REPORT OF A SURVEY FOR A RAILROAD ROUTE FROM SCHENECTADY TO OGDENSBÜRGH, AUTHORIZED TJnder Chap. 897, Laws of 1866. E, F.E,ANOHOT, Chief Engineer, A. MASON PEEK, Chief Assistant, JANUARY 1, 1868. ALBANY: C. VAN BENTHÜYSEN A SONS' STEAM PRINTING HOUSE. 1868. ' ^iaie of Ith) gorL ]sro. 61. m ASSEMBLY, Febrnary 15, 1868. REPORT OF A SURVEY FOR A RAILROAD ROUTE FROM SCHENECTADY TO OGDENSBURGH. Office of the Seceetart of State of the ) State of New Yoek, Albany, F>:hruary 15, 1868. ^ To the Honorable the Legislature : In compliance with youi' resolution of this rlnte, I herewith respectfully transmit a copy of the Report of a Survey for a Railroad Route from Schenectady to Ogdensburg, authorized under chapter 897, Laws of 1866—filed in this ofiice this day. HOMER A. NELSON, Secretary of State, REPORT. To the Hon. Homes A. Nelson, Secretary of State: Sir—As engineer designated to made a survey for a railroad route from Schenectady to Ogdensburgh, authorized under chapter 897, Laws of 1866, I have the pleasure of submitting, herewith, a map and profile of the route surveyed; also make the following KEPOET; Immediately after receiving my appointment, I proceeded to organize a corps of engineers to prosecute the work, at the head of which I placed Mr. A. Mason Peek, an engineer of accredited ability and extensive experience. Having perfected all the neces¬ sary preliminary arrangements to proceed with the survey, I found myself baulked by a legal question being raised as to the wording of the act authorizing the Comptroller to pay moneys under it. This necessitated a postponement of operations until the act could be submitted for legal advisement. This question being satisfactorily disposed of, I commenced the siuwey at the city of Schenectady on the 16th of July following, reaching Long lake, in Hamilton county, on the 28th of October, that year. At this point I suspended work, owing to unfavorable weather for further field operations, and inability to maintain the necessary force to pack provisions, tents and camp equipage. These obstacles, as well as the approaching winter before me, when surveying in that region cannot be prosecuted advantage¬ ously, induced me, as a matter of economy, to close my labors for the season, to be resumed as soon as practicable the coming spring. The past spring proved very unfavorable for an early resump¬ tion of labors. I, howeyer, organized a party early in May, to enter the field again, but owing to heavy rains, I was deterred 6 [Assesibly from active operations until the 6th of June, when I resumed my line of survey and carried it forward to Ogdensburgh, arriving there on the 10th of September. The line starts at the depot of the New York Central railroad, in the city of Schenectady, following the track of said road northerly about one mile to the junction of the Schenectady and Saratoga branch of the Eensselaer and Saratoga railroad. At this point the line leaves said roads, and runs through the town of Gleiiville, in Schenectady county, a distance of about eight miles. It then enters the county of Saratoga and runs through the town of Charlton, about four miles, following the vallc}- of the Aalplatz creek, crossing the highway leading to Charlton village at Dawson's mills; thence through the town of Galway, a distance of about seven and one-eighth miles, passing near Cramer's mills in the westerly suburbs of. the village of Galway, and crossing the Chuctanunda creek three times in the vicinity of Grinnell's mills; thence through the town of Providence a distance of about two- thirds of a mile, passing over Fuller's summit and crossing the Kcneyetto creek near Hagerdorn's mills; then entering Fulton county, it runs the town of Broadalbin, a distance of five and one- half miles, passing through the village of Union Mills, crossing the Amsterdam and Fish House plank road and about one-half mile westerly of Benedict's Corners; thence through the town of Northampton for a distance of eight and three-fourth miles, cross¬ ing the big " Valle " and entering the valley of the Sacandaga, fol¬ lowing up the west shore of said river through the village of Denton's Corners and about one-half mile westerly of the village of Northville. Then entering Hamilton county it runs through the towns of Benson and Hope, a distance of about eight and one- fourth miles, crossing the Sacandaga about three-fourths of a mile below Hope Centre, following up the easterly shore.of said river to the south line of the town of Wells; thence through the towns of Wells, Gillman, Indian Lake and Long Lake, to the south line of St. Lawrence county, a distance of about seventy and three- fourths miles. Commencing at the town of Wells, the line follows the Sacan¬ daga, passing through Pickloville and Wellstown to the junction of the Lake Pleasant outlet, Avhcre the wilderness may be said to commence. Hero the line crosses that river to the westerly shore, following up said outlet to a point about two miles below Burn- ham's Mills, where it crosses to the northerly side, continuing up No. 61.] ' 1 the same (crossing Robb's brook) to the jmiction of the Valle creek; thence up Valie creek to its summit, descending thence to the valley of Cungemunck river, crossing that stream about three miles above Elm lake and the Rhinelander mansion, thence up the Cungemunck through "Oregon," passing near Burnham's and Mur¬ phy's shanties to Little Round lake, thence down its outlets (des¬ ignated as Big Brook) to Indian river, crossing it about one mile below Indian lake ; thence to Cedar river settlement, where that river is crossed and followed a short distance; then bearing northerly to Rock river, crossing it about one and one-half miles above Rock lake; thence the line follows along the easterly slope of Blue mountain or " Mount Clinch " to Terrell's pond, thence to Little Salmon pond. South pond and Long lake, striking the lat¬ ter near its head, following down the southerly shore and crossing to the north side about one mile above the village of Long Lake ; thence to Clear pond, Mud pond. Long pond. Slim pond. Strong pond. Round pond. Little Topper's lake or " Lake Clute," and fol¬ lowing up the southerly margin of said lake, crossing South bay to the Bog stream, crossing it and continuing on to Middle or O ' O O Round lake; thence down Little Tupper's lake stream about one mile to the boundary line between the counties of Hamilton and St. Lawrence. ' • Entering St. Lawrence county, the line runs through the toAvn of Atherton, a distance of about eight and three-quarter n]iles, following the last named stream a short distance, crossing it and continuing down the same about one mile to Bog river, then turn¬ ing westerly up the southerly margiu of said river to Winding Falls, then crossing to the northerly side, and continuing along said stream to the outlet of Horse Shoe pond, where the line bears to the north, passing over the summit or dividing line between the waters of Bog and Grasse rivers, to the head waters of the east or main branch of the Grasse; thence along the valley of the Grasse river, through the towns of Oakham, about four and a half miles (crossing that stream several times and passing near " Wheeler's " on the Long Lake and Colton road), Jamestown about seven miles (crossing the river twice), Harwood about eight miles, and Clifton eight and a half miles. In Clifton the line of survey is about one and a half miles east of the Clifton Company's ore beds and the Myers' Iron and Steel Company's works, on Grasse river, and about two and a half miles west of the Parish 8 [Assemblt ore beds, wbicb for richness and quantity are not exceeded by any in our country. ^ Passing from Clifton into Clare, the line leaves the Grasse val¬ ley and runs through said town, about eleven miles, passing near Parmenteer pond ; crossing the middle branch of the Grasse river three and a half miles beyond, and the north branch on the farm of Mrs. Dewey, at whicln point the wilderness may be said to ter¬ minate, making the distance traversed thi-ough an almost unbroken forest of 115 miles. Leaving Clare, the line runs about four miles through the town of Pierrepont, following Wilson's brook, passing through Wilson's Corners, and intersecting the east line of Russell near McFadden's mill on Rensselaer creek; thence through the town of Russell about 3^ miles, keeping along the said creek for a portion of the distance, crossing the road leading from Matthew's Corners to the Russell turnpike near Ray's Falls ; thence through the town of Canton 11 ^ miles, crossing Rensselaer creek and the Russell turn¬ pike near S. Botsford's, and continuing westerly of and nearly parallel to said turnpike, crossing Little river near its confluence with the Grasse and the Canton and Potsdam branch of the Rome, Watertown and Ogdensburgh railroad near the station in the vil¬ lage of Canton ; thence through said village along Miner and Water streets (crossing Main street near the Hodskin's house), crossing Grasse river at Champlain, and following the west bauk of the river to the bend at the county house, where the line takes the general direction of the Ogdensburgh turnpike, crossing Indian creek or the natural canal, and intersecting the east line of Lisbon near the cross road at Patrick Mackey's ; thence through the town of Lisbon about 7^ miles, passing through Flackville and crossing the turnpike near the house of Archibald Boyd ; thence through the town of Oswegatchie about 4| miles, recrossing the turnpike at the widow Shepard's, and ending at the Parish wharf on the St. Lawrence river, in the village of Ogdenburgh, making the total length of line 190 miles. The country between Schenectady and Ogdensburgh is very favorable for the construction of a railroad. The surface is, in general, undulating, presenting no insurmountable obstacles, and but few abrupt changes in level. The ground lying between the most important streams which I have enumerated as being crossed or followed by the line of survey, is not of a precipitous character, but is overcome with a practicable grade, without resorting to very heavy work, and at a reasonable expense. No. 61.] 9 Taken, togethei', this route will compare favorably with other lines of equal extent in our State, which have been constructed or are in contemplation. . The line, surveyed, has been run with great care and accuracy, much more so than is customary for the mere testing feasibility of a railway route through an unsettled country, such as presents itself in the wilderness of northern New York. I would remark, here, that rny aim was to select the most eligible ground, or that which seemed to combine economy, in cost, dis¬ tance and greatest public accommodation. Owing to the difficulty of making explorations in such a densely wooded country, as well as lack of time and means for a more critical and extended exami¬ nation, it is possible, that the best ground in some instances may have escaped my observation. Should the construction of the road be decided upon, a more minute reconnoissance of the ground should precede the final location. I am of the opinion, however, that it will not be found advisable to make any very important deviations from the general course of the route surveyed. Before taking up the charateristics of the line, the cost of con¬ struction, the character of the work, the importance of pushing it to an early completion, with its prospective traffic and benefits to the State and individual interests, I will give a brief description of the country through which the line passes. From Schenectady to Wellstown, the lii>e is through a settled farming country, embracing within its range the flourishing villages of Charlton, Galway, Union Mills, Vail's Mills, Broadalbin, Fish House, Denton Corners, Northville, and Wellstown. Along this portion of the route, there are numerous extensive tanneries, mills and manufacturing establishments, now laboring under greatembarrassments for want of some ready means of transit to and from our great thoroughfares and commercial centres. Less than half a dozen miles beyond Wellstown, the line may be said to enter the wilderness of northern New York. This sec¬ tion of the State has for its topographical boundaries the St. Law¬ rence river on the north, through which the waters of the great lakes Ontario, Erie, Huron, Michigan and Superior, are discharged into the ocean. Upon the east is Lake Champlain and the Hudson river. Upon the south and west the table lands flanking the val¬ leys of the Mohawk and Black rivers and waters of Lake Ontario, being almost one hundred miles in extent from north to south and from east to west. % 10 [Assemblt The southern portions of St. Lawrence, Franklin ancT Clinton counties, nearly all of Hamilton, Warren and Essex counties, the eastern part of Lewis county and northern part of Herkimer county, are embraced within this wilderness, having an area of about 10,000 square miles, now a primeval forest, inhabited only by a few hunters and trappers, and an occasional settler on some of its principal waters, where sportsmen and pleasure seekers ren¬ dezvous during their sojourn in this wild and romantic region. Within this wilderness are to be found hundreds of beautiful and picturesque sheets of water, filled with the choicest of broox, lake and river trout, while the surrounding forest abounds iu deer and other game in abundance, affording great inducements to the lovers of fishing and hunting. The varied and romantic scenery of this territory, embracing its kdces, streams and mountains, present to the tourist and person of taste a combination of attractions, which the pen fails to correctly delineate—and only waits the construction of a line of road to invite to their shores and slopes people who now suffer themselves to be roasted and choked with the heat and dust of our fashion¬ able watering places and summer resorts. Here the pure bracing mountain air would bring new vigor and life to the debilitated system and over-taxed brain of thousands of our mercantile and professional men. Soon the shores of these waters would be studded with ornamental cottages and country residences of those seeking pleasure and recreation from the cares of business, where they could commune with nature in all her pristine beauty and grandeur. I will now proceed to consider the resources of this vast wilder¬ ness, and for convenience, will classify them under four general heads, namely: forest, agricultural, mineral and hydraulic. The Forest. This region is now clothed in a dense and primitive growth of forest trees, embracing a great variety of the evergreen or soft and hard woods. Among the first named are the. spruce, pine, hemlock, tamarack, fir, and white, cedar, while of the latter there is the maple, beech, birch, white and black ash, and in some parts of the w.estei'ly portion black cherry and rock elm. From my observation, I should judge the predominance in growth of the various timbers to be about in the order in which they are enume¬ rated. The whole of this immense growth of timber is of great No. 61.j ^ 11 height and size, with clean thrifty bodies free from limbs for a distance of twenty to eighty feet from the ground. Amongst the pines, spruce and tamarack, are lofty trees of suitable height and diameter of body for the masts of our largest ocean vessels, and for the general purpose of ship building, a great variety of useful and valuable timber and roots could be obtained. Much of this timber would command a ready market at remunerative prices for docking, piling, cribwork and wharf improvements. For cabinet purposes, passenger cars, and ornamental wood¬ work, the richly grained birds-eye and curled maple would be of great value, eventually superseding many more expensive woods now in use. Of this class of wood there are thousands of acres interspersed through this vast tract, of as thrifty and large a growth as will be found in any other part of our country. O. L'. Holley, Esq., during his administration as Surveyor-Gen¬ eral of the State of New York, in a report made to the Legisla- tiu'c (Senate Doc. No. 61, 1840), of a survey of this region, made with a view of introducing internal improvements, for the opening of this section of the State to our markets, says, after speaking of the diiferent kinds of timber: " The whole forest growth, indeed, is for the most part lofty, and furnishes by its great bur¬ den per acre, abnndant evidence of the strength of the soil. If this interior region, within which the principal masses of the State lands are situated, had the means of reaching a market, the pro¬ duce of the forest in its various forms of round and square timber, sawed stuff, fire wood, charcoal and potashes, would, it is believed, pay both for the land and for the clearing; a result as desirable in the markets below, as it would be beneficial to the interior." "This access to market, is in fact the prime want of the region; the settlements having already been pushed back as far as they can go, without placing themselves entirely beyond the reach of the common traffic of the country. Genërally, the settlements have advanced up the base of the high table land on all sides, and in some instances, made a lodgement within the verge of the table. Eackett lake cannot be far from the practicable summit of this region—to which sequestered but quite central point the project of a road to lead on one side, naturally suggests the relations of the same point on the other; and the clear expediency of caiTying the improvement through, and thus laying ojjen the very core of this district, and preparing the large tracts of excellent lands held 12 [AsSEMBLt by citizens as well as by the State, for rapid and prosperous set tlement." A. F. Edwards, Esq., Chief Engineer of the Sackett's Harbor and Saratoga railroad, in his report made in October, 1853, speaks in the most flattering terms of the products of this forest. The following extract of the average yield per acre is from his report: " In fine, so great is the growth of this whole forest, that were it felled and cut into cord wood, it would average upon each and every acre seventy-five cords. The following is the general aver¬ age (on one acre,) of a series of estimates made at different parts of this forest, during the prosecution of the survey, viz: 2,000 feet, board measure Spruce, 1,000 do do 4,000 do do .... 2,000 do do Maple, 1,500 do do 1,500 do do 1,000 do do Various, not enumurated; 2^ cords of hemlock bark, and 50 cords of merchautable wood, or 2,500 bushels of charcoal." "From repeated examinations, this country wants only commu¬ nication with the markets, to give it rank among the best of agri cultural districts." The foregoing estimate of Mr. Edwards, I should judge from my observation, to be quite correct, and will apply to the yield per acre along the route of the proposed S. & O. E. W., with the exceptions of the items of spruce and hemlock ; the quantities of each I should reverse, making of spruce 4,000 feet, and of hem¬ lock 2,000 feet, B. M. The timber just enumerated, as adapted to specific purposes, is but a tithe of the great bulk contained in this forest. To that should be added the varied and endless variety of sawed lumber suitable for our largest and most magnificent architectural struc- O O tures. For this class of lumber there is a constant demand, at remunerative prices ; and particularly is this so for timber of great length, such as is used for bridge and roof trusses; most of this kind of timber is now procured in the Canadas, and in Michi¬ gan, at an enormous cost for transportation. There are still other and valuable products to be taken into account, such as railway ties, fire wood, hemlock bark, hop poles, maple sugar, (and with ^^o, 61.] 13 the aid of machinery) shingles, broom handles, laths, wooden ware, &c., &c. Agbicultüke. It is not until recently that the minds of many have become disabused of erroneous opinions entertained in regard to this vast tract of undeveloped land in our State. Professor Emmons, iu his annual geological reports, made during the several years he was engaged in his professional examinations of this region, has thrown much light on the true value of its agricultural and mineral resources. He says, after speaking of opinions which have been formed from published accounts (especially from Burr's and Gor¬ don's statistics of this country): " That I have the pleasure of stating that it is far from being that cold, wet, swampy and barren district which it has been represented to be. The soil is generally strong and productive; the mountains are not so elevated or steep but that the soil is preserved of sufficient thickness to their tops to secure their culivation ; and most of the marshes may be reclaimed by ditching; by this means they will become more valu¬ able than the upland for producing hay. In fine, it will be found an excellent country for grazing, raising stock, and for producing butter and cheese. The strength of the soil is sufficiently tested by the heavy growth of timber, which is principally of hard wood, as beech, maple, yellow birch, butternut and elm ; the evergreen or pine are confined mostly to the lower range of mountains; some of them are the largest growth of any in the State. " From the observations of persons who have been residents of the country for a number of years, it appears that the seasons are much the same, as regards heat and cold, the length of summer, &c., as the northern parts of New England. "The incorrect opinions which prevail as regards its soil and its irreclaimable marshes have arisen undoubtedly from hasty exami¬ nations. " It is true that the flyes, or marshes, are mimerons, but they are not so wet as to be unproductive, or so sunken as to form nui¬ sances. When the timber is removed they produce spontaneously a heavy crop of grass, which is reproduced from year to year with out cultivation. Again, the flys are bottomed on a hard, clean gravel and sand, which occurs at the depth of from one foot to ten, but when the depth is greater it is not an unfavorable circumstance for in almost every instance of the kind I found the superior strata to consist of peat. 14 [Assembly " So far, then, as it regards marshes, wet and cold lands, and irreclaimable bogs, they are rare, and most of the marsh land forms the most valuable and productive portions of the country, producing, as I have already remarked, a valuable grass called ' blue joint,' which makes a nourishing food for cattle, without the labor of tillage; or supplies it until such time as the better grasses can be raised by the tabor and prosperity of the husbandman. " Again, it is probable that when the country is settled exten¬ sively, and the timber and wood removed, there will be aji ameli¬ oration of climate; it will then become dryer and less frosty, and the summer warmer and better suited to the raising of corn. The condensation of moisture over an extent of surface equal to this uncultivated tract in this section, must have a great influence in reducing the temperature to a low standard. The density of the forest, the thick growth of underwood, eflectually excludes the rays of the sun during the entire summer. For this cause the temperature of a wooded district is considerable lower than an open country under tillage." Mineral. Already immense beds of iron ores have been discovered, and I have reason to believe, from outcroppings observed along the route of survey, that otlier metals, embracing silver, lead and copper, will be found. This country, as yet, may be said to be only partially explored ; a line of railway penetrating it would soon invite the attention of geologists and metallurgists, from whose investigations we might safely anticipate new discoveries of great value. The iron ores along the route are of the same o o class as those spoken of b}' Prof. Emmons (late State geologist) in one of his reports, wherein he says: " Probably no portion of the world can vie with Mclutyr'e iu its ores of iron; even the far- famed iron mountains of Missouri are eclipsed by the rich ores of Essex county. New York." Many of the mountains and hills adjacent to the line of survey contain veins of ore which for quantity and qualitj*^ are equal if not superior to those now being worked in many of our States, while the same are surrounded by all the necessary materials und power for its reduction. The natui-al facilities which these ore beds present, occupying as they do elevated positions as to the water surfaces, enables the business of mining to be conducted oii a very economical scale. The beds can be opened by side cuttings or drifts, and the ore quarried and broken ready for shipment to market without the No. 61.] 15 aid of machinery. It will readily be seen that open cuts present great advantages in point of facilities, and cheapness in working, as well as drainage, over that of tunneling or subterranean exca¬ vations. In the one case the laborers have open daylight to per¬ form their work in, while in the other they are dependent upon the faint glimmer of lamps, and forced to the use of steam or water power for conducting the work. The work of mining ore from these beds could be carried on for many years without resorting to the more costly method last mentioned. This, of itself, is an item worthy of note, when con¬ sidering the expense of mining and handling the ore. These large deposits of ores are in a region highly favored for the manu¬ facture of iron, except the distance from market, and the heavy expense which must be met, in so much land transportation. What is needed now to overcome these obstacles, is the construction of a line of railway through this region. This done, the natural sequence would be the opening up of these mines of wealth, and the establishment of iron works in all its various branches, along the route of the road. As Prof. Emmons gave the subject of these ores a good deal of consideration, while making a .survey of this region, 1 will agein quote from one of his reports whereiu he says: " The ores of St. Lawrence county belong, it will be observed, to three different kinds or species, the specular, the magnetic, and the bog ore." For the working of these beds he says, much depends upon the facilities of intercourse with a market. It is certain that before they can be made valuable, roads of a durable kind will have to be constructed. The face of the country is favorable to enterprise on every other consideration; with a good road it appears a feasible project to bring out the magnetic ores, after separating from earthy matter. In this State they would be important to the fur¬ naces and forges now in operation at several places, and in partic¬ ular tlicy might be added with great advantage to the specular and bog ores, cither for castings or bar iron. The quality of the iron will not only be improved, but the whole can be worked with greater economy in fuel." As to the quantity of iron ore in the south-easterly townships, I have no hesitation in saying that it is inexhaustible. #«♦###»## " The above remarks are intended to show that this country possesses hu'ge resources for the iron business ; that many advan¬ tages accrue from the possession of the several kinds of ore which 16 [Assembly have been mentioned, for the purpose of mixing, so as to adapt them to qualities of iron it is wished to make or produce. It is rare that such a combination of circumstances exist for the pro¬ duction of this important article, in a territory no larger than this county." Again Prof. Emmons says, in speaking of the second geological district, which embraces the territory under consideration, that "one of its most remarkable features is the abundant distribution of iron ore; with the exception of the extreme portion, and some parts of Jefferson county, scarcely a mile can be traveled over but indications of this ore will be obtained more or less." "Almost the whole of this extensive tract is well wooded, and by judicious management, attending to the second growth, would furnish charcoal for the working of the ores of its inexhaustible mines for an indefinite period." The analysis and tests to which these ores have been subjected shows them to be eminently adapted for the manufacture of mer¬ chantable iron in all its various forms, kinds and qualities, as well as producing a superior quality of steel. In regard to its value, it is safe to say that it will produce iron fully equal to the best manufactured in this country. Already extensive works have been erected in the towns of Harewood and Clifton, in St. Lawrence county, for the reduction of ore. The first named works are located on the Oswegatchie river, about three miles northerly of Craueberry lake, and the same distance southerly of the line of survey. These works were originally known as the " Harewood Iron and Mining Company," but the name has since been changed to the "Lincoln Iron Works," with M. Ellis, Esq., of New York, as its president. These works as yet have not been brought into use. The " Clifton Company " was organized 1863, with a capital stock of $1,000,000. Ou this company's grounds are located the buildings of the " Myers Iron and Steel Company," with a capital stock of $100,000. Its president and managing director is the Hon. Charles G. Myers, of Ogdensburgh. The site selected for the furnace is at High Falls, on Grasse river, about one and a half miles west of the route of survey. This furnace was put in suc¬ cessful operation last September, and is now turning out ten tons of pig iron daily. There is also being erected at the mine (two miles south of the furnace) a steel works, which will cost when No. 61.] 17 completed, about $100,000. These works will probably be ready for operation the eoming spring. • Arrangements are being made as I am informed, for the erec¬ tion of two more blast furnaces at an early day for smelting ore at this place. The Clifton company have already expended large sums of money, solely for the development of their mineral lands, and have in contemplation the expenditure of still larger sums, in an¬ ticipation of having a more feasible route of transportation to market. There has already sprung up at the furnace, within the past year, a thriving little settlement, numbering twenty-five houses, a saw mill, shingle mill, broom-handle and lath factory, with a popula¬ tion of about two hundred inhabitants. I mention this single instanee as proof, tliat scores of like establishments and settlements would spring up along the route of a railroad, connecting this region with our main thoroughfares and tide water. Hydeaulic. The principal streams that traverse this region are formed from the numerous lakes and springs so liberally distributed over this part of the State, which, in their course to the large rivers that discharge into the ocean, present in number and volume immense hydraulic powers, easily, converted for driving the machinery of mills and manufactories on a gigantic scale. Probably no part of our country presents the same advantages for hydraulic powers as are contained in this region. They are also susceptible of being greatly increased by damming up the lakes forming reservoirs by which a never failing supply of water could be maintained during the driest season. A line of railroad through this part of our State, would soon result in a development of these vast powers, adding largely to the business of the country and to the wealth of the State. [Assem. No. 61.] 2 IS [A^'emblt Estimated Cost of the Proposed Eoute divided in Sections of Five Miles each. . First. Earth excavation » $42,905 20 Embankment... 11,932 80 Ditching.. , 38 00 Masonry 180 00 Bridging 22 00 Superstructure 43,850 00 $98,928 00 Second. Earth excavation $12,615 00 Eock excavation 7,100 00 Embankment t. 41,192 50 Masonry ....... ........ 2,555 00 Bridging 1,448 00 Superstructure 43,850 00 $108,760 50 Third. Earth excavation — .... $58,275 00 Embankment 13,150 00 Masonry 1,197 00 Superstructure 43,850 00 $116,472 00 Fourth. Earth excavation. ..... ... $34,750 00 Embankment..... 48,237 50 Masonry 4,392 50 Bridging .... .......... ..... , 2,215 00 Superstructure ...... - 43,850 00 $133,445 00 No. 61.] > 19. Fifth, Earth excavation Embankment- - Masonry Bridging — — Superstructure Sixth. Earth excavation, — - — -- r- $3,300 00 Embankment - 17,450 00 Masonrj* ..i.." — ---- 276 50 Bridging - 2,065 00 Superstructure ..... — ....... 43,850 00 $66,941 50 ■ ■ ■ • • ■ - Seventh. Earth excavation Embankment.. . Masonry Bridging Superstructure . $95,148 50 Eighth. Earth excavation...... — Eock excavation .......... Embankment Masonry ......... Bridging Superstructure ....... $74,283 50 ■ Ninth. Earth excavation ■. $4,450 00 Rock excavation. 14,900 00 Embankment ..... ....—..... .... 9,567 50 Masonry..... .....................—..... 392 00 $3,000 00 48,837 50 140 00 330 00 43,850 00 $96,157 50 $14,554 00 28,228 00 3,258 50 5,258 00 43,850 00 $5,194 00 8,500 00 6,785 00 3,892 50 6,062 00 43,850 00 20 [Assembly Bridging $10 Superstructure 43,850 $73,169 Tenth. Earth excavation.. - $6,030 Kock excavation 10,050 Embankment —. 36,436 Masonry 3,993 Superstructure 43,850 $100,359 Eleventh. Earth excavation.. ... $78,935 Eock excavation ... —......... 142,400 Embankment. —. — 83,928 Masonry 6,300 Bridging...... .... 1,205 Superstructure 43,850 $356,618 Twelfth. , Earth excavation : — $61,100 Eock excavation 18,500 Embankment 72,900 Masonry —. 10,426 Bridging 1,290 Superstructure 43,850 $208,066 Thirteenth. Earth excavation $6,140 Eock excavation ... 3,240 Embankment ..... 192,650 Masonry 2,948 Bridging ..... 3,355 Superstructure — 43,850 00 00 50 00 00 00 50 00 50 00 00 00 00 00 00 00 00 00 00 00 00 00 00 00 00 00 50 00 00 $252,183 50 No. 61.] 21 Fourteenth. Earth excavation..- .... $75,150 GO Kock excavation ..... 124,000 00 Embankment. —.— 25,050 00 Masonry. .... ........ .... 6,117 50 Bridging ... ....— .... ....... 593 00 Superstructure ..... - — --- 44,850 00 $274,760 00 Fifteenth. Earth excavation — .... $54,637 50 Kock excavation ............ 47,222 50 Embankment «•— 200,562 50 Masonry ................. 5,375 00 Bridging .... 250 00 Superstructure ... ...— 43,850 00 $351,897 50 Sixteenth. Earth excavation $9,197 50 Rock excavation ...... .... 1,040 00 Embankment ..... ........ 45,475 00 Masonry ............ ..... 17,914 50 Bridging ... 6,750 00 Superstructure ......... J. 43,850 00 $124,227 00 Seventeenth. Earth excavation. $29,250 00 Rock excavation ........ 18,655 00 Embankment 30,750 00 Masonry ... ........ 858 50 Bridging 80 00 Superstructure........... 43,850 00 $123,443 50 Eighteenth. Earth excavation $46,825 00 Rock excavation 38,350 00 Embankment ............. . 91,150 00 22 [Assemblt Masonry Bridging ... . Superstructure Nineteenth. Earth excavation — Eock excavation .. ... ...... . Embankment. —.- Masonry — Bridging ..... — -- Superstructure Twentieth. Earth excavation Eock excavation .... Embankment — Masonry — Bridging Superstructure — Twenty-first: Earth evcavation ... Eock excavation Embankment — Masonry Bridging Superstructure Tioenty-second. Earth excavation.. Eock excavation Embankment. .. — Mîisonry $13,954 50 2,250 00 43,850 00 $236,379 50 $37,975 00 38,935 00 110,500 00 2,840 50 375 00 43,850 00 $234,475 50 $41,975 00 44,395 00 139,600 00 3,981 00 750 00 43,850 00 $274,551 00 $30,875 00 35,880 00 16,275 00 3,139 GO 30,750 00 43,850 00 $160,769 00 $7,050 GO 9,360 00 4,100 00 1,584 50 No. 61.] 23 Bridging $42 Superstructure -- 43,850 $65,986 Twenty-third. Earth excavation — $10,975 Rock excavation - — 14,105 Embankment ........... 8,475 Masonry .... .. 469 Bridging 18,010 Superstructure 43,850 $95,884 Twenty-fourth. Earth excavation $10,275 Rock excavation 20,995 Embankment 32,750 Masonry 8,610 Bridging — 4,630 Supersiructure 43,850 $121,110 Twenty-fifth. Earth evcavation...... $7,825 Rock excavation 2,405 Embankment.. 6,425 Masonry 1,080 Superstructure .... 43,850 $61,585 Twenty-sixth. Earth excavation $11,075 Rock excavation 6,370 Embankment 5,700 Masonry 1,546 Bridging 300 Superstructure 43,850 00 00 50 00 00 00 00 00 00 00 00 00 OO 00 00 OO 00 00 00 00 00 00 00 00 00 00 00 00 00 $68,841 00 24 [Assembly Twenty-seventh. Earth excavation $1,150 00 Rock excavation ' .... 390 00 Embankment 18,025 00 Masonry ........ ..... ..... 2,085 00 Superstructure 43,850 00 $65,500 00 Twenty-eighth. v Earth excavation..$6,675 00 Rock excavation .............................. 3,965 00 Embankment.. .................. 11,475 00 Masonry :... ............ 3,145 00 Bridging -—... - -750 00 Superstructure 43,850 00 $69,860 00 Twenty-ninth. Earth excavation.. $1,975 00 Rock excavation .......................... .... 1,690 00 Embankment... ......... 6,500 00 Masonry 1,429 50 Superstructure ... .......— 43,850 00 $55,444 50 Thirtieth. Earth excavation.. ........................ .... $8,800 00 Rock'excavation 10,075 00 Embankment 2,650 00 Masonry...- .......< .....—......... 1,071 00 Bridging ........ ......... ............ 310 00 Superstructure 43,850 00 $66,756 00 Thirty-first. Earth excavation ....^— $5,850 00 Rock excavation 5,265 00* Embankment 1— .. ...... 133,425 00 Masonry .1.... 1,259 00 So, 6i:] 25 Bridging.......... .. ... $10 00 Superstructure — 43,850 00 $189,659 00 Thirty-second. Earth excavation $34,400 00 Eock excavation 28,470 ©0 Embankment.. 8,900 00 Masonry ...'. 1,635 50 Superstructure j 43,850 00 $117,255 50 Thirly-lhird, Earth excavation — $27,000 00 Rock excavation 17,160 00 Embankment 18,100 00 Masonry 877 50 Bridging 2,000 00 Superstructure 43,850 00 $108,987 50 Thirty-fourth. Earth excavation $ 10,500 00 Rock excavation 6,435 00 Embankment 10,500 00 Masonry 2,077 50 Bridging 750 00 Superstructure 43,850 00 $74,112 50 • Thirty-fifth. Earth excavation $13,375 00 Rock excavation ... .... 5,265 00 Embankment 22,625 00 Masonry 2,066 50 Bridging 1,050 00 Superstructure 43,850 00 $88,231 50 26 [A#s£iuBÛr • ■ Thirty-sixth. Earth excavation $25,725 00 Rock excavation 10,010 00 Embankment... 45,400 00 Masonry ...... 6,135 00 Bridging.... 750 OQ Superstructure. —43,850 00 $131,870 00 , Thirty-seventh. Earth excavation .............. $1,425 00 Rock excavation 130 00 Embankment 13,550 00 Masonry —..— -—.— ... .... 2,570 00 Bridging .... 10,500 00 Superstructure.. .........— — ........ 43,850 00 . . $72,025 00 Thirty-eighth. Earth excavation .... $14,650 00 Rock excavation — 4,940 00 Embankment .... 4,275 00 Masonry. 1,420 00 Bridging ...*.. ...... 750 00 Superstructure .... - 43,850 00 $69,885 00 Thirty-ninth. Earth excavation .... $12,425 00 Embankment ....4.. ..... 2,450 00 Masonry 4 ..... ...4*4... .... 840 00 Superstructure....... ..................... 43,850 00 $59,565 00 ' V ■ , Total estimated cost of whole line .. ..$5,142,563 50 Average cost per mile ...: ... 26^372 12 The above estimates do not cover land damages. This item of cost will be but nominal, as most of the owners along the route will probably donate the land to the road. No. 61.] 27 For equipment and other necessary incidental expenses, to put the road in successful operation throughout its entire" length, I assume an addition of fifteen per cent to the foregoing estimate. The estimated cost of construction I consider favorable, the gradients and alignments are both practicable. The maximum grade in a few instances equals eighty feet to the mile for short distances ; on final location I think this can be reduced, which, compared with other roads now in operation in this State, is con¬ sidered a practicable grade. ' By this road fifty to sixty miles can be saved in reaching tide¬ water at Albany or Troy. This saving of distance would be the means of reducing the time and expense in transportation of pas¬ sengers and freight ; naturally inviting to this route a large traffic from Ogdensburgh and surrounding country, as well as from the Canadas. At Ogdensburgh it would connect with the principal roads in Canada, as well as the heavy shipping on the St. Lawrence river, making it for their interest to patronize this route, it being the shortest and most direct to our great commercial posts. In order to judge of the prospective traffic of the road, I will say that its eastern terminus, Schenectady, is a city of about eleven thousand inhabitants, doing a flourishing mercantile and manufac¬ turing business. I submit the following statements of business done in a few localities, gathered from parties along the route of this road. Mr. F. D. Curtis, of Charlton, furnishes the following estimate of the trade of that vicinity ; 50,000 bilshels grain, 18,000 barrels apples, potatoes, etc., 310 tons hay, pork, beef, etc., 40 tons butter and cheese, together with various other items. Mr. Thomas Mairs, of Gal way, furnishes the following estimate of that locality, viz : 325 tons merchandise, pork, flour, etc., 100 tons manufactured articles, 175 tons butter, eggs, etc., 710 tons potatoes, cider, grain and other articles. In addition to the above, the fire-wood cut at this place would be an important item of freight. Judge Darius Moore, of Northville, gives the following estimate of the trade and tonnage of that localit}', viz : 28 fAsSKMBLT 3,400 tons hide and leather, 1,130 tons flour and pork, 4,760 tons merchandise and other articles. To the foregoing estimates of the freight traffic along this part of the route should be added that of passengers, as well as freight, of other localities. To the prospective trafiic, already enumerated, must be added the products of the forest. This item alone would furnish a remu¬ nerative freighting business for years to come. Ogdensburgh, the western terminus, has a population upwards of 10,000, being one of the largest and most thriving villages in our State. I am indebted to J. F. Rossul, Esq., for the following information as to its business: "It contains over 300 establish¬ ments engaged in mercantile, manufacturing and various other pursuits. It has an extensive and never-failing water power, flour mills of a capacity of 500,000 barrels per annum, three steamers ferrying to Prescott and connecting every day in the year with the Canadian railways—tliv only point in the winter between the Vic¬ toria and Suspension bridges where such connection is practicable. "The tonnage of vessels entered at the Custom House for the year 1867 amounted to 255,491. The leading articles of produce received during the year 1867 were as follows : Wheat 1,073,330 bush. Oats 86,651 do Corn 1,3.53,342 do Barley 54,192 do Flour 240,296 bbls. Apples 24,133 do Salt 15,971 do Pork 3,741 do Oil 2,648 do Beef 350 do Butter 4,877 tubs. Wool 3,378 bales Eggs 249,033 doz. Coal 3,705 tons. Lumber 28,179,481 feet. Shingles... 5,934,000 Hides 20,315 Hop-poles, about 1,000,000 No. 61.J 29 "The above, with the product of about 20,000 cords of stave and shingles bolts, manufactured here annually, seek a market by rail. The figures do not include the produce brought from Canada by the Grand Trunk ferry-steamer, or any of the products of the county of St. Lawrence, of which in 1864 the butter and cheese alone aggregated 8,409,780 lbs." Hon. Benjamin Squire, of Canton, furnishes the following infor¬ mation relative to that villiage : " It contains a population of about 2,000, being the county seat of St. Lawrence county, it is an active business place, containing about fift}' stores, mills, factories and various other establishments in successful operation. Its annual tonnage is about 55,000." 'The foregoing statements are made from an actual trade now existing. With this road built, it is reasonable to suppose that the business would annually increase; at least such has been the pre¬ cedent, wherever a railroad has been constructed. Aside from Ogdensburgh and Canton, the local traffic at other points at this end of the route, would add largely to the business of the road, as it passes through a thickly settled farming country, producing a large amount of butter, cheese and other products of the farm. Much valuable information relative to this portion of our State is contained in reports made to the Legislature, by the Hon. Silas Wright, in 1826; George F. Hoftman, Esq., Engineer; Assembly Doc. No. 3, 1840; Prof. F. W. Benedict 1845 and 1846; Senate Doc. No. 72, and also his recommendations to the Assembly, Feb. 9, 1850. Joseph H. Jackson and others, commissioners appointed in 1841. Edwin W. Johnson's report, the engineer appointed to make a survey fora railroad from lake Champlaiu to Ogdensburgh; Assembly Doc. No. 133, 1839. Also, from the report made in 1853, by A. F. Edwards, Esq., the Chief Engineer of the Sackett's Harbor and Saratoga railroad. In his report much valuable statistical information can be obtained, of the prospective business of a railroad, through the wilderness of Northern New York. I take pleaaure in acknowledging my indebtedness to the.Hon. Benj. Squire, of Canton, St. Lawrence county, one of the oldest and most respected citizens of that place, for the valuable assist¬ ance rendered by him, in selecting the most feasible route for a road through that country. 30 [AsspiBi^r Also, to Mr. Peek, for his valuable aid in preparing the map, profile, estimate, &c., of this line, all of which is Respectfully submitted, E. Fkanchot, Engineer. Dated Schenectady, Jan. 1, 1868. Endorsed : Filed February 15, 1868. D. WILLEES, Je., Dep. Secretary of State. Al true copy from the original. H. A. NELSON, Secretary of State. 4 MONTREAL LKNtiTIl OF MAIL KOADS IN OI'KUATION MILES . ((n. ■S(tr/.e/ts /Jftr/)or /It/nte A A.' >' /8. •Sttrtttof/ft A- •Sf/ti'/icr/ftty 2!. • Santtof/tt '{- W/ti/e/t(t// /tOUf, .Stft ten /stattft ¡5. •Syrant.se //iny/ifttnton A- S.Y. 81. j '/'roy ant/ /ioston .74..9/ \ 'Xroy ,{'• /S('/t/tt/t{/ton /ett.sn/to'/.A//e.v. .7.58 Troy (t ft ft (tree/tfias/t 6. Tn/y ftnt/ /{at/ant/ ¡8.50 t'ticft 5 /itact. Hi ver 54 94 11 'ffrwte/i Vtt//ef' ¡0.55 Albcuiy ^ Susque2tcuina/i 81. ( ian/itnawuign BYTOWN V r,a t*ipe.ojnei r TOI tro WATER üHíD) roft-R®» œmraî»; kLONE* ojSTALSAN^ PLATTSBUR' PRESCOTTQ^ O 0 (?!>€: y ¿ B U R 6 H \\Hn(vettoiL * * * * 't'otmlan ' Villoffe- ¡iroc/i\itte. TON URÜLINGTON' fñermon p R A\N C H OT. Eog J^idivUle (htvemenr LYMAN SAH.^NA( ■\iiiwcrjL ^\®TiWl®R,:ii^|;-p ujtí<|i¡)£'Ri C:HIA\P. 8»7/ "'eresar^^^. PHILAO^PHfV ELIZABE- "OWN MTSEWARD'i mTmarcy iXtitara. lurlingviUe 'A XrXJSend ^ C/tit/f Ass'^fn^inter. ADtlUlNI). ni'.OK WORKS* CROWN ' l'î MiUfont Smit/ivi/te pettra/ai: /i/'ave Ii R F-'AKADOX I. Scfiroon 'é Corners MAFTTINSBURGoX^ SCHKOON« (Tiencf/ont Sí (Ut or TORONTO AJannsvtlle SomXCrce/if \V./,pbctnort CASTLETON \ à©L\DrAN'I, AlpOS\ Johtishnrji/O Cot/t/i.sville C>\ \V thn^Yt//1ei'i//e^^ y hevdetvú rutland NC \ SVJlutlarn ■vonsflm Jiieh/ftnfl ASindsor^ IV6rr/vn.sJ/>.»-? BOONVILl tñ(/iranvi/h' i CLAREMONT Í tSWEGÍ caldwell •ort ann ^ Crcuiesvük. 'MOOkfe/HOüSI fiams. Fiemseno Hati/ey TTedwari TRENTONj^ Talis oäTtO.svflle / MORCAJ' i)UEENSTOWJ^ 'ROM BEtk.OWS FALLS (.'orinf/ .X t^Cp'enJif ireer/sCoT: :wiSTOi Sfarey ROCHE; ¡y O/RECT'ft] AHDOA1 |p\»X\:"%>NOM)A(lA K Ttamo ins \ v SARATOGA yspGs ttAGARA fallí Nwertionf^/// OOHNSTQWN [GfRAN] L TSV 8ALLST0N.S. rii Jatnesyo"^ JolmsviUe.^ a-:NöviA NySENNIf^TON ^r(mL8Cor.\ S/ijrkville\ can an: >AMdTEFi^M MORRJ^VILLE y/oitrloo .ßlOO! ^ benningtoN- lOUCK V. ^HLe/fayettc (ER ErievÜUßemrv'. j^in/Len \ j mfyo7,¡ú,f-] )2\Ufuidlel)m^ \ y-fosíi VILLE ;yrFALO 'falls tWANSEY i^OVASCO • ' yOe s JnerfUe JfmtíUhort Arnes ^ SCH£necta2\ * WtfrlesCern iAnrort ''ansing.burgh :emete«y 'COHOEÍ Rnrtingmi FlatsX mimson ( Oalzsvi^ O; / COOPERS-r^N( Eltaron. (TSBGOI. Juyfei Taniburglr cX R I NORTH AÎ#AMS MoravÙL SILVE] öardmrsV NorthfieLd Winchendeii JS'nJcion (rainesvifM ■¿SCHOHARIE HOMER( .LBANY i^^Riehtn^d V CuryfviZle^' ¡ i o XCLva. '^^Ñftection lïk Chùta^ ■'TCHBURGH Lisboi CoUins Concord «■ Sardi Nt"NORWICI /Oiford Orouts (DANSVILLE. MID.BURCH Portage hi/ilnn^ ^ ^ P ^!'j Pig ff 7, y / oaJNORWIi "e.vion Springvüh Sandusky j Fairvi^ PITTSFIl /om/zRylv ^Marpèr^l/etfl Otsdam l*ristonHoi TunonxP Port ^ WHITIN6P0NI Centre A. Coxsat PORTLAND <<^BATH yHnbari o/S'. Kortwrig h ( mnvf'Ile nortRam ptoi havan- Jfornellsville. \\7iitney-A fCHATi^AM AdORN: ^rankvüle\ Y^orcélona testñdd '^Mercdit/í \Sb>chhi o ANGELICA Hroion hydon I worcester*^ tELLICOTTSVILLE )Wï2Èe\ nmcy iarríngton Œucklins MAYSVILLE ßarkei DELFtl LUOSOI .Beniot ■fiai duba yy Partís ^^opers úrWdüev C£tnver(9\ MaJ/te MiUport Vffarspheat Hiunjífireyf MinsdaL^^ ■ ' Rharpcrs > (ORNE WLLOW Aetíbover Aiutes llsdiUf \ Sftc/fielíi. >RTCRANE 'Óak/u/t AND Al. Sf'RINGFIELO ^Pig \Prwin CsrU^e y^Ándleyt^A OWESO/CW, hnghamton Xtidiiteti Topacton , BLOOMS^'u >(ia Harbor ixfïAiiâiE']!:®!' COLOMBIA RIVERHEi worthpori fifíUnuj^»'^ '•^MAUCHVjCHUNK (*>'v CANUL belvidere MOR^istOWN' EWARI /¡odfts in f/pero(/Ott in //rof/ress Prof/oseft »A 'íi-etnont (OdRLYN'^ fiabvitMk OTRíC» 1'^ ('a/t/tls- VeRTHAm elemington NE^RUNSWICK 'ÍTTSBURGH