicious circle, the indolence of their minds led them to believe the shorter mode was to rely upon the opinions of others. All religious notions, are founded upon authority alone, all the religions of the world forbid investigation, and will not permit reasoning ; it is authority which requires us to believe in God, this God himself is only founded upon the authority of some men, who pretend to know him, and to be sent by him to announce him to the world. A God made by men has doubtless need of men to make him known to men. Is it then only, for the priests of the inspired, for metaphysicians, that a conviction of the existence of a God is reserved, and which is nevertheless said to be necessary to all mankind. But do we find a harmony of theo- logical opinion among the inspired, or the reflective, in the different parts 134 NOTES, mes se sont toujours payees de ce cercle vicieux ; la paresse de leur esprit leur fit trouver plus court de s'en rapporter au jugement des autres. Toutes les notions religieuses sont fondees uniquement sur l'autorite; toutca les religions du monde defendent l'exaraen et ne veulent pas que Ton raisonne ; c'est l'autorite que veut qu'ou crut en Dieu; ce Dieu n'est lui-meme fonde que sur l'autorite de quelques hommes qui pretendent le connoitre, et venir de sa part pour l'annoncer a la terre. Un Dieu fait par les hommes, a sans doute besoin des hommes pour se faire connoitre aux hommes. Ne seroit-ce done que pour des pretres des inspires, des metaphysiciens que seroit reservee la conviction de l'existence d'un Dieu, que 1'on dit neanmoins si necessaire a tout le genre-humain ? Mais trouvons- nous de I'hannonie entre les opinions theologiques des differens inspires, ou des penseurs repandus sur la terre? Ceux meme que font profession d'adorer le meme Dieu, sont-ils d'accord sur son compte? Sont-ils contents of the world ? Are those even who profess to worship the same God agreed respecting him? Are they satisfied with the proofs of his existence which their colleagues bring forward ? Do they unanimously subscribe to the ideas which they adduce respecting his nature, his conduct, and the mode of understanding his pretended oracles ? Is there a country, throughout the earth in which the knowledge of God is really perfected. Has it assumed in any quarter the consistency, and uniformity, which we perceive human knowledge to have assumed, in the most trifling arts, in trades the most despised, The words spirit, immateriality, creation, predestination, grace, this croud of subtile distinctions with which theology, in some countries, is universally filled, these ingenious inventions, imagined by the successive reasoners of ages, have, alas ! only embroiled the question, and never has the science, the most important to mankind, been able to acquire the least stability, for thousands of years, have these idle dreamers transmitted to NOTES. 135 des preuves que leurs collegues apportent de son exis- tence? Souscrivent-ils unanimement aux idees qu'ils presentent sur sa nature, sur sa conduite, sur la facon d'entendre ses pretendus oracles? Est-il une contree sur la terre, ou la science de Dieu se soit reellement perfectionn6 ? A-t-elle pris quelque part la consistence et l'uniformite que nous voyons prendre aux connois- sances humaines, aux arts les plus futiles, aus metiers les plus meprises? des mots d'esprits, dHmmaterialite, de creation, de predestination, de grace; cette foule de distinctions subtiles dont la theologie s'est partout remplie dans quelques pays, ces inventions si ingeni- euses, imaginees par des penseurs que se sont succedes depuis tant de siecles, n'ont fait, helas! qu'embrouilles les choses, et jamais le science le plus necessaire aux hommes n'a jusqu'ici pu acquerir la moindre fixite. Depuis des milliers d'annees, ces reveurs oisifs se sont perpetuellement relayes pour mediter la Divinite, pour deviner ses voies cachees, pour inventer des hypotheses each other, the task of meditating on the Deity, of discovering his secret paths, of inventing hypotheses calculated to solve this important enigma. The little success they have met with, has not discouraged theological va- nity. God has always been talked of, mankind have cut each others throats for him, and this great being still continues, to be the most unknown, and the most sought after. Fortunate would it have been for mankind if confining themselves to the visible objects in which they are interested, they had employed in per- fecting true science, laws, morals, and education, half the exertions they have made in their researches after a Deity. They would have been still wiser and more fortunate, could they have resolved to leave their blind guides to quarrel among themselves and to sound the depths calculated only to turn their brains without meddling with their senseless disputes. But it is the very essence of ignorance to attach importance to w hat it 136 NOTES. propres a developper cette enigme importante. Leur peu de succes n'a point decourage la vanity theologique ; toujours on a parle de Dieu: on s'est egorg6 pour lui, et cet etre sublime demeure toujours le plus ignore et le plus discut6. Les hommes auroient et6 trop heureux, si, se bornant aux objets visibles qui les interessent, lis eussent em- ploye a perfectionner leurs sciences reelles, leurs loix, leur morale, leur education, la moiti6 des efforts qu'ils ont mis dans leurs recherches sur la Divinite. lis auroient ete bien plus sages encore, et plus fortunes s'ils eussent pu conseutir a laisser leurs guides desoeu- xr6s se quereller entre eux, et sonder des profondeurs capables de les etourdir, sans se meslerde leurs disputes insensees. Mais il est de l'essence de l'ignorance d'at- tacher de l'importance a ce qu'elle ne comprend pas. La vanite humaine fait que l'esprit se roidit eontre les difficultes. Plus un objet se derobe a nos yeux, plus nous faisons d'efforts pour le saisir, parce que des-lors does not understand. Human vanity is such that the mind became irri- tated by difficulty. In proportion as an object fades from our sight do we exert ourselves to seize it, because it then stimulates our pride, it excites our curiosity and becomes interesting. In contending for his God every one in fact is only contending for the interests of his own vanity, which of all the passions, produced by the mal-organization of society, is the most prompt to take alarm, and the most calculated to give birth, to great ab- surdities. If laying aside for a moment the gloomy ideas which theology gives us of a capricious God, whose partial and despotic decrees decide the fates of men, we fix our eyes upon the pretended goodness which all men, even whilst trembling before this God, agree in giving to him, if we suppose him to be actuated by the project which is attributed to him, of having only laboured for his own glory, of exacting the adoration of intelligent NOTES. 137 il aiguillone notre orgueil, il excite notre curiosite, il nous paroit interessant. En combattant pour son Dieu, chacun ne combattit en effet que pour les interetsdesa propre vanite, qui de toutes les passious produits par la mal organization de la societe, est la plus prompte a s'allarmer, et la plus propre a produire des tres grands folies. Si ecartant pour un moment les idees facbeuses que la theologie nous donne d'un Dieu capricieux, dont les decrets parteaux et despotiques decident du sort des bumains, nous ne voulons fixer nos yeux que sur la bonte pretendue, que tous les hommes, meme en trem- blant devant ce Dieu, s'accordant a lui donner; si nous lui supposons le projet qu'on lui prete, de n'avoir tra- vaille que pour sa propre gloire, d'exiger les hommages des etres intelligens ; de ne chercher dans ses ceuvres que le bien-etre du genre humain; comment concilier ses vues et ses dispositions avec l'ignorance vraiment invincible dans lequelle ce Dieu, si glorieux et si bon, beings, of seeking onry in his works, the welfare of the human race ; how can we reconcile his views and dispositions with the truly invincible igno- rance in which this God so good and glorious leaves the greater part of mankind respecting himself ? If God wishes to be known, beloved, and praised, why does he not reveal himself under some favourable features, to all those intelligent beings by whom he wishes to be loved and wor- shipped ! Why does he not manifest to all the earth in an unequivocal manner, much more calculated to convince us, than by these particular revelations which seem to accuse the Deity of an unjust partiality for some of his creatures. Would not the Omnipotent possess more con- vincing means of revealing himself to mankind than these ridiculous meta- morphoses, these pretended incarnations, which are attested to us by writers who so little agree among themselves in the recitals they give of them ? Instead of so many miracles invented to prove the divine mission 138 NOTES. laisse la plupart des hommes sur son compte? Si Dieu veut etre connu, cheri, remercie, que ne se montre-t-il sous des traits favorables a tous ces etres intelligens dont il veut etre aime et adore? Pourquoi ne point se mani- fester a toute la terre d'une facon non equivoque, bieu plus capable de nous convaincre, que ces revelations particuliers qui semblent accuser la Divinite d'une par- tiality facheuse pour quelqu'uns de ses creatures? Le tout-puissant n'auroit-il done pas des moyens plus con- vinquans de se montrer aux borames que ces metamor- phoses ridicules, ces incarnations pretendues, qui nous sont attestees par des ecrivains si peu d'accord entre eux dans les recits qu'ils en font? Au lieu de tant de miracles, invent6s pour prouver la mission divine de tant de legislateurs, reveres par les differens peuples du monde, le souverain des esprits ne pouvoit-il pas convaincre tout d'un coup Fesprit humain des cboses qu'il a voulu lui faire conuoitre? Au lieu de suspendre un soleil dans la voute du firmament ; au lieu de re- pandre sans ordre les 6toiles, et les constellations qui of so many legislators revered by the different nations of the world, could not the Supreme Being convince in an instant the human mind of the things which he chose to make known to it? Instead of suspending the sun in the vault of the firmament, instead of dispersing the stars and the constellations, which occupy space without order, would it not have been more conformable to the views of a God so jealous of his glory, and so well disposed to man, to write in a mode not liable to be disputed, his name, his attributes, and his unchangeable will, in everlasting characters, equally legible to all the inhabitants of the earth ? No one could then have doubted the existence of a God, his manifest will, his visible intentions. Under the eye of this terrible Deity, no one would have had the audacity to violate his ordinances, no mortal would have dared to place himself in the situation of drawing down his wrath; and, lastly, no man would NOTES. 139 remplissent l'espace, n'eut-il pas ete plus conforme aux vues d'un Dieu si jaloux de sa gloire et si bien inten- tionne pour l'homnie; d'ecrire d'une fac,ou uon sujette a dispute, son nom, ses attributs, ses volontes perma- nentes, en caracteres ineffacubles, et lisibles egalement pour tous les habitants de la terre? Personne alors n'auroit pu douter de l'existence d'un Dieu, de ses volontes claires, de ses intentions visibles. Sous les yeux de ce Dieu si terrible, personne n'auroit eu l'au- dace de violer ses ordonnances; nul mortel n'eut ose se mettre dans le cas d'attirer sa colere: enfin nul homme n'eut eu le front d'en imposer en son nom, ou d'interpreter ses volontes suivant ses propres phan- tasies. En effet, quand meime on admetteroit l'existence du Dieu theologique, et la realite des attributs si discordaus qu'on lui donne, Ton ne peut en rien conclure, pour autoriser la conduite ou les cultes qu'on present de lui rendre. La tbe^ologie est vraiment le tonneau des Da- naides. A force de qualities contradictoires et d'as-. have had the effrontery to impose on his fellow creatures, in the name of the Deity, or to interpret his will according to his own fancy. In fact, even should the existence of the theological God be admitted, and the reality of the discordant attributes which are given to him, nothing could be inferred from it, to authorise the conduct or the modes of worship, which we are told to observe towards him. Theology is truly the tub of the Danaides. By dint of contradictory qualities and rash assertions, it has so trammelled, as it were, its God, that it has made it impossible for him to act. If he is infinitely good, what reason have we to fear him ? If he is infinitely wise, why should we be uneasy for our future state ? If he knows all, why inform him of our wants, and tease him with our prayers ? If he is omnipresent, why raise temples to him ? If he is master of all, why sacrifice and make offerings to him ? If he is just, how can we believe that HO NOTES. sertions hazardees, elle a, pour ainsi dire, teUement garote son Dieu qu'elle a mis dans I'impossibilite d'agir. S'il est infiuiment bon quelle raison aurions-nous de le craindre? S'il est innnimerjt sage, dequoi nous inquie- ter sur notre sort? S'il sait tout, pourquoir l'avertir de nos besoins, et le fatiguer de nos prieres? S'il est par- tout, pourquoi lui elever des temples? S'il est maitre de tout, pourquoi lui faire des sacrifices et des offrandes ? S'il est juste, comment croire qu'il punisse des creatures qu'il a rempli des foiblesses? Si la grace fait tout en elles, quelle raison auroit-il de les recompenser ? S'il est tout-puissant, comment l'offenser, comment lui re- sister? S'il est raisonnable, comment se mettroit-il en colere contre des aveugles, a qui il a laisse la liberty de deraisonner? S'il est immuable, de quel droit pre- tend rions-nous faire changer ses decrets? S'il est inconcevable, pourquoi nous en occuper? , S'IL A PARLE', POURQUOI L'UNIVERS N'EST-IL PAS CONVAINCU? Si la connoissance d'un Dieu est la plus necessaire, pourquoi n'esfcelle pas la plus evidente, et la plus claire. Sysleme de la Nature, London, 1781. he punishes creatures -whom he has afflicted with weaknesses? If grace does all in them, for what reason should he reward them ? If he is omni- potent how can we offend, how resist him ?- If he is reasonable, how could he be incensed against his blind creatures, to whom he has only left the liberty of falling into error ? If he is immutable, by what right do we pre- tend to make him change his decrees ? If he is incomprehensible, why do we busy ourselves in endeavouring to understand him ? If HE HAS SPOKEN, WHY IS NOT THE UNIVERSE CONVINCED ? If the knowledge of a God is the most necessary, why is not the clearest and most evident? — System of Nature, London, 1781. NOTES. 141 The enlightened and benevolent Pliny thus publicly professes himself an, atheist : — Quapropter effigiem Dei, formamque quaerere, imbeciilitatis humanae reor. Quis- quis estDeus (si raodo est alius) et quacunque in parte, totus est sensus, totus est visus, totus auditus, totus animae, totus animi, totus sui. * * * * * Imperfecta vera in nomine naturse praecipua solatia ne deum quidem posse omnia. Namque nee si bi po- test mortem consciscere, si velit, quod homini dedit optimum in tantis vitee poenis : nee mortales eeternitate donare, aut revocare defunctos ; nee facere ut qui vixit non vixerit, qui honores gessit non gesserit, nullumque habere in prseteritum jus, praeterquam oblivionis, atque (ut facetis quoque argumentis societas haec cum deo copuletur) ut bis dena viginta non sint, et multa simi- liter efiicere non posse. — Per quae, declarator haud dubie, naturae potentiam id quoque esse, quod Deum vocamus a . — Plin. Nat. His. cap. de Deo. a For which reason, I consider that the inquiry after the form and figure of the Deity, must be attributed to human weakness. Whatever God may be (if indeed there be one) and wherever he may exist, he must be all . sense, all sight, all hearing, all life, all mind, self-existent. * * * * But it is a great consolation to man with all his infirmities to reflect that God himself cannot do all things : for he cannot inflict on himself death, even if he should wish to die, that best of gifts to man amidst the cares and sufferings of life ; neither can he make men eternal, nor raise the dead, nor prevent those who have lived from living, nor those who have borne honours from wearing them ; he has no power over the past, except that of oblivion, and (to relax our gravity awhile and indulge in a joke) he cannot prevent twice ten from being twenty, and many other things of a similar nature. From these observations it is clearly apparent that the powers of nature are what we call God. Plin. Nat. Hist. 142 NOTES. The consistent Newtonian is necessarily an atheist. See Sir W. Drummond's Academical Questions, chap, iii. — Sir W. seems to consider the atheism to which it leads, as a sufficient presumption of the falsehood of the system of gravitation : but surely it is more con- sistent with the good faith of philosophy to admit a deduction from facts, than an hypothesis incapable of proof, although it might militate with the obstinate preconceptions of the mob. Had this author, instead of inveighing against the guilt and absurdity of atheism, demonstrated its falsehood, his conduct would have been more suited to the modesty of the sceptic, and the toleration of the philosopher. fj3r» Omnia enim per Dei potentiam facta sunt : imo, quia natura potentia nulla est nisi ipsa Dei potentia, autem est nos eatenus Dei potentiam non intelligere, quatenus causas naturales ignoramus; adeoque stulte ad eandem Dei potentiam recurritur, quando rei alicu- jus, causam naturalem, sive est, ipsam Dei potentiam ignoramus. Spinosa, Tract. Theologico-Pol. chap. i. p. 14. a All things are made by the power of God, yet, doubtless, because the power of nature is the power of God : besides we are unable to understand the power of God, so far as we are ignorant of natural causes; therefore we foolishly recur to the power of God whenever we are unacquainted with the natural cause of any thing, or in other words, with the power of God — Spinosa, Tract. Theologici. Pol. chap. i. p. 14. NOTES. 143 VII. Page 63. Ahasuerus, rise ! Ahasuerus the Jew crept forth from the dark cave of Mount Carmel. Near two thousand years have elapsed since he was first goaded by never-ending restlessness, to rove the globe from pole to pole. When our Lord was wearied with the burthen of his ponde- rous cross, and wanted to rest before the door of Ahasuerus, the unfeeling wretch drove him away with brutality. The Saviour of mankind staggered, sinking under the heavy load, but uttered no complaint. An angel of death appeared before Ahasuerus, and ex- claimed indignantly, " Barbarian! thou hast denied rest to the Son of Man : be it denied thee also, until he comes to judge the world." A black demon, let loose from hell upon Ahasuerus, goads him now from country to country ; he is denied the consolation which death affords, and precluded from the rest of the peaceful grave. Ahasuerus crept forth from the dark cave of Mount Carmel — he shook the dust from his beard — and taking up one of the sculls heaped there, hurled it down the eminence : it rebounded from the earth in shivered atoms. This was my father! roared Ahasuerus. Seven more sculls rolled down from rock to rock ; while the infuriate Jew, following them with ghastly looks ex- claimed — And these were my wives! He still conti- nued to burl down scull after scull, roaring in dreadful accents — And these, and these, and these were my 144 NOTES children! They could die; but, I! reprobate wretch, alas! I cannot die! Dreadful beyond conception is the judgment that hangs over me. Jerusalem fell — I crushed the sucking babe, and precipitated myself into the destructive flames. I cursed the Romans — but, alas ! alas ! the restless curse held me by the hair* — and I could not die ! Rome the giantess fell — I placed myself before the falling statue — she fell, and did not crush me. Nations sprung up and disappeared before me; — but I remain- ed and did not die. From cloud-encircled cliffs did I precipitate myself into the ocean ; but the foaming billows cast me upon the shore, and the burning arrow of existence pierced my cold heart again. I leaped into Etna's flaming abyss, and roared with the giants for teu long months, polluting with my groans the Mount's sulphureous mouth — ah ! ten long months. The volcano fermented, and in a fiery stream of lava cast me up. I lay torn by the torture snakes of hell amid the glowing cinders, and yet continued to exist. A forest was on fire: I darted on wings of fury and despair into the crackling wood. Fire dropped upon me from the trees, bat the flames only singed my limbs; alas! it could not consume them. — 1 now mixed with the butchers of mankind, and plunged in the tempest of the raging battle. I roared defiance to the infuriate Gaul, defiance to the victorious German; but arrows and spears rebounded in shivers from my body. The Saracen's flaming sword broke upon my scull: balls in vain hissed upon me: the lightnings of battle glared harmless around my loins : in vain did the ele- NOTES. 145 phant trample on me, in vain the iron hoof of the wrathful steed ! The mine, big with destructive power, burst upon me, and hurled me high in the air — I fell on heaps of smoking limbs, but was only singed. The giant's steel club rebounded from my body ; the exe- cutioner's hand could not strangle me; the tyger's tooth could not pierce me, nor would the hungry lion in the circus devour me. I cohabited with poisonous snakes, and pinched the red crest of the dragon. The serpent stung, but could not destroy me ; — the dragon tormented, but dared not to devour me. I now pro- voked the fury of tyrants: I said to Nero, Thou art a bloodhound! I said to Christiern, Thou art a blood- hound ! I said to Muley Ismail, Thou art a blood- hound ! — The tyrants invented cruel torments, but did not kill me. Ha ! not to be able to die — not to be able to die — not to be permitted to rest after the toils of life — to be doomed to be imprisoned for ever in the clay -formed dungeon — to be for ever clogged with this worthless body, its load of diseases and infirmities — to be condemned to hold for milen- niums that yawning monster Sameness and Time, that hungry hyena, ever bearing children, and ever de- vouring again her offspring! — Ha! not to be permitted to die! Awful avenger in heaven, hast thou in thine armoury of wrath a punishment more dreadful? then let it thunder upon me, command a hurricane to sweep me down to the foot of Carmel, that I there may lie extended; may pant, and writhe, and die! This fragment is the translation of part of some Ger- 10 146 NOTES. man work, whose title I have vainly endeavoured to discover. I picked it up, dirty and torn, some years ago, in Lincoln's-Inn Fields. VII. Page 66. I will beget a Son, and he shall bear The sins of all the world. A book is put into our hands when children, called the Bible, the purport of whose history is briefly this: That God made the earth in six days, and there plant- ed a delightful garden, in which he placed the first pair of human beings. In the midst of the garden he planted a tree, whose fruit, although within their reach, they were forbidden to touch. That the Devil, in the shape of a snake, persuaded them to eat of this fruit ; in consequence of which God condemned both them and their posterity yet unborn to satisfy his jus- tice by their eternal misery. That, four thousand years after these events, (the human race in the mean while having gone unredeemed to perdition,) God en- gendered with the betrothed wife of a carpenter in Judea (whose virginity was nevertheless uninjured), and begat a Son, whose name was Jesus Christ; and who was crucified and died, in order that no more men might be devoted to hell-fire, he bearing the bur- then of his Father's displeasure by proxy. The book states, in addition, that the soul of whoever disbelieves this sacrifice will be burned with everlasting fire. During many ages of misery and darkness this story NOTES. 147 gained implicit belief; but at length men arose who suspected that it was a fable and imposture, and that Jesus Christ, so far from being a God, was only a man like themselves. But a numerous set of men, who de- rived and still derive immense emoluments from this opinion, in the shape of a popular belief, told the vul- gar, that, if they did not believe in the Bible, they would be damned to all eternity ; and burned, impri- soned, and poisoned all the unbiassed and unconnected enquirers who occasionally arose. They still oppress them, so far as the people, now become more enlight- ened, will allow. The belief in all that the Bible contains, is called Christianity. A Roman Governor of Judea, at the instance of a priest-led mob, crucified a man called Jesus eighteen centuries ago. He was a man of pure life, who desired to rescue his countrymen from the tyranny of their barbarous and degrading supersti- tions. The common fate of all who desire to benefit mankind awaited him. > The rabble, at the instigation of the priests, demanded his death, although his very judge made public acknowledgment of his innocence. Jesus was sacrificed to the honour of that God with whom he was afterwards confounded. It is of impor- tance, therefore to distinguish between the pretended character of this being, as the Son of God and the Saviour of the world, and his real character as a man, who, for a vain attempt to reform the world, paid the forfeit of his life to that overbearing tyranny which has since so long desolated the universe in his name. Whilst the one is a hypocritical demon, who announces 148 NOTES. • himself as the God of compassion and peace, even whilst he stretches forth his blood-red hand with the sword of discord to waste the earth, having confessedly devised this scheme of desolation from eternity; the other stands in the foremost list of those true heroes, who have died in the glorious martyrdom of liberty, and have braved torture, contempt, and poverty, in the cause of suffering humanity a . The vulgar, ever in extremes, became persuaded that the crucifixion of Jesus was a supernatural event. Testimonies of miracles, so frequent in unenlightened ages, were not wanting to prove that he was something divine. This belief, rolling through the lapse of ages, met with the reveries of Plato and the reasonings of Aristotle, and acquired force and extent, until the divinity of Jesus became a dogma, which to dispute was death, which to doubt was infamy. Christianity is now the established religion: he who attempts to impugn it, must be contented to behold murderers and traitors take precedence of him in pub- lic opinion; though, if his genius be equal to his cou- rage, and assisted by a peculiar coalition of circum- stances, future ages may exalt him to a divinity, and persecute others in his name, as he was persecuted in the name of his predecessor in the homage of the world. The same means that have supported every other popular belief, have supported Christianity. War, * Since writing this note I have seen reason to suspect, that Jesus was n ambitious man, who aspired to the throne of Judea. , NOTES. 149 imprisonment, assassination, and falsehood; deeds of unexampled and incomparable atrocity have made it what it is. The blood shed by the votaries of the God of mercy and peace, since the establishment of his re- ligion, would probably suffice to drown all other sec- taries now on the habitable globe. We derive from our ancestors a faith thus fostered and supported: we quarrel, persecute, and hate for its maintenance. Even under a government which, whilst it infringes the very right of thought and speech, boasts of permitting the liberty of the press, a man is pilloried and imprisoned because he is a Deist, and no one raises his voice in the indignation of outraged humanity. Eut it is ever a proof that the falsehood of a proposition is felt by those who use coercion, not reasoning, to procure its admission; and a dispassionate observer would feel himself more powerfully interested in favour of a man, who, depending on the truth of his opinions, simply stated his reasons for entertaining them, than in that of his aggressor, who, daringly avowing his unwil- lingness or incapacity to answer them by argument, proceeded to repress the energies and break the spirit of their promulgator by that torture and imprisonment whose infliction he could command. Analogy seems to favour the opinion, that as, like other systems, Christianity has arisen and augmented, so like them it will decay and perish; that, as vio- lence, darkness, and deceit, not reasoning and persua- sion, have procured its admission among mankind, so, when enthusiasm has subsided, and time, that infalli- ble controverter of false opinions, has involved its pre- 150 NOTES. tended evidences in the darkness of antiquity, it will become obsolete ; that Milton's poem alone will give permanency to the remembrance of its absurdities ; and that men will laugh as heartily at grace, faith, re- demption, and original sin, as they now do at the metamorphoses of Jupiter, the miracles of Romish saints, the efficacy of witchcraft, and the appearance of departed spirits. Had the Christian religion commenced and conti- nued by the mere force of reasoning and persuasion, the preceding analogy would be inadmissible. We should never speculate on the future obsoleteness of a system perfectly conformable to nature and reason: it would endure so long as they endured ; it would be a truth as indisputable as the light of the sun, the cri- minality of murder, and other facts, whose evidence, depending on our organization and relative situations, must remain acknowledged as satisfactory, so long as man is man. It is an incontrovertible fact, the consi- deration of which ought to repress the hasty conclu- sions of credulity, or moderate its obstinacy in main- taining them, that, had the Jews not been a fanatical race of men, had even the resolution of Pontius Pilate been equal to his candour, the Christian religion never could have prevailed, it could not even have existed: on so feeble a thread hangs the most cherished opinion of a sixth of the human race! When will the vulgar learn humility? When will the pride of ignorance blush at having believed before it could comprehend ? Either the Christian religion is true, or it is false: if true, it comes from God, and its authenticity can NOTES 151 admit of doubt and dispute no further than its omni- potent author is willing to allow. Either the power or the goodness of God is called in question, if be leaves those doctrines most essential to the well being of man in doubt and dispute ; the only ones which, since their promulgation have been the subject of un- ceasing cavil, the cause of irreconcileable hatred. If God has spoken, why is the universe not con- vinced ? There is this passage in the Christian Scriptures : " Those who obey not God, and believe not the Gos- pel of his Son, shall be punished with everlasting destruction." This is the pivot upon which all reli- gions turn : they all assume that it is in our power to believe or not to believe ; whereas the mind can only believe that which it thinks true. A human being can only be supposed accountable for those actions which are influenced by his will. But belief is utterly distinct from and unconnected with volition : it is the apprehension of the agreement or disagreement of the ideas that compose any proposition. Belief is a pas- sion, or involuntary operation of the mind, and, like other passions, its intensity is precisely proportionate to the degrees of excitement. Volition is essential to merit or demerit. But the Christian religion attaches the highest possible degrees of merit and demerit to that which is worthy of neither, and which is totally unconnected with the peculiar faculty of the mind, whose presence is essential to their being. Christianity was intended to reform the world; had 152 NOTES. an all-wise Being planned it, nothing is more impro- bable than that it should have failed: omniscience would infallibly have foreseen the inutility of a scheme which experience demonstrates, to this age, to have been utterly unsuccessful. Christianity inculcates the necessity of supplicating the Deity. Prayer may be considered under two points of view ; as an endeavour to change the intentions of God, or as a formal testimony of our obedience. But the former case supposes that the caprices of a limited intelligence can occasionally instruct the Creator of the world how to regulate the universe ; and the latter, a certain degree of servility analogous to the loyalty demanded by earthly tyrants. Obedience indeed is only the pitiful and cowardly egotism of him who thinks that he can do something better than reason. Christianity, like all other religions, rests upon mira- cles, prophesies, and martyrdoms. No religion ever existed, which had not its prophets, its attested mira- cles, and, above all, crowds of devotees who would bear patiently the most horrible tortures to prove its authenticity. It should appear that in no case can a discriminating mind subscribe to the genuineness of a miracle. A miracle is an infraction of nature's law, by a supernatural cause ; by a cause acting beyond that eternal circle within which all things are included. God breaks through the law of nature, that he may convince mankind of the truth of that revelation which, in spite of his precautions, has been, since its introduc- tion, the subject of unceasing schism and cavil. NOTES. 153 Miracles resolve themselves into the following ques- tions — Whether it is more probable the laws of na- ture, hitherto so immutably harmonious, should have undergone violation, or that a man should have told a lie? Whether it is more probable that we are ignorant of the natural cause of an event, or that we know the supernatural one? That, in old times, when the powers of nature were less known than at present, a certain set of men were themselves deceived, or had some hidden motive for deceiving others; or that God begat a son, who, in his legislation, measuring merit by- belief, evidenced himself to be totally ignorant of the powers of the human mind — of what is voluntary, and what is the contrary ? We have many instances of men telling lies; — none of an infraction of nature's laws, those laws of whose government alone we have any knowledge or experi- ence. The records of all nations afford innumerable instances of men deceiving others either from vanity or interest, or themselves being deceived by the limited- ness of their views and their ignorance of natural causes: but where is the accredited case of God having come Upon earth, to give the lie to his own creations? There would be something truly wonderful in the appearance of a ghost; but the assertion of a child that he saw one as he passed through the church-yard, is universally admitted to be less miraculous. But even supposing that a man should raise a dead body to life before our eyes, and on this fact rest his * See Hume's Essay, vol. ii. page 121. 154 NOTES claim to being considered the son of God; — the Hu- mane Society restores drowned persons, and because it makes no mystery of the method it employs, its mem- bers are not mistaken for the sons of God. All that we have a right to infer from our ignorance of the cause of any event is that we do not know it: had the Mexi- cans attended to this simple rule when they heard the cannon of the Spaniards, they would not have consi- dered them as gods: the experiments of modern chemis- try would have defied the wisest philosophers of an- cient Greece and Rome to have accounted for- them on natural principles. An author of strong common sense has observed, that " a miracle is no miracle at second-hand;" he might have added, that a miracle is no miracle in any case; for until we are acquainted with all natural causes, we have no reason to imagine others. v There remains to be considered another proof of Christianity — Prophecy. A book is written before a certain event, in which this event is foretold; how could the prophet have foreknown it without inspira- tion? how could he have been inspired without God? The greatest stress is laid on the prophecies of Moses and Hosea on the dispersion of the Jew^s, and that of Isaiah concerning the coming of the Messiah. The prophecy of Moses is a collection of every possible cursing and blessing ; and it is so far from being mar- vellous that the one of dispersion should have been ful- filled, that it would have been more surprising if, out of all these, none should have taken effect. In Deuter- onomy, chap, xxviii. ver. 64, where Moses explicitly NOTES. 155 foretells the dispersion, he states that they shall there serve gods of wood and stone: " And the Lord shall scatter thee among all people, from the one end of the earth even to the other, and there thou shalt serve other gods, which neither thou nor thy fathers have known, even gods of wood and stone." The Jews are at this day remarkably tenacious of their religion. Moses also declares that they shall be subjected to these causes for disobedience to his ritual: " And it shall come to pass, if thou will not hearken unto the voice of the Lord thy God, to observe to do all the commandments and statutes which I command you this day, that all these curses shall come upon thee and overtake thee." Is this the real reason? The third, fourth and fifth chapters of Hosea are a piece of immo- dest confession. The indelicate type might apply in a hundred senses to a hundred thiugs. The fifty-third chapter of Isaiah is more explicit, yet it does not exceed in clearness the oracles of Deiphos. The histo- rical proof, that Moses, Isaiah and Hosea did write when they are said to have written, is far from being clear and circumstantial. But prophecy, requires proof in its character as a miracle; we have no right to suppose that a man fore- knew future events from God, until it is demonstrated that he neither could know them b} 7 his own exertions, nor that the writings w r hich contain the prediction could possibly have been fabricated after the event pretended to be foretold. It is more probable that writings, pre- tending to divine inspiration, should have been fabri- cated after the fulfilment of their pretended prediction, 156 NOTES, than that they should have really been divinely inspir- ed ; when we consider that the latter supposition makes God at once the creator of the human mind and igno- rant of its primary powers, particularly as we have numberless instances of false religions, and forged pro- phesies of things long past, and no accredited case of God having conversed with men directly or indirectly. It is also possible that the description of an event might have foregone its occurrence; but this is far from being a legitimate proof of a divine revelation, as many men, not pretending to the character of a prophet, have nevertheless, in this sense, prophesied. Lord Chesterfield was never yet taken for a prophet, even by a bishop, yet he uttered this remarkable predic- tion: " The despotic government of France is screwed up to the highest pitch ; a revolution is fast approaching ; that revolution, I am convinced, will be radical and sanguinary." This appeared in the letters of the pro- phet long before the accomplishment of this wonderful prediction. Now, have these particulars come to pass, or have they not? If they have, how could the Earl have foreknown them without inspiration? If we admit the truth of the Christian religion on testimony such as this, we must admit, on the same strength of evidence, that God has affixed the highest rewards to belief, and the eternal tortures of the never-dying worm to disbelief ; both of which have been demonstrated to be involuntary. The last proof of the Christian religion depends on the influence of the Holy Ghost. Theologians divide the influence of the Holy Ghost into its ordinary and NOTES. , 157 extraordinary modes of operation. The latter is sup- posed to be that which inspired the Prophets and Apostles ; and the former to be the grace of God, which summarily makes known the truth of his revelation, to those whose mind is fitted for its reception by a sub- missive perusal of his word. Persons convinced in this manner, can do any thing but account for their convic- tion, describe the time at which it happened, or the manner in which it came upon them. It is supposed to enter the mind by other channels than those of the senses, and therefore professes to be superior to reason founded on their experience. Admitting, however, the usefulness or possibility of a divine revelation, unless we demolish the foundations of all human knowledge, it is requisite that our reason should previously demonstrate its genuineness; for, before we extinguish the steady ray of reason and com- mon sense, it is fit that we should discover whether we cannot do without their assistance, whether or no there be any other which may suffice to guide us through the labyrinth of life a : for, if a man is to be inspired upon all occasions, if he is to be sure of a thing because he is sure, if the ordinary operations of the spirit are not to be considered very extraordinary modes of demonstra- tion, if enthusiasm is to usurp the place of proof, and madness that of sanity, all reasoning is superfluous. The Mahometan dies fighting for his prophet, the Indian immolates himself at the chariot-wheels of Brahma, the a See Locke's Essay on the Human Understanding, book iv. chap, xix., on Enthusiasm. 158 NOTES. Hottentot worships an insect, the Negro a bunch of feathers, the Mexican sacrifices human victims! Their degree of conviction must certainly be very strong: it cannot arise from conviction, it must from feelings, the reward of their prayers. If each of these should affirm, in opposition to the strongest possible arguments, that inspiration carried internal evidence, I fear their in- spired brethren, the orthodox Missionaries, would be so uncharitable as to pronounce them obstinate. Miracles cannot be received as testimonies of a dis- puted fact, because, all human testimony has ever been insufficient to establish the possibility of miracles. That which is incapable of proof itself, is no proof of any thing else. Prophecy has also been rejected by the test of reason. Those, then, who have been ac- tually inspired, are the only true believers in the Chris- tian religion. Mox numine viso Virginei tumuere sinus, innuptaque mater Arcano stupuit compleri viscera partu Auctorum paritura suum. Mortalia corda Artificem texere poli, latuitque sub uno Pec to re, qui totura late complectitur orbem. Claudian, Carmen Paschale. a a Upon seeing the Divinity, the Virgin's womb soon swelled, and the unmarried mother was amazed to find herself filled with a mysterious pro- geny, and that she was to bring forth to the world her own Creator. A mortal frame veiled the Framer of the Heavens, and he who embraces the wide surrounding circle of the world, lay himself concealed in the recesses of the womb. NOTES. 159 Does not so monstrous and disgusting an absurdity carry its own infamy and refutation with itself? VIII. Page 79. Him, (still from hope to hope the bliss pursuing, Which, from the exhaustless lore of human weal Dawns on the virtuous mind,) the thoughts that rise In time-destroying infiniteness, gift With self-enshrined eternity, &c. Time is our consciousness of the succession of ideas in our mind. • Vivid sensation, of either pain or plea- sure, makes the time seem long, as the common phrase is, because it renders us more acutely conscious of our ideas. If a mind be conscious of an hundred ideas during one minute, by the clock, and of two hundred during another, the latter of these spaces would actu- ally occupy so much greater extent in the mind as two exceed one in quantity. If, therefore, the human mind, by any future improvement of its sensibility, should become conscious of an infinite number of ideas in a minute, that minute would be eternity. I do not hence infer that the actual space between the birth and death of a man will ever be prolonged ; but that bis sensibility is perfectible, and that the number of ideas which his mind is capable of receiving is indefinite. One man is stretched on the rack during twelve hours; another sleeps soundly in his bed : the difference of time perceived by these two persons is immense ; one hardly will believe that half an hour has elapsed, the other could credit that centuries had flown during his agony. 160 NOTES. Thus, the life of a man of virtue and talent, who should die in his thirtieth year, is, with regard to his own feelings, longer than that of a miserable priest-ridden slave, who dreams out a century of dulness. The one has perpetually cultivated his mental faculties, has ren- dered himself master of his thoughts, can abstract and generalize amid the lethargy of every-day business; — the other can slumber over the brightest moments of his being, and is unable to remember the happiest hour of his life. Perhaps the perishing ephemeron enjoys a longer life than the tortoise. Dark flood of time ! Roll as it listeth thee — I measure not By months or moments thy ambiguous course. Another may stand by me on the brink And watch the bubble whirled beyond his ken That pauses at my feet. The sense of love, The thirst for action, and the impassioned thought Prolong my being: if I wake no more, My life more actual living will contain Than some grey veterans' of the world's cold school. Whose listless hours unprofitably roll, • By one enthusiast feeling unredeemed. See Godwin's Pol. Jus. vol. i. page 411; — and Condorcet, Esquisse dlun Tableau Historique des Progres de V Esprit Uu- main, Epoque ix. NOTES 161 VIII. Page 79. No longer now He slays the lamb that looks him in the face. I hold that the depravity of the physical and moral nature of man originated in his unnatural habits of life. The origin of man, like that of the universe of which he is a part, is enveloped in impenetrable mystery. His generations either had a beginning, or they had not. The weight of evidence in favour of each of these suppositions seems tolerably equal; and it is perfectly unimportant to the present argument which is assumed. The language spoken, however, by the mythology of nearly all religions seems to prove, that at some distant period man forsook the path of nature, and sacrificed the purity and happiness of his being to unnatural appetites. The date of this event seems to have also been that of some great change in the climates of the earth, with which it has an obvious correspondence. The allegory of Adam and Eve eating of the tree of evil, and entailing upon their posterity the wrath of God, and the loss of everlasting life admits of no other explanation than the disease and crime that have flowed from unnatural diet. Milton was so well aware of this, that he makes Raphael thus exhibit to Adam the con- sequence of his disobedience. — : Immediately a place Before his eyes appeared: sad, noisome, dark: A lazar-house it seem'd; wherein were laid 11 162 NOTES. Numbers of all diseased: all maladies Of ghastly spasm, or racking torture, qualms Of heart-sick agony, all feverous kinds, Convulsions, epilepsies, fierce catarrhs, Intestine stone and ulcer, cholic pangs, Dsemoniac frenzy, moping melancholy, And moon-struck madness, pining atrophy, Marasmus, and wide-wasting pestilence, Dropsies, and asthmas, and joint-racking rheums. And how many thousands more might not be added to this frightful catalogue! The story of Prometheus is one likewise which, al- though universally admitted to be allegorical, has never been satisfactorily explained. Prometheus stole fire from heaven, and was chained for this crime to mount Caucasus, where a vulture continually devoured his liver, that grew to meet its hunger. Hesiod says, that, before the time of Prometheus, mankind were exempt from suffering; that they enjoyed a vigorous youth, and that death, when at length it came, approached like sleep, and gently closed their eyes. Again, so general was this opinion, that Horace, a poet of the Augustan age, writes — Audax omnia perpeti, Gens humana ruit per vetitum nefas; Audax Iapeti genus Ignem fraude mala gentibus intulit: Post ignem aetheria domo NOTES, 163 Subductum, macieset nova febrium Terris incubuit cohors, Seraotique prius tarda necessitas Lethi corripuit gradum a . How plain a language is spoken by all this. Prome- theus (who represents the human race) effected some great change in the condition of his nature, and applied fire to culinary purposes ; thus inventing an expedient for screening from his disgust the horrors of the sham- bles. From this moment his vitals were devoured by the vulture of disease. It consumed his being in every shape of its loathsome and infinite variety, inducing the soul-quelling sinkings of premature and violent death. All vice arose from the ruin of healthful innocence. Tyranny, superstition, commerce, and inequality, were then first known, when reason vainly attempted to guide the wanderings of exacerbated passion. I con- clude this part of the subject with an extract from Mr. Newton's Defence of Vegetable Regimen, from whom I have borrowed this interpretation of the fable of Pro- metheus. " Making allowance for such transposition of the a Thus, from the sun's ethereal beam When bold Prometheus stole th' enlivening flame, Of fevers dire a ghastly brood, Till then unknown, th' unhappy fraud pursu'd ; On earth their horrors baleful spread, And the pale monarch of the dead, Till then slow-moving to his prey, Precipitately rapid sv/ept his way. Francis's Horace, Book i. Ode 3.- 164 NOTES. events of the allegory as time might produce after the important truths were forgotten, which this portion of the ancient mythology was intended to transmit, the drift of the fable seems to be this: — Man at his creation was endowed with the gift of perpetual youth ; that is, he was not formed to be a sickly suffering creature as we now see him, but to enjoy health, and to sink by slow degrees into the bosom of his parent earth with- out disease or pain. Prometheus first taught the use of animal food (primus bovem occidit Prometheus 3 ) and of fire, with which to render it more digestible and pleasing to the taste. Jupiter, and the rest of the gods, foreseeing the consequences of these inventions, were amused or irritated at the short-sighted devices of the newly-formed creature, and left him to experience the sad effects of them. Thirst, the necessary concomitant of a flesh diet," (perhaps of all diet vitiated by culina- ry preparation,) ensued; water was resorted to, and man forfeited the inestimable gift of health which he had received from heaven: he became diseased, the partaker of a precarious existence, and no longer de- scended slowly to his grave V But just disease to luxury succeeds, And every death its own avenger breeds; The fury passions from that blood began, And turned on man a fiercer savage— man. Man, and the animals whom he has infected with his » Prometheus first killed an ox. Plin. Nat. Hist. lib. y'd. sect. 57. b Return to nature. Cadell, 1811. NOTES. 165 society, or depraved by his dominion, are alone diseas- ed. The wild hog, the mouflon, the bison, and the wolf, are perfectly exempt from malady, and invariably die either from external violence, or natural old age. But the domestic hog, the sheep, the cow, and the dog are, subject to an incredible variety of distempers; and, like the corrupters of their nature, have physicians who thrive upon their miseries. The supereminence of man is like Satan's, a supereminence of pain; and the ma- jority of his species, doomed to penury, disease and crime, have reason to curse the untoward event, that by enabling him to communicate his sensations, raised, him above the level of his fellow animals. But the steps that have been taken are irrevocable. The whole of human science is comprised in one question:-— How can the advantages of intellect and civilization be re- conciled with the liberty and pure pleasures of natural life? How can we take the benefits, and reject the evils of the system, which is now interwoven with all the fibres of our being ? — I believe that abstinence from animal food and spirituous liquors would in a great measure capacitate us for the solution of this important question. It is true, that mental and bodily derangement is at- tributable in part to other deviations from rectitude and nature than those which concern diet. The mistakes cherished by society respecting the connection of the sexes, whence the misery and diseases of unsatisfied celibacy, unenjoying prostitution, and the premature arrival of puberty necessarily spring; the putrid atmo- sphere of crowded cities; the exhalations of chemical 166 NOTES. processes; the muffling of our bodies in superfluous apparel; the absurd treatment of infants:— all these, and innumerable other causes, contribute their mite to the mass of human evil. Comparative anatomy teaches us that man resembles frugivorous animals in every thing, and carnivorous in nothing ; he has neither claws wherewith to seize his prey, nor distinct and pointed teeth to tear the living fibre. A Mandarin of the first class, with nails two inches long, would probably find them alone, ineffi- cient to hold even a hare, After every subterfuge of gluttony, the bull must be degraded into the ox, and the ram into the wether, by an unnatural and inhuman operation, that the flaccid fibre may offer a fainter resistance to rebellious nature. It is only by softening and disguising dead flesh by culinary preparation, that it is rendered susceptible of mastication or digestion ; and that the sight of its bloody juices and raw horror does not excite intolerable loathing and disgust. Let the advocate of animal food force himself to a decisive experiment on its fitness, and, as Plutarch recommends, tear a living lamb with his teeth, and plunging his head into its vitals, slake his thirst with the steaming blood ; when fresh from the deed of horror, let him revert to the irresistible instincts of nature that would rise in judgment against it, and say, Nature formed me for such work as this. Then, and then only, would he be consistent. Man resembles no carnivorous animal. There is no exception, unless man be one, to the rule of herbi- vorous animals having cellulated colons. NOTES. 1#7 The orang-outang perfectly resembles man both in the order and number of his teeth. The orang-outang is the most anthropomorphous of the ape tribe, all of which are strictly frugivorous. There is no other species of animals, which live on different food, in which this analogy exists a . In many frugivorous animals, the canine teeth are more pointed and distinct than those of man. The resemblance also of the human stomach to that of the orang-outang, is greater than to that of any other animal. The intestines are also identical with those of herbi- vorous animals, which present a larger surface for absorption and have ample and cellulated colons. The coecum also, though short, is larger than that of carnivorous animals ; and even here the orang-outang retains its accustomed similarity. The structure of the human frame then is that of one fitted to a pure vegetable diet, in every essential particular. It is true, that the reluctance to abstain from animal food, in those who have been long accus- tomed to its stimulus, is so great in some persons of weak minds, as to be scarcely overcome ; but this is far from bringing any argument in its favour. A lamb, which was fed for some time on flesh by a ship's r" crew, refused its natural diet at the end of the voyage. There are numerous instances of horses, sheep, oxen, and even wood-pigeons, having been taught to live upon flesh, until they have loathed their natural ali- a Cuvier, Lecons d' Anat. Comp. torn. iii. pages 169, 373, 448, 465, 480. Rees's Cyclopaedia, article Man. 168 NOTES. merit. Young children evidently prefer pastry, oranges, apples, and other fruit, to the flesh of animals, until, by the gradual depravation of the digestive organs, the free use of vegetables has for a time produced serious inconveniences ; for a time, I say, since there never was an instance wherein a change from spirituous liquors and animal food to vegetables and pure water, has failed ultimately to invigorate the body, by ren- dering its juices bland and consentaneous, and to re- store to the mind that cheerfulness and elasticity, which not one in fifty possesses on the present system. A love of strong liquors is also with difficulty taught to infants. Almost every one remembers the wry faces which the first glass of port produced. Unsophisti- cated instinct is invariably unerring ; but to decide on the fitness of animal food, from the perverted appetites which its constrained adoption produces, is to make the criminal a judge in his own cause: it is even worse, it is appealing to the infatuated drunkard in a question of the salubrity of brandy. What is the cause of morbid action in the animal system? Not the air we breathe, for our fellow deni- zens of nature breathe the same uninjured;, not the water we drink, (if remote from the pollutions of man and his inventions' 1 ,) for the animals drink it too ; not% the earth we tread upon ; not the unobscured sight of a The necessity of resorting to some means' of purifying water, and the disease which arises from its adulteration in civilized countries, is suffi- ciently apparent. — See Dr. Lambe's Reports on Cancer. I do not assert that the use of water is in itself unnatural, but that the unperverted palate would swallow no liquid capable of occasioning disease. NOTES. 169 glorious nature, in the wood, the field, or the expanse of sky and ocean; nothing that we are or do in com- mon with the undiseased inhabitants of the forest. Something then wherein we differ from them : our habit of altering our food by fire, so that our appetite is no longer a just criterion for the fitness of its grati- fication. Except in children there remain no traces of that instinct which determines, in all other animals, what aliment is natural or otherwise ; and so perfectly obliterated are they in the reasoning adults of our species, that it has become necessary to urge conside- rations drawn from comparative anatomy, to prove that we are naturally frugivorous. Crime is madness. Madness is disease. Whenever the cause of disease shall be discovered, the root, from which all vice and misery have so long overshadowed the globe, will lie bare to the axe. All the exertions of man, from that moment, may be considered as tending to the clear profit of his species. No sane mind in a sane body resolves upon a real crime. It is a man of violent passions, blood-shot eyes, and swollen veins, that alone can grasp the knife of mur- der. The system of a simple diet promises no Uto- pian advantages. It is no mere reform of legislation,, whilst the furious passions and evil propensities of the human heart, in which it had its origin, are still un- assuaged. It strikes at the root of all evil, and is an experiment which may be tried with success, not alone by nations, but by small societies, families, and. even individuals. In no cases has a return to vegeta- ble diet produced the slightest injury; in most it has 170 NOTES. been attended with changes undeniably beneficial. Should ever a physician be born with the genius of Locke, I am persuaded that he might trace all bodily and mental derangements to our unnatural habits, as clearly as that philosopher has traced all knowledge to sensation. What prolific sources of disease are not those mineral and vegetable poisons that have been introduced for its extirpation! How many thousands have become murderers and robbers, bigots and do- mestic tyrants, dissolute and abandoned adventurers, from the use of fermented liquors; who had they slaked their thirst only with pure water, would have lived but to diffuse the happiness of their own unper- verted feelings. How many groundless opinions and absurd institutions have not received a general sanc- tion from the sottishness and intemperance of indivi- duals! Who will assert that, had the populace of Paris satisfied their hunger at the ever-furnished table of vegetable nature, they would have lent their brutal suffrage to the proscription-list of Robespierre? Could a set of men, whose passions were not perverted by unnatural stimuli, look with coolness on an auto da ft? Is it to be believed that a being of gentle feelings, .rising from his meal of roots, would take delight in sports of blood ? Was Nero a man of temperate life? Could you read calm health in his cheek, flushed with ungovernable propensities of hatred for the human race? Did Muley Tsmael's pulse beat evenly, was his skin transparent, did his eyes beam with healthful- ness, and its invariable concomitants, cheerfulness and benignity? Though history has decided none of these NOTES. 171 questions, a child could not hesitate to answer in the negative. Surely the bile-suffused cheek of Buona- parte, his wrinkled brow, and yellow eye, the cease- less inquietude of his nervous system, speak no less plainly the character of his unresting ambition than his murders and his victories. It is impossible, had Buo- naparte descended from a race of vegetable feeders, that he could have had either the inclination or the power to ascend the throne of the Bourbons. The desire of tyranny could scarcely be excited in the indi- vidual, the power to tyrannize would certainly not be delegated by a society neither frenzied by inebriation, nor rendered impotent and irrational by disease. Pregnant indeed with inexhaustible calamity is the renunciation of instinct, as it concerns our physical nature ; arithmetic cannot enumerate, nor reason per- haps suspect, the multitudinous sources, of disease in civilized life. Even common water, that apparently innoxious pabulum, when corrupted by the fillh of populous cities, is a deadly and insidious destroyer*. Who can wonder that all the inducements held out by God himself in the Bible to virtue should have been vainer than a nurse's tale ; and that those dogmas, by which he has there excited and justified the most fero- cious propensities, should have alone been deemed essential ; whilst Christians are in the daily practice .of all those habits which have infected with disease and crime, not only the reprobate sons, but these fa- voured children of the common Father's love. Omnit a Lanibe's Reports on Cancer. 172 NOTES. potence itself could not save them from the conse- quences of this original and universal sin. There is no disease, bodily or mental, which adop- tion of vegetable diet and pure water has not infallibly mitigated, wherever the experiment has been fairly tried. Debility is gradually converted into strength, disease into healthfulness ; madness, in all its hideous variety, from the ravings of the fettered maniac, to the unaccountable irrationalities of ill temper, that make a hell of domestic life, into a calm and considerate evenness of temper, that alone might offer a certain pledge of the future moral reformation of society. On a natural system of diet, old age would be our last and our only malady ; the term of our existence would be protracted; we should enjoy life, and no longer preclude others from the enjoyment of it ; all sensa- tional delights would be infinitely more exquisite and perfect; the very sense of being would then be a con- tinued pleasure, such as we now feel it in some few and favoured moments of our youth. By all that is sacred in our hopes for the human race, I coojure those who love happiness and truth, to give a fair trial to the vegetable system. Reasoning is surely super- fluous on a subject whose merits an experience of six months would set for ever at rest. But it is only among the enlightened and benevolent that so great a sacrifice of appetite and prejudice can be expected, even though its ultimate excellence should not admit of dispute. It is found easier, by the short-sighted victims of disease, to palliate their torments by medi- cine, than to prevent them by regimen. The vulgar NOTES. 1 73 of all ranks are invariably sensual and indocile ; yet I cannot but feel myself persuaded, that when the be- nefits of vegetable diet are mathematically proved ; when it is as clear, that those who live naturally are exempt from premature death, as that nine is not one, the most sottish of mankind will feel a preference to- wards a long and tranquil, contrasted with a short and painful life. On the average, out of sixty persons, four die in three years, Hopes are entertained that in April 1814, a statement will be given that sixty per- sons, all having lived more than three years on vege- tables and pure water, are then in perfect health. More than two years have now elapsed ; not one of them has died; no such example will be found in any sixty persons taken at random. Seventeen persons of all ages (the families of Dr. Lambe and Mr. Newton) have lived for seven years on this diet without a death, and almost without the slightest illness. Surely, when we consider that some of these were infants, and one a martyr to asthma now nearly subdued, we may challenge any seventeen persons taken at random in this city to exhibit a parallel case. Those who may have been excited to question the rectitude of estab- lished habits of diet, by these loose remarks, should consult Mr. Newton's luminous and eloquent essay 3 . When these proofs come fairly before the world, and are clearly seen by all who understand arithmetic, it is scarcely possible that abstinence from aliments de- monstrably pernicious should not become universal. a Return to Nature, or Defence of Vegetable Regimen. Cadell, 1811. 174 NOTES. In proportion to the number of proselytes, so will be the weight of evidence ; and when a thousand persons can be produced, living on vegetables and distilled water, who have to dread no disease but old age, the world will be compelled to regard animal flesh and fermented liquors as slow but certain poisons. The change which would be produced by simpler habits on political economy, is sufficiently remarkable. The monopolizing eater of animal flesh would no longer destroy his constitution by devouring an acre at a meal, and many loaves of bread would cease to con- tribute to gout, madness, and apoplexy, in the shape of a pint of porter, or a dram of gin, when appeasing the long-protracted famine of the hard-working pea- sant's hungry babes. The quantity of nutritious vege- table matter, consumed in fattening the carcase of an ox, would afford ten times the sustenance, undepraving indeed, and incapable of generating disease, if gather- ed immediately from the bosom of the earth. The most fertile districts of the habitable globe are now actually cultivated by men for animals, at a delay and waste of aliment absolutely incapable of calculation. It is only the wealthy that can, to any great degree, even now, indulge the unnatural craving for dead flesh, and they pay for the greater licence of the privi- lege, by subjection to supernumerary diseases. Again, the spirit of the nation that should take the lead in this great reform, would insensibly become agricultural; commerce, with all its vice, selfishness, and corrup- tion, would gradually decline ; more natural habits would produce gentler manners, and the excessive NOTES. 175 complication of political relations would be so far simplified, that every individual might feel and under- stand why he loved his country, and took a personal interest in its welfare. How would England, for ex- ample, depend on the caprices of foreign rulers, if she contained within herself all the necessaries, and des- pised whatever they possessed of the luxuries of life? How could they starve her into compliance with their views? Of what consequence would it be that they refused to take her woollen manufactures, when large and fertile tracts of the island ceased to be allotted to the waste of pasturage? On a natural system of diet, we should require no spices from India; no wines. from Portugal, Spain, France, or Madeira ; none of those multitudinous articles of luxury, for which every corner of the globe is rifled, and which are the causes of so much individual rivalship, such calamitous and. sanguinary national disputes. In the history of mo- dem times, the avarice of commercial monopoly, no less than the ambition of weak and wicked chiefs, seems to have fomented the universal discord, to have added stubbornness to the mistakes of cabinets, and- indocility to the infatuation of the people. Let it ever be remembered, that it is the direct influence of com- merce to make the interval between the richest and the poorest man, wider and more unconquerable. Let it be remembered, that it is a foe to every thing of real worth and excellence in the human character. The odious and disgusting aristocracy of wealth, is built upon the ruins of all that is good in chivalry or repub- licanism ; and luxury is the forerunner of a barbarism 176 NOTES. scarce capable of cure. Is it impossible to realize a state of society, where all the energies of man shall be directed to the production of his solid happiness? Certainly, if this advantage (the object of all political speculation) be in any degree attainable, it is attain- able only by a community, which holds out no facti- tious incentives to the avarice and ambition of the few, and which is internally organized for the liberty, security, and comfort of the many. None must be entrusted with power (and money is the completest species of power) who do not stand pledged to use it exclusively for the general benefit. But the use of animal flesh and fermented liquors, directly militates with this equality of the rights of man. The peasant cannot gratify these fashionable cravings without leav- ing his family to starve. Without disease and war, those sweeping curtailers of population, pasturage would include a waste too great to be afforded. The labour requisite to support a family is far lighter 3 than is usually supposed. The peasantry work, not only for themselves, but for the aristocracy, the army, and the manufacturers. The advantage of a reform in diet is obviously greater than that of any other. It strikes at the root of the evil. To remedy the abuses of legislation, be- a It has come under the author's experience, that some of the workmen on an embankment in North Wales, who, in consequence of the inability of the proprietor to pay them, seldom received their wages, have support- ed large families by cultivating small spots of sterile ground by moonlight. In the notes to Pratt's Poem, u Bread, or the Poor," is an account of an industrious labourer, who, by working in a small garden, before and after his day's task, attained to an enviable state of independence. NOTES. 177 fore we annihilate the propensities by which they are produced, is to suppose, that by taking away the effect, the cause will cease to operate. But the efficacy of this system depends entirely on the proselytism of individuals, and grounds its merits, as a benefit to the community, upon the total change of the dietetic habits in its members. It proceeds securely from a number of particular cases to one that is universal, and has this advantage over the contrary mode, that one error does not invalidate all that has gone before. Let hot too much, however, be expected from this system. The healthiest among us is not exempt from hereditary disease. The most symmetrical, athletic, and long-lived, is a being inexpressibly inferior to what he would have been, had not the unnatural habits of his ancestors accumulated for him a certain portion of malady and deformity. In the most perfect speci- men of civilized man, something is still found wanting by the physiological critic. Can a return to nature, then, instantaneously eradicate predispositions that have been slowly taking root in the silence of innume- rable ages? — Indubitably not. All that I contend for is, that from the moment of the relinquishing all unna- tural habits, no new disease is generated ; and that the predisposition to hereditary maladies gradually pe- rishes, for want of its accustomed supply. In cases of consumption, cancer, gout, asthma, and scrofula, such is the invariable tendency of a diet of vegetables and pure water. Thosa who may be induced by these remarks to give the vegetable system a fair trial, should in the 12 178 • NOTES. first place, date the commencement of their practice, from the moment of their conviction. All depends upon breaking through a pernicious habit resolutely, and at once. Dr. Trotter" asserts, that no drunkard was ever reformed by gradually relinquishing his dram. Animal flesh, in its effects on the human sto- mach, is analagous to a dram. It is similar to the kind, though differing in the degree, of its operation. The proselyte to a pure diet must be warned to expect a temporary diminution bf muscular strength. The subtraction of a powerful stimulus will suffice to account for this event. But it is only temporary, and is succeeded by an equable capability for exer- tion, far surpassing his former various and fluctuat- ing strength. Above all, he will acquire an easiness of breathing, by which such exertion is performed, with a remarkable exemption from that painful and difficult panting now felt by almost every one, after hastily climbing an ordinary mountain. He will be equally capable of bodily exertion, or mental appli- cation, after as before his simple meal. He will feel none of the narcotic effects of ordinary diet. Irrita- bility, the direct consequence of exhausting stimuli, would yield to the power of natural and tranquil im- pulses. He will no longer pine under the lethargy of ennui, that unconquerable weariness of life, more to be dreaded than death itself. He will escape the epi- demic madness, which broods over # its own injurious a See Trotter on the Nervous Temperament, NOTES. 17!) notions of the Deity, and " realizes the hell that priests and beldams feign." Every man forms as it were his god from his own character ; to the divinity of one of simple habits, no offering would be more acceptable than the happiness of his creatures. He would be in- capable of hating or persecuting others for the love of God. He will find, moreover, a system of simple diet to be a system of perfect epicurism. He will no lon- ger be incessantly occupied in blunting and destroying those organs from which he expects his gratification. The pleasures of taste to be derived from a dinner of potatoes, beans, peas, turnips, lettuces, with a dessert of apples, gooseberries, strawberries, currants, rasp- berries, and, in winter, oranges, apples, and. pears, is far greater than is supposed. Those who wait until they can eat this plain fare with the sauce of appetite will scarcely join with the hypocrital sensualist at a lord-mayor's feast, who declaims against the pleasures of the table. Solomon kept a thousand concubines, and owned in despair that all was vanity. The man whose happiness is constituted by the society of one amiable woman, would find some difficulty in sympa- pathiziug with the disappointment of this venerable debauchee. I address myself not only to the young enthusiast, the ardent devotee of truth and virtue, the pure and passionate moralist, yet unvitiated by the contagion of the world. He will embrace a pure system, from its abstract truth, its beauty, its simplicity, and its promise of wide-extended benefit; unless custom has turned poison into food, he will hate the brutal plea- 180 NOTES. sures of the chase by instinct ; it will be a contempla- tion full of horror and disappointment to his mind, that beings capable of the gentlest and most admirable sympathies, should take delight in the death-pangs and last convulsions of dying animals. The elderly man, whose youth has been poisoned by intemperance, or who has lived with apparent moderation, and is afflicted with a variety of painful maladies, would find his account in a beneficial change, produced with- out the risk of poisonous medicines. The mother, to whom the perpetual restlessness of disease, and unac- countable deaths incident to her children, are the causes of incurable unhappiness, would on this diet expe- rience the satisfaction of beholding their perpetual health and natural playfulness 3 . The most valuable lives are daily destroyed by dis- eases, that it is dangerous to palliate and impossible to cure by medicine. How much longer will man con- tinue to pimp for the gluttony of death, his most insi- dious, implacable, and eternal foe ? a See Mr- Newton's book. His children are the most beautiful and healthy creatures it is possible to conceive ; the girls are perfect models for a sculptor; their dispositions are also the most gentle and conciliating ; the judicious treatment which they experience in other points, may be a correlative cause of this. In the first five years of their life, of 18,000 children that are born, 7,500 die of various diseases ; and how many more of those that survive are rendered miserable by maladies not immediately mortal ? The quality and quantity of a woman's milk are materially in- jured by the use of dead flesh. In an island, near Iceland, where no vegetables are to be got, the children invariably die of tetanus, before they are three weeks old, and the population is supplied from the main land. — Sir G. Mackenzie's Hist, of Iceland. See also Emile, chap. i. p. 53, 54, 56. NOTES. 181 'AXXa ogXKOvlxt; xfpitsc kx\e7te kxi nxgoccXiiS kxi Xi'onxs, xvtoi c!£ (AixiipoysTrt eU, uiJ.ort)T ol b\|/o» ectt/v. * * * ' * * * * Or; yxq «* ecr//v avSjaiBTo) xara i KXTxaKErr^. Ovoevi yxg Ioikc to xv9punru aujfxx tuv eth (7xgKoipuyi.ee yeyonorcuv, 8 ysvirorv; j^eiA**?, aim o^vtius ovvxps, a Tgxyvrite ooovrwv neocnartv , a koiXixs EuTovix, kxi tdiev^xto^ •3if-u.orri$, T££\j/a< kxi KXTEpyxt^xoSxi ovvxttq to pxgv kxi k^euioes. AAA xvroSev o5 tynfffi Tt) Aeot»)T( tS o"Z-o/w.«to$, xct» t>i ^.a.'KxKOT-nrt Tys yXiixraris, kxi tj? TTfos we'\| ctu/xxti auv, r> x-p-vx 'o Xxyuov oixppri^ov, kxi (payf irpoairsauv tri Cpvros w<; EHshx* ******* 'H/!X.£?S OE «Ti/; EV TW [AlXlQovto T^v'pCdfA.EV, WTTE 0^/OV TO KPEX^ irgo&xyogEvofjiEv, eitx o-^cuv vipos xvro To v.pixq '^lOfj.E^x, xvxf/.iyvvv tes eXxiov, ohov, (aeXi, yxp>ov, o^os, iovatAxai 'ZvpizKoTi;, AppxffiiioTs, UGTIEP- OVTCOS ])tK.p01l EVTxQtXt^lVTEq. K.XI yXP> OTUS U.VTOJV O lx7\'jdsvTCUV xxi y.x\xypivTuv kxi t^otcov t'ivx KgEoaxTrevTwv k'gyov Ictti tv>v irz^/iv xgxTYicrxf kxi oiXKgxTyZilryis oe sjediw; Bx^vtyitxs kxi vocru/^Eiq xin^'ixs. O'vtu to tcp-utov ayf-tov Tt ^uiov E/S^ii-J*) kxi Kxy.H^yov, utx ogvis t/; '/} '%Sw? ElXxvaTO' KXi yEV0(AEV0V VTU KXI 9Tf0^l£A£T^J'aV £1/ EKs'iVOii; TO v»tS>, Ivt |3Sv l^yxTw »i/We, kxi to Koa-^iiv Tipofixrov, kxi tov o'tKapov xXEKTgvQVX' KXI KXTX (jLlKgOV HTU TfjV X1l\ri£A& ff^V* nFC 6 'A* Utv w * " '' Ji ' li ^ ' ; - ■ "" ^ "* 1 Form 335. 45M 8-37. Twvwvwvnw 8.21 ,77 S545QB 323641