American History from German Archives. BY J. G. ROSENGARTEN. (Read before the American Philosophical Society, April 16, 1900.) American History from German Archives. BY J. G. ROSENGARTEN. (Read before the American Philosophical Society, April i6, igoo.) While a body of able historians, McMaster, Rhoades, Fisk,- Schouler and others, are enriching the world by an admirable series of works on American history, there still remains another field for historical research of interest and value. There are in Germany many papers dealing with the services of the Germans who were here as soldiers under the British flag and took an active and im- portant part in the War of American Independence. Bancroft and' Lowell, Kapp and Ratterman have collected and used such mate- rial as they could gather. General Stryker, in his History of the- Battle of Trenton, has added largely to our stock of material for a better knowledge of the contents of the German Archives, still carefully preserved at Marburg and Berlin ; and other collections of German records. It was through Kapp's labors that Bancroft added to his own collections, now belonging to the New York Pub- lic Library, and deposited in the Lenox Library of that city. These include Steuben's letters, Riedesel's papers, the Anspach papers, the Brunswick papers, Ewald's Feldzug der Hessen nach Atnerika, Geschichte der Hessichen Yager in Amerkanischen Kriege, fourteen REPRINTED FROM PROC. AMER. PHILOS. SOC. VOL. XXXIX. XO. 162. ^ KOSEISrGARTEJSr — AMERICAN HISTORY. volumes of German MSS., diaries and journals of Wiederhold, Malzburg, the Lossberg Regiment, von Malsingen, Papet, Wieder- hold, the Third Waldeck Regiment, Lotheisen, Reuber, Piel, Dohla, RufFer, Dinklage, the Hessian Yager Regiment and many volumes of reports on the battles of Long Island, Bennington, the Brandywine, and State papers relating to Prussia and America, Prussia and France, Prussia and Holland, Prussia and England and Washington and Frederick the Great, in all forty MS. volumes bearing on the American Revolution. Sparks in his collection, now deposited in the Library of Harvard University, had a collection of papers of Steuben, the MS. of DeKalb's mission to America in 1768 (since printed in part in French), and the correspondence of Frederick the Great with his Ministers in London and Paris during the American War of Inde- pendence, procured in Berlin in 1844 by Wheaton, then American Minister there. In the Magazine of American History for 1877 there is a translation by A. A. Bierstadt of Bauermeister's Narra- tive of the Capture of New York, addressed to Captain vonWangen- heim. This was part of the Bancroft collection. In the same volume is De Lancey's account of the capture of Fort Washington, with a map, from the original in Cassel, obtained by Prof. Joy for Mr. J. Carson Brevoort. The New York Historical Society has printed the journal of Krafft, a volunteer and corporal in Donop's regiment and a lieutenant in that of von Bose, who married in New York, became a clerk in the Treasury Department at Washington and died there in 1804. That Society has also printed \h^ Journal ^ II with Heister and Knyphausen in reference to the Hessian losses ~^ at Trenton. In fact, the regiments that suffered most there now make that battle part of their record of honor. It is one of their traditions that Ewald first threw aside the powdered queues and heavy boots of the Hessians, clothing his Yager battalion in a fash- ion suited to American climate and conditions, and thus set the example followed with great advantage in the Napoleonic wars. Other Hessian officers who had served here, notably Miinchhausen, Wiederhold, Ochs, Emmerich, Ewald and others, applied the les- sons they had learned here and became distinguished among the soldiers who showed great ability in restoring to Germany its inde- pendence of French mastery. The reputation brought home by the Hessians who served in America led Frederick the Great of Prussia to try to secure for his army the services of their officers, particularly of the Light Infantry and Yagers. Many of them won distinction in the wars with Napoleon against the French officers who had also served against them in America. The army lists of France, Germany and England are full of the names of those who ROSENGARTEN — AMERICAN HISTORY. 9 had learned useful lessons in the art of war in the American Revo- lution. Even the pay, clothing, food and allowances of the Hes- sian soldiers were increased in order to secure something like the advantageous conditions under which officers and men served under the British flag in America and in the other wars and expeditions that were carried on largely by German allied troops. Of the German diaries and journals now accessible in print there are : 1. Melsheimer, printed in Montreal from a copy furnished by Stone. 2. Papet, in Pennsylvania Magazine of History. 3. Dohla, printed by Ratterman in Deutsch. Anierik. Magazin, Vol. i, No. I, October, 1866. 4. Pausch, printed by Stone in MiinseW s Series. 5. Baurmeister, in Mag. of Afner. History, 1877, by Bierstadt, of the N. Y. Historical Society. 6. Riedesel's Letters, in His Life by Eelking, reprinted in a translation by Stone. 7. Madame von Riedesel's Letters, first printed in Berlin in 1 80 1, and since then in several editions both in Germany and in this country. 8. Schubert v. Senden's Journal (an extract was printed in 1839 in Vol. xlvii of the Journal for Art, Science and History of War, Berlin, Mittler). Of others not yet printed there are MSS.: 1. Malsburg, mentioned by Eelking as in his possession in Mein- ingen in 1862. Of it Bancroft's collection (now in the Lenox Library, N. Y.) has a copy in two volumes, made by Kapp's direc" tion, with his note that '' Malsburg was a superficial observer and reporter," as well as of: — 2. Renter's, of Rail's regiment, 1776-83. 3. Lotheisen's Journal of the Leib (Body Guard) Regiment, 1776-84, with a description of Philadelphia in 1777-7. Eelking notes that he had compared the original signed by Lotheisen, Mar- burg, August I, 1784, with the copy. 4. Piel, Lossberg Regiment, 1776-83, Vol. i, includes Diary of Voyage, 1782, and Extracts from Trenton Court of Inquiry. 5. Steuernagel, Waldeck Regiment, 1776-83. 6. Wiederhold, Diary. 7. Ewald, Feldziig der Hessen in Amerika, copied from Ephem- eriden, Marburg, 1785. 10 ROSENGARTEX— AMERICAN HISTORY. 8. Journal of Lowenstein Regiment. 9. That of Plattes Battalion by Bauer. 10. That of Lossberg Regiment by Heusser. 11. That of Huyn Regiment by Kleinschmidt. 12. That of the Feldjager Corps. 13. That of the Trumbach Regiment. 14. That of the Knoblauch Regiment. 15. That of the Mirbach Regiment. 16. Reports of Knyphausen and Riedescl. Of printed books by Germans who served here, many are note- worthy, for instance, Friedrich Adolph Julius von Wangenheim, first lieutenant and later captain on the staff; came in 1777 from the ducal Gotha service into the Hessian Yager Corps, and remamed in it after the war. He published in Gottingen in 1781 a Description of American Trees, with reference to their use in German forests, and this little volume, dated at Staten Island, was after his return, reprinted in 17S7 in a handsome illustrated folio He afterwards entered the Prussian forestry service and established near Berlin a small collection of American trees, still preserved with pride by his successors in office in charge of it and named " America. Dr. Johann David Schopf was a military surgeon in the German forces serving here during the American Revolution, and he printed in 1781 an account of his medical experiences, which was translated and reprinted in Boston in 1875. He also printed in 1787 ^Materia Mediea Americanis Septentionalis Potissimum Re^ni .Vf f ! ' '" "^'^''''^ ''" "'"^ '"^'^'■'^^ ^"PPlied to him by G. H E Muhlenberg of Lancaster. Later he returned here and ' hi; Travels published in 1 788, are well known, and he did even greater service by making American botanists and men of other scientific pursuits better known to those of Germany by exchange of let- LCI o^ tie • In 181 7 General Baron von Ochs published in Cassel his obser- vations on Modern Art of War, containing much of his personal experiences dunng his service in this country as a subaltern. His Life has a very good account of his services in this country In 1796 Ewald, then a lieutenant-colonel in the Danish service printed in Hesse Cassel ,n 1784; it is full of references to his per- sonal experiences in America, and it is significant of the man ROSENGARTEN — AMERICAN HISTORY. 11 that, after carrying off from the Hopkinson house at Bordentown, N. J., the volume edited by Provost Smith of the College of Phila- delphia, containing young Hopkinson's Prize Essay, he returned it with thanks, and the book is still in the possession of the Hopkin- son family as one of their rare treasures. In his little book he reports what General Howe told him of his personal experience during the old French War in America, and confirms it by his success with light troops in the American War of Independ- ence. He gives a curious picture of Philadelphia in 1778, when Colonel von Wurmb had charge of the expeditions sent out to bring in supplies. He divided his force into three parties : one went out on the Lancaster road, another out the Marshall road, and the third out the Darby road — these three roads being parallel and only a half hour's march apart — the woods that lined them being thor- oughly searched by patrols, so that the enemy, in spite of Washing- ton and Morgan, could never reach the foragers. He speaks of the success of the Americans in their attacks on small and large English forces not properly protected by light infantry outposts. His own experience in the Seven Years' War in Europe was of service to him in America, and that again increased his efficiency in the war with France and Germany. He describes Pulaski's failure at Egg Har- bor, and Donop's at Red Bank, and Arnold's in Virginia, and Armand's at Morristown, and Tarleton's success, and his own, as examples of what light infantry can do or fail in, just as they are well or badly led. He criticises Howe's failure to follow up his success at Brandywine, and calls it building a golden bridge for the enemy thus to neglect to drive him with fresh troops when he is in retreat. In the Jerseys, on Rhode Island, at G'ermantown, in Vir- ginia, he saw just such examples of the neglect to use light infantry to advantage, and he points out many instances in which their value was shown on both sides. Ewald also printed at Schleswig, in 1798, 1800 and 1803, three small volumes, Belehrungen ilber den Krieg, with anecdotes of soldiers from Alexander and Pompey to Frederick the Great and Napoleon, and some of his own personal experience in America. Seume, a well-known German writer, wrote at Halifax in 1782 his account of his experience in the Hessian service ; it was first printed in Archenholz' Journal in 1789, and a translation is in the Proceedings of the Massachusetts Historical Society for November, 1887; it is also found in his Autobiography, published in his col- 12 ROSENGARTEN — AMERICAN HISTORY. lected works, and the changes between this and the earlier version have been unfavorably commented on. Schlozer's Briefwcchsel, ten volumes, 1 776-1 782, and his Staats Anzeigen, a continuation, in eighteen volumes, contain many papers of interest relating to the American War of Independence, notably a series of letters from an officer who served under Burgoyne, and dragged out weary months as a prisoner of war in Cambridge and later in Virginia. The Frankfort Neuesten Staatshegehcnheiten published letters by German officers describing the battle of Long Island. V. Senden, Tagebuch, in Zeitschrift filr Geschichte dcs Krieges, Berlin, Mittler, 8th and 9th parts, 1839. He too was a general officer at the time of his death. V. Heister, Diary, in Zeitschrift filr Kunst des Krieges, Berlin, Mittler, Vol. xii. No. 3, 1828. Reimer, Amerikanisches Archiv., 3 vols., Brunswick, 1777-8. Melslieimer, Tagebuch, Minden, 1776. Riedesel, Mme., Die Berufsreise nach Amerika, Berlin, 1801 (and frequently reprinted). One of the most charming books that can be found — full of womanly heroism. Leiste, Beschreibung des Britfischen Amerika, Wolfenbiittel,. 1778. Schlieffen, Von den Hessen in Avicrika, 1782. Brunstoick Magazine, a Hessian journal reprinted in translation in the Pennsylvania Magazine, and a letter from the Duke to Rie- desel advising all supernumerary officers and sick and wounded and men under punishment \o remain in America. Der Hessische Officier in Amerika, a comedy, Gottingen, 1783, has no great literary value or importance, but some local interest, as the scene is laid in Philadelphia during its occupancy by the British, and Indians, Quakers, British and German soldiers and native citizens are among the dramatis personce. If it was not written by some one who had been here, it shows at least consider- able familiarity with the conflicting parties during the Revolution. Of recent works dealing with the German soldiers in the British army during the American War of Independence, the most notable are : Max von Eelking, Die Deutschen Hiilfstruppen im Nordameri- kanischen Befreiungskricge, 17 j6 bis iy8j. Hanover, 1863, 2 vols. (An abridged translation was printed by Munsell in Albany in i893.)> ROSENGARTEN — AMERICAN HISTORY. 13 Eelking, Lebeti unci IVirken dcs Herzoglich Braunschwctgschen General Lietitcnants Friedrich Adolph von Riedesel, Leipzig, 1856, 3 vols. (Stone's translation was printed by Munsell in Albany.) Esbeck, Zweibrilcken, 1793. Friedrich Kapp, Der Soldatenhandel Deutschen Filrsten nach Amerika, Berlin, 1864, and a second edition, 1874. His Life of Steuben and that of De Kaib were printed, the former in Berlin, 1858, and the latter in Stuttgart in 1862, and both in English in New York subsequently. His Gescidchte der Deutschen in Staate New Yor/i, N. Y., 1869. His Friedrich der Grosse utid die Ver- einigten Staaten von Amerika, Leipzig, 1871. Ferdinand Pfister, Der Nordatnerikamsche Unabhdngigkeits Krieg, Kassel, 1864. An anonymous pamphlet, Friedrich II und die neuere Geschichte Schreiben, etc., Melsungen und Kassel, 1879, "^^^s translated (in an abridged form) and printed, with portraits of the two Electors of Hesse Cassel, father and son, who sent their soldiers to America under treaty with Great Britain, in The Pennsylvania Magazine of History and Biography in July, 1899. Besides its defense of the Hessian princes on the ground that their alliance was in con- formity with their traditional and historical cooperation with Great Britain, and a desperate and successful war in behalf of Protestant liberty against French tyranny and Romanism and the free-thinking Voltairianism of Frederick the Great of Prussia, it is of interest from its demonstration of the falsity of Seume's Autobiography, and from its denial of the authenticity of the pretended letter of the Elector of Cassel, urging his general not to cure sick and wounded Hessian soldiers, as the dead ones returned more profit to their Landesvater ! It is somewhat odd that this very letter should be claimed for Franklin as one of his literary burlesques by Tyler in his Literary History of the Afnerican Revolution (see Vol. ii, pp. 377, 8-80), while Bigelow in his Life of Franklin (Vol. ii, p. 393) and in his Works of Franklin (Vol. v, J)p. 224 and 243, and Vol. vi, pp. 4-8), says it was written by Franklin not long after his arrival in France, in the latter part of 1776, and "is in some respects the most powerful of all the satirical writings of Franklin, equaled only by Swift in evolving both the horror and the derision of mankind." Franklin, in a letter to John Winthrop, sends from Paris on May i, 1777, " one of the many satires that have appeared on this occasion" — /. e., the sale of soldiers by German princes. 14 ROSEXGARTEN — AMERICAN HISTORY. This pretended letter of Count de Schaumburg is dated Rome, February i8, 1777, but is not printed in Sparks, or any of the authorized editions of Franklin's works. It still remains a question of when and where and how it was first printed and published, — it does not appear in Ford's Franklin Bibliography, which prints most of Franklin's c\tvtx jeux d' esprit that were printed on his press at Passy and soon found their way into print in Europe and America, but Ford printed it in his Many-Sided Franklin, p. 244; Bigelow says it appears in a French version in Lescure Correspond- ence ineditc secrete stir Louis XVI (Vol. i, p. 31), Paris, but with no allusion to Franklin. No copy of it is found in the Amer- ican Philosophical Society's collection of the imprints of the Passy Press, although Ford accepts Sparks' and Bigelow's attribution of the authorship to Franklin, and the internal evidence fully confirms the statement ; it would be of interest to fix the time and place of its first publication, its fortune in being virulently attacked, and its use in exciting justifiable indignation against the Hessian princes who shared, with other German petty sovereigns, in the sale of sub- jects to fight under a foreign flag in a war which, as Frederick the Great said, was none of their business, — for these things have given it a value and importance far beyond the other satirical letters produced by Franklin at his busy Passy Press. Bancroft tells us that Frederick the Great encouraged France to enter into the alliance with America — a counter stroke of vast im- portance, far outweighing in its advantages for the struggling young republic any benefit gained for Great Britain by its costly pur- chase of German soldiers. His hostility to England, however, did not lead him to fulfill his implied promise to join France in its active and substantial support of the Americans — no doubt rebellion and independence were more than he could encourage, little as he liked the British effort to crush them. It is curious that Lowell should speak of Franklin's smart satire as a clumsy forgery. Kapp, in his Soldatenhandel (Berlin, 1864), prints the letter in the Appen- dix 29, on p. 267, from Vol. No. 600 of the pamphlets in the Library of the Historical Society of New York, and described as printed on six octavo pages, without place of publication, but in very large type. He reproduces the original French with all its typographical mistakes; he prints on pp. 196-7 of his book a Ger- man version of the letter, and speaks of it as one of a flood of pamphlets, of which a very characteristic example was Mirabeau's ROSENGARTEN — AMERICAN HISTORY. 15 Avis aux Hessois et aicires Peuples de I'AllemagJie, Vendus par leurs Princes d rAngleterre, a Cleves chez Bertol, 1777, which is now very rare, Kapp says, because the Elector of Cassel bought up all the copies he could find. It is very characteristic of the two, Mira- beau and "Franklin, that the latter refers to his now famous letter only once, and that in sending it to his friend Winthrop, as one of the issues of the press then current, it nowhere appears in his printed works or correspondence, but in the Life of Mirabeau, by his son, it is said that the first work written by Mirabeau in Am- sterdam was the pamphlet Avis aux Hessois, pp. 12, 1775, that it was translated into five languages, and reprinted twice by Mirabeau, in V Espion devaiise, chap. 16, pp. 195-209, and in VEssai sur le despotisme, pp. 509-18, Paris, Le Gay, 1792, and Mirabeau him- self speaks of it in his Lettres de Vincennes on March 14, 1784, and March 24, 1786. A reply to it, Conseils de la raison, was published in Amsterdam in 1777, by Smidorf, supposed to be inspired by the Minister of the Elector of Hesse Cassel, Schlieffen ; to it Mirabeau replied in return in his Reponse aux Conseils de la Raison. All of these and other pamphlets, such as Raynal's on the side of the Americans, are now forgotten, but Franklin's clever skit continues to be reprinted and read, and to keep alive the feeling against the German princes who sent their soldiers to fight in a war which, as Frederick the Great said, was none of their business. However, the fact remains that it was through these Germans that America got many good citizens from their ranks, and better still, many of those who went home wrote of this country in a way that quick- ened emigration, in which, indeed, some of them took tlieir part later on. To this and similar attacks the Elector, through his Minister, Schlieffen, made answers in the Dutch newspapers, then the most largely sold,' because they were free from censorship. Abbe Ray- nal, then an accepted historical authority, supported Mirabeau's attack by one that was met by Schlieffen in 1782. Kapp says Franklin himself both inspired and drew from this flood of French pamphlets against Great Britain and its German allies ; but Kapp attributes this Hohendorff letter not to Franklin but to some French pamphleteer of Mirabeau's circle, and says it was revived by Loher at the time of the Know-Nothing agitation, and attributed to a St. Louis paper, although its falsity was shown in an article printed in the New Miltlary Jourtial, Darmstadt, 1858, No. 14. 16 ROSENGARTEN — AMERICAN HISTORY. It was, as Bancroft tells us, a Count Schaumburg who acted as the go-between of the British Ministry, who made unsuccessful offers of pay for troops to the Duke of Saxe Weimar, dated Nov. 26, 1777 : was that known to Franklin when he wrote his letter in the name of Count Schaumburg? No doubt he chose it in full consciousness that it would be familiar to his European readers, who would thoroughly enjoy seeing the English agent thus serving as a thin disguise for the Hessian prince, and the indignation excited by this clever and effective bit of satire would be directed' alike against master and man, against prince and agent, together trading for soldiers. In the French service under Rochambeau there were many Ger- :^ man soldiers, and Ratterman in Der Deutsche Pionier, Vol. xiii, / 1 88 1, gives an account of them, notably the Zweibriicken regi- ment, of which two princes or counts of that name were respect- ively colonel and lieutenant-colonel. It is worth noting that Lafayette wrote to Washington of a visit to them in Zweibriicken long after the American war, when he met " Old Knyp " and offi- cers who had served both with and against him there. There was a battalion from Trier in the Saintonge regiment under Cus- tine, himself from Lothringen. There were Alsatians and Loth- ringers in light companies attached to the Bourbonnais and Sois- sonnais regiments. There were many Germans in the Duke de Lauzun's cavalry legion, whose names are printed from the records preserved in Harrisburg. In the army that made part of d'Es- taing's expedition against Savannah, in the autumn of 1779, there was an " Anhalt " regiment, 600 strong; of individual German officers with Rochambeau there were Count Fersen, his chief of staff, Freiherr Ludwig von Closen Haydenburg, his adjutant, Capt. Gau, his chief of artillery, and a Strasburg Professor Lutz, his interpreter. The Count of Zwei-liriicken (Deux-Ponts) published \i\% American Campaigns in Paris in 1786, and his pamphlet was translated and reprinted by Dr. Green, of the Massachusetts His- torical Society. Count Stedingk and Count Fersen both took ser- vice with Sweden, the latter to fall a victim to a popular outbreak, the former to take part in the Peace of Paris in 1814. Von Closen returned to Europe, became an officer of the house- hold of Marie Antoinette, and died in 1830, at Zweibriicken. Custine rose to high command in the French Revolution only to end his days on the guillotine; his biography has been printed ROSENGARTEX — AMERICAN HISTORY. 17 both in French and German. Ratterman thinks at least one-third of Rochambeau's army at Yorktown consisted of Germans, Alsa- tians, Lothringers and Swiss. Gen. Weedon, he says, was born in Hanover, served in the Austrian War, 1742-81, and for his services at Dettingen was promoted first to ensign and next to lieutenant, coming in that rank to America in the Royal American Regiment under Bouquet. He became a captain in the Third Virginia, and colonel of the First Virginia, and later a brigadier-general of the Continental army. The Germans under Ewald were driven back by the Germans under Armand at Gloucester, Va., and in the siege of Yorktown, Deux-Ponts led his Germans in the attack on a redoubt defended by Hessians, and at several points commands were given on both sides in German. Washington and the King of France both commended the valor of the Zweibriicken regiment. German soldiers held the trenches on both sides when the surrender was finally made. German regiments under the French and Amer- ican flags received the surrender of German regiments — Anspach, Hessian, serving under the British flag — and the officers and men joined in warm greetings; the Anspachers offered to serve with their countrymen in Lauzun's Legion, an offer declined as a viola- tion of the terms of capitulation. The German novelist Sealsfield, in his story Morton, Stuttgart, 1844, describes Steuben's share in this crowning victory. Mr. J. F. Sachse has drawn from his large store of material a letter written by the Duke of Brunswick on February 8, 1783, to Gen. Riedesel, in view of the return of his force to Germany, in which he says that as not half of his officers and subordinates can remain in active service at home, while many of them must be reduced in rank and more discharged altogether, all who can had better remain in America, as he would not burthen his people and his war budget with pensions for young and able- bodied men; he therefore authorizes and recommends the discharge of officers, especially those of the staff, with six months' pay out of the regimental funds; non-commissioned officers, too, should be encouraged to take their discharge and stay in America, so that companies may be reduced to fifty in the infantry and thirty- six in the dragoons, and these must all be natives of Brunswick ; all men under punishment or charged with offenses or physically unfitted must be left behind. Chaplains, paymasters, surgeons, etc., who can make their living in America, were recommended to stay here. In this way, and with those who died in the service or deserted. 18 ROSENGARTEX — AMERICAN HISTORY. the force returning to Brunswick was greatly reduced. This letter is printed in the Brunswick Magazine of June 4, 1825 ; the same and earlier numbers contain extracts from Papet's diary, which was then in possession of his son-in-law, Captain Heusler, in Brunswick. It was not until April 29, 1783, that peace was officially pronounced to the troops, and they sailed from Quebec on August ist for a six weeks' voyage home. Papet says that the deserters had a price put on their heads, and many of them were arrested and brought back, so that the Duke's orders were not very literally obeyed. On their return to Bruns- wick the division was reduced to an infantry regiment of two bat- talions and a small dragoon regiment. Among them were some black men enlisted by Gen. Riedesel as drummers. Until 1806 the dragoons served as guard of the palace — a sort of recognition of their services. Riedesel named one daughter "Canada," she died in Canada; and another "America," who died in 1856. Eelking adds to his Life of Riedesel a list of officers, and among them Chaplain Melsheimer figures as a deserter, in 1779; Avhile Paymaster Thomas remained in America after the peace of 1 783, and so did Lieut, v. Reizenstein, Lieut, v. Konig, Ensign Langer- jahn, Ensign Kolte, Lieut. Bielstein, Lieut. Conradi, Lieut, v. Pui- seger, and Ensign Specht, while some of those reported " deserters " and "missing" no doubt remained in America. It is curious that in Riedesel's Life, with its voluminous correspondence with the Duke of Brunswick, there is no mention of the letter recommend- ing that his officers and men should be encouraged to remain in America. It looks very much as if Eelking thought it indiscreet to print it, as likely to invite hostile criticism, a caution that does not seem to have deterred the editor of the Brunswick Magazine in 1825, a time when the censor kept a sharp eye on anything that might lessen the respect for the Landesvater. In its way it fully justifies Franklin's clever skit at the Elector of Hesse in the ficti- tious letter to his commander in America. There must still remain in Marburg and Cassel and Berlin and Brunswick, and in the pri- vate families of Germany, much interesting and valuable material throwing light on the Germans who served under the British flag in the War of American Independence. Is it not well worth while to get a complete descriptive catalogue of the papers in the Marburg Archives ? The expense would not be great, and that once secured, it would not be difficult to have similar catalogues made for other ROSENGARTEN — AMERICAN HISTORY. l9 public collections. In the meantime efforts could be made to print such items of these catalogues as are new, and to enlist the help of private owners of papers of the kind in securing copies to use in printing in part or in whole for historical students. There is no better example of the interest in such material than the letters of Mme. Riedesel. Printed in Berlin in 1800, and again in 1 80 1, they first became known to English readers through por- tions of them printed by Gen. Wilkinson in his Memoirs, and re- printed in Silliman's Tour in Canada. In Germany they were reprinted in 1827, and again in 1881. The original edition was intended only for the family, and Gen. Riedesel himself died in 1800, before it appeared. His widow survived until 180S. Her daughters " Canada " and " America " perpetuate in their names their place of birth. The only son died in 1854, and with a grandson the last of the family ended. Amer- ican readers will always find interest in Mme. Riedesel's simple narrative of her life here. Mme. Riedesel's Letters were first issued in 1799 in a privately printed edition for the family and their friends, and regularly published in 1800; the latest German edition is that published in Tubingen in 1881, in which the letters of Riedesel, together with brief biographies of husband and wife, and an account of their children are given. It is stated in the Preface that of the 4300 Brunswick soldiers led by Riedesel from Germany to America only 2600 returned home with him. Of the 1700 lost to their native country many were of course a gain for America. Riedesel died on January 5, 1800, after a harsh expe- rience in the Napoleonic wars. His wife died on March 29, 1808; their only son died in 1854, and the daughter " Canada " died in childhood ; the daughter "America " married and left children. General Stryker in the Appendix to his History of the Battle of Trenton prints (on pp. 396, etc.) the pretended letter from the Landgraf of Hesse, in which there is mention of the losses at Trenton, and at p. 401 Gen. Heister's report of that battle, and on p 403 the real letter written by the Prince of Hesse to Knyphausen, dated Cassel, i6th June, 1777, in which he speaks of the painful shock of the news, and directs a court of inquiry to investigate and a court-martial to try those responsible, and another of April 23, 1779, insisting on a detailed explanation of the captains and others as to the finding of the original court ; these proceedings continued and a final verdict was arrived at in New York in Jan- 20 ROSENGAETEN — AMERICAN HISTORY. uary, 1782, accompanied by a petition for mercy for those incul- pated but surviving. Rail and Dechow had paid the penalty with their lives. This was signed (among others) by Schlieffen in April, 1782, and thus that incident was closed by the Elector's pardon to the survivors from the penalty imposed by the court-martial. The actual correspondence consisted of Gen. v. Heister's report, dated New York, January 5, 1777, answered by the Elector on April 7, regretting that Rail should have been entrusted with a post to which he was not entitled by seniority or service. That Kapp is mistaken in crediting the pretended letter to Mirabeau is best shown by comparing his wordy Avis aux Hessois with the short, sharp, pun- gent letter that bears internal evidence of Franklin's master hand. Reprinted by Ford and Stryker and Bigelow and Tyler, it is easily ac- cessible, while the Avis aux Hessois of Mirabeau is much less known, and a reprint of it may be of interest as one of the forgotten pamphlets of the man who later on played such a leading part in the French Revolution, yet failed to do for his country a tithe of the good that Franklin did for America. Still, it must not be forgotten that Mirabeau was one of the earliest French advocates of Ameri- can independence, and that his Avis aux Hessois was a warning note, the opening of a war of words, of a long-drawn-out battle of pamphlets, in which the American cause was fought for by French allies on the one side, and on the other by Germans in the pay of English and Hessian authorities. Undoubtedly Mirabeau's influ- ence led Beaumarchais to his best efforts to supply men and provi- sions and munitions of war for the American cause, culminating, largely, no doubt, through Franklin's efforts, in the alliance which played so great a part in the final result. Of even greater value, however, is Schiller's eloquent protest in his Kabale und Liebe against the sale of German soldiers to Great Britain to be used against America. Frederick the Great denounced his cousin of Hesse for selling his subjects to the English as one sells cattle to be dragged to the shambles. Napoleon made it one of his reasons for overthrowing the house of Hesse Cassel and making the country part of the Kingdom of Westphalia, over which his brother reigned. Lowell praises Mirabeau's pamphlet as an eloquent protest against the rapacity of the German princes who sold their subjects to Great Britain, and a splendid tribute to the patriotism of the Americans. Fortunately the large number of Germans who served in the American army on the patriot side. ROSENGARTEN — AMERICAN" HISTORY. 21 from Steuben and De Kalb down to the humblest soldiers, greatly helped to secure American independence. Although Franklin's letter is printed in both Ford and Bigelovv's lives and books of Franklin, it may not be without interest to reproduce the original French and the pamphlet by Mirabeau, Avis aux Hcssois, the first of a long series of pamphlets, notably those by Schlieffen on the German side and by Raynal on the American side, for in their day these were most effective weapons in that war of pamphlets and books which greatly strengthened the American cause abroad. These copies I owe to the kindness of Mr. Wilberforce Fames, of the Lenox Branch of the New York Public Library ; the originals are part of the wealth of original papers and pamphlets and books collected by Mr. Bancroft as material for his history and now owned by the Lenox Library, Their free use for students of Amer- ican history is one of the advantages of this present generation. APPENDIX. I. Lettre du Landgrave de Hesse, au Commandant de ses Troupes en Amerique. Monsieur le Baron de Hogendorf je ne puis asses vous temoigner combien la Relation que vous mavez Envoye m'a comble de joye — I'a conduite de mes hessois qui sent fait Immoles si heroiquement pour une cause qui nous est si Etrangere, confirme toute I'opinion que javois de leurs bravoure, & Justifie I'Espoir que javois fondee sur leur attachement a mes Interes — mais je ne puis pardonner aux nouvellistes Anglois d'avoir diminue si fort, le nombre de nos morts — pourquoy n'avoir, pas a vouee franchement, qu'aulieu de neuf cent nous en avons perdu 1700! En veritie je ne trouverois Guere mon Compte a ce calcule, & je ne puis Tattribuer qu-a un motif tres Interresse de leurs part — ces Messieurs Croyent-ils done, que trentes Guinnes de plus, ou de mois me sont Indifferents ! & cela, apres un voiage aussi couteux, que celuy que je viens de faire, & qui, m'a fait contracter tant de nouvelles dettes .... non, mon cher, que votre Zele pour mon service, & vos desirs, pour contribuer a mes plaisirs Redoublent defforts en secondant par tous les moiens possibles, toutes les Occasion qui pourois se presenter pour animer, de plus en plus mes fideles sujets a se sacrifier Jusqu'au dernier meme. Pour Repondre a des vues aussi legitime, que necessaries. 22 ROSEN GARTEN— AMERICAN HISTORY. Temoignes bien de m'apart au Colonnel M combien je suis m^content de la conduite qu'il a tenu jusqu-ici, — quoy ? Le seul de tous nos corps qui n'a perdue qu'un seul homme jusqu'a preserit — c'est, ce couvrir de honte, & Redoubler mes peines ; — la Signora F que je viens, d'Engager en Italie va me couter au de la de Cinq cents Guinees par an, & puis ces Anglois, voudroient encore mechicaner sur las blesses, & les estro pies — mais non ils me les payeront selon le meme Tarif fixe pour les morts — si non, jaime mieux, quils Imitent I'Exemple de ceux qui se sont laisses prendre a Trenton — en effets — a quoy meserviroient ses miserables ! ici ? Ils ne sont plus a bon a Rien ; d'ailleurs, ces maudits Rebelles qui, tirent toujours si bas, les auront sans doubte Rendus Impuissants, mais quant a cela, les Jesuites que j'ai envie d'appcller dans mes etats, s'en acquitteront mille, & mille fois mieux, & R6pareront bientot, toute la de population, qui ne s'y manifeste deja que trop, c'est un Expedient que m'a donne a Rome, le Cardinal T qui m'a promis de me menager cette afifaire avec toute la dexteritee Imaginable, — Vous ne sauriez croire (matil dit ;) combien la vue de tant de belles Guinees Ranime la vigueur. Or quoy qu'il en arrive jouissons du present & ne nous mettons pas en peine du Reste ; sur ce, je prie Dieu, qu'il vous tienne Monsieur le Baron de Hogendorf, en sa sainte, & bonne Garde, a Cassel, 1777. 11. Avis aux Hessois et Autres Peuples de l'Allemagne Vendus par Leurs Princes a l'Angleterre. ■ A Cleves. Chez Bertol. 1777. Quis furor iste novtis ? quo nunc, quo teiiditis ? — Heu ! miseri ewes ! non hostein, inimicaque castra ; .... Vesiras spes uritis. — Virg. Intrepides Allemands ! quelle fletrissure laissez vous imprimer sur vos fronts genereux ! quoi ! c'est a la fin du dix-huitieme siecle, que les peuples du centre de I'Europe sont les satellites mercenaries d'un odieux Despotisme ! quoi! ce sont ces valeureux Allemands, qui dcfendirent avec tant d'acharnement leur liberte contre les vainquueurs du monde, & braverent les armces Romaines, qui, sembables aux vils Africains, sont vendus & courent verser leur sang dans la cause des tyrans ! ils souffrent qu'on fasse chez eux LE Commerce des Hommes ! qu'on depeuple leurs villes, qu'on epuise leurs campagnes, pour aider d'insolens dominateurs a ravager un autre hemisphere ! . . . . Par- tageres vous, longtems encore, le stupide aveuglement de vos maitres ROSENGARTEN — AMERICAN HISTORY. 23 • ■ . . VOLS, respectables soldats ! fidelles & redoutables soutiens de leur pouvoir ! de ce pouvoir qui ne leur fut confic- que pour proteger leurs sujets ! . . . . vous etes vendus ! .... Eh ' pour quel usage! justes dieux ! .... Amonceles comma des troupeaux dans des navires etrangers, vous parcourez les mers : vous volez a travers les ecueils & les tempetes. pour attaquer des peuples qui ne vous ont fait aucun mal ; qui defendent la plus juste causes, qui vous donnent le plus noble des exemples. Eh ! que ne les imitez vous. ces peuples courageux, au lieu de vous efforcer de les detruire ! ils brisent leurs fers: Hs combattent pour maintenir leurs droits naturals & garantir leur liberte : ils vous tendent les bras : ils sont vos freres ' ils sont doublement : la nature les fittals, & des liens sociaux ont confirme cestitressacres: plus de la moitie de ces pauple est composea da vos compatnotes, de vos amis, de vos parens. Ils ont fui la tyrannie aux extremitcs du monde ; & la tyrannie les y a poursuivis : des oppressaurs egalemant avidas & ingrats, leur ont forge des fers ; & les respectables Amencams ont aiguise ces fers. pour repousser leurs oppressaurs. .... Le nouveau monde va done vous compter au nombre das monstres, affames d'or & de sang, qui Font ravage ! Allamands. dont la loyaute fut toujours la caractere distinctif, ne fremissez vous pas d'un tel reproche ? A ces motifs, faits pour toucher des hommes, faut-il joindre ceux d'un mteret egalemant prassant pour des esclaves & des citoyans libres ? Savez vous quelle nation vous allez attaquer ? Savaz vous ce que peut le fanatisme de la liberte ? Cast le seul qui ne soit pas odieux : c est le saul respectable ; mais c'est aussi le plus puissant da tous. .... Vous na la savez pas, 6 peuples aveugles ! qui vous croyaz libres, en rampant sous la plus odieux des Despotismas : calui qui force au crime ! Vous ne le savez pas. vous qua la caprice ou la cupidite d'un Despote peuvent armer contre des hommes, qui meritant de I'humanite enticra. puis qu'ils defendant sa causa, & hii preparent un asile ! .... 6 guarriers mercenaires ! 6 satellites des tyrans ! 6 Europeans cnerves ' vous allez combattre des hommes. plus forts, plus industrieux, plus couraga.ux, plus actifs, que vous ne pouvez I'etre : un grand interet les anime : un vil lucre vous conduit : ils defendant leur propriete, & com- battent pour leurs foyers : vous quittez les votres. & ne combattez pas pour vous : c'est au sain da leur pais, c'est dans leur climat natal, c'est aide de toutes les resources domestiques qu'ils font la guerre contre des bandes, que 1 'ocean a vomies, aprcs avoir prepare leur defaite. Las motifs les plus puissans & les plus saints excitant leur valeur, & appellent la victoire sur leurs pas. Des chefs, qui vous meprisant. en se servant de vous, opposeront da vaines harangues a I'eloquence irresistible de la liberte, du basoin, de la necessite. Enfin, & pour tout dire an un mot, la causa das Americains est juste : le ciel & la terre reprouvent celle que vous ne rougissez pas de soutenir : . . . . 24 ROSENGARTEN — AMERICAN HISTORY. O Allemands ! qui done a souffle, parmi vous, cette soif de com- battre, cette frenesie barbare, cet odieux devouement a la tyrannic ? Non : je ne vous comparerai pas a ces fanatiques Espagnols, qui detruisoient pour detruire, qui se bagnoient dans le sang, quand la nature epuisee for