Texas Agricultural Experiment Stations Bulletin No. 81 BOTANICAL SECTION. DECEMBER, I905. Alfalfa Seed Testing By O. l"l. BALL. Postoffice: College Station, Brazos County, Texas. TEXAS AGRICULTURAL EXPERIMENT STATIONS. OFFICERS. GOVERNING BOARD. (BOARD OF DIRECTORS A. AND u. cOLLEGE.) M. SANsOM, President . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .Alvarado F. A. REICHARDT . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .. . Houston K. K. LEGGETT . . . . . . . . . . _ _ _ _ . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .Abilene GEO. T. JESTER . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . ._ . .Corsicana W. I. CLAY. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .Austin A. HAIDUSEK. . . ._ . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . _LaGrange L. D. AMSLER . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . ..Hempstead A. j. BROWN . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . ..Dallas STATION OFFICERS. H. H. HARRINGTON, M. S., President of the College. JOHN A. CRAIG . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .Dean and Director M. FRANCIS, D.V.M. ......V€IE'I'lll£l1‘ldI1 F. S. JOHNSTON . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . ..Agriculturist E. j. KYLE, M S . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .Horticulturist F. R. MARSHALL . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . ...~\nimal Husbandry EDWARD C. GREEN, B. S. . . .. .... . . .. ......"\SSlSlf‘-.llt IIOI-tietilturist G. S. FRAPS. .. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .. ... ...._....ACting Chemist R. L. BENNETT . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . ..C<>tton Specialist O. M. B.~'\I.l..... . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .. ........Botani.~:t B. C. PITTUCK . . . . . . . . . . .. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .Feerl Inspector C. O. MOSER . . . . . .. .............. . ..Deputy Feed Inspector M. S. CIIIIRQI: . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . _ _ __ . .Deputy Feed In.~pector JOHN C. BURNS . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .A f, ‘- H/ -' i’ i //‘ Z711’. ‘if '.“ "l“/' ,V,¢; / . / Q / GREEN FOXTAIL. CHAETOCHLOA VIRIDLS I The small drawing represents natural size of the seed, while the larger is magnified fifteen diameters. ALFALFA SEED TESTING 9 are extremely small and usually escape detection, often appearing like minute grains of sand. When young and fresh, they are golden yellow, roundish or slightly granular, sometimes indented on one side, from one-twentieth to one-twenty-fourth of an inch in size. The color graduates into brown in old seed. Green (Setaria viridas.) The seeds of this grass are also some= FOXt8il- times very abundant in alfalfa, They are about one- twelfth inch long. bi-convex, oval, blunt at ends. The color is usu- “ally light green, when the glumes or “chaff” is absent, when these are present the color is light gray. On the convex side, the grain is minutely cross-striated. See Plate II. Yellow (Setaria glauca.) These seeds are larger than the pre- Foxtail. ceding but otherwise closely resemble them. They are roughly marked on the surface with irregular cross striations. Plate II. Curled (Rumex crispus.) Given as an example of docks, which DOCk. are commonly present in clover and alfalfa. Seeds are triangular i11 outline, reddish-brown, about one-tenth inch long. When once introduced into alfalfa itiis very hard to extermi- nate this weed. The Writer has seen one patch of about two acres of alfalfa which had been completely taken by this weed and which had to be repeatedly ploughed and hoed in order to get rid of the pest. All these plants came from one small patch of weeds which had found lodging in the field. Plate II. Besides the seeds here described and figured, many others are met with to. a greater or less extent in '~inspectin“g samples of alfalfa seed. Many samples show a number of different kinds of sunflower seeds or seeds of members of that family. Any weed that is abund- ant in the place where the alfalfa seed are grown may mingle its seed with the latter and hence weeds that are strange and unknown in a given locality may become rapidly dispersed and because of their un- familiar aspect may escape observation until they have become a pest. It is often quite easy for the expert to determine accurately just where any sample of alfalfa or other seed was grown by observing the particular weed seeds it contains. Thus, the seeds of Careless Weed and Pig Weed are very characteristic of American grown alfalfa and clover, so that the European can at once distinguish these seeds from the home grown. This fact may be of importance in checking the source given by the seedsman, though this is usually accurately stated. Very many farmers in America are now planting Turke- stan and German alfalfa and most of those seeds are quite foul with weed seeds. In this way many new and vile weeds may be in- troduced from Europe and Asia and may become the source of great annoyance, Seeds SOmeIimeS Used Some of the other members of the alfalfa and as Adulterants. allied families have seeds very similar to those of the alfalfa. In some cases these are used as adulterants, Since IO TEXAS AGRICULTURAL EXPERIMENT STATIONS. they are often cheaper than alfalfa and clover. Of these, Bur Clover, (Medicago Denticulata), Sweet Melilot, white, (Melilotus Alba) and Sweet Melilot, yellow, (Melilotus Indica) sometimes occur to a greater or less extent, but chiefly the first. The plates show figures of these seeds, Bur Clover. (Medieago denticulata.) As will appear from a glance at the plate, the seeds of this plant are considerably larger than those of alfalfa, more regular in outline, and have a slightly different shape. They are also of a more brownish yellow and do not show the pleasant olive green of the latter. The weed is annual and is killed by the . heat of the long summers of Texas and is also very sensitive to cold, showing black in the cold snaps in the winter. At College Station bur clover was killed almost to the ground during the winter of I904- o5 by a temperature of 2o deg. F. but came up again. It does not possess the food value of alfalfa and must be considered an undesira- ble weed when present in a field of the latter. Sweet (Melilotus alba and Indica.) XVhite and yellow sweet Clflver. clover. These seeds are rarely found in alfalfa, yet some- times are present in large quantity as is shown by the fact that sever- al farmers have sent the plants to the experiment station to enquire whether they were alfalfa or not, and stating that the weeds were abundant in the field lately sown to alfalfa. The seeds of these plants have the characteristic sweet odor of the plants which bear them and when a sample of alfalfa contains them to any large extent they may be detected by the odor, This fact renders them unsuitable for use as adulterants. In appearance they are remarkably like alfalfa and are sometimes very difiicult of detection even by the expert. Neither of the plants has the food value of alfalfa or clover. SAMPLES TESTED FOR PURITY. During I905 samples of alfalfa were procured from all the whole- sale seed houses doing business in the state and were tested in this laboratory. This line of work is new ' to the people of Texas and many do not yet appreciate its value, but in the main the seedsmen have been very ready to have their seed inspected and are anxious to place only pure goods upon the market. In all, 32 samples have been received and tested. A record of each sample is kept, giving name of seedsman, origin of seed, price per pound and, when possible, year of growth. It is hoped that many other merchants as well as prospective planters will become in- terested. in the work and will forward samples. A tabulated state- ment of the purity tests follows. The names of seedsmen are with- held in this list, since in the few cases of high percentages of impuri- ties in the seed, the handler was not to blame and an injustice might be done if the names were published. No case of willful adulteration has as yet been observed .- ‘PBLLHUJBIQPUH "jfaEugnfi -U¥.’S LllfDlLlEd ‘ssmQ qeJQ ‘wmeusol um); -ued ‘perpeeg ‘ssmg ngued ‘UJHIFHHDBLU I i5 ksliafikiwéééi i 2 (grass) 1 (carrot / FE .ffl -sv ... Ii‘ 3N UHIlUOD ‘fiJOlLlli-JH UOSlOd smemoguxoj sn10'] ‘|lO§8.l_|_ flood spJgg sgnefiln/x BHQUIUQ ‘leaH gag E Eisabgogsoiqwe ulngpodoueqj) ‘eel ueagxaw ‘SHBEJL HEX VIOSIBS ‘allsllll "Qlssnkl ‘dg ofimueld ‘upnuleld wuqnju —u9p ozleagpaw "Ja/xmj m8 ‘smo; utzQ snnneg ‘wusj pHM ‘d5 umpeJagH ‘paaM >1MI2H suezpawg) ‘ SHLIIUEZJBLLIV ‘paaM a|qu1ni ‘snpuq/(q snqlueleulv ‘iaaaM ssapnej) ‘.10_[FZ SHSOJBBJE] ‘sswg Bumuglg wunqm um -1p0d0uauj)‘1euvn@ squmq ****1u'n'w wiqudg mnJsnQ ‘JGPPOG "esoyaon xaumg wpoq mog WEED SEEDS FOUND IN ALFALFA SEED. mugssglge xaumg Bpoq "vi "muegmd xauxn}; wpoq 429'] moueN wig snmueglag ‘Jamogung 'E3|\2[3 tzgmlag ‘HBJXOII MOHGA TABLE I. '5!P!—‘!/\ epma g ‘flBlXOj £199.19 ‘snxagon -a1 SULHUUJBUJV ‘paaM 31d ‘mew -aoue| Ofimuegd ‘S5919 qgg ‘asua; 421d l1ll1l[Ojl.l_]_,‘J9/\O|:) pea ‘SPGQS PQQM w ~qs*12u_,,1?1°4~ 1395f] a|dum§ ;0 mnouuy ‘UMOJQ QJGQM ‘9|du1e§;0 0N , 16; Tear Thumh-Polygonum Sagitatum, 4. f undetermined grass, 1 Dock, 2 Sunflowers, Green Foxtail and 2 unknown seeds imen o ; Orache-Atriplex Truncata 1 19135 5 grms 11101 ined. T Whole sample was found to contain besides above, 1 spec ** 31. Also White H0reh0und—Manubium Vulgare, 1 1 Germanyié. . 2Turke5tan.......... 3Turke$tan.......... 4Ariz0na............ 5Utah............... 6Germany........ .. *7Texa5.............. QGermany-u gKansasnn... ]()Texas.............. 11 NewMexlco---- 12Utah............... 16coloradg......,.... T|7 Turkestan---- 19 SouthTexas---- 20TeXa5........... glTexasuu. 22']'exa§.............. 23Texa§.............. 24TeXa$.............. . . 27Texa5...... **31Utah...... * Two samples exam IByweight. 12 TEXAS AGRICULTURAL EXPERIMENT STATIONS It will be seen from the table that no less than 3o different weed Seeds were found in the samples examined,of course not all 0f them in the same sample. Some weed seeds were far more abundant than others, and some samples are very much fouler than others. Four of the samples showed no weed seeds in the portion drawn, though if a whole pound had been examined it is probable that some foreign seed would have been found. On the other hand, Nos. 8, 19, 25, 29, 3o and 31 contained more than fifty such seeds in five grams, or one-sixth ounce. No. 8, a seed imported from Ger- many was very foul, showing 52 weed seeds to the sample, consisting of nine sorts which were determined and three which were not. Mul- tiply this number by six and the result by 320, the number of ounces of alfalfa usually sown t0 the acre and the product will be 100,000 in round numbers; quite a respectable patch of weeds for each acre. It wlll also be observed that occasionally a very serious pest will find its way into a lot of seed and may thus be distributed t0 localities in which it was heretofore unknown. A good example will be found in N0. 27 where one seed of Deadly Hemlock appeared. Many comparatively harmless weeds are widely distributed and their seeds are 0f common occurrence. Such are rib-grass and the green and yellow foxtails. It is scarcely necessary to point out that a large percentage of the seeds of such weeds is greatly preferable t0 any per cent at all 0f noxious weeds such as Russian Thistle and Tum- ble Weed. Table II shows the relative frequency of the more important weed seeds found in the samples examined. TABLE II.—Of the Samples Examined. 41 per cent had Rib-Grass 47 per cent had Green Foxtail 36 “ Red Clover 12.5 a “ Yellow Foxtail 6 “ Dodder 16 “ Careless Weed 6 “ Tumble Weed 16 " Docks. Much 0f the impurities found in seed consists of sand and broken seeds and very often there is a high rate 0f dead and immature seed. Certain samples contained such a high percentage of trash and im- mature seed as very materially t0 lower their value and to suggest that cleaning of the seed had been entirely neglected. The per- centage of sand, trash and broken seed, all included under the head- ing, inert matter, was as follows: TABLE III. N0. Per Cent. No. Per Cent. N0. Per Cent. N0. Per Cent. 1 .00 9 .20 17 2.00 25 .05 2 .50 10 .18 18 6.60 26 .02 3 .50 11 .12 19 5.00 27 .031 4 .70 12 .25 2o 29.00 28 .01 5 .80 13 6.00 21 .22 29 .02 6 .40 14 1.60 22 .01 3o .13 7 1.00 15 5.oo 23 .02 31 .11 8 1.00 16 6.00 24 .01 32 .02 ALFALFA SEED TESTING 1 3 In this table the percentages in numbers 14, 15, 16, I7, 18, I9 and 2o include in addition to the above-mentioned materials designat- ed “inert matter”, the amounts, by weight, of dead and immature seeds. These samples contained so much of the latter that it was thought best to reckon the amounts in along with the other waste ma- terials. The actual percentages of sand and trash were about the same in these samples as in the others. II .——TESTING THE VITALITY. The amount of seed usually recommended to be sown per acre is so large that only when the seed are quite old and in consequence have lost vitality, does the latter question become of importance. In cases where the percentage of impurities is high and the vitality of the seed low, it not unfrequently occurs th it even twenty pounds to the acre will not be sufiicient to obtain a good stand, leaving out of question the matter of the actual value, compared to the market price, of such sample. As already pointed out, dead seed and those of low vitality are usually quite discolored, being yellow, brown or even quite black. It is worthy of note, that in the warmer regions of the United States, especially in Texas, weevils are very abundant and will quick- ly destroy alfalfa as well as other seeds. The weevil eaten seeds are sometimes difficult to detect, if freshly infected. Generally, however, they will hang together in threads and so the extent to which the seed have been damaged may be estimated. The seeds so eaten will, of course, not germinate. Mellwd 0f To test the vitality is a simple matter. A suf- Home Testing Samples. ficient number of seeds is taken from the sample which has just been tested for purity and these are planted and the number germinating is counted. The seeds must not be selected, but should be counted at random, so that a sample containing both good and bad seeds in about the same proportion as they occur i11 the whole will be obtained. To facilitate reckoning of percentages, the seeds are counted out in hundreds, as many of these as is thought necessary being taken. These are now placed in any suitable place for germi- nation. A good and inexpensive apparatus for home testing may be made from two dinner plates and a piece of clean blotting paper or white cotton cloth for the bedding, which is first to be vvetted with luke-warm water. Place the seeds upon this, fold over the loose end of the blotting paper or cloth,put into one plate and cover the whole with the other.- The apparatus should now be placed in a warm corner where the temperature will be about that of the ordinary living room, and left alone. At the end of the second day the plate may be examined and, if necessary, the seeds again dampened. Germination begins usually in three days; the seeds that have then sprouted are carefully counted by lifting the young sprouts out, leaving the others for a clay or two longer. In six days all will sprout that are living. The count of the second lot, added to the first will give the percentage germinating, directly, if one hundred seeds have been taken. For ex- I4 TEXAS AGRICULTURAL EXPERIMENT STATIONS ample, in testing the vitality of sample No. 1, it was found that 82 seeds had sprouted at the end of the third day, leaving 18 to be ac- counted for. At the end of the sixth day ten more of these had germinated, leaving 8 which were still hard, and which gave no sign of life. The sum of the two counts gives 92, the percentage germa- nating. All such tests should be made at least in duplicate, since some error of counting or of preparation may occur in the first and so give misleading results. We have found that two tests will give very satisfactory and even results. Some precautions of minor importance must be observed. The plates, paper or cloth, and the water used in making the tests should all be scrupulously clean, else various moulds and mildews will make their appearance upon the seeds thus altering very quickly the apparent value of the seed, since the latter will be quickly killed by these pests. Quite frequently, when every precau- tion possible has been taken with the apparatus, moulds will be found on the germinating seeds, their spores having been on the seeds them- selves. This occurs so rarely that it is not a source of serious error, however, and a second test will correct the trouble. Nevertheless, we may learn from this that cleanliness is of great importance in handling seed, because injurious fungus pests may be introduced if proper precautions are not taken, which may be the source of great loss. We need only to refer to the danger incurred by planting smut-infected oats or corn to emphasize this point. In a laboratory especially fitted up for the purpose, all these tests may be very accurately and expeditiously made; at home anyone may secure quite accurate results with very little care, by following the directions given. Samples Tested At the Experiment Station, the tests for purity and f0!‘ Vitality vitality are made as soon after receipt of the sample as is possible and the results are tabulated and kept for record. Table IY gives the vitality, in percentages, of the seeds examined, two tests being averaged. TABLE IV—VI’I\ALITY OF ALFALFA SPEED. No. Per Cent. No. Per Cent. No. Per Cent. No. Per Cent. 1 8o. 9 7o.5 17 87.5 25 82.5 2 90.5 1o 78.5 18 92. 26 91. 3 89.5 11 49.5 19 81. 27 93. 4 89. 12 79. 2o 8o. 28 96.5 5 74. 13 95. 21 29.5 29 89. 6 87.5 14 67. 22 80.5 3o 90.5 7 94.5 I5 85-5 23 94- 31 94-5 8 78. 16 88.5 24 89.5 32 92.5 From these figures it will Lbe seen that the vitality or germinat- ing power of the 32 samples varies between 49.5 and 96.5 per cent, the greater number having vitality of more than 8o per cent. These latter accord very well with germination standards adopted for other seeds by seedsmen. a ALFALFA SEED TESTING 1,5 If, now, the latter percentages be combined with the purity, the actual value of the seed may be derived from the market price. Thus, in number 2o, the market price of which was 14 cents per pound, the percentage of pure seed of apparently good vitality, was 71; these seed. when tested, however, showed a germination of only 8o per cent, 14x7Ix8o—7.85 cents, or almost 8 cents per pound for the ac- tual value. The actual value of the various samples is given in the following table, only in percentages, since in many cases the mar- ket price was not known to the writer. I TABLE V-Acrnar. VALUES OF SEED IN PERCENTAGES. No. Per Cent. N0. Per Cent. No. Per Cent. No. Per Cent. 1 8o. 9 7o. 17 85 75 25 82.5 2 9o. 1o — 18 85.8 26 91. 3 88.6 11 39.6 19 81.75 27 93. 4 88.1 12 79. 2o 56.6 28 96. 5 73.2 13 89. 21 89. 29 89.8 6 86.8 14 65.25 22 80.5 3o 9o.3 7 93-5 I5 31-2 23 94- 31 94-25 8 74.9 16 85.6 24 89.25 32 92.4 The writer has been informed by some seedsmen that they are obliged to handle inferior grades of seeds to supply the demands of farmers who wish them. Let us reason a little about this. Suppose you buy a seed costing 16 cents a pound and sow fifteen pounds to the acre. If it has the quality indicated in No. 31 of the last table, the cost per acre will be $2.40 of which you may reasonably look to get $2.30 worth to germinate, in which case you undoubtedly get a good stand. Now suppose you prefer a cheaper grade and buy No. 11, costing, say, 12 cents a pound, or $1.80 an acre. From this you can hope to get only 72 cents back in germinated seeds, or a very poor stand. I11 order to get the same number of plants to the acre from the latter seed as trom the former you will have to sow about three and one-half times as many seed to the acre of the poorer quality, costing about $6.25, of which $2.50 worth will never come up. In short, if you sow a sixty per cent seed, you can at most hope to get only a sixty per cent stand and a sixty per cent crop, while the labor required to produce it will be the same as if good seed had been sown. In reality, however, you can never get out of poor seed a crop which will correspond in any way to the relative value of the seed, but it will be still poorer. The best is here the cheapest. Free Testing In order to be of service to the seed sower as by Expefimefll 516N300 well as to the seed seller, the‘ Experiment Station of the Agricultural and Mechanical College will examine and test for purity and vitality, free of charge, all seeds sent. Such sam- ples should fairly represent the entire lot, being taken from different parts of the pile and should amount to an ounce or more. Name of sender, price per pound, date and place of growth, should always ac- company the samples, in order to make’ the records as complete as possible. ‘ ‘