'^^ivethe/e Banks 1933 EARLY DAYS AT COUNCIL BLUFFS By CHARLES H. BABBITT ILLUSTRATED 'All that I know is, that the facts I state Are true, as Truth has ever been of late." — Byron WASHINGTON, D. C. PRESS OF BYRON S. ADAMS 1916 CoPYBIGHT 1916 By Cham.es H. Babbitt CONTENTS Pages INTRODUCTION : Wherefore and How 5—6 EARLY DAYS AT COUNCIL BLUFFS: Longitude and Latitude; First Occupancy ; Origin of Name ; Hart's Cut-Off ; Hart's Bluff; Bloomer and Gue Histories; De Smet's Letter to Jones; Hart's Trapping Station; Who was Hart ? Pottawattamie Indians Arrive ; Old Blockhouse ; Billy Caldwell 's Village ; Jesuit Mission ; Fort Croghan; Camp Kearney; Mormons; Miller's Hollow ; Kanesville ; Colonel Kane ; Mormon Church Reorganization; President Chosen; General G. M. Dodge; United States Land Office; First "Gentile" Church Edifice; Named Council Bluffs; City Incor poration ; Townsite Entry ; Survey of Townsite ; News papers ; First Dramatic Performance 9 — 24 POTTAWATTAMIE INDIANS: United States Acquire Land in Iowa and Missouri ; Indian Cessions in Illinois and Indiana ; Removal of Pottawattamies ; Errone ously Located ; Platte Purchase ; Arrival in Iowa ; Number Removed; Blockhouse Erected; Dr. Edwin James ; Iowa Lands Described ; Father De Smet ; His Mission; Early Writers Err; Old Indian (Wicks) Mill; Historical Works; Colonel Kearney; Sub- Agency Locations; Camp Fenwick; Fort Croghan; Pottawattamies Relinquish Iowa Lands; Indian and Mormon Co-Occupancy; Departure of Pottawat tamies 25 — 40 THE OLD BLOCKHOUSE: Subject of Surmise; Writer's Memory Concerning; Bloomer's Description; Gue's History; Field and Reed History ; H. H. Field's Per sonal Recollection ; Spencer Smith 's Memory ; Ephraim Huntington's Remembrance; Henry De Long's De scription; Appearance in 1846 ; Fort Croghan 's Rela tion; De Smet's Barometric Reading; Nicollett and Fremont's Visit; Camp Kearney; War Department Memorandum; Official Records; When Erected; Jesuit Mission Established ; Mission Abandoned ; Com ment on Memory 41 — 60 4 EARLY DAYS AT COUNCIL BLUFFS FORT CROGHAN: When Established; By Whom Estab lished ; Camp Fenwick ; Name Changed ; Log Canton ment ; Flooded by Missouri ; Removal to Highlands ; Scope of Name; Original Site; Where Removed; Bloomer's Statements; Hardin's Testimony; Section 10; Casady's Farm; Council Point; Casady's Town House; Duck Hollow; De Smet's Reply to Inquiry; Log of Steamer ' ' Omega ' ' ; Audubon 's Visit ; Audubon Returns ; Abandonment of Fort ; Writer's Deductions ; General Comment 61 — 76 THE MORMONS : Arrive at Missouri River ; Civil Govern ment ; Whither Were They Going ? Camps of Israel ; The Stakes of Zion; Enlistment of Battalion; Its Rendezvous; Farewell Ball; Change of Emigration Plans ; Semi-Permanent Encampment ; Winter Quar ters; Municipal Government Established; Miller's Hollow; Kanesville; President of the Church Ap pointed; Abandonment of Winter Quarters; Post- offices Established; Frontier Guardian; Peter A. Sarpy; Dagger's Mill; The Bugle; Orson Hyde and His People Depart 77 — 89 POTTAWATTAMIE COUNTY: Temporary Organization Authorized; Organization Effected; Boundaries Changed and Area Reduced; Seat of Justice to be Selected; Election for Seat of Justice and Officials; Date and Result of Election 91 — 96 ILLUSTRATIONS MAP of VICINITY of Council Bluffs 7 SKETCH MAP of the Pottawattamie Country (1837) 23 OLD BLOCKHOUSE ; Simons Picture ; Bloomer and Gue ; 45 OLD BLOCKHOUSE; Supposititious Picture; Original Ap pearance 59 STREET SCENE in Council Bluffs (About 1861) 90 WHEREFORE AND HOW. For about forty years the author or compiler of this little book has been a more or less regular contributor to the columns of the Daily Nonpareil, at Council Bluffs, Iowa. During that period, — especially the latter part, — his writings have been chiefly reminis cences of early days at and near that city, where he resided in his boyhood and early manhood for twenty-one years — 1853 to 1874. In September, 1915, he attended and read a reminiscent paper before a gathering of "pioneers" and "early settlers" of South western Iowa. The conversations that ensued indicated the existence of much discrepancy in memory among those in attendance and sug gested the preparation of this work. Entering upon the necessary research the writer soon discovered that not only was his memory defective, but that, in some instances, it presented things that never existed, — mere figments of imagination. He found, also, that others were afflicted in the same manner; that some who had essayed the task of "history writers" had become, so to speak, "makers of history" by introducing into their works as real some of those imaginary things, and by setting down as facts mere inferences, deductions and assumptions. Thereupon he resolved that nothing should he stated as a fact in this work that might not be authenticated by either conclusive or very convincing evidence, and in the preparation of this booklet he has been controlled and guided by that resolution. While it has not been possible to secure absolutely conclusive testi mony in support of each and every incident herein recorded, and some inferences, deductions and assumptions have been unavoidable, he has endeavored to present only such of these as may be corroborated or sustained by reasonably strong circumstantial evidence, and where introduced they are distinctly set down for what they are. Where matters are stated as facts, they are facts. Instead of simply stating the facts in his own language and re ferring in footnotes to the authorities from whence they have been gleaned, as per the custom of professional historians, the writer has incorporated and quoted the original sources ; in other words, he has allowed the authorities to tell their own stories, and has merely O EARLY DAYS AT COUNCIL BLUFFS pointed out to those who may wish to pursue the matter what the authorities are and where they may be found. It is his belief that this course will prove more satisfactory to the general reader, to whom the source of many quotations and citations made are absolutely un attainable. Some of the matters quoted have never before been pub lished in any form, and the records containing them are not con veniently accessible to the general public. It is not the purpose of this work to present a commercial and personal history of early days at Council Bluffs, its scope being re stricted to substantially the period between the coming of the Potta wattamie Indians to Southwestern Iowa and the general exodus of the Latter Day Saints from the locality — that is between 1835 and 1853, though for the completion of some subjects events as late as 1857 are necessarily incorporated. For assistance rendered and information furnished the writer acknowledges obligation to Rev. Henry De Long, Hon. H. H. Field, Hon. Spencer Smith, Ephraim Huntington, City Engineer, E. E. Spetman, William H. Campbell, Theodore Guittar, James N. Casady, and W. S. Cooper, of Council Bluffs ; Hon. Frank Shinn, of Carson ; General Hiram Martin Chittenden, of Seattle, Washington; Rev. G. J. Garraghan, of the University of St. Louis; Anthon H. Lund, Latter Day Saints Historian, A. Wm. Lund and Andrew Jensen, Assistant Historians, and Edgar S. Hills, of Salt Lake City; Ben jamin F. Shambaugh, Superintendent, and Jacob Van der Zee, State Historical Society of Iowa, Iowa City; Edgar R. Harlan, Curator, Historical Department of Iowa, Des Moines; Albert Watkins, His torian, Nebraska State Historical Society, Lincoln ; Rev. Michael Shine, Plattsmouth, Nebraska; officials of the War Department, Post Office Department, and Bureau of Indian Affairs, Washington, D. C. If the work shall serve in any degree to preserve the truth of history, that shall be the compiler's reward; for such errors, defects or imperfections as may appear, the responsibility in his. Charles H. Babbitt. Washington, D. O, October 21, 1916. EARLY DAYS AT COUNCIL BLUFFS MAP OF THE VICINITY OF COUNCIL BLUFFS EARLY DAYS AT COUNCIL BLUFFS MAP OF THE VICINITY OF COUNCIL BLUFFS. This map, or diagram, has been prepared from the plats of surveys made in 1851-1852 by the United States Government, and from other sources of information deemed reliable. It shows the west two-thirds of each of the townships 74 and 75, range 43, and all of each of the fractional townships 74 and 75, range 44. All points laid down thereon, except Camp of Mormon Battalion, Hart's Trapping Station, Caldwell's Village, and Omega Landing — 1843, are fixed in accordance with the records of the General Land Office. The locations of the Old Blockhouse and Caldwell's Village have been indicated from records found in the Indian Bureau and War Department, and various concurrent sources of information. The locations of the Omega Landing and Hart's Trapping Station are shown as supposed to be from historical writings found to have bearing in relation thereto. The Camp of the Mormon Battalion is shown to be located as indicated upon information by Rev. Henry De Long, and by writings of Colonel Thomas L. Kane and others made at the time. The authorities are more fully described in the text of the book. EARLY DAYS AT COUNCIL BLUFFS. About the beginning of the nineteenth century the site of the present city of Council Bluffs, Iowa, — (longitude 18° 48' west from Washington, 95° 50' west from Greenwich, and 41° 15' north lati tude) — was occupied by the village of a tribe or band of aborigines known as the "Ayauway (Iowa) Indians" which is mentioned in the "History of the Expedition of Captains Lewis and Clark, 1804-5-6; reprinted from the edition of 1814; with Introduction by J. K. Hosmer. Chicago. A. C. McClurg & Co. 1902", and indicated on a map accompanying that work. It appears from the journal of the expedition kept at the time that Captains Lewis and Clark camped July 27, 1804, on the west (right) bank of the Missouri river, slightly to the north and west from the point at which the original town was located some forty-two years later. The name is derived from "Council Bluff", a hill near the present village of Fort Calhoun, Nebraska, at the foot of which was held a council with some Indians by Lewis and Clark. Their journal says : — "The incidents just related induced us to give this place the name of the Council Bluff." Subsequently "the Council Bluff" was used by early traders, trappers and navigators of the Missouri river, and by government officials, to indicate the site of that council, and later the final word became pluralized and the term "the Council Bluffs" was applied to the entire region of country between the Council Bluff and the mouth of the Platte river, the designation appearing upon all, or nearly all, early maps in connection with the range of hills on the west (right) bank of the Missouri river between the points mentioned. The early history of the region contains very little regarding the territory on the east (left) bank of the river, because that history re lates, primarily, to the affairs of the several fur companies doing business along the stream, and, with the solitary exception of the trading establishment of Robidoux, Papin, Chouteau & Berthold, at the mouth of the Nishnabotna, none of the trading houses were on that side. When an Indian agency for the Otoes, Pawnees and Omahas was 10 EARLY DAYS AT COUNCIL BLUFFS established at Bellevue, where previously a sub-agency under the Agent at Fort Leavenworth had existed, it became known as "the agency of the Council Bluff", and subsequently as the Council Bluffs agency. By treaty of September 26 and 27, 1833, the Pottawattamie Indians of Illinois and Indiana, together with the Chippewas and Ottawas, with whom they were affiliated, ceded their possessions in those States and were assigned territory for a new home in south western Iowa, but through errors of the emigrating agents those who removed in 1835, 1836 and early 1837 were carried into territory now in the northwestern part of the State of Missouri, opposite and near to Fort Leavenworth. They were removed to their own lands, in Iowa, in 1837, and the Council Bluffs Sub-agency was established at a point about one mile above the mouth of the Platte river, on the east (left) bank of the Missouri, which was under the juris diction of the agency at Bellevue. Later (about 1843) the sub-agency offices were moved up the river to Point aux Poules (Point of the Pulls), opposite Bellevue, afterward known as Trader's Point, and there are indications that, before those Indians removed from the region, the sub-agency offices were removed to or near what was after ward known as Council Point. A trading post was established at Trader's Point about the time that the Pottawattamies came to the country which was known as Hamilton's, and Peter A. Sarpy, agent for the American Fur Company at Bellevue, soon afterward opened a branch of his concern at the same place. There is tradition, supported by much circumstantial evidence of convincing character, to the effect that one Hart or Heart had a trading or trapping station at an early day (some say as early as 1824, and the writer here believes it was established before that), at or very near the site of the present city of Council Bluffs, and that the adjacent hills, as well as those in and among which the original town was built were, for that reason, known to the early traders, trappers and navigators of the Missouri river as "Hart's Bluffs" (Cotes a Hart). No record has been found to indicate in any manner that this Mr. Hart was in any way connected with the American Fur Company or any of its predecessors, subsidiaries or successors; nor does his name appear in any of the published official lists of independent traders licensed or granted permits by the United States government. If he were a white man trading on his own account with the Indians EARLY DAYS AT COUNCIL BLUFFS 11 in the vicinity without a license, he would have been reported to the Indian Department by the other traders upon whose privileges he would have been intruding, such as Roye, on the site of the original city of Omaha; Pratt, on the site of Florence; Cabanne, a few miles above, and Manuel Lisa, near the old Council Bluff. But there is no record of such proceeding. It seems to be a fact, nevertheless, that someone named Hart or Heart did conduct a trading house or trapper's station at the indi cated point prior to 1832. As late as 1843 notes in the American Fur Company's steamboat logs bore mention of "Hart's Cut Off" and "Hart's Bluffs". The precise spot on which Hart's establishment stood is not posi tively known, and may not at this late day be located with absolute certainty. In Annals of Iowa (Volume 9, page 526, 1870-1871) D. C. Bloomer said that a trading point — "was situated as early as 1824 at what was in those days known as 'Hart's Bluffs', from a Frenchman who located there, and which is found upon inquiry to have been a place in the city of Council Bluffs known as Mynster Spring. ' ' Hon. B. F. Gue, in his "History of Iowa", writing of Pottawattamie County, said: "The first town laid out was called Hart's Bluff and stood on the present site of Council Bluffs. ' ' Unfortunately neither of these historians gave any tangible authority or source of information upon which his statement was based, and those of the latter were probably simply appropriated from the works of earlier writers. Surely there is no evidence now extant to confirm the fact that a "town was laid out" at the point and time referred to by Gue. He probably misread the writing of some earlier historian to whom he failed to give credit. Mr. Bloomer's statement is founded, manifestly, upon tradition and hearsay. He says, "which is now found upon inquiry", but does not say of whom inquiry was made. It might be inferred from other matter in the article quoted that he derived his information from Mr. Francois Guittar, who had long been familiar with the locality. Even if this inference be correct, the facts are not conclusively estab lished. Although Mr. Guittar may have mentioned Mynster Spring as the site of Hart's establishment, he used that object as the place 12 EARLY DAYS AT COUNCIL BLUFFS most prominent in the vicinity of Hart's plant, without meaning that it was the precise spot. There was then no suitable site immediately at the spring for a trading house. The best evidence found by the writer tending to convincingly prove that Hart's trading house was near the site of the present city of Council Bluffs, is contained in a letter addressed to A. D. Jones, of Omaha, by Father De Smet, December 28, 1867. Mr. Jones submitted to the celebrated Missionary several inquiries, of which one, with the answer, was as follows: — "(Question) There is an earthen remain of fortifications on the east bank of Omaha ; do you know who built it? " (Answer) The remains alluded to must be the site of the old trading post of Mr. Heart. When it was in existence the Missouri river ran up to the trading post. In 1832 the river left it, and since that time it goes by the name of 'Heart's Cut-Off', leaving a large lake above Council Bluffs City." (See Chittenden and Richardson's De Smet, Volume 4, Page 1353; also Volume I, Nebraska Historical Society's report.) The writer of this work resided at Council Bluffs from June 4, 1853 to June 4, 1874, continuously, and from about 1855 or 1856 to the date last-before mentioned was very familiar with the lake referred to — called Big Lake — now Iowa Lake — and with its surroundings, having hunted game all around its shores and over the adjacent hills. Mynster Spring, lies hack in the hills a short distance from the eastern shore of the old river bed — the original lake bed — and less than one-half mile to the north and east, over a high and sharp ridge — "hog back" — there was a confluence of two other live springs of lesser importance and smaller water flow, situated in a broad valley among the bluffs, from which flowed a brooklet of fair proportions that entered the original lake bed, from which the water had partly receded, probably one hundred yards north from where the Mynster Spring came out of its little gorge, and followed along the foot of the bluff for a considerable distance northwesterly entering the shrunken lake an eighth of a mile or more above the month of the Mynster Spring branch, the trend of the latter being southwesterly from the foot of the bluff where it emerged. At the confluence of springs jnst mentioned — less than a half mile from the lake shore as it was in 1855, and much nearer the original bank — were the remains of buildings of considerable size, surrounded, or partly so then, by what appeared to have been a sod fence within EARLY DAYS AT COUNCIL BLUFFS 13 the enclosure of which had been included the meeting of the springs. The area of land embraced in the original enclosure had been two or more acres, and there were indications that at a period long before the enclosed land, together with quite a quantity outside of the en closure, had been cultivated. When passing through this place for the first time, accompanied by his father, on a duck-hunting trip to the lake, the writer was informed that the remains mentioned marked the site of an old Indian trading post. This site corresponds very closely with Father De Smet's all too brief reference to "Heart's trading post", and does not seriously conflict with the location described by Mr. Bloomer. At the time to which reference is here had nearly twenty-five years had elapsed sub sequent to the change of river channel by which were formed the lake and cut-off mentioned by Father De Smet in his letter to Mr. Jones. During that period the waters of the lake had been receding and the springs had been busy carrying down from the hills and depositing large quantities of silt upon the delta — part of the old river-bed lake — so that considerable land had been formed between the bluff and the then existing lake shore. If, as the writer verily believes, Hart's establishment was located at the confluence of springs above mentioned, the line of the bluffs being the shore of the river at the time the post was erected — perhaps - thirty years or more before the writer saw the place — the trapping station was only a short distance from the river bank. The ' ' remains ' ' referred to by Father De Smet are believed to be the same as men tioned herein as a "sod fence"; and that the place was "the site of the old trading post of Mr. Heart", is not improbable. It must not be assumed that the term "Hart's Bluffs" of the early traders and voyageurs was applied to any one bluff or hill in par ticular, but rather to the entire range of bluffs extending from the Indian creek delta, wherein the original town of Council Bluffs was built, to the delta above, through which Pigeon and Honey creeks and the Boyer river pass out from the hills and into the Missouri. The same mentioned by Lewis and Clark as "the first highlands that approach the river on that side since we left the Nodaway". So, while it is not conclusively established, there is at least very convincing evidence to indicate, that the first distinctive name given to the site of the present city of Council Bluffs ; that by which it was designated and differentiated by the traders, trappers and steamboat 14 EARLY DAYS AT COUNCIL BLUFFS men from other similar situations along the Missouri river, was "Hart's Bluffs". Who was this "Hart" or "Heart" whose name became attached to the locality in question ? Messrs. Bloomer, Gue, and others whose works relating to the place have come under the inspection of the writer, all say that he was a "Frenchman". However, none of them give any authority for the assertion, nor does any of them appear to have definite knowledge respecting him. Their information about him is vague, to say the least, and apparently based entirely upon hearsay, legend and tra dition. A most diligent and careful search of the governmental and other records pertaining to the early traders and trappers operating in this region, as far back as 1810, fails to disclose anything by which the identity of "Hart" or "Heart" may be indubitably established. Incorporated in "Thwaite's Early Western Travels" is the report of Long's Expedition to the Rocky Mountains, by Dr. Edwin James, secretary. In that portion of the paper relating to the "Winter Cantonment", near "Camp Missouri" — (otherwise known as Fort Atkinson and Fort Calhoun) — has been found (Vol. 14, Chap. 9, page 250) a possible identification of the mysterious person from whom the names of "Hart's Bluff" and "Hart's Cut Off" may have been derived. It is the following : — ' ' The principal Iowa chief was once at our camp ; he is a very intelligent Indian, with solemn dignity of deportment, and would not deign to enter our houses or even to approach them until invited. He is said to have more intimate knowledge of the manners of the whites than any other Indian of the Missouri and to be acquainted with many of the words of our language, but will not willingly make use of them fearing to express himself improperly, or not trusting his pronunciation. He remained near Council Bluffs in the autumn, in order to be present at the councils with the different nations, and to observe the conduct of the whites toward them respectively, a consider able time after his nation had departed down the river to their beaver trapping. After this he went with his family to the headwaters of the Boyer, and during their stay there trapped 163 beaver; when with us he was about to go in search of his people. . . . "This Indian is known by several names, as Grand Batture, Hard Heart, Sandbar, and, in his own language, as Wang-e- waha. During our late contest with Great Britain he turned EARLY DAYS AT COUNCIL BLUFFS 15 his back upon his nation in consequence of their raising the tomahawk upon our citizens, and, crossing the Missouri, united his destiny with the Otoes. Last autumn his nation joined him and submitted to his guidance; so that the Otoes, Missouries, and Iowas were then united." One of the parties, who signed the treaty of October 15, 1836, at Bellevue, by which the Iowas, Otoes and Missourias completed the cession of the triangle of land in northwestern Missouri known as the "Platte Purchase", was "No Heart", whose aboriginal name does not appear; and he signed as an Iowa Chief. From "Hard Heart" to "No Heart" is not a far change, nor would it be a surprising one. The terms have practically the same significance and were readily interchangeable under the circumstances of the lives of those people. It was of the winter of 1819-1820 that Dr. James wrote, after or during which, the Indian mentioned "went with his family to the headwaters of the Boyer" and engaged in trapping. In the legends and traditions relating to "Hart's trading house at the site of Council Bluffs" the date of its founding is said to have been "as early as 1824". Now, a study of the topography of the country adjoining the Boyer river valley should make it clear that, at no point other than that herein set out as the probable site of "Hart's trading or trapping station" would there then have been found as good accommodations for such an establishment. There is no other place on the east (left) side of the Missouri river within one hundred miles of the mouth of the Boyer, where at that time existed so fine a situation for the trading or trapping station of one operating in that region ; well protected as it was from weather, as well as against the encroachment of enemies or competing operators, immediately on the bank of the Missouri and only a few miles below the mouth of the Boyer. No stretch of imagination is required, nor is it a violent presumption, to assume that this ' ' intelligent Indian chief ' ' who expatriated himself and became affiliated with the Otoes, in whose country the site men tioned then was, actually established his headquarters at that point; and the fact that he was known to be in occupancy thereof and operating a trading or trapping station there, would have furnished good reason for the application of the names "Hart's Bluffs" to the adjacent hills and of "Hart's Cut-Off" to the new channel formed by the Missouri river when it receded to the westward. There appears 16 EARLY DAYS AT COUNCIL BLUFFS to the writer good presumptive evidence to support the belief that this Indian gave the locality its name. In 1837 the Pottawattamie, Ottawa and Chippewa Indians, removed from Illinois and Indiana, who had been residing upon what was known as the "Platte Purchase", in Missouri, were brought to their new homes in Iowa, and the Village of one of their principal chiefs, Billy Caldwell, became located and a blockhouse was undoubtedly erected on the very site of the present city of Council Bluffs. Billy Caldwell died there September 27, 1841. (See Pottawattamie Indians.) May 31, 1838, a Jesuit Mission was established at the place by the renowned Father Pierre-Jean De Smet, in connection with which the blockhouse was used. Father De Smet was transferred elsewhere in 1839 and in July or August, 1841 the mission was abandoned. (See Old Blockhouse.) Mr. J. N. Nicollet, accompanied by Lieutenant John C. Fremont, of the Corps of Topographical Engineers, made explorations in the Missouri river valley in 1838 and 1839, and the place now occupied by the city of Council Bluffs was referred to in the report of the ex pedition published by the War Department in 1843, as "Camp Kearney", which, it is believed by the writer, was the name given by the explorers to their engineer encampment in that vicinity, although no specific mention of such encampment has been found. In 1842 a company of dragoons, under the command of Captain John H. K. Burgwin, was sent from Fort Leavenworth to protect the Pottawattamie Indians against threatened attack by the Sioux. Its encampment, named "Camp Fenwick" which was afterward changed to "Fort Croghan", was located somewhere in the vicinity of the old steamboat landing, about five miles south of the site of the old block house; but, on account of high water, was removed in the spring of 1843 to the highlands, and was abandoned October 6, 1843. (See Fort Croghan.) Upon the arrival of the Mormons, June 14, 1846, on their way to the "New Zion", a battalion of troops was recruited from their number at the site of the present city of Council Bluffs and sent to the Mexican war, and a semi-permanent camp was established at the place by the emigrating Latter Day Saints. One of their number, Henry W. Miller, settled a short distance west from the old block house, where a village soon took form and was given the name "Miller's Hollow". EARLY DAYS AT COUNCIL BLUFFS 17 Upon petition presented by Brigham Young a postoffice named "Kane" was established at Miller's Hollow January 17, 1848, and at a conference meeting of the Saints held April 8, 1848, in the "Log Tabernacle" at Miller's Hollow, a resolution was adopted changing the name of the village to "Kanesville". This action was taken in honor of Colonel Thomas Leiper Kane, who had befriended the Mormons in many ways. Col. Kane was born at Philadelphia, Jan uary 27, 1822; was son of John Kintzing and Jane Duval (Leiper) Kane. His father was a prominent lawyer of Philadelphia and Wash ington and an adviser of several Presidents of the United States, in- eluding Andrew Jackson. Another son, Elisha Kent Kane, became quite well known on account of his explorations in the Arctic. Colonel Kane visited the Mormon settlement at Commerce (Nauvoo), Illinois, in 1847, and was with the Saints at Council Bluffs in 1846 when the brigade was recruited for the Mexican war. He went to Salt Lake in 1858, with letters from President Buchanan, and assisted in settling the "Mormon War". In April, 1861, he raised a regiment of hunters and lumbermen which became known as the "Bucktails"; was several times wounded during the war of the rebellion, on account of which he resigned in 1863. He founded the town of Kane, in northwestern Pennsylvania; was author of "The Mormons" (1850); "Alaska" (1868); Coahuila (1877). He died at Philadelphia December 26, 1883. (See The Mormons.) The population of Kanesville was increased by more than one hun dred per cent, by the influx of Saints from Winter Quarters, aban doned in the spring of 1848, and the place gained a number of business houses, some of which became quite prominent in after years. The population is said to have approximated seven thousand in 1849. In 1852 Apostle Orson Hyde, who had been in charge of Latter Day Saint affairs since the abandonment of Winter Quarters, departed from Kanesville, and with him went every Mormon whom he could induce to follow, and the population became greatly decreased. It was probably not in excess of two thousand or twenty -five hundred in the spring of 1853. On page 8 of Field and Reed's "History of Pottawattamie County," referring to the Mormon occupancy of the place, it is said : — "At this time everything was controlled by the church. Idle ness and dissipation were not tolerated. There was no jail nor need for one." 18 EARLY DAYS AT COUNCIL BLUFFS This accords with information given the writer by persons who were there at the time ; but, when he went there, in 1853, a marked change had occurred. There were numerous drinking. and gambling places, running "wide open", the most pretentious of which was called the "Ocean Wave" on the site now occupied by the Methodist Episcopal Church, at the junction of Broadway and First street. Nor was gambling confined to the houses devoted to the purpose, all of which were named, "Humboldt", "Bloomer", &c. ; but, during emigration days, when passing "pilgrims" were numerous, the professionals oc cupied the sidewalks where they dealt many kinds of "sure-thing" games — "thimble rigging", "chuck-a-luck", "monte", etc., using empty packing boxes upturned for tables, stacked upon which might frequently be seen hundreds of dollars in gold coin to catch the eye of passers by. There was little manufacturing in the very early days ; commercially none. Of course there were artisans of various kinds: shoemakers. blacksmiths, wagon makers, etc., but theirs was chiefly custom work and repairing. The first saw and grist mill was built by the Pottawattamie Indian Chiefs in 1841 from their own funds, the government having failed for more than three years to keep its promise to them in this respect. It was located on Mosquito creek, about two-and-one-half miles north and east from the site of Billy Caldwell's village and the old block house, and was known as the "Pottawattamie Mill" while operated by or for the Indians. Afterward it was called "Wicks' Mill", and, finally, "Parks' Mill". In 1848 Madison Dagger built a grist mill at the foot of the bluff, in the western part of the Mormon settlement, less than a half mile north of the site of the present Federal Building. Its power was derived from Indian creek, the water being led by a race from the original channel at Benton street, along what were then known as Green and Race streets, to the mill site. Afterward machinery for manufacturing lumber was added. The field notes of the government survey, made in November, 1851, mention a saw mill on section 11, township 75, range 44. It was probably built early in 1851 by either Cornelius Voorhis or Stephen T. Carey or by them jointly, being at times given the name of each — "Voorhis Mill" or "Carey Mill" — and sometimes as " Carey- Voorhis Mill". They made a joint purchase from the government of the land upon which it stood. Its power came from a spring that issued from EARLY DAYS AT COUNCIL BLUFFS 19 the hills there, and near by were quarries of limestone, and several kilns for calcining the product. How long it was in operation no dis covered record discloses. It was in ruins when first seen by the writer, in 1855. It stood at the then extreme head of "Big Lake". The writer has been informed that the little powder house which in early days was perched upon the top of the high bluff on the south side of Pierce street, between South First street and Park Avenue, was built of bricks made in "Duck Hollow" in 1848. His memory recalls the fact, however, that it was commonly reported, in 1853, that the bricks for its construction were brought by boat from St. Louis or St. Joseph. There was no other brick building in the town in the spring of 1853. The first brickyard of commercial importance was established early in 1853 and was located not far from Dagger's mill. From bricks made there was constructed the first brick building (excepting the powder house) erected within the limits of the city. It was a one-story, two-room structure; owned by W. C. James and built with his own hands except as to carpentery. Its first occupant was the United States Land Office, in the late summer or fall of 1853. My father was then Register and Dr. Enos Lowe was receiver. Each office oc cupied a room. Subsequently the ownership passed to Gardner ("Gid") Robinson, by whom it was enlarged and for many years occupied as a residence. It is said that the Federal Building now covers the site. No steam ferry existed at Council Bluffs until 1854, when the Iowa and Nebraska Ferry Company was organized and placed in service a small boat named the "Nebraska." The president of the company was Samuel S. Bayliss, and when a larger boat was required a few years later, it was named for his youngest daughter, "Lizzie Bayliss". Prior to the establishment of this ferry line regular steamboats plying the Missouri river, especially those built for the fur trade on the Upper Missouri, visited the place at the season of emigration and carried emigrants, all called "pilgrims" in those days, across the stream. Such fact is mentioned by Captain Joseph La Barge in the work relating to his life and adventures elsewhere quoted and cited in this work. (See History of Early Navigation on the Missouri River, Life and Adventures of Joseph La Barge.) Subsequent to the abandonment of the De Smet mission (1841) and until the arrival of the Mormons (1846), no church organization of any kind was represented among the Pottawattamies of the region. 20 EARLY DAYS AT COUNCIL BLUFFS The Indians were without school teachers or religious instructors. In 1851 a small organization of Congregationalists and Methodists was formed under the leadership of Revs. G. G. Rice and Wm. Simpson, which occupied rented quarters for use as a chapel. The first church edifice erected by "gentiles" was due to the efforts of Elder Moses F. Shinn, who persistently solicited in the highways and by ways until sufficient funds were raised to erect the small frame structure known as the Methodist Church which for many years stood on Pierce street, between Park Avenue and First street, where it was built in 1854. Under act of Congress of August 22, 1852 (10 Stat., 26), the United States established at Kanesville, September 2, 1852, a land office, for which Joseph H. D. Street and Dr. Samuel M. Ballard were commis sioned Register and Receiver, respectively. Delay in preparation of necessary books deferred the beginning of land sales, however, until March 12, 1853. The office name was changed to Council Bluffs in 1855. The office was discontinued May 13, 1873. Subsequent Registers were Lysander W. Babbitt, James Pollard, Lewis S. Hills (demo cratic) ; Frank Street, Sylvanus Dodge, N. Baldwin (republicans) ; the Receivers were Enos Lowe, A. H. Palmer (democrats), and Dexter C. Bloomer (republican), the latter serving from April 2, 1861, to dis continuance of the office — twelve years. An act of the State legislature (approved January 19, 1853, to become effective after publication) authorizing the change of name from Kanesville to Council Bluffs, became operative February 9, 1853. (See Sess. Laws, 4th Gen. Ass., Chap. 43, page 72.) By legislative enactment of January 24, 1853 (Sess. Laws, 4th Gen. Ass., page 108), entitled "Incorporation of Council Bluffs City", incorporation under the name Council Bluffs was authorized. Many letters of business men immediately following incorporation were dated and bore the printed heading "Council Bluffs City". This act became operative immediately upon its passage; so, the city was in corporated before legal change of name occurred. Although not strictly within the purpose of this work to make special mention of individual citizens of Council Bluffs, except as merely incidental to some other matter, it is deemed proper to state that, in 1853, Grenville M. Dodge became one of her citizens, afterward becoming a prominent figure in the history of the United States, earning the military title of Major General in the War of the Re bellion and serving with great distinction as Chief Engineer in the construction of the Central Branch of the Union Pacific Railroad. EARLY DAYS AT COUNCIL BLUFFS 21 In a biographical sketch published in connection with his obituary it was stated that he "discovered the South Pass" through the Rocky Mountains; but history accords that honor to Etienne Prevost, about the year 1832. The pass was well known to and used by the fur companies operating in that region at an early day, and it was through information and sketch maps obtained from them that Brigham Young, with his exploring party, was aided in finding his way by that route to Great Salt Lake in 1847. By act of Congress, approved April 6, 1854 (10 Stat., 273), it was provided — ' ' That the judge of the county court, as such, for the county of Pottawattamie, in the State of Iowa, be, and he is hereby, authorized to enter at the proper land office, by paying there for, at the rate of one dollar and twenty-five cents the acre, the west half of the southwest quarter of section thirty, the west half of the northwest quarter of section thirty-one, in township number seventy -five, north of range forty-three west ; the southeast quarter and the east half of the southwest quarter of section twenty-five, and the northeast quarter and the east half of the northwest quarter of section thirty-six, in township seventy-five, north of range forty-four west, in said State of Iowa, in trust for the several use and benefit of the occupants thereof, according to their respective interests; . . . ." Under which authority Frank Street, then county judge, made what is known as the townsite entry of "Kanesville" or "Council Bluffs", May 10, 1854. Prior to this, however, on June 3, 1853, Cornelius Voorhis, who had been elected Mayor of the recently incorporated city, applied to ". . . purchase in trust for the benefit of the occupants of said city, the NW14SW14 of section No. 30, in Township No. 75, north of Range No. 43 west, and the SE14 and the SE14 SW14 of section No. 25, and the NEV4NWV4 and the North west quarter of the Northeast quarter of section No. 36, all in Township No. Seventy-five North of No. 44 West, in the district of lands subject to sale at Kanesville, Iowa; . . . which lots of land above described contain Three Hundred and Four teen Acres and Fifty Hundredths. ' ' This application was rejected on the ground, chiefly, that no law existed authorizing entry in that manner; but also because protest against allowance thereof had been made by the Bishop of the Diocese of Dubuque, who claimed for the Catholic Church ownership to twenty 22 EARLY DAYS AT COUNCIL BLUFFS acres in the W^SW^ of said section 30, on which stood the old blockhouse formerly occupied by the De Smet mission; the claim of the church being based upon the language of Article IX, of the Potta wattamie treaty of 1846. This building stood upon the SWL4SW14 of section 30, and it is presumed that said tract was omitted from the Voorhis application for the purpose, of avoiding controversy. In connection with the church protest proceedings were had before the General Land Office and the Bureau of Indian Affairs, which were pending at the time Judge Street's entry was made, serving to suspend action thereon and preventing issue of patent for the townsite until April 20, 1883, almost precisely twenty-nine years from date of entry. (See Old Blockhouse.) A survey of the townsite, as entered by Judge Street, was made by Thomas Tostevin, in 1854, delimitating the boundaries of the holdings of the several occupants of the land, which served as the basis for all deeds of conveyance executed by the county judge thereafter, and upon which now rest all land titles within that portion of the present city. Prior to 1857 newspapers, or publications having general subscrip tion circulation, were established as follows: Frontier Guardian, by Orson Hyde, 1849; Weekly Western Bugle, by Almon W. Babbitt, 1850 ; Council Bluffs Chronotype, by W. W. Maynard, 1854 ; Democratic Clarion, by A. P. Bentley, 1855. The Guardian was absorbed by the Bugle ; the Chronotype and Clarion died natural deaths; the Bugle was discontinued in 1870, being suc ceeded by the Council Bluffs Times, which died a lingering death a year or so afterward. The Weekly Nonpareil was established in 1857 by Maynard and Long; developed a daily edition during the civil war, and is still "doing business at the old stand". The first dramatic performance at Council Bluffs was by amateurs, "The Forrest Dramatic Association", in 1856. Babbitt's Hall, in the old Phoenix Block, was fitted with stage and George Simons painted the scenery. The opening bill was "The Forest Rose" and "Paddy Miles' Boy". Many of the leading citizens participated in the performances of the association, which continued for two or three years when the field was abandoned to professionals represented by traveling combinations. EARLY DAYS AT COUNCIL BLUFFS 23 >• Assumed Boundary of Missouri SKETCH MAP OF THE POTTAWATTAMIE COUNTRY 24 EARLY DAYS AT COUNCIL BLUFFS SKETCH MAP OF POTTAWATTAMIE COUNTRY. The Sketch Map from which this diagram is taken — slightly larger than this copy — was made at or near Council Bluffs in 1837 by Dr. Edwin James, the first Sub-Agent in charge of the Pottawattamie Indians in Iowa, to accompany the first official report (August 11, 1837,) submitted by him to General William Clark, Superintendent of Indian Affairs at St. Louis, and was by the latter forwarded to the Secretary of War, then in charge of Indian Affairs, with a letter dated September 20, 1837. It will be remembered that at the time the sketch map was made no survey of any character had been made of the country to which the map relates; that Dr. James made the drawing entirely from his own observation and from information derived from trappers and others who had partially explored the region. Taking into considera tion these facts the map is wonderfully accurate. The original of this map is in the office of the Commissioner of Indian Affairs, Washington, D. C. (Pottawattamie File "C"). Notice the name "Welch's Creek" applied to what is now called Pigeon. It was named "Indian Knob Creek" by Lewis and Clark, and is shown on Nicollet's map of 1843 as ' ' Gopher Creek. ' ' THE POTTAWATTAMIE INDIANS. By treaty executed July 15, 1830 (7 Stat., 328-332), territory on the Missouri river, now embraced in southwestern Iowa and the north west corner of Missouri, was ceded to the United States by the tribes or nations of Indians known as Sacs, Sioux, Iowas, Otoes, Missourias, Foxes; they reserved hunting privileges therein until such time as the government should locate upon the lands other Indians, whose removal from east of the Mississippi river was contemplated, or until other appropriation thereof should be made. That portion of the ceded territory now in the State of Missouri was triangular in form, or wedge shaped, and situated between the Little Platte and Missouri rivers, being about fifty miles wide at the northern end and running to a point at the junction of the streams, opposite the site of the present Kansas City. By treaties executed September 26 and 27, 1833 (7 Stat., 442 to 448), several bands of Chippewas, Ottawas and Pottawattamies ceded to the United States their possessory right to lands in the States of Illinois and Indiana, consenting to removal to the west of the Missis sippi river, and a portion of the territory acquired by the United States under the treaty of 1830, above mentioned, was assigned to them, being specifically described by metes and bounds in the later treaty, when finally ratified, as follows : "Beginning at the mouth of Boyer 's river; thence down the Missouri river to a point thereon from which a due E line would strike the NW corner of the State of Missouri; thence along said E line to the NW corner of said State ; thence along the northern boundary of Missouri till it strikes the line of the lands of the Sac and Fox Indians; thence northwardly along said line to a point from which a W line would strike the sources of the little Sioux river; thence along said W line till it strikes the sources of said river ; thence down said river to its mouth ; thence down the Missouri river to the beginning, provided that the said boundary shall contain 5,000,000 acres ; but should it contain more, then the said boundaries are to be correspondingly reduced. ' ' The northern boundary of this territory was never delimitated ; but the site of the present city of Council Bluffs was embraced therein; 26 EARLY DAYS AT COUNCIL BLUFFS the wedge-shaped tract in Missouri was not. It may here be said that, at the dates of the treaty last mentioned, the north line of the State of Missouri appeared upon official maps several miles north of the now existing Missouri-Iowa boundary, and the northwest corner of Missouri, referred to in the description of lands above given, was fifty or sixty miles east of the point at which it was finally established — that is, a few miles east of Bedford, the county seat of Taylor County, Iowa. The removal of the Pottawattamie Indians from Illinois, under the treaty of 1833, began in the fall of 1835, as hereinafter shown by official records. The removal was under the supervision of the War Department of which the Indian Bureau was then a part, and, for reasons not necessary to state here, the officers and contractors having charge thereof carried the greater number of their charges to the triangular territory above mentioned, although this land was not included in the 1833 treaty. The Indians were located near and opposite Fort Leavenworth and it was with great difficulty that they were afterward induced to leave such location and take up residence upon the Iowa lands. The lands embraced in the triangle were unconditionally ceded to the United States by the Indians party to the treaty of 1830 by treaties of Sept. 10, 17, 27 ; Oct. 15, and Nov. 30, 1836 (see 7 Stat., 510, 511, 516, 524, 525, 527 ) , and became a part of the State of Missouri. It was known as the "Platte Purchase". Then the trespassing Indian emi grants were forced to remove to the country assigned them in Iowa. There is some obscurity as to the precise date when the first of the Indians arrived in the vicinity of the site of the present city of Council Bluffs. There is some evidence, not fully convincing, in dicating that one party reached that locality in 1835 or 1836, but no official record showing such fact has been found. Stutely E. Wicks, a white member of the tribe through marriage with an Indian woman, executed an affidavit at Council Bluffs, April 5, 1854, in which appears the following allegation, viz. : — "That he resided in the year 1836 with the Pottawattamie Indians in the Territory of Iowa immediately adjoining and contiguous to the Missouri River." But other allegations made in his deposition are so inconsistent with facts well established by conclusive evidence as to discredit this, it THE POTTAWATTAMIE INDIANS 27 being apparent that he was mistaken in respect to dates of occurrences. (See "Old Blockhouse".) The earliest officially authenticated arrival of the Pottawattamies at or near the site of the present city of Council Bluffs, occurred July 28, 1837, when Brigadier General H. Atkinson, commanding the First Department of the Western Division of the Army, accompanied by Dr. Edwin James, recently appointed Indian Sub-agent and placed in charge of the Pottawattamies, with about one hundred of the women and children and other members of the nation unable to march, on board the steamer "Kansas", arrived at a point on the Missouri river "fifteen or eighteen miles above the mouth of the great Platte river" and landed "on the left bank of the Missouri river", where he formally committed the Indians to the care of the sub-agent by letter of that date wherein he said : "Hd. Qrs. 1st Dept. West. Div. of the U. S. Army, Steamboat Kansas, near Belleview, July 28, 1837. Sir:— Having been ordered by the General in Chief of the Army, bearing date 20th June, and given in conformity with instruc tions from the Secretary of War of the 19th of June, to remove the Pottawattamies to their lands agreeably to the treaty made on the 26th September, 1833, and ratified 21st February, 1835, and having landed a portion of them at this point, and the residue being on their march and will shortly arrive, I consider the object of the Government accomplished. . . . With respect, Sir, Your Ob't Serv't H. Atkinson, Brig. Gen'l. Dr. Edwin James, Sub-Agent for Pottawattamies." Pursuant to his duty General Atkinson made report to the Governor of Missouri, as follows: "Hd. Qrs. 1st Dept. West. Div. of the Army, Steamboat Kansas, Roche 's Point, August 2, 1837. To His Excellency, G. W. Boggs, Governor of the State of Missouri. Sir:— I have the honor to inform you that, in obedience to orders from the Secretary of War, I have removed the Pottawattamie Indians from within the limits of this State to their own lands, and they have selected a position and located themselves on the left bank of this river fifteen or eighteen miles above the great Platte river. . . . 28 EARLY DAYS AT COUNCIL BLUFFS With highest Consideration, Sir, I have the Honor to be Your Most Ob't Serv't, H. Atkinson, Brig. GenT U. S. Army." General Atkinson submitted simultaneous, but separate, reports, in substantially the same language, to Major General Macomb, General in Chief of the Army, and to General William Clark, Superintendent of Indian Affairs. The following is from the letter to General Clark, to-wit : "Hd. Qrs. 1st Dept. West. Div. of the U. S. Army, Jefferson Barracks, August 5, 1837. Sir:— I returned yesterday from among the Pottawattamies and Iowas and Sacks of the Missouri River, whither I had been ordered by the Secretary of War to remove the Pottawattamies to their own lands agreeably to treaty. Part of the band, accom panied by their agent, Dr. James, was landed at a point on the left bank of the Missouri river fifteen or eighteen miles above the mouth of the great Platte, whither the main body were under march and would arrive in four or five days after. This position or one In the immediate neighborhood is selected by the Indians as their permanent home. . . . With Great Respect, Sir, I have the Honor to be Your Ob't Serv't, H. Atkinson, Brig. Gen'l U. S. Army. General William Clark, Superintendent of Indian Affairs, St. Louis." The foregoing extracts are taken from unpublished copies of letters and reports in the files of the Indian Office, Washington, D. C, re lating to the emigration of the Pottawattamie Indians under the treaty of 1833. The removal of those who finally located in Southwestern Iowa, never exceeding 3000, began in 1835 and terminated in 1838. With his official report, dated November 28, 1840, the Commissioner of Indian Affairs submitted a statement from which has been taken the following : Captain Russell removed, in the fall of 1835, a large party of the Chicago Indians, and, in 1836, Mr. Ker- cheval removed another party ; but it would appear, from a letter from Dr. James, sub-agent, &c, that both to gether did not exceed 1,455 Prior to November, 1837, the same band had removed, themselves 842 THE POTTAWATTAMIE INDIANS 29 On the 26th of November, 1837, Colonel Sands de livered 287 And, in the fall of 1838, Mr. Berry delivered 150 Whole number of Ottawas, Chippewas and Potta wattamies removed prior to 1840 (all in the Council Bluffs sub-agency) 2 734 (H. Doc, 26th Cong., 2d Sess., Volume 1, Page 253.) August 4, 1837, Captain D. B. Moore, in command of Company C of the First Regiment of Dragoons, having marched from Fort Leav enworth, arrived at the Council Bluffs Sub-agency for the purpose of affording protection to the emigrating Pottawattamies from hostile treatment by their belligerent neighbors to the northward. Pursuant to his orders he caused to be erected in that vicinity a blockhouse, and, with his command returned to Fort Leavenworth on November 1, 1837, his report to Colonel Kearny relative to the carrying out of orders given in connection with the expedition having been dated at Fort Leavenworth on the 11th of that month. (See "Old Block house.") This blockhouse formed the nucleus of Chief Billy Caldwell 's village. The precise dates when it was begun and finished have not been found ; nor is it known with certainty when Caldwell and his band took up residence there; but it may be presumed that the two events were coincident. The place of first encampment of the Pottawattamies was described in the first official report submitted by Dr. James, sub-agent, and the report was accompanied by a sketch map of the new Pottawattamie country, a diagram prepared from it is printed herein. From Dr. James' report is taken the following: "Sub-Agency of Council Bluffs, (Bellevue) Aug. 11th, 1837. Gen. Wm. Clark. Sir: The second detachment of emigrating Pottawattomies, about seventy-five in number, arrived in their own country pr. steamboat Howard on the 8th inst. and encamped with those who came by the Kansas, about two miles above this place in a grove adjoining a fine dry prairie. This position combines more advantages than we can find in any other; here we expect to establish the issue house, and to be joined before many days by the main body of the nation, who have now been twenty- 30 EARLY DAYS AT COUNCIL BLUFFS three days on the march by land from the Black Snake Hills. . . . With great respect your obedient servant, Edwin James, Sub-Agent for Council Bluffs." (S. Doc. 25th Cong., 2d Sess., Vol. 1, page 549.) From the next letter or report submitted by Dr. James, which does not appear to have been published, though on file in the Indian Office, the following extract is made, to-wit : "Sub-Agency of Council Bluffs, Aug. 30th, 1837. Gen. Wm. Clark. Sir : All of the Pottawattomies lately resident in the Platte Purchase have arrived in their own country, except two or three who died by the way. They express themselves well satisfied with the lands and profess a strong desire to cultivate largely ; and to have schools established among them without loss of time. . . . " It is not the purpose of this work to give a complete history in detail of the Pottawattamie Indians in southwestern Iowa, but to note merely such principal matters of interest among them as pertain to the immediate vicinity of Council Bluffs, although the writer feels constrained to make correction of error relating to the general history of these Indians where the same has come to his notice in the course of research for this publication. It clearly appears, from the report of Dr. James, and other authorities herein cited, that all of the Potta wattamies who had been upon the Platte Purchase, and about 280 from east of the Mississippi, not reported by him, reached the neighborhood of the site of the present city of Council Bluffs in 1837, and about 150, from the east, joined them in 1838. In his annual report for 1838, the Commissioner of Indian Affairs said : "There have emigrated within the year 151 Chippewa, Ottawa and Pottawattamies." (Sen. Doc, 25th Cong., 3d Sess., Vol. 1, page 443.) The various bands soon spread over the adjacent country and estab lished villages at many points. The village of Billy Caldwell's band was situated upon the precise spot where the original town of Council Bluffs became located in 1846, and probably not over 500 Indians were at any one time located in that immediate vicinity. Mr. Jacob Van der Zee, in a paper published in the July, 1913, THE POTTAWATTAMIE INDIANS 31 number of the Iowa Journal of History and Politics, reprinted as a booklet under the title ' ' Episodes in the Early History of the Western Iowa Country", has stated, upon the authority of a number of writers and publications duly accredited, that : "Dr. James continued to reside at 'the Council Bluffs sub- agency ' until his resignation in 1838, and after that the Council Bluffs agent at Bellevue took charge for a while. David Hardin and his family arrived early in the spring of 1838 on board the steamer 'Antelope' from Fort Leavenworth. He had been appointed farmer to the Pottawattamies in September, 1836, at a salary of $600. It is said that he located near a big spring on what is now East Broadway, Council Bluffs. The Potta wattamies planted very little corn or anything else, 'except here and there one, who happened to have a hoe or a plough'. One band consisting of about one-third of the nation, headed by Chief Big Foot, did not enter the Iowa country until the fall of 1838 and then retired eastward to set up a village on the Nishnabotna river almost fifty miles away. All the other villages were from two to fifteen miles distant from the agency buildings." Mr. Hardin's name was Davis (not David). He was appointed Assistant Indian Farmer September 1, 1836, with salary of $600, and assumed duty in 1837 at the Council Bluffs Sub-agency, under contract with Dr. James, and appears upon the published roll of Indian Bureau employees for that year as "David Harolin"; on the 1838 roll the name is " Hardin". It appears from unpublished records in the Indian Office that his legal connection with the service terminated with that year, but he was recognized by the Superintendent of Indian Affairs as entitled to pay to the close of 1839, when his name was dropped from the official roll. He continued to reside upon the agency farm although efforts were made to oust him, and alleged that he had not been formally notified of his removal; so, June 20, 1842, a formal letter of dismissal was delivered to him in person, whereupon he demanded payment to that date. The attainable records do not disclose the final disposition of his claim. He may have located with his family temporarily at the spring on East Broadway; but the agency farm,— to at least a part of which one of his sons subsequently acquired title,— was found by the United States Surveys made in 1851 and 1852, to embrace the Lot 4 (W^ SW14) Sec. 14, and Ey2SEV4 Sec 15, T. 74 N.,R. 44 W., 5th P. M. 32 EARLY DAYS AT COUNCIL BLUFFS (See Kanesville Cash Entry No. 160, made by Richard S. Hardin, May 28, 1853, General Land Office file.) This land lies two miles west and four miles south of the site of Billy Caldwell's village, and is partly within the "4-mile circle from the postoffice," as that circle is laid down on "Allen's Suburban Map of Council Bluffs" published in 1890. In his official report of October 12, 1840, Sub-agent Stephen Cooper said: ' ' There is no farmer within my agency and the Indians state they do not wish for one." (Sen. Doc, 26th Cong., 2d Sess., Vol. 1, page 322.) (Also see Sen. Doc, 28th Cong., 1st Sess., Vol. 1, page 393.) May 31, 1838, Father Pierre-Jean De Smet, S. J., accompanied by Father Felix Verreydt and lay brother Mazelli, arrived at the Council Bluffs sub-agency and established among the Pottawattamies a mission which was named St. Joseph but frequently mentioned by the name St. Mary. The old fort given them by Colonel Kearney, to which they built an addition, together with some small cabins given by Chief Caldwell and a dwelling erected by themselves in 1839, served as church or chapel, school and residence for the missionaries. (See "Old Blockhouse".) Father De Smet's early letters from this mission are said to have been the beginning of the series from which his name became so widely known. They contained glowing accounts of the success being attained in the evangelization and education of the Indians ; but he was called away and sent to other fields late in 1839, and prosperity, which had already begun to wane, seems to have forsaken the mission entirely soon after his departure, and it was closed and finally abandoned in July or August, 1841, having lived but a little more than three years. No other mission or school of any kind appears to have been established at the place during the subsequent six years of occupancy by the Pottawattamies. Hon. Dexter C. Bloomer, of Council Bluffs, published more matter relative to the early history of the Council Bluffs region than any other person. He was a most estimable and conscientious man ; but, unfortunately, although a lawyer by profession, he was not a deep investigator. Nearly all of the quasi historical matter furnished by him was based upon hearsay, legend and tradition, and much of it proves upon investigation to have been erroneous. Especially is this THE POTTAWATTAMIE INDIANS 33 the case with his contributions to Annals of Iowa relative to the coming of the Pottawattamies and the building of the old blockhouse. (See Annals of Iowa, Volumes 8-9, pages 523, 527, 666; also Third Series, Volume 2, page 549.) Mr. Bloomer fixed the dates of the coming of the Indians and the erection of the blockhouse as 1838 and 1839 respectively; whereas they were practically synonymous events which occurred in 1837. He said that the blockhouse was the "first building erected in Potta wattamie county", apparently forgetting or ignoring the fact that he had also written of the location of Hart's trading house within that territory "as early as 1824". In connection with the arrival of the Indians he said: "Davis Hardin was their agent and came with them"; also that, "Mr. Hardin caused a mill to be built on Mosquito creek for the grinding of grain raised by them and himself". There is no record connected with the arrival of the Pottawattamie Indians in the vicinity to indicate that Mr. Hardin was with them. The record shows that Dr. Edwin James came with the party that first arrived, having been appointed as a sub-agent and assigned to the Pottawattamies in April, 1837, and that the emigrating Indians were delivered to him by General Atkinson on the date of arrival. The farm settled upon by Mr. Hardin — that is selected by him for the Indians, whose farmer he was — comprised land near what was after ward called "Council Point", but no such name existed at the date of his arrival. The official records (letters on file in the Indian Office) show that the mill referred to by Mr. Bloomer was built at the expense of the Indians, in 1841, by Samuel N. Holcomb, under contract made in 1840 between him and Chief Billy Caldwell, at which time Mr. Hardin had no connection with the Indian service. For several years after the Pottawattamies left the vicinity the mill just mentioned was operated under lease by Stntely E. Wicks, and, in time, became known as "Wicks' Mill". Tradition accredited Mr. Wicks as miller for the Indians, but no government record attests the fact. He was undoubtedly connected with the institution while under Indian or government control, but does not appear to have held ap pointment as miller. He became owner of the property by purchase from George Scofield, who entered and acquired title from the govern ment to the land upon which it stood. (See Cash Entry No. 184, Kanesville series, May 31, 1854, in General Land Office files, Wash ington, D. C.) 34 EARLY DAYS AT COUNCIL BLUFFS The first mention of this mill found in published reports of the Indian service appears under date of October 2, 1841, wherein Sub- agent Cooper said : "There is neither farmer nor school teacher employed by the Government within this sub-agency. The Chiefs complain that their treaty stipulations have not been compbed with, and, in consequence of which, they have built a saw-and-grist mill at their own expense that is doing a tolerable good business. Bill Caldwell, the principal business chief of this nation, and who drew a life annuity of $1,000 per annum, died on the 27th ultimo." (Sen. Doc, 27th Cong., 2d Sess., Vol. 1, page 357.) (Sen. Doc, 28th Cong., 1st Sess., Vol. 1, page 393.) Some of the errors above mentioned have been repeated and per petuated in publications of later date. Among those that have come to the attention of the writer are : "History of Pottawattamie County, Iowa", by Homer H. Field and Joseph R. Reed; "History of Iowa", by Hon. Benjamin F. Gue; "History of Western Iowa", published by the Western Pub lishing Company, Sioux City; "History of Mills County, Iowa", published by the Iowa His torical Company, Chicago; "History of Pottawattamie County, Iowa", published by 0. L. Baskin & Co., Chicago ; "Biographical History of Pottawattamie County, Iowa", 1891, published by the Lewis Publishing Company; "Episodes in the Early History of Western Iowa", by Jacob Van der Zee, reprinted from the July, 1913, number of the Iowa Journal of History and Politics, by the State Historical Society of Iowa, Iowa City. A quotation from the work last-above mentioned has been made hereinbefore which contains, in addition to other things, the statement that Bigfoot's band did not "enter the Iowa country until the fall of 1838" and then "set up a village on the Nishnabotna River" (page 24). On page 25, referring to the fear of the Pottawattamies soon after arrival that they would be attacked by the Sioux, it is said: "To quiet their alarm and apprehensions Colonel Stephen Watts Kearny hastened from Fort Leavenworth in command of a body of dragoons, arriving on board the steamer 'Antelope'. THE POTTAWATTAMIE INDIANS 35 They at once erected a block-house twenty-four feet square and set up barracks and tents on the ground near by. ' ' Both of the statements are erroneous. According to the official records Bigfoot's band arrived in the Iowa country in the fall of 1837. Indian Agent John Dougherty, then in charge of the Pottawattamie sub-agency, in his official report dated Bellevue, November 25, 1838, stated that: ' ' Big Foot 's band came too late to raise corn last spring. They came in last fall and received their annuities and rations, and returned to the Des Moines River, where they spent the winter with some of the Missouri Sacs, and I understand it is their intention to return to that place as soon as they receive their annuities again." (Sen. Doc, 25th Cong., 3d Sess., Vol. 1, page 321.) Official documents indicate that Colonel Kearny was officially present in the vicinity of Council Bluffs' site spring of 1838; summer of 1839, and in 1840 ; no other visits mentioned. On the latter occasion he was in command of troops contemplating punitive measures against the Pawnees and Otoes. The other visits were for examination of sites for a fort, on the west (right) side of the river, resulting in the location of the old fort which bore his name at the site of Nebraska City. He left Fort Leavenworth June 30, 1846, for participation in the war with Mexico. (Sen. Doc, 29th Cong., 2d Sess., Vol. 1, page 49.) Referring to the location of the several bands or tribes under his jurisdiction, Sub-agent Cooper, in his report dated October 12, 1840, said: "Many of them have large fields, well fenced in, with good log cabins, and are settled in villages from two to five, ten or fifteen miles from the Council Bluffs sub-agency — except Big Foot's band, who live upon the waters of the Nishnebottona, about fifty miles east of this agency, which band constitutes about one-third of the nation." (Sen. Doc, 26th Cong., 2d Sess., Vol. 1, page 321.) It is within the knowledge of the writer, founded on good authority, that Big Foot's village was on Indian creek, a tributary of the Nish nabotna river, a short distance above the confluence with that river, which place subsequently became known, and still appears upon maps, as Iranistan. That is, the village was "on the waters of the Nish nebottona", but not actually on that stream. 36 EARLY DAYS AT COUNCIL BLUFFS The report last quoted showed, also, that the offices of the sub- agency were still situated nearly opposite the month of the Platte river, and that the number of Indians within the sub-agency was about two thousand, of whom 550 were warriors. (See Sen. Doc, 26th Cong., 2d Sess., Vol. 1, page 322.) An additional report was submitted by Sub-agent Cooper, in the fall of 1840, wherein appears the following: ' ' Schools, there are none here under the authority of the gov ernment. There are two Roman Catholic priests residing within my agency, of good moral character, who set a good example to the Indians and half breeds. They have a chapel, and school, and teacher, and have several young Indians in the school who are coming on pretty well." (Sen. Doc, 26th Cong., 2d Sess., Vol. 1, page 397.) The original landing of the Indians in T837 was in the vicinity of the site of the agency farm as located by Mr. Hardin ; possibly at the landing shown by government survey about a mile below Hardin's house, now in Lake Manawa. Soon after the landing headquarters of the sub-agency were established at a point nearly opposite the mouth of the Platte river. Sometime prior to 1845 removal to Point aux Poulos was effected. July 24, of that year, Sub-agent Elliott re ported that: "The number in this sub-agency is about 2000. We have no schools or missions among the Pottawattamies. The half breeds, men and women, among the Pottawattamies, all wear the dress of the whites, and adopt our mode of life so far as their knowledge and means enable them to do so. The office of this sub-agency is located at Point aux Poulos, on the northeast bank of the Missouri river, about twenty miles below the mouth of Boyer 's river, and opposite Bellevue, as marked on the map. The distance to the Missouri State line is about thirty-five miles. High Creek postoffice, in Atchison (late Holt) County, Missouri, is the nearest postoffice to this place. The three trading houses of this sub-agency are at Point aux Poulos." (Sen. Doc, 29th Cong., 1st Sess., Vol. 1, page 470.) When the offices of the sub-agency were removed from the point opposite the month of the Platte ; where removed to at the time, or when established at Point aux Poulos, are questions not answerable THE POTTAWATTAMIE INDIANS 37 from any of the discovered official records. In the spring of 1843, when Captain Burgwin's cantonment of Fort Croghan was inundated by the Missouri river, it appears that the sub-agency establishment was also flooded, and it is not improbable that the offices were re moved from the site then occupied at the same time as the troops removed to the highlands. Captain Burgwin was at the time in charge, temporarily, of the sub-agency affairs, and it is probable that he had removed the offices to his cantonment for convenience, and that they were removed to the same point to which the military estab lishment was taken. Richard S. Elliott was appointed sub-agent of the Council Bluffs agency early in 1843, and assumed charge on June 1st of that year. In a letter of that date, addressed to the Superintendent of Indian Affairs at St. Louis, he reported his arrival and acknowledged receipt of the papers and effects of the sub-agency from Captain Burgwin as of that date. The precise point from which he wrote does not appear, but he said: "The mills for the agency for lumber and grist are in toler able order; and a blacksmith shop is in progress of erection at the mills, the tools having been removed from the river on account of the high waters of a few weeks since. ' ' I find no suitable buildings for the agency. There is a cabin some distance down the river from the point at which I write this, but it is unfortunately located as well for the health and comfort of the Sub-Agent as for the business of the Indians; and it should, I think, be sold as soon as possible. It might, I have no doubt, be disposed of to the present occupant, Mr. Stephen Cooper, who is a mere tenant by sufferance, but would be very unwilling to leave the place if he could avoid it. If authorized to do so I will dispose of the building. Mr. Cooper is a licensed trader. "Under the circumstances I deem it my duty, as well to the Indians as to my family, to request an allowance of at least five hundred dollars to erect a suitable agency house, and, if I receive the allowance, I will locate the building so as to accommadate the Indians during their stay in the country, and to bring the government a good price when they leave. I have no house now. . . ." Soon after his arrival Mr. Elliott recommended the appointment as interpreter for the sub-agency of Claude Laframboise, to succeed Louis Ouilmot, and, in a letter dated July 31, 1843, explained to the 38 EARLY DAYS AT COUNCIL BLUFFS Superintendent of Indian Affairs his reasons for the recommendation as follows: " . . . . My reasons for nominating Mr. Laframboise were these: Mr. Louis Ouilmot informed me that he did not desire to remain in the situation, and Mr. Laframboise appeared to be well quabfied, resides near my office at Caldwell 's Village, and is very hospitable to the Indians. . . ." It thus appears that at the date of that letter the offices of the sub- agency, such as they were, were at Billy Caldwell's village, the site of the present city of Council Bluffs. How long they were maintained at that point does not appear; but it is evident that the location was merely temporary, and that they were established (probably re-estab lished) at Point aux Poulos, where was situated the house mentioned as being occupied by Mr. Cooper, as indicated by Mr. Elliott's letter of June 1, 1843, quoted and cited above. It does not clearly appear whether Mr. Elliott was allowed the funds for the erection of a new house; the correspondence relating to his request indicated that the Superintendent of Indian Affairs was opposed to the making of such expenditure at the time. September 26, 1843, Sub-Agent Elliott, who had been in charge of the sub-agency for about four months, wrote regarding the Potta wattamie lands as follows : "These lands are exceedingly fertile, but, owing to the scarcity of timber, of rock and indeed minerals of every kind, they are not so valuable for the purposes of the white man as one would suppose by looking at the map, which shows this region to be the only outlet to market for the vast Territory of Iowa. Still, their value is sufficient to justify the Govern ment in paying a very handsome price for them, and it is mani fest that they must be treated for at a very early date. ' ' This appraisement of the value of the Pottawattamie lands must he regarded as almost humorous by readers of the present day when there is scarcely an acre of the entire domain, except that occupied by towns and cities, highways and other public service works, not actually devoted to purposes of agriculture of the most profitable character ; and when the newspapers frequently announce sale at from one hundred and twenty-five to two hundred dollars per acre at public auction in the settlement of estates, &c Within the territory formerly occupied by the Pottawattamies are THE POTTAWATTAMIE INDIANS 39 thousands of acres of the finest and most profitable apple orchards in the world, while the production of corn and other field crops throughout the region is phenomenal. These, coupled with the stock- raising pursuits of the people, justify the belief that there exists no richer section anywhere. Early in 1842 circumstances indicated serious trouble between the Pottawattamies and Sioux, the latter never having become reconciled to the occupancy of the country by the former. The Pottawattamies, anticipating attack, had arranged for assistance in the defense with neighboring Otoes, Iowas and Sacs, and war seemed imminent. Colonel Kearny, in command at Fort Leavenworth, despatched Captain J. H. K. Burgwin, with a company of the First Dragoons to the scene of action. The troops arrived May 31st and established a military post near the Indian farm which they named Camp Fenwick. In the fall they constructed a log cantonment and the name was changed to Fort Croghan, where the command spent the winter. In April, 1843, a freshet in the Missouri river inundated the cantonment, compelling the command to retire to the highlands. Soon afterward the eminent naturalist, John James Audubon, visited the place and there for the first time saw a Yellow-headed Troupial. The fort was abandoned October 6, 1843. (See Fort Croghan.) The Pottawattamie occupancy of the territory in Iowa, in which is included the site of the present city of Council Bluffs, continued for a period of a little more than ten years — 1837 to 1847- — their possessory right having been terminated by a treaty negotiated at Washington during the winter and spring of 1846 (see 9 Stat. 853-856), which was signed by the Iowa bands June 5th, and by those on the Osage river June 17th, of that year. Under the terms of this treaty the Indians relinquished claim to the Iowa lands receiving in exchange a money consideration and a tract of land thirty miles square in Kansas, and they were obligated to remove within two years from the date of the ratification of the treaty by the United States Senate, which occurred July 22, 1846, and the treaty was officially promulgated by proclamation issued the following day. These bands were composed of Ottawa, Chippewa and Pottawattamie Indians and, it was pro vided by the treaty just mentioned that thereafter they should be known as the "Pottowautomie Nation". The removal occurred, or was at least begun, in the fall of 1847, and in reference to that event Thomas H. Harvey, Superintendent of 40 EARLY DAYS AT COUNCIL BLUFFS Indian Affairs at St. Louis, addressed a communication to the Com missioner of Indian Affairs, dated October 29, 1847, wherein he said : "The Potawatomies, although not compelled to emigrate until July, 1848, have commenced emigration under the most satisfactory circumstances. I attended the payment at the Council Bluffs sub-agency, and urged their immediate emigra tion; they entered into it with great spirit, and immediately after payment, started for their new homes, crossing the Mis souri river at different points in large parties. ... I presume before this reaches you, the Potawatomie emigration will have been completed. ' ' And he added, as an apparent important piece of information, this statement, viz.: "At the late Pottawattamie treaty (at both the Council Bluffs and Osage river sub-agencies) the Indians gave their notes to the traders for more than ninety thousand dollars." (Sen. Doc, 30th Cong., 1st Sess., Vol. 1, page 837.) The total number of these Indians did not exceed three thousand, so the notes given to the traders represented indebtedness amounting to about thirty dollars per capita. The precise date when the Pottawattamies began their removal from the vicinity of the site of the present city of Council Bluffs may not be more definitely fixed than it is by the preceding quotation; that is about September, 1847. It is clearly established, however, that the removal had been completely effected prior to the fall of 1848. In his official report dated Fort Leavenworth, , September 26, 1848, Indian Agent R. S. Cummins said : "A census of the Pottawattamies I have not been able to take; even if they had been taken, they would not fully have answered the purpose. These Indians have but recently emi grated to their new country." (Sen. Doc, 30th Cong., 2d Sess., Vol. 1, page 445.) In a communication dated October 4, 1848, the Superintendent of Indian Affairs at St. Louis, said: "The Pottawattamies, who, at the date of my annual report of last year, had not emigrated, have since removed to their new homes, without causing the slightest embarrassment to the government; they deserve much credit for their prompt- THE POTTAWATTAMIE INDIANS 41 ness, especially as the entire emigration was effected within the time limit of the treaty for their removal. They are pleased, and justly so, with their new homes, and I am gratified to be able to inform you that they are now living in fraternal amity, after having lived in separate bands for so many years. ' ' (Sen. Doc, 30th Cong., 2d Sess., Vol. 1, page 439.) In his official report for the year, dated November 30, 1848, the Commissioner of Indian Affairs stated that: "Within the past year the Pottawattamies, who have hereto fore been separated (the larger portion being in Iowa and the others on the Osage river), have completed their removal to their new country on the Kansas river, between the Delawares and Shawnees, where they are now comfortably settled. . . . Much credit is due them, not only for their prompt removal, but for the peaceable and orderly manner in which it was con ducted. It was a new feature in our Indian system, to see an entire tribe of Indians quietly and without disorder of any kind remove themselves to a new country, nearly two hundred miles from most of them, in conformity with a stipulation to that effect in a treaty which had been made with the government; and bearing their own expenses out of funds set apart for that purpose." (Sen. Doc, 30th Cong., 2d Sess., Vol. 1, page 395.) The Commissioner, in this same report, referring to the Winne bago Indians, said: "The removal of this tribe, and of the Pottawattamies, has entirely freed Iowa of her Indian population." (Sen. Doc, 30th Cong., 2d Sess., Vol. 1, page 435.) During their residence in Southwestern Iowa the Pottawattamies made very slight progress toward civilization and established little or nothing resembling permanent homes or improvements of value. Their shortcomings in these respects were due, no doubt to their un settled condition. There was scarcely an interval between the com pletion of the treaty of 1833 by which they surrendered their lands in Illinois and Indiana and the beginning of overtures for the cession of the lands to which they were about to be removed, it having occurred to some one that they should be located farther south, at some point south of the Missouri river. (Sen. Doc, 24th Cong., 2d Sess., Vol. 1, pages 392-3, 395-6.) Efforts to secure a new treaty with these Indians continued to be 42 EARLY DAYS AT COUNCIL BLUFFS made from time to time thereafter during their entire occupancy of the lands in Iowa and on the Osage river. Sub-agent R. B. Mitchell, in a report dated September 11, 1846, said: "The unsettled condition of this nation for some years has prevented their making the improvements necessary for con venience and comfort." (Sen. Doc, 29th Cong., 2d Sess., Vol. 1, page 300.) The Missouri river near the site of the present city of Council Bluffs was reached by the advance guard of the Mormon emigration to the Rocky Mountains, June 14, 1846 ; a few days after the Potta wattamie treaty had been signed by the Indians in that vicinity, and three days before it was signed by those residing in the Osage country. Their arrival was announced to the Department at Washington by report of the Superintendent of Indian Affairs, dated St. Louis, Sep tember 5, 1846. He said: "There is at this time, and has been for several months, a large number of Mormons (supposed to be 4,000 to 8,000) in the Indian country. They have passed into the Potawatomie Country at the Council Bluffs. A large number have crossed the Missouri river and are on their way to Grand Island, in the Platte or Nebraska river. Another portion of them are de sirous to remain next spring on the Boyer river, in Potawatomie Country; to which they have obtained the consent of the In dians. The sub-agent at that place reports that they are con ducting themselves well, and do not seem disposed to interfere at all with the Indians. I have instructed him to use his in fluence to prevent a waste of timber by them." (Sen. Doc, 29th Cong., 2d Sess., Vol. 1, page 287.) These Mormons, the Pottawattamie Indians, and here and there a "gentile" pioneer, occupied this southwestern Iowa country, the Mormon villages being scattered about as greatly as those of the Indians, for upward of a year prior to Indian removal, and, inasmuch as neither the records of the Indian Office nor those of the Mormon Church disclose serious difficulty among them, it may be assumed that they dwelled together in harmony and brotherly love. (See The Mormons.) THE OLD BLOCKHOUSE. Perhaps no one object at or near the site of the present city of Council Bluffs has afforded a wider field for surmise, discussion and dissemination of erroneous information than the "Old Blockhouse" of frontier days. It stood for about twenty years (1837 to 1857) upon the plateau crowning the blunt nose of the hill jutting into and almost perpendicularly towering, something like fifty feet, above the road, now called Broadway, between the present-day Grace and Union streets (the latter being known as Spring Street at an early day). From the earbest occupation of the country by white people — 1846 — to the time of its demolition — 1856-1857 — it was commonly mentioned as the "Old Fort" or "Old Mission", both of which designations were appropriate, because it was originally constructed by United States troops for military purposes (1837) and afterward (1838-1841) occu pied as a Jesuit Mission known as St. Joseph or St. Mary. June 4, 1853, at the age of a little more than ten years, the writer began residence at Council Bluffs with the family of his father — Lysander W. Babbitt, — at which time the "Old Fort" or "Mission House", surmounted by a cross, occupied the above-described site. His home was about a half mile farther up (east and north) on Broadway — now known as "Babbitt Place", and almost daily while the old building remained he passed it at a distance of only a few yards, and often played about it with other children. In his memory it is pictured as a log structure, about 24 x 40 feet in dimension of ground space, one and one-half story in height, with an ordinary sloping roof, with embrasures (small windows) on north and west sides, and loopholes for musketry all around, standing in the open without stockade or other enclosure, or any evidence that it had ever been enclosed. Near by was a grave yard surrounded by a fence constructed of hand-riven palings. During the year 1856 intense rivalry existed between what were termed "up-town" and "down-town" portions of the city. The principal hotel, recently erected, was located "down town", and, for the benefit of their end of the town, a company of "up-towners" was formed for the purpose of building a better and finer hostelry, the site of the old blockhouse being selected for its location. The old 44 EARLY DAYS AT COUNCIL BLUFFS fort, then in a tumbled-down condition, was removed either that Fall or the following Spring, and the ground, still practically in its natural condition (a plateau but slightly graded when the blockhouse was built) was cut away so that a precipitous bank something like thirty feet high formed the south line of Pierce Street, where the sharp pitch of the great bluff swept down to the plateau, and the grading necessary to the preparation of the hotel building site greatly reduced the elevation of the blunt nose of bluff jutting onto Broadway. Beyond the grading here mentioned nothing was done toward the erection of the new hotel ; probably because of the financial crisis of the Fall of 1857. An article entitled "The Old Blockhouse at Council Bluffs", written in August, 1896, by Hon. Dexter C. Bloomer, of Council Bluffs, ap peared in the October issue of the Annals of Iowa for that year (Third Series, Volume 2, No. 7, page 549), with an illustration said to have been prepared from a sketch made from memory by George Simons, wherein it is said : ' ' This was the first building erected in Pottawattamie county. In 1838 the Pottawattamie Indians were removed from the 'Platte Purchase', so-called, in Missouri, to a location on the Missouri river which subsequently was organized into a county and took the name of the tribe. . . . ' ' In 1839 the general government stationed two companies of troops among these Indians for the purpose of keeping peace and quiet among them, although, through the careful manage ment of their Agent, their presence did not prove necessary for that purpose. These troops located themselves a short distance up in the bluffs in the little subsidiary valley of Indian creek and near a living spring found at that point. Here, on a gentle elevation, in the same year, they erected a blockhouse of logs and rough puncheons and raised the American flag over it. Its sides were pierced with numerous holes through which muskets could be discharged in case of assault from without. The barracks, tents and parade grounds, and probably some minor structures, were located in the vicinity of this building. No record can be found of the names of the officers in command of these troops. They did not remain a great while, for the reason already stated. With the Indians came a Roman Catholic Mission in charge of Fathers De Smet and Verreydt. They also built for themselves a rude dwelling, but when the troops left they took possession of the government buldings, blockhouse and barracks, for religious purposes, erecting a wooden cross THE OLD BLOCKHOUSE 45 over one of them. When the writer took up his residence in Council Bluffs, in 1855, these buildings (as shown in the cut), one of them surmounted by a cross, were yet standing. . . . " In the four- volume "History of Iowa" compiled and published by Hon. Benjamin F. Gue, the foregoing narrative, with identically the same illustration is substantially reproduced. (Volume 1, pages 100-101.) THE OLD BLOCKHOUSE, FORT AND MISSION (Picture by George Simon.) This is a reproduction of an illustration accompanying an article by Hon. D. C. Bloomer, published in Annals of Iowa in 1896 (3d Series, Volume 2, page 594), the cut having been made from a painting said to have been done by George Simons, from memory. 46 EARLY DAYS AT COUNCIL BLUFFS In a two-volume "History of Pottawattamie County, Iowa", written, compiled and published by Homer H. Field and Hon. Joseph R. Reed, of Council Bluffs (Volume 1, page 6), appears the following: ' ' The conditions above described continued until 1838, when, during President Van Buren 's administration, the Pottawat tamie Indians were assigned a reservation here, and Davis Hardin was appointed to instruct them in farming. He, with his family and a company of soldiers arrived here on the steamer Antelope from Fort Leavenworth, in the spring of that year. . . . Arriving here they found the country a solitude. They located by a big spring on what is now East Broadway and the soldiers immediately commenced building a house for the Hardins, and then a fort on the promontory that was a continuation of the hill between Franklin and Lincoln avenues, and which at that time jutted into what is now Broadway, where the dwelling of the late John Clausen now stands." Many other stories relating to this old fort have been published from time to time in current newspapers and otherwise, and the date of construction has been stated by some to have been as early as 1819, running from that to the years above given ; but, in no instance that has come to the knowledge of the writer, has a letter-press descrip tion of it, other than as above set out, been given. Hon. H. H. Field, a man of experience in estimating the dimensions of standing buildings, now residing at Council Bluffs, having been there continuously since 1855, in answer to inquiry, says — ' ' The ruins of the old blockhouse were standing when I first came here. I should think it was about 20 feet square. It disappeared in the Spring of 1857, and several feet of the ground was taken off and put on Broadway to improve the grade ; but by what authority I do not know, but it was rumored that a hotel was to be built there by L. W. Babbitt and Dr. S. H. Craig. If there was anything in it the great crash that came in the Fall of that year put an end to it. I don't know when the Government relinquished title to it, but suppose when Judge Casady was commissioned to make deeds to the occu pants. John Warner was the first that owned it to my knowl edge as he employed me to fence it, and John Clausen the last, as I worked on his dwelling some forty years ago. The lot then consisted of nearly all the square bounded by Broadway, Grace, Union and Pierce streets." THE OLD BLOCKHOUSE 47 Hon. Spencer Smith whose arrival at Council Bluffs was at about the same time as that of the writer, but at a slightly earlier age, answering an inquiry, says : "Since the receipt of your letter I have been trying to refresh my memory of early days, but find little response as to the 'Mission House' of which you make inquiry. I called on my way to lunch today at the library and took a look at the picture in Mr. Bloomer's sketch which appears to me about as it looked when I first saw it. I know of no picture of the ' Old Fort ' as we called it other than the one given by Mr. Bloomer. ' ' Mr. Ephraim Huntington, at about the age of seven years, began residence as a member of the family of his father — John Huntington, — at Kanesville, as the place was then named, in 1850. In a con versation with the writer, in September, 1915, speaking of the old blockhouse, he said: "I remember it as it appeared to me when a boy and until it was demolished. It was originally surrounded with a stockade several feet high and constructed of very heavy oak timbers. ' ' In a communication dated June 13, 1916, referring to the illustra tion above mentioned which had been called to his attention, he said : "The picture of the Fort and Mission resembles the build ings, &c, very much as I remember it." Reverend Henry De Long, then a boy of twelve or fourteen years, accompanied the Mormons from Nauvoo as far as the site of Council Bluffs, arriving in July, 1846, and has continued to reside there ever since. He is now the "dean of old settlers" in the county. Upon request he furnished a very complete description of the "Old Fort" as memory recalls its first appearance to him, to-wit : ' ' There were three buildings in the fort. The main building was what we 'd call a story and a half, about sixty feet long and twenty-four feet wide, running parallel with Broadway. It was made of hewed logs and the logs were hewed square so they fit right down together. The port holes were made by sawing out half of the log and should judge they were about eight feet apart. "There was a building just west and south of the main building, built in the form of a chapel, with a place for a bell 48 EARLY DAYS AT COUNCIL BLUFFS in the center. I think it was used by the Catholics. This chapel was about 24 x 30. "There was a small one-story building back of the fort, to the east. Don't know what it was used for, but it looked like it might have been officer's quarters. It was about 16x20. ' ' The roofs were made of clapboards which were smooth and of much better appearance than usual. ' ' The chapel roof was built four square, running to a center containing a cupola. "The other roofs were made with gable ends. ' ' There was no stockade surrounding the fort. ' ' Commenting upon the illustration accompanying the Bloomer article, to which his attention had been directed after he had written the foregoing description, "Uncle Henry", as he is familiarly called by intimate friends, said: "With the main building I speak of torn down, the picture is probably a fair representation of the fort in 1855; but I think this picture was drawn by someone from memory and is not an exact copy of the buildings as they were. The picture shows two buildings and the smaller one is what I recollect was probably used for officers' quarters." It is presumed, in absence of citations of authority or any sources of information by the writers named, that all of the foregoing matter quoted is founded upon memory, hearsay, legend and tradition ; and it is given here for such consideration as may be merited. Official data relating to the old blockhouse appears to be meagre and difficult of access or discovery at this late date. In connection with Mr. J. N. Nicollet's report of his explorations made in the Missouri river country in 1838 and 1839 is published a map prepared by the War Department, upon which at or near the site of the present city of Council Bluffs is shown "Fort Croghan". For a time it was assumed by the writer that the old blockhouse and Fort Croghan were identical ; but, in a certain sense, this was error. No name for the old blockhouse appears in any of the official records of the War Department nor in those of the Office of Indian Affairs, though it is mentioned occasionally in letters from the agents and sub-agents. In Mr. Nicollet's report a reference to "Camp Kearney" is apparently, but not necessarily, applicable to this old fort. Fort Croghan was not a blockhouse or fortification; but merely a military cantonment located, originally, near the old Indian farm THE OLD BLOCKHOUSE 49 upon which Mr. Davis Hardin resided while and after acting as farmer for the Pottawattamies ; and, because of a flood in the Missouri river in April, 1843, was removed to the hills. The old blockhouse appears to have been used by the troops by whom Fort Croghan was founded, and was no doubt considered a part of that fort or cantonment. Richard S. Elliott, Pottawattamie sub-agent, in a letter to the Superintendent of Indian Affairs (unpublished) dated June 1, 1843, said: "There are in the block house of the Dragroons some goods which were seized in November last, and which yet, as I under stand, await their disposition by the Department." Senate Document No. 237, 26th Congress, 2d Session, consists solely of a "Report intended to illustrate a map of The Hydrographic Basin of Upper Mississippi River, made by J. N. Nicollet while in employ under the Bureau of the Corps of Topographical Engineers", which is the map referred to above. On pages 93 and 94 is the following language, to-wit : "Assured that every reader will partake of my sentiments on this subject, I shall, without further prelude or apology, acknowledge the services I have received, in this respect, from . . . The Revs. P. J. De Smet and Felix Werreydf, mis sionaries among the Pottawattamies at Camp Kearney, near Council Bluffs on the Missouri. . . ." On pages 98 and 99 is found matter pertinent to the subject here under treatment, and, although some of it may seem to be irrelevant, it is fully quoted because of the general information contained, to-wit : "When the course of my observations carried me to the regions of the North and Northwest, the stationary barometer of St. Louis, to which my portable barometers were referred, became too distant for simultaneous observations to be any longer comparable. I had foreseen this difficulty, and had succeeded in establishing, as soon as needed, two new fixed barometer stations, much higher north — the one at St. Peters, on the Mississippi; the other at Camp Kearney, near Council Bluffs, on the Missouri. At each of these points was a sta tionary barometer, corresponding four or five times a day with the barometer at St. Louis, and affording, at the same time, for my portable barometers, a reference to one or the other, according as my position at any time brought one or the other nearest. "Nevertheless, as both of these stations are at a great dis- 50 EARLY DAYS AT COUNCIL BLUFFS tance from St. Louis, whether the length of the journey neces sary for communication between them, or their geographic positions and direct distance apart, be considered, it became necessary that their differences of level, as respects St. Louis, should be determined by the greatest number of observations possible. In this view, I deem it fit to introduce here the results of these determinations : "1. The station at Camp Kearney was occupied by the venerable missionaries, Rev. Messrs. De Smet and Werreydt. I furnished them with a barometer, well compared with that of Dr. Engelman at St. Louis, and with my own, and delivered it at their missionary station in good condition. Mr. De Smet, with whom I had passed some days of travel on the Missouri, soon made himself acquainted with the manner of taking obser vations; and proved it, in furnishing me with a four-months' series, made with a care that the most scrupulous examination could only confirm, and embracing the period between the 17th of May and 17th of September, 1839, — an interval during which I was exploring in the Northwest. "The barometer at St. Louis was situated in a small exposed plain; that at Camp Kearney was placed in the valley of the Missouri, which is deep, and often three to five miles wide. Using only the noon observations for both, grouping them 20, and applying the reduction of the stations to their respective levels, the calculations give the following results : Station at Camp Kearney, above St. Louis by — 20 observations at noon in May and June, 1839. 596 feet 20 2020 20 13 June, 1839 680 June and July, 1839 633 July and August, 1839 659 August, 1839 694 September, 1839 667 113 " " " " Mean difference in level.... 655 Reduction of St. Louis to Gulf 332 Altitude of Missouri at low water, near Council Bluffs, above Gulf of Mexico 1,037 " The foregoing matter may be found, also, in House Executive Documents, 28th Congress, 2d Session, Vol. 1, No. 52, page 94. The name "Camp Kearney" used by Mr. Nicollet probably relates to the camp of his exploring party, in the near vicinity of the old blockhouse, and was not intended to apply either to the blockhouse itself or to any other military encampment proper in the neighbor- THE OLD BLOCKHOUSE 51 hood. The missionaries De Smet and Verreydt were at the time in occupancy of the blockhouse. A letter of inquiry, addressed to the War Department, in which reference was made to Mr. Nicollet's report, was returned with en dorsement as follows : "WAR DEPARTMENT The Adjutant General's Office Washington, January 22, 1916. "Respectfully returned to — "Mr. Charles H. Babbitt, 933 Massachusetts Avenue, N. W., Washington, D. C. ' ' Such search of the records of this Department as it has been found practicable to make, based on -the data submitted, has resulted in failure to identify any record of the establishment of a Camp Kearny at or near the present city of Council Bluffs, Iowa. The records indicate that Captain D. B. Moore, with Company C, 1st Dragoons, was sent by Colonel S. W. Kearny from Fort Leavenworth to that section in 1837 for the purpose of protecting the Pottawattamies, then about to move to their new country, and with instructions to throw up a block house of one story about 25 feet square, and with sufficient loop holes, at such place as Captain Moore might deem eligible. The location is more particularly described as being above the State Line of Missouri, near the river and not far from Belle View. Captain Moore returned to Fort Leavenworth early in November, 1837, when he reported to Colonel Kearney that he had reached the locality mentionel August 4, 1837 ; erected a block-house and departed November 1, 1837. "The records further show that Colonel Kearny himself spent about 12 days in that vicinity between April 12 and 24, 1838, and in that time examined the country above and below the Platte and fixed upon a site for a military post. "It is further shown by the records that Captain J. H. K. Burgwin, 1st Dragoons, with a company of that regiment, was stationed near Council Bluffs from about May 31, 1842, to about October 6, 1843. He called his post Camp Fenwiek, and on his recommendation it was named by the War Department about November, 1842, Fort Croghan. It appears that this post was about 6 miles from 'the Bluff' and at a point that was reached by an excessive overflow in the Spring of 1843. "Nothing has been found of record to indicate that any of the stations or posts mentioned was ever called Camp Kearny H. P. McCain, The Adjutant General." 52 early days at council BLUFFS A personal examination of the records referred to in the foregoing note disclosed the following orders and reports relating to the errand of Captain Moore and the erection of a blockhouse, to-wit : ' ' Order No. 11. Headquarters 1st Dept. West. Division, Fort Leavenworth, July 19, 1837. "Colonel Kearny will detail a Troop of Dragoons from his Regiment for immediate service in the vicinity of the position to be occupied by the Pottawattamie Indians opposite to Belle- view on the Missouri river. Special instructions will be given to the Commanding Officer of the Troop respecting the duties to be assigned to it. . . . "By order of Brigadier General Atkinson. T. S. Alexander, A. D. C. & Ast. A.G." "Headquarters 1st Regiment Dragoons, Fort Leavenworth, July 21, 1837. "Sir: ' ' You will, in command of Company ' C, ' march to the Potta wattamie country, above the State line of Missouri, and take a position in it near the river, and not far from 'Belle View', so as to intervene between those Indians and the Sack and others as reside above them. "As the Pottawattamies are now about to move to their New Country your object will be to afford them protection from being molested by other Indians. . . . "I wish you to throw up a Blockhouse of one story, about 25 feet square, at such place as yon may deem eligible, with a sufficient number of loop holes, which will serve as a hospital for any sick you may have and as a storehouse for your pro visions. . . . S. W. Kearny, Colonel 1st Regiment Dragoons. Captain D. B. Moore, 1st Regiment Dragoons." "Headquarters 1st Regiment Dragoons, Fort Leavenworth, August 5, 1837. " ... Company 'C, (66 strong) under Captain Moore, 1st Dragoons, by order of Brigadier General Atkinson, of the 19th, left here on the 22nd ulto., to take a position in the Potta- wattamy Country for the purpose of giving confidence to those emigrating Indians and affording them protection (if neces sary) from being disturbed by the Indians above them. The THE OLD BLOCKHOUSE 53 service of the company, I think, will not be required after the 1st of October, at which time I will look for its return. S. W. Kearny, Colonel 1st Regiment Dragoons. General William Clark, Superintendent of Indian Affairs, St. Louis." "Fort Leavenworth, November 11, 1837. "I have the honor to inform you that, in compliance with your order of the 21st July, 1837, dated at Forth Leavenworth, I took a position in the Pottawattamie Country, with my Com pany ' C ', 1st Dragroons, at a point near Belle-View, on the east side of the Missouri river, at which place I erected a Blockhouse for the defense of the Pottawattamies while they are moving to their new land. I arrived there on the 4th of August and re mained until the 1st of November, 1837, when I broke camp and marched to this post in pursuance of your order. D. B. Moore, Captain 1st Regiment Dragoons. Colonel S. W. Kearny, Commanding 1st Regiment Dragoons. ' ' The foregoing shows conclusively that a blockhouse about 25 feet square, was constructed, in 1837, in the vicinity of the site of the present city of Council Bluffs. It has been found impossible to secure equally as positive proof that the blockhouse then erected and the "Old Blockhouse at Council Bluffs", the "Old Fort" that Colonel Kearny gave to De Smet in 1838, are identical. But, in absence of any indication either through hearsay, legend or tradition, that any other blockhouse was ever known to exist in that neighborhood, and taking all circumstances into consideration, little room for doubt in that regard may be reasonably entertained. Papers on file in the Indian Office at Washington relating to the emigration of the Pottawattamies, reproduced in connection with that portion of this booklet entitled "Pottawattamie Indians", prove that General Atkinson, commanding the First Department of the Western Division of the Army, personally superintended the removal of a part of the tribe or nation from the "Platte Purchase"; that he arrived with them on board of the steamboat "Kansas" July 28, 1837, and landed them at a point on the east (left) bank of the Missouri river, about eighteen miles above the mouth of the Platte river and there turned them over to the proper agent; that one week later 54 EARLY DAYS AT COUNCIL BLUFFS Captain Moore arrived for the purpose of protecting them from Northern foes, and erected a blockhouse for that purpose, it may be presumed that he located it at a convenient place; the fact that Billy Caldwell, one of the principal Pottawattamie chiefs, located his village precisely upon the spot where the original town from which Council Bluffs developed became situated, and that a blockhouse actually existed at that place, would appear to be strong circum stantial evidence in support of the presumption that it was the one built by Captain Moore. In the four- volume book entitled "Life, Letters and Travels of Father Pierre-Jean De Smet, S. J., 1808-1873, by Hiram Martin Chittenden and Alfred Talbot Richardson", on pages 14 to 16 of Volume I, is found the following: "In the Spring of 1838 he (De Smet) was sent with Father Verrydt and two lay brothers to found a mission among the Pottawattamies, a part of whom were located about where the city of Council Bluffs, Iowa, now stands. . . . Father De Smet left St. Louis by the steamboat Howard May 10, 1838. . . . They seem to have first occupied an abandoned fort turned over to them by Colonel S. W. Kearney; but Father De Smet says that they also erected a small house. The mission was named St. Joseph, although it has been more frequently referred to as St. Mary. It was located within the present limits of Council Bluffs, Iowa. . . . The Pottawattamie mission at Council Bluffs is of particular interest in this narra tive, not so much for results accomplished, as because it reveals at this early date the full character of Father De Smet as an Indian missionary. It was from here that he began that famous series of letters which have made his name well known through out the world. In one of the first of these letters, written in July, 1838, Father De Smet said: "We arrived among the Pottawattamies on the afternoon of May 31st. Nearly 2,000 savages, in their finest rigs and care fully painted in all sorts of patterns, were awaiting the boat at the landing. I had not seen so imposing a sight nor such fine looking Indians in America; the Iowas, the Sauks and Otoes are beggars compared to these. Father Verreydt and brother Mazelli went at once to the camp of the half breed chief, Mr. Caldwell, four miles from the river (page 157.) THE OLD BLOCKHOUSE 55 "The chief has given us possession of three cabins, and we have changed the fort which Colonel Kearney has given us into a church. On the day of Corpus Christi I put a cross on the roof, and while I climbed the ladder to put it into place, and my flag floated from a hole in my breeches, Father Felix (Verreydt) beheld the devil clap his tail between his legs and take flight over the big hills." (Page 158.) In a letter dated at the "Nation of the Pottawattamies, July 20, 1838," Father De Smet said: "We have a fine little chapel, twenty-four feet square, sur mounted by a little belfry ; four poor little cabins beside, made of rough logs; they are fourteen feet each way, with roofs of rude rafters, which protect us from neither rain nor hail, and still less from snow of winter." (Page 168.) In the spring of 1839 De Smet visited the Sioux Indians near the mouth of the Big Sioux river, in an effort to preserve peace between them and the Pottawattamies, and, on the steamboat he met Mr. Nicollet. His account of the meeting is summarized as follows : ' ' On the 29th of April I went on board the American Com pany 's steamboat, which makes every year the voyage from St. Louis to the Yellowstone river. ... To my great joy I found on board the celebrated Nicollet, whom I had had the honor of knowing for a long time. ... At present he is making a scientific excursion upon the upper Missouri, as he did last year to the sources of the Mississippi and its tribu taries. ... He made me a present of several instruments, thermometers, barometers, compass, etc., to take observations during the summer, to aid those he was making in the upper country. (Pages 179-80.) On pages 183 and 184 is printed a letter from Father De Smet, under date "Pottawattamie Nation, St. Joseph (Mission), July 1838", but in a foot note the authors say the year should be 1839. The following extract is made from that letter, viz. .- ' ' Our Superior sent us from St. Louis, goods to the amount of $500, in ornaments for the church, a tabernacle, a bell, and provisions and clothes for a year. I had been for a long time without shoes, and from Easter we were destitute of supplies. All of the Pottawattamie nation were suffering from scarcity, having only acorns and a few wild roots for their whole stock of food. At last, about the 20th of April, they announced to 56 EARLY DAYS AT COUNCIL BLUFFS us that the much-desired boat was approaching. Already we saw it from the highest of our hills. I procured, without delay, two carts to go for our baggage. I reached there in time to witness a very sad sight. The vessel had hit a sawyer, was pierced, and rapidly sinking in the waves. The confusion that reigned in the boat was great, but happily no lives were lost. The total damage was valued at $40,000. All the provisions forwarded by the government to the savages were on board of her. Of our effects, four articles were saved; a plough, a saw, a pair of boots and some wine. Providence was still favor able to us. With the help of the plough, we were enabled to plant a large field of corn; it was the season for furrowing. We used the saw to build a better house and enlarge our church, already too small." A thorough search of official reports and various other sources has failed to discover any account, other than the above, of the wrecking of a steamboat at or near the site indicated. Father De Smet's service at this mission ceased in the fall of 1839, when he was transferred to the far Northwest. On his return to the eastern country, late in 1840, he visited the old place, arriving about November 24th. Of that visit he says : ' ' The very night of our arrival among our Fathers at Council Bluffs, the river closed. It would be vain for me to attempt to tell what I felt at finding myself once more amidst our brothers, after having travelled 2,000 Flemish leagues, in the midst of the greatest dangers and across the territories of the most barbarous nations. I had, however, the grief of observing the ravages which unprincipled men, liquor sellers, had caused in this budding mission ; drunkenness, with the invasion of the Sioux on the other hand, had finally dispersed my poor savages. While awaiting a more favorable turn of events, the good Fathers Verreydt and (Christian) Hoeken busy themselves with the cares of their holy ministry among the fifty families that have had the courage to resist these two enemies." (Page 258.) The writer, wishing to ascertain if possible up to what period the mission at Council Bluffs was maintained, and, findng no authentic evidence in that respect, addressed a letter of inquiry to the St. Louis University regarding the abandonment and final closing of the St. Joseph or St. Mary Mission among the Pottawattamies, to which reply was received, as follows: THE OLD BLOCKHOUSE 57 "Mo. Prov. S. J., St. Louis, May 16, 1916. "Mr. Chas. H. Babbitt, Washington, D. C. "Dear Sir: "In answer to your inquiry relative to the Jesuit Pottawat tamie Mission at Council Bluffs, I am able to inform you that the last resident missionary departed from the place in July or August, 1841. The last entry in the baptismal register of the mission, bears date July 17, 1841. I am very sincerely yours, G. J. Garraghan, S. J." The "Old Fort" or "Mission House", with other buildings used for mission purposes, stood upon the West half of the Southwest quarter of Section 30, Township 75 North, of Range 43 West, Fifth Principal Meridian; and, upon its inclusion in the appbcation for entry of the townsite of Council Bluffs, that tract became a bone of contention between Mrs. S. T. Carey and the Catholic Church. In the record of evidence relating to the long-drawn-out controversy that ensued (Case No. 139, Pottawattamie file, No. 40-L) before the Indian Office and Land Department, is an affidavit made by Stutely E. Wicks, wherein he alleged : " ... That, about the year 1837 two Catholic priests, named Veright and De Smith, took possession of the buildings and a small field adjacent thereto and continued to occupy the same until some time in 1842. . . ." It will be observed that Mr. Wicks was mistaken, both as to the date when the mission was established and when it was abandoned. The foregoing sets out all that the writer has been able to discover, relating to the "Old Blockhouse at Council Bluffs", by a most thorough search of governmental records and examination of numer ous other sources of information ; together with some things, true and otherwise, that have been written and published, as well as the memory pictures of the establishment retained by himself and others still living who saw it at an early day. It would appear, from the record evidence, conclusive and con vincing in character, that all that ever existed of the "Old Fort" was the simple little blockhouse, twenty-four feet square, erected by Captain D. B. Moore in 1837. That the "Old Mission" consisted of that building, to which addition was made by the missionaries in 1839 ; the little cabins given to the Fathers by Chief Billy Caldwell in 58 EARLY DAYS AT COUNCIL BLUFFS 1838, and the house erected by the missionaries at the same time that enlargement of the church was made, as described by Father De Smet. The illustration which accompanied the article of Mr. Bloomer, in Annals of Iowa, later used in Gue's History of Iowa, is reproduced herein to the end that the reader may more readily understand the comment of the writer in relation thereto. From personal observation, almost daily, for a period of fully twenty years, the writer knows, of his own knowledge, that there was never a road up the nose of the promontory upon which the old build ing stood. He believes that it would have been impossible to construct there such a road as that depicted in the illustration and still have left on the little plateau at the top sufficient space for such buildings as there portrayed. Even had the construction of such roadway been practicable, there would have been no necessity for so doing, because the plateau was easily accessible from both east and west by gentle inclines having ample space for roadways. See supposititious picture of the old blockhouse, showing topography as remembered by the writer. Captain Moore's command consisted of only sixty-six persons; it arrived at the Pottawattamie country August 4, and departed thence November 1, 1837. Such force could not, within such period, have constructed such works as Mr. Simons' memory or imagination de picted when he made the drawing that was used in preparing the illustration. It would be folly to discuss or attempt to explain the differences between the several memory pictures of the "Old Fort" as set out by persons who have been heard, and the facts as disclosed by official records and other evidence. It is deemed sufficient to say that, memory, especially that extending back to childhood days, is fre quently at fault — "distance lends enchantment to the view" — and one relying merely upon memory will find, upon investigation, that she is frequently an unfaithful painter who magnifies, softens and gilds the images which she presents, misleading the individual as to facts and appearances with which one may for years have believed oneself thoroughly familiar. "Things are not what they seem." i-3 a w o r dwr o o« oC OLD BLOCKHOUSE (SUPPOSITITIOUS PICTURE) 60 EARLY DAYS AT COUNCIL BLUFFS THE OLD BLOCKHOUSE. (Supposititious Picture) By this picture attempt is made to depict the old blockhouse as it probably appeared when completed by Captain D. B. Moore in 1837, together with the blunt nose of bluff whereon it stood. No portholes are shown because there was no reason why any should have been originally provided. United States troops did not ordinarily employ cannon in the control of the Indians at that early day, and it is not probable that the same were furnished the Pottawattamies for their protection. The building was a simple hewn-log structure, twenty- four feet square, without openings on the north and west sides except loopholes for small-arms fire. After it came into the possession of the Jesuit missionaries small windows were cut in those sides which were afterward taken by some to have been portholes for cannon fire. The folly of such belief is apparent upon consideration of the size and character of the building, and what would probably have happened to the occupants had a large gun been fired from the inside. No frontier blockhouse, even at the largest of the government military posts, appears to have been constructed with a view to firing cannon from within. When cannon were provided for such posts they were usually mounted outside the buildings in bastions especially designed for the purpose. FORT CROGHAN. May 31, 1842, Captain John H. K. Burgwin, under orders from the War Department established a military cantonment, for the protection of the Pottawattamie Indians against threatened attack by the Sioux, the garrison consisting of one company of dragoons. July 1, 1842, the Captain reported to the Adjutant General of the Army, from "Camp Fenwick, on the Missouri river near Council Bluffs", that he had established encampment as above set forth. October 7, 1842, in connection with report as to condition of his command and post, Captain Burgwin suggested the substitution of the name "Fort Croghan" for the station in lieu of "Camp Fenwick." November 8, 1842, Brigadier General R. Jones, Adjutant General, approved the suggestion of Captain Burgwin, and thereafter the cantonment was known as "Fort Croghan", being so indicated on a map published by the War Department in 1843 in connection with the report of the explorations made by J. N. Nicollet and Lieutenant John C. Fremont, 1838-9. When it became definitely determined, against earnest protest by Captain Burgwin, that the post should be maintained during the ensuing winter, due preparation was made by the erection of log quarters for the officers and men and suitable protection for the animals; the tents theretofore used were stored, and the cantonment assumed a more permanent appearance. April 17, 1843, from "Fort Croghan, I. T." Captain Burgwin reported the greatest rise in the Missouri river known within seven teen years; that his camp was threatened by the flood and he had prepared for removal "to the Bluffs, which are about six miles from me". August 15, 1843, still using the "Fort Croghan" heading, the Captain reported the original camp yet surrounded by water ; that it would probably not be fit for future use ; that troops were no longer needed in the locality, and requested relief from further duty there. His request was granted and the command returned to Fort Leaven worth, from which place the Captain submitted report, dated October 13, 1843, saying that his command had just arrived and that Fort Croghan was abandoned on the 6th of that month. The foregoing brief sketch of "Fort Croghan" is compiled from 62 EARLY DAYS AT COUNCIL BLUFFS unpublished orders, reports and letters in the files of the office of the Adjutant General, War Department, Washington. The use of the date line "Fort Croghan, I. T." by Captain Burgwin clearly fixes the site of the cantonment on the east (left) bank of the Missouri river. In his "American Fur Trade of the Far West" (Vol. 3, page 950), General Hiram Martin Chittenden says that: "Fort Croghan stood a little above the Union Pacific bridge in Omaha;" but he is mistaken, as Captain Burgwin's report dated April 17, 1843, clearly demonstrates. The fact that Captain Burgwin continued to use the headline ' ' Fort Croghan" after the removal of the command to the highlands, in dicates that the name applied to the territory under his jurisdiction rather than to the cantonment itself or to its precise site. The precise plot of ground upon which the original location of "Camp Fenwick" and "Fort Croghan" was made, or whether the log structures of 1843 were erected upon that identical spot, is not known and may never be positively determined ; nor is there attainable evidence to show conclusively to what place Captain Burgwin re ferred when he reported : "I commenced yesterday morning moving the public prop erty to the Bluffs which are about six miles from me" — the point to which the troops removed and took position that was maintained during the remainder of their stay in the vicinity. No records exist containing specific descriptions of these sites or either of them. Probably the most circumstantial reference to and description of the two points occupied by Captain Burgwin as "Fort Croghan" here tofore published, is contained in an article that appeared in the Annals of Iowa (3d Series, Volume 3, page 471), which is here re produced in full, viz.: "Fort Croghan. — In April, 1842, while the Pottawattamie Indians were located in what is now the eastern part of Potta wattamie County, it was thought necessary to send up the Missouri river a detachment of troops for their protection. Captain John H. K. Burgwin therefore arrived on a steamer from Fort Leavenworth, with a company of United States troops, and established a post on the edge of the timber at Section 10, near the present southwest corner of the city of Council Bluffs. This he first named 'Camp Fenwick', hut FORT CROGHAN 63 afterwards changed it to 'Fort Croghan'. There has been some dispute about the location, but 'there is certain evidence', says Hon. D. C. Bloomer, 'that it stood as mentioned'. The troops staid there during the remainder of 1842, and until the spring of 1843, when a great flood covered the Missouri Bottoms compelling the command to remove to a temporary location on the western side of Little Mosquito Creek, on the high grounds later occupied by Mr. J. P. Casady for farming purposes. Here they remained until the water, which covered the valley, subsided, when they returned to the fort. In Sep tember, following, the presence of the troops being no longer necessary for the protection of the Indians, the company, still under the command of Capt. Burgwin, returned to Ft. Leaven worth, and 'Fort Croghan' was abandoned, never again to be occupied. For the above information we are indebted to Hon. D. C. Bloomer, of Council Bluffs." As stated elsewhere in this work the writer resided at Council Bluffs from 1853 to 1874, and was very familiar with the surrounding country, having gunned for ducks, prairie chickens, turkeys and other game, pretty much all "round about there", and, upon reading the foregoing article, a few months ago, he was surprised by some of the statements therein contained; doubted that the original encamp ment of Captain Burgwin was located upon "Section 10" and knew that J. P. Casady's farm was not near the Little Mosquito creek, but on Pony creek, some three miles south and one mile east of the mouth of the Little Mosquito. So, contemplating the writing of this paper, he began investigating. Mr. Edgar R. Harlan, Curator of the Historical Department of Iowa, at Des Moines, under the direction of whom Annals of Iowa is now published, has furnished copies of letters sent to Hon. Charles Aldrich, founder of the Historical Department of Iowa, by Mr. Bloomer, including that ' ' certain evidence ' ' referred to in the article quoted above. There are two letters from Mr. Bloomer dated, re spectively, November 24 and 25, 1896, the latter being in correction of a clerical error in and elaborative of the former. Both are here quoted to the end that the entire matter may be fairly placed before the reader : "Council Bluffs, Iowa, Nov. 24, 1896. "Hon. Charles Aldrich, Des Moines, Iowa. "Dear Sir: "I return the correspondence relative to Fort Croghan and its occupancy by U. S. troops in 1842-3. 64 EARLY days at council bluffs "The question as to the actual location of Camp Fenwick, changed to Fort Croghan, has elicited a good deal of contro versy among the people in this section. I have spent a good deal of time and made some journeys in order to settle it in my own mind. Some claim that it was on the west side of the river, up in the vicinity of Old Fort Atkinson, later known as Fort Calhoun. Others claim that it was on the east side of the river, on the wide bottom, a few miles south of the present site of the modern Council Bluffs. My great object was to find some one who then resided here, and who could from personal recollections settle the question. And such a person I have at last found in Mr. Richard S. Hardin, an old gentleman, son of Indian agent Hardin, who came here with the Pottawattamie Indians in 1838, and who now resides at Nodaway Station in Missouri. In a letter written to me on the 21st of November, 1896, he says: ' ' ' The old Fort yon wish to know about was built in '42, and vacated in the spring of '43, on account of high water. It was northwest of my old farm 3*4 of a mile, in the edge of the timber on the bottom. When they left it they stuck their tents in the hollow near where Judge Casady's house stands. If there is anything I can give you light on, let me know. I think I will be in Council Bluffs in the spring, and if you will get a reporter, I will answer any questions you may wish to ask, as I think I am the only man living now that can". "This statement is reliable and really settles the question. It corresponds perfectly with the letter of Capt. Burgwin, '43, page 6, in which he stated that his cantonment 'was flooded and that he had commenced removing the public property to the Bluffs, which are about six miles from me'. True, his first letter was written from 'Camp Fenwick near Council Bluffs' evidently referring to the Council Bluffs of the olden time, but that point was less than twenty miles distant, and was the name then applied to all this immediate region. I may add that A. D. Jones, now of Omaha, who in early days resided in Council Bluffs and made the first survey of the town in 1852, insists that 'Camp Fenwick — Fort Croghan' was on the east side of the river not far from the southwest corner of the present corporate limits of the city of Council Bluffs. It was very near, almost the middle of, the then home of the Potta wattamies — the very Indians Captain Burgwin was sent here to protect, although as it turned out, no protection was required. ' ' This Fort Croghan had no connection in any way with the military buildings, the 'Old Block House in Council Bluffs' at or near the Bryant Springs. That had been built by U. S. troops in 1839. They seem to have left and Capt. Burgwin's Company was probably sent to take their place. Instead, how- FORT CROGHAN 65 ever, of going to the old site, they camped on the bottom near the timber, three or four miles distant in a southwesterly direc tion from it. Possibly, when I have the interview with Mr. Hardin, this point will also be explained more fully. Very truly, D. C. Bloomer." "Council Bluffs, Nov. 25, 1896. "Mr. Charles Aldrich. "Dear Sir: Referring to my letter of yesterday in relation to the location of Camp Fenwick — Fort Croghan, I would state that I have just received a letter from Mr. Hardin in which he states that the fort instead of being 3 and ^4 miles northwest from his old farm, that it was only % of a mile from it. I suspected that this was the fact, and this correction enables us to exactly locate the spot. Mr. Hardin's old farm was in the Ey2 of the SE14 of Section 15-74-44, and % of a mile from it takes us to the Ey2 of Section 10 in the same township and range, and through about the center of this section the line of timber passed. That was the identical spot where the old fort stood. And now I remember that when I first came to the county 41 years ago, there was right there the remains of buildings of some kind, erected in former years. It turns out now that they had been erected by the U. S. troops under Capt. Burgwin in the first instance, and perhaps reconstructed by the Mormons. Yours very truly, D. C. Bloomer. "P. S. — I enclose plat of Tp. 74-44, which shows the loca tion." In that portion of this work relating to the Pottawattamie Indians it is clearly shown that they arrived at or near the present site of the city of Council Bluffs July 28, 1837 ; that the blockhouse was built at that time; that Davis Hardin (father of R. S. Hardin) was not agent for those Indians; that the farm entered by R. S. Hardin in 1854, — undoubtedly the place mentioned by him as "my old farm", — consisted of Lot 1 (Wy2SWy4) Sec. 14, and Ey2SEy4 Sec 15, in the township indicated by Mr. Bloomer. On this tract the plat of the United States survey made in 1852 shows three houses, of which two are on the lot 4. It was in one of the latter, according to the writer's recollection, wherein Mr. Hardin resided, about one mile from the old steamboat landing as indicated by the plat of survey. 66 EARLY DAYS AT COUNCIL BLUFFS On the SV2NEL4 Sec. 15 of said township appears the village of "Council Point", immediately north of and contiguous to the western part of the Hardin farm, and almost exactly three-quarters of a mile from R. S. Hardin's dwelling. In the belief of the writer the site of Council Point, Camp Fenwick or Fort Croghan, was identical. The place was probably renamed because of the fact that it was there that the Pottawattamie Indians of the Iowa region met the Commissioners of the United States June 5, 1846, and signed the treaty ceding their lands, which had actually been negotiated at Washington between the head men of the nation and government officials at a time previous. The buildings erected by Captain Burgwin's command in 1842 afforded facilities for such transaction not existing at any other place near by. It is impossible to secure conclusive evidence to support these as sumptions; but they do no violence to Mr. Hardin's testimony as furnished by Mr. Bloomer. No point in section ten, Mr. Bloomer's location of Camp Fenwick, could have been reached by traveling only three-quarters of a mile northwest from Mr. Hardin's farm house. The plat of government survey shows only one house on Section 10, and none other is mentioned in the field notes of the survey as being on said section. When the Mormons reached that locality, June, 1846, they found the little village of Council Point already named, and it was there that their High Council was organized July 21, by which was accepted the name "Miller's Hollow" that had attached to the settlement made by the Saints on the site of the present city of Council Bluffs. Mr. A. D. Jones, who resided at Council Bluffs for some time after the advent of the writer in that vicinity and was well known to him, has been quoted as supporting the claim that Fort Croghan was near the original site mentioned in the article quoted from Annals of Iowa ; it being said that he made a survey of the city in 1852, and is therefore an authority. If he made survey of any part of the city his work was private and not public in character. In a letter dated May 9, 1916, the Council Bluffs City Engineer says : "There is no evidence in my office to indicate that a survey of the town was made by A. D. Jones prior to the survey made by Tostevin". (1854.) Judge (J. P.) Casady never owned, resided upon or cultivated any farm near the site mentioned in the quoted article other than that FORT CROGHAN 67 embracing the SEi^SE^ Sec. 9; SW14SW14, Ei/aSWi/i Sec 10; NE%NWV4, Wy2NW% Sec 15, and Ey2NEi/4 Sec. 16, T. 74 N., R. 43 W. Six miles due east and across Mosquito creek from the Ft. Croghan site mentioned in the quoted article, and about two miles back of the first bluffs skirting the Missouri river bottom. In 1843 that would have been an inaccessible and undesirable site for a military encampment dependent upon steamboat transportation for its supplies. The boat landing was more than five miles, air line, from such site, and no practicable route between the points could have been less than eight miles. Mr. Hardin could not have intended to designate the Casady farm as the site where the troops "stuck their tents". Judge Casady owned and resided for some years in a house in Council Bluffs, near the mouth of what was known in early days as "Duck Hollow", only a short distance from the "Old Block House", It was one of the most prominent houses of that time in the city. Just to the east of it, and immediately north from the old blockhouse, was a broad, almost level plateau, an ideal spot for a military camp such as required by Captain Burgwin's command, and, notwithstanding Mr. Bloomer's positive assertion that the blockhouse and Fort Croghan had "no connection in any way", it very convincingly appears from unpublished letters of the Pottawattamie sub-agent, written in 1842 and 1843, that the dragoons at that time used the blockhouse for storage purposes. (See Mr. Elliott's letter of June 1, 1843, quoted in connection with "Pottawattamie Indians" and "Old Blockhouse", elsewhere in this work.) It is the belief of the writer that Captain Burgwin and his men, when forced to retire from the bottom, made their encampment upon the plateau described in the preceding paragraph, and that it was the site referred to in the language quoted in Mr. Bloomer's letter to Mr. Aldrich : "When they left it they stuck their tents in the hollow near where Judge Casady's house stands". This opinion is corroborated by an unpublished letter from Sub- Agent Elliott, dated June 1, 1843, quoted in the article herein relating to "The Old Blockhouse". True, this site was about five miles from the boat landing, but it was connected therewith by the best and probably only real road in the vicinity at the time, and was at the site of the Caldwell village, then existing, and of the De Smet mission 68 EARLY DAYS AT COUNCIL BLUFFS abandoned about two years before. Captain Burgwin who had been acting ad interim Sub-Agent for the Pottawattamies, appears to have turned over the agency effects to Sub-Agent Elliott at that point June 1, 1843. Captain Burgwin evidently overestimated the distance between Fort Croghan and the bluffs, as there is no point in the Missouri river bottom, above the boat landing as indicated by government survey, in that vicinity where the air-line distance between river and bluffs is six miles. The early settlers made the same error, calling it six miles from Kanesville to the boat landing, whereas it is little more than four miles. There is no intention to impugn Mr. Bloomer's good faith, nor to question his veracity, by what has been said here ; but simply to differ from some of his inferences, assumptions and conclusions, and to in dicate the reasons for such differences. The writer knew Mr. Bloomer well and knows him to have been a conscientious man, but doubts the correctness of his findings upon the evidence considered by him, taken in connection with his knowledge of the locality and the subjects of which he was writing. On whatever particular sites the "Camp Fenwick" and "Fort Croghan" of Captain Burgwin may have stood, in the vicinity of Council Bluffs, there is ample evidence that neither was in the imme diate vicinity of the Council Bluff of Lewis and Clark, nor in any manner connected with Fort Atkinson which was located near the latter. It has been said that there was once a "Fort Croghan" on or near the site of the latter place ; but there appears to be no record evidence to sustain such allegation. Mr. A. D. Jones, at the time Secretary of the Old Settlers' Association of Omaha, addressed a letter of inquiry to Father De Smet, containing several interrogations, to which the eminent missionary, writing from ' ' St. Louis University, December 26, 1867 ' ', made separate replies, in part as follows : "To the best of my knowledge, and assisted by Captain Joseph La Barge, the old explorer of the Missouri river, I will here answer your various questions .- "First, 'Where was old Fort Calhoun located?' ' ' Fort Calhoun was never located ; it took the name of Fort Atkinson, which was built on the very spot where the council was held by Lewis and Clark, and was the highest and first military post above the month of the Nebraska (Platte) river. "Second, 'Where was old Fort Croghan?' FORT CROGHAN 69 "After the evacuation of Fort Atkinson or Calhoun, either in 1827 or 1828, or thereabouts, the troops came down and made winter quarters on Cow Island — Captain La Barge states it was called Camp Croghan. The next spring the flood dis turbed the soldiers and they came down and established Fort Leavenworth. Colonel Leavenworth was commandant at the breaking up of Fort Atkinson. (See pages 1533-34-35, Chit tenden and Richardson's Life, Letters and Travels of Father De Smet, Volume 4, where the letter above quoted is credited to Nebraska Historical Society's Report.) "Third, 'There is an earthen remain of fortifications on the east bank of Omaha ; do you know who built it ? ' "The remains alluded to must be the site of the old trading post of Mr. Heart. When it was in existence the Missouri river ran up to the trading post. In 1832 the river left it, and since that time it goes by the name of 'Heart's Cut-Off', leaving a large lake above Council Bluffs city." Assuming this last information to be correct, a starting point is established from which, with other existing evidence, a fairly good inference may be derived respecting the location to which Captain Burgwin removed the government property and his command upon the occasion of the flood in the spring of 1843. The log of the steamboat "Omega", on a voyage made in 1843, con tains the following entries : "May 9, Tuesday. Passed Trudeau Island, Five Barrels Island, la Calumet, L'Oeil de fer. . . . Went on to L 'Issue, where I put off freight for the sutler and for Captain Burg win. Set out at 7 P. M. and camped above the bad sandbar, near the marsh at Hart's cut-off at 9 P. M. "May 10, Wednesday. We progressed finely as far as Hart's Bluffs (cotes a Hart), where at 7 A. M., we were summoned by an officer and four dragoons to land. I received a polite note from Captain Burgwin informing me that it was his duty to make an inspection of the boat. We put ourselves to work immediately, while Mr. Audubon goes to call upon the Captain. They return in about two hours. • . . . " (See Chittenden's American Fur Trade of the Far West, Vol. 3, page 988; also Chittenden's History of Early Navi gation on the Missouri river, Life and Adventures of Joseph La Barge, Vol. 1, pages 143-144.) The following extract is from the work last mentioned, and is a part of a very circumstantial account of the inspection of the boat, viz. : 70 EARLY DAYS AT COUNCIL BLUFFS ' ' On the occasion of the voyage of 1843 the agent at Bellevue happened to be absent from his station when the boat arrived. Elated at this unexpected good fortune, Captain Sire lost no time in putting off the freight destined for this point and in getting on his way. He pursued his voyage until nine o'clock that evening, and doubtless felicitated himself that he was out of danger. But it appears that the agent had delegated the function of inspector during his absence to the commander of the United States troops in the vicinity. The boat left her mooring at daylight next morning, but had scarcely gotten under way when a couple of rifle shots were fired across her bow. She brought to at once and made for the shore. There Captain Sire found a lieutenant in charge of a few dragoons, who had come from his camp four miles distant. The young officer came on hoard and presented to Captain Sire a polite note from Captain Burgwin, commander of the camp, stating that his orders required him to inspect the boat before letting her proceed. ' ' This was like a dash of cold water to the buoyant spirits of Captain Sire, and none the less so to Audubon, to whom, as well as the company, the loss of the liquid portion of the cargo would have been irreparable. The naturalist had a permit from the government to carry with him a quantity of liquor for the use of himself and party, and upon showing his cre dentials to the young officer he was, to use his own words, 'im mediately settled comfortably'. But in the moment of his good fortune he did not forget his companions who were not yet 'settled comfortably'. He understood that time was required to prepare for the approaching function, and he could at least help to secure this time by delaying inspection as long as possible. He accordingly expressed a desire to visit the camp, and the lieutenant detailed a dragoon to accompany him. The great naturalist rode four miles to call upon an obscure army officer whom he knew he could see in a short time by waiting at the boat. . . . " The Audubon referred to in the foregoing excerpts was the well- known and justly celebrated naturalist John James Audubon, and his own story of this occurrence, more interesting for the evidence and information it contains than because of the importance of the trans action above mentioned, is as follows : "May 9, Tuesday. Another fine day. After running until eleven o'clock we stopped to cut wood. . . . This afternoon we reached Bellevue where resides the brother of Mr. Sarpy of St. Louis, as well as the Indian Agent, or as he might be more appropriately called, the Custom House officer. Neither were at home, both away on the Platte river, about 300 miles FORT CROGHAN 71 off. . . . We landed some cargo for the establishment. . . . The store is no great affair, and yet I am told that they drive a good trade with the Indians on the Platte river, and others on this side of the Missouri. We unloaded some freight and pushed off. . . . We soon reached the post of Fort Croghan, so called after my old friend of that name with whom I hunted Raccoons on his father's plantation in Kentucky some thirty-eight years ago, and whose father and mine were well acquainted, and fought together in conjunction with Washing ton and Lafayette during the Revolutionary War, against 'Merrie England'. Here we found only a few soldiers, dra goons; their camp and officers having been forced to move across the prairie to the bluffs, five miles. After we had put out some freight for the sutler, we proceeded on until we stopped for the night a few miles above, on the same side of the river. The soldiers assured us that their parade ground and so-called barracks, had been four feet under water, and we saw fair and sufficient evidence of this. . . . We landed for the night under trees covered by muddy deposits from the great overflow of this season. I slept soundly, and have this morning, May 10, written this. "May 10, Wednesday. The morning was fine, and we were under way at daylight, but a party of dragoons, headed by a lieutenant, had left the camp four miles distant from our anchorage at the same time, and reached the shore before we proceeded far; they fired a couple of shots ahead of us, and we brought to at once. The young officer came on board, and presented a letter from his commander, Captain Burgwin, from which we found that we had to have our cargo examined. Our captain was glad of it, and so were we all ; for, finding that it would take several hours, we at once made ready to go ashore. I showed my credentials and orders from the Government, Major Mitchell of St. Louis, etc., and I was therefore imme diately settled comfortably. I desired to go to see the com manding officer, and the lieutenant very politely sent us there on horseback, guided by an old dragoon of considerable re- spectabiUty. I was mounted on a young white horse, Spanish saddle with holsters, and we proceeded across the prairie to wards the Bluffs and the camp. My guide was anxious to take a short cut, and took me across several bayous, one of which was really up to the saddle ; but we crossed that, and coming to another we found it so miry, that his horse wheeled after two or three steps, whilst I was looking at him before starting myself ; for you all well know that an old traveler is, and must be prudent. We had now to retrace our steps till we reached the very tracks that the squad sent after us in the morning had taken, and at last we reached the foot of the Bluffs, when my 72 EARLY DAYS AT COUNCIL BLUFFS guide asked me if I 'could ride at a gallop', to which not answering him, but starting at once at a round run, I neatly passed him ere his horse was well at the pace ; on we went, and in a few minutes we entered a beautiful dell or valley, and were in sight of the encampment. We reached this in a trice, and rode between two lines of pitched tents to one at the end, where I dismounted, and met Captain Burgwin, a young man brought up at West Point, with whom I was on excellent and friendly terms in less time than it has taken me to write this account of our meeting. I showed him my credentials, at which he smiled, and politely assured me that I was too well known throughout the country to need any letters. While seated in front of his tent, I heard the note of a bird new to me, and as it proceeded from a tree above our heads, I looked up and saw the first Yellow-headed Troupial that ever came across my own migrations. . . . The Captain and the doctor, Madison by name, returned with us to the boat. . . . The officers came on board and we treated them as hospitably as we could; they ate lunch with us, and are themselves almost destitute of provisions. . . . The Sioux Indians are great enemies to the Pottawattamies, and very frequently kill several of the latter in their predatory excursions against them. This kind of warfare has rendered the Pottawattamies very cowardly, which is quite a remarkable change from their previous valor and daring. . . . We left our anchorage (which means tied to the shore) at twelve o'clock, and about sunset we did pass the real Council Bluff. Here, however, the bed of the river is utterly changed, you may yet see that which is called the Old Missouri. The Bluffs stand, truly speaking, on a beautiful bank about forty feet above the waters and run off on a rich prairie, to the hills in the background to a gentle slope, that renders the whole place a fine and very remarkable spot. . . ." (See Audubon and His Journals, by Maria R. Audubon, with Zoological and Other Notes, by Elliott Coues, Volume 1, pages 477 to 482.) At the time referred to in the foregoing extracts, from the lower end (or mouth) of the then known "Hart's Cut-off"; that is from the western end of the lake formed by that change in location, the Missouri river flowed in a northwesterly and westerly course through "Cutoff Lake", shown upon recent maps, thence southerly, about as is now does, near the foot of the bluff where stands the city of Omaha except that at about the site of South Omaha it bore further west sweeping against the bluff; thence, by a broad curve, southward and easterly, and then bearing to the north and east, it passed on the FORT CROGHAN 73 eastern side of the Hardin farm and village of Council Point ; thence, through what is now "Lake Manawa", turning to the east and south, bore southwesterly beyond Trader's Point (Point aux Poulos). So, the Hardin farm and Council Point were within what was locally known later as the "Big Bend". The distance between Bellevue and Hart's Bluffs, by the course of the river, was much greater in 1843 than now. Beginning on the river bank about a mile south and west from the Hardin farm, a large marsh, with many lateral branches, extended up the river to the shore of the lake formed by Hart's Cut-Off. Its width varied from one-half to one and one-half miles, and covered nearly all of the surface, though there was exposed a high point in the angle between the river and the lake where now is ' ' East Omaha ' ' or "West End", — the name depending upon whether one is in Omaha or Council Bluffs. This was the marsh referred to in the "Omega" log. The location of the "bad sandbar" near this marsh is not deter minable; Missouri river sandbars are not stable land marks. It is probable that it was not far from Hardin's, possibly near the site of South Omaha. When the writer arrived at Council Bluffs, in 1853, the swamp still existed in diminished area and some of it may be there yet. For many years thereafter — surely up to 1870 — portions of it were known to Council Bluffs sportsmen as "Grassy Slough" and "Smith's Lake". Upon resuming her voyage above the "bad sandbar" on the morning of May 10, 1843, the "Omega" progressed finely until stopped by the dragoons at 7 : 00 A. M. Giving due consideration to the course of the river, the slow speed of the boat, it may be assumed that the landing of the ' ' Omega ' ' was at the southern bend of the river, below Hart's Cut-Off, near the then foot of the lake, about two miles from the supposed site of Hart's trading house. The distance from this point to Captain Burgwin's camp, as given by La Barge, was four miles, twice repeated, and Audubon says the troopers "had left their camp four miles distant from our anchorage at the same time" that the boat got under way. From this "Omega" landing to Casady's farm the distance would have been approximately ten miles by any route then practicable, as may be seen by examination of a sectionized map. The concurrent estimate of time elapsed between Audubon's departure from the boat and his return accompanied by Captain Burgwin and the surgeon is ' ' about two hours ' ', which would indicate 74 EARLY DAYS AT COUNCIL BLUFFS that such a distance could not have been covered by his travel to and from the military encampment, even had he not spent some time in talk with the officers and in shooting birds, and had no delay occurred by reason of being required, as Audubon says, to "retrace our steps". The distance from the point of landing, as here assumed, to the site of the encampment of Captain Burgwin in Council Bluffs, as suggested hereinbefore, would have been substantially four miles — possibly a trifle less. Audubon's description of the ride along the foot of the bluffs, and " on we went, and in a few minutes we entered a beautiful dell or valley, and were in sight of the encampment", tallies perfectly with the situation last suggested. Had they gone to the Casady farm from the point where the steamer was "summoned to land" they would have been obliged to cross the Mosquito creek, probably unbridged, and if they had done this surely Audubon, noted for attention to minute detail, would have mentioned the fact. It might be said, upon the same line of argument, that it is strange that he did not mention Indian creek, coursing through the "beautiful dell or valley" described; but, one familiar with the location there knows that he might not, in fact would not, have seen Indian creek at all. Coming from the halted steamer the course would naturally, in the condition of affairs then existing, have been along the southern margin of the lake, reaching the bluffs at or near the Mynster Spring, thence along the foot of the bluffs and into the dell, following the present Washington Avenue in Council Bluffs to the site of the en campment, without even noticing the little rivulet which Indian creek then probably was. Captain Burgwin and his troopers, according to Mr. R. S. Hardin, evacuated their cantonment because of the flood and — "stuck their tents in the hollow near where Judge Casady's house stands." The "Duck Hollow" plateau — on which stood the "Log Tabernacle" of the Mormons — logically meets this description. The conditions leading to the sending of the command of Captain Burgwin to the Pottawattamie country are referred to in the 1842 report of the Indian agent. (See Sen. Doc. No. 1, 3d Sess., 27th Cong., Vol. 1, page 387.) The agent said: "There was reason to apprehend, during the last spring, that hostilities would be commenced by the Sioux against the united FORT CROGHAN 75 band of Ottawas, Chippewas and Pottawattamies, on the Missouri, who invited the Delawares to aid in their defence. Prompt and rigorous measures were adopted to prevent this outbreak, which, if it had commenced, would have involved consequences of the most hazardous character to the com batants; would have probably embroiled neighboring tribes, and could have been arrested by the Government only at great cost. A company of dragoons was ordered by your direction to Council Bluffs, and assurances given the threatened party that they would be protected, while the Indians charged with meditating the attack were warned to abstain from it. These measures were effective, and the quiet of the frontier has been preserved. ' ' In addition to Captain Burgwin's report hereinbefore mentioned, and which no doubt formed the basis of the statement of the War Department, dated January 22, 1916, relative to the period during which "Fort Croghan" was in existence (quoted in connection with the account of the Old Blockhouse), testimony by one who was there present showing the date of abandonment is contained in Audubon's journal of the return trip of his party, made by way of the Missouri river in small boats in the months of September and October, 1843. Under October dates appear the following notes, viz. : "Wednesday, 4th. Cloudy and coldish. Left early and can't find my pocket knife, which I fear I have lost. We were stopped by wind at Cabane Bluffs, about twenty miles above Fort Croghan. . . . Windbound till night, and nothing done. "Thursday, 5th. Blew hard all night, but clear and beauti ful sunrise. Started early, but stopped by wind at eight. Bell, Harris and Squires have started off for Fort Croghan. As there was every appearance of rain we left at three and reached the fort about half past four. Found all well, and most kindly received. We were presented with some green corn and had a quantity of bread made; also bought thirteen eggs from an Indian for twenty-five cents. Honey bees are found here, and do well, but none are seen above this place. "Friday, 6th. Some rain and thunder last night. A toler able day. Breakfast at camp and left at half past eight. Our man Michaux was passed over to the officers' boat, to steer them down to Fort Leavenworth, where they are ordered, but we keep in company, and he is to cook for us at night. The whole station is broken up, and Captain Burgwin leaves in a few hours by land with the dragoons, horses, etc. . . . " 76 EARLY DAYS AT COUNCIL BLUFFS Inasmuch as Captain Burgwin stated in August that the old en campment would not be fit for reoceupancy, there is no probability that the troops returned there for encampment prior to departure. Thus ends this story of "Fort Croghan", which the writer believes to contain all attainable facts material to the history of the canton ment, as well as some of his own deductions, inferences and assump tions resting upon apparently strong circumstantial evidence when considered in connection with the conditions existing at the time when the transactions occurred. Other troops were sent to this region at various times during the occupancy of the southwestern Iowa country by the Pottawattamie Indians, but none other than those mentioned herein and in the several articles comprised in the booklet appear to have been quartered in the immediate vicinity of the site of the present city of Council Bluffs. THE MORMONS. The beginning of the history of civil government at and in the vicinity of the site of the present city of Council Bluffs dates from the arrival there of the Mormons — ' ' Church of Jesus Christ of Latter Day Saints"— on June 14, 1846. Whither they were going, that is to say, where would they fix their permanent resting place, was at that time unknown even to their leaders. They were fleeing from persecution which they had suffered for a period of years in various portions of the United States, especi ally in Ohio, Missouri and Illinois, and they had started upon a pilgrimage, seeking, like the Children of Israel of old, a New Zion or ' ' promised land ' '. There is strong proof to indicate that it was their intention, at the time of leaving the beautiful city of Nauvoo — the largest then in the State of Illinois — which they had builded at much expense, time and labor, to go beyond the jurisdiction of the Government of the United States; and there is good reason for the belief that California — then a part of Mexico — was the contemplated goal ; that they intended to effect settlement there and, eventually, to seize the territory occupied and found a government of their own. And there is evidence of no mean character to indicate that in such enterprise they were encour aged and promised aid by prominent officials of the United States Government, and that the Government itself, as represented by several cabinet officers and influential members of the Senate, if not actually a party to the undertaking, allowed it to be understood that the move ment would not meet with federal opposition or interference. It was under such conditions and with the hope that at least the advance parties would reach the Pacific coast that season that the emigrants began crossing the Mississippi river on February 5 and 6, 1846, and established their first camp on Sugar creek, opposite Nauvoo and not far from Keokuk, in the Territory of Iowa, where, on the 15th of that month, they were joined by Brigham Young and other leaders, and organization of the caravans was begun. The start from Sugar creek was made on March 1, 1846, and at about the same time the ship "Brooklyn", with a number of "Saints" and large quantities of supplies on board, sailed from New York, via Cape Horn, for San Francisco. 78 EARLY DAYS AT COUNCIL BLUFFS On March 21, 1846, near the river Chariton, the organization of the "Camps of Israel" was perfected. Near the end of April, Garden Grove (so named by them) was reached and there was established a settlement. Shortly afterward another settlement was founded at what they called Mount Pisgah; and, on June 14, the head of the column reached the Missouri river at or near the site of the present city of Council Bluffs, where another settlement was begun. These settlements were made for the purpose of affording rest for the moving trains, for the planting of crops to be cultivated and used by following parties, and similar ones were to be established and maintained along the route, as relay stations, forming a continuous line of connection from the beginning to the end of the journey, and they were called "Stakes of Zion". Within a few days after arrival at Council Bluffs ¦ Captain James Allen, with a few dragoons, visited the camp and laid before the leaders a proposition, submitted by the Government through Colonel Stephen W. Kearny, commandant of the military district with head quarters at Fort Leavenworth, for the raising by the Mormon Church of a force of from five hundred to one thousand men for service in the war with Mexico. As an inducement for compliance with the re quest it was promised that the men should be taken through to Cali fornia, where, at the expiration of the term of enlistment, they would be discharged with full pay and permitted to retain their arms and all equipment. There not being a sufficient number at Council Bluffs, Brigham Young, Heber C. Kimball and Willard Richards (of the High Council), accompanied by Captain Allen and three dragoons, visited the settlement at Mount Pisgah, and, by sending messengers to Garden Grove, secured volunteers to the number of five hundred and twenty. Within three days after the arrival of these men at Council Bluffs they were equipped, mustered into the United States service and ready to march to Fort Leavenworth, for which place they departed on July 20, 1846. "A Concise History of the Mormon Battalion in the Mexican War — 1846-1847 — by Sergeant Daniel Tyler", is the title of a work con taining much first-hand information concerning the movements of this body of troops. Incorporated in it are various other papers, one of which is "The Mormons, a Discourse delivered before the His torical Society of Pennsylvania, March 26, 1850, by Thomas L. Kane". Speaking of the raising of this battalion, he having been present at the time, Mr. Kane said : THE MORMONS 79 "They were collected a little above the Pottawattamie Agency. The hills of the 'High Prairie' crowding upon the river at this point, and overhanging it, appear of an unusual and commanding elevation. They are called the Council Bluffs ; a name given them with another meaning, but well illustrated by the picturesque congress of their high and mighty summits. To the south of them, a rich alluvial flat of considerable width follows down the Missouri, some eight miles, to where it is lost from view at a turn, which forms the site of an Indian town of Point aux Poules. ' ' Referring to the departure of the volunteers for Fort Leavenworth, many of whom were married and leaving wives and children, and the events connected therewith, the author said: "There was no sentimental leave taking. The afternoon was appropriated to a farewell ball; and a more merry dancing rout I have never seen, though the company went without re freshments, and their ball room was of the most primitive. It was the custom, whenever the larger camps rested for a few days together, to make great arbors, or boweries, as they called them, of poles and brush, and wattling, as places of shelter for their meetings of devotion or conference. In one of these where the ground had been trodden firm and hard by the worshippers of the popular Father Taylor's precinct, was gathered now the mirth and beauty of the Mormon Israel. . . . Light hearts, lithe figures and light feet, had it their own way from an early hour till after the sun had dipped behind the sharp sky-line of the Omaha hills." The precise place where these troops were mustered does not appear in any of the works which have fallen under the eye of the writer here, but in the Journal of Sergeant William Hyde, incorporated in Sergeant Tyler's History (page 128), it is said: "We were mustered into the service of the United States on the 16th of July, 1846, and marched to the Missouri river, a distance of eight miles. . . . " Reverend Henry De Long, who still resides at Council Bluffs, was with the Mormons who early arrived at that place, being then some twelve or fourteen years of age. In a letter addressed to the writer November 18, 1915, he says : "My remembrance of the raising of the Mormon Battalion is this: They had a regular city composed of wagons and tents; some four thousand inhabitants, at what is now Dodge 80 EARLY DAYS AT COUNCIL BLUFFS Orchard and J. G. Rice's place. Brigham Young's tent was the most conspicuous of them all. A flag pole sixty or eighty feet high stood in front of it. Amidst the beating of drums and martial music the men fell into line as volunteers were called for. Most of those that went were counseled by Brigham Young to go. When five hundred men were secured they marched to Trader's Point and there took a steamboat for St. Louis, about the middle of July, if I remember rightly. Among them was William Garner. ' ' This would indicate that the first rendezvous of volunteer soldiers in Western Iowa was at the identical place, upon the very same ground, as were those of later date, at the beginning of the War of the Re bellion. On the plateau on the north (right) bank of Mosquito creek, opposite the site of the Institute for the Deaf and Dumb. Mr. De Long is mistaken, however, in regard to the battalion taking passage by steamboat for St. Louis. The record shows that they marched to Trader's Point (Point aux Poules) on the day of muster, where they were outfitted, and thence, by way of Black Snake Hills (St. Joseph), to Fort Leavenworth, from which point, in conjunction with other troops, they marched and found their way, along the old "Santa Fe Trail", onward to Cabfornia, where, joined with the command of General Kearny, they assisted in the seizure of the territory now embraced in that State which resulted in its becoming a part of these United States. The raising of this battalion resulted in materially modifying the plans of the emigrants. It was believed by the leaders that, with such a reduction of their numbers, the taking away of the flower of their defensive force, it would not be prudent to undertake to cross the plains that season in the face of the numerous bands of hostile Indians ; so a semi-permanent encampment was established at Council Bluffs, then still in the possession of the Pottawattamie Indians, though they had previously negotiated and some of them had signed a treaty by which their lands were ceded to the United States. These Indians were, under the circumstances, willing that the emigrants should live among them and readily granted permission. To the end that an early resumption of their journey the following season should not be interfered with by late opening of the Missouri river, it was deemed advisable that the main body should cross the stream and, if possible, make settlement on its western (right) bank. Accordingly negotiations were begun with the Omaha Indians who THE MORMONS 81 then occupied the lands on that side. Those Indians being at war with the Sioux immediately recognized the advantage it would be to them to have so large a body of whites upon their northern border, who would serve as a buffer and protect them from the onslaughts of their enemies; therefore, permission was readily granted by them that the emigrants should occupy the territory for a period not ex ceeding two years. Because of the beauty of the site, its desirability on account of bountiful supplies of wood and water, and because of the existence there of an abandoned trading post, with stockade, in fairly good condition, "Winter Quarters" were established upon the site later occupied by the town of Florence (now embraced within the limits of the Greater Omaha), and Brigham Young and other leaders located headquarters there. In a work the title page of which is, "Route from Liverpool to Great Salt Lake City, Illustrated with Steel Engravings and Wood Cuts from Sketches made by Frederick Piercy; Edited by James Linforth. Liverpool : Published by Franklin D. Richards, 36 Islington. London: Latter Day Saints' Book Depot, 35 Jevin Street, City. MDCCCLV", on page 83, in regard to Winter Quarters, it is said: "Upwards of 1000 houses were soon built — 700 of them in about 3 months — on a pretty plateau overlooking the river, and neatly laid out with highways and by ways, and fortified with breastwork and stockade. 'It had too its place of worship, "Tabernacle of the Congregation", and various large work shops, mills and factories provided with water power.' . . . Always capricious, and in this case instigated by white men, the Indians, notwithstanding they had formally given the Saints permission to settle upon their lands, complained to the Indian Agents that they were trespassing upon them, and they were requested to remove. From this circumstance is at tributable the rise and rapid growth of Kanesville, leaving Winter Quarters again entirely to its savage inhabitants, and only ruins point to its former prosperity, and now its situation. The visit of Mr. Piercy to this place was made in 1853 or 1854, at which time it appears that practically all of the improvements made by the Mormons had been destroyed, and the site was used merely as camping grounds for the later emigration of the Saints, and a ferry had been established there. On page 81 of the book just cited it is said: 82 EARLY DAYS AT COUNCIL BLUFFS "At Kanesville I was kindly permitted to join the emi grating company, under the presidency of Elders Miller and Cooley. . . . The company being ready to move we drove down to Ferryville, or Council Bluffs Ferry, 12 miles distant, and just opposite Winter Quarters, at which point we crossed the Missouri into Indian Territory, now Nebraska and Kansas. "The ferry-boats are flat bottomed, and large enough to carry 2 wagons of ordinary size. The starting point is usually chosen a considerable distance up the stream, so that the current may assist in conveying the boats to the landing place on the opposite side of the river. . . . The camping place on the west side of the Missouri was about a mile from the landing, in the vicinity of 2 springs, near the site of Winter Quarters. I paid a visit to the old place, and found that some person had set fire to the last house that remained of the once flourishing settlement. . . . (Page 84) : "Since the organization of Nebraska Territory an effort has been made, owing to the desirable situation of Winter Quarters, and its good ferriage and water facilities, to build a city by the name of Florence upon the old site. ' ' ' The total population of Winter Quarters, at the time of the general removal thence in 1848, is not positively known; but, judging from the number of houses erected, it must have been in the neighborhood of from five to six thousand. Probably more than half of the people went with the departing train to Salt Lake City; and a majority of those remaining removed to Kanesville, while others settled at various places within the Pottawattamie country, notably at Carterville, Macedonia, Springville, in Pottawattamie County, and Cutler's Camp, Coonville (now Glenwood), and Bethlehem, in what is now Mills County, the last-mentioned place having been swept away by the Missouri river long ago. It was opposite the mouth of the Platte river. Within a few weeks after the arrival of the emigrants at the Missouri river they arranged a form of government for the contemplated en campment at that point, in regard to which the writer has a letter from the Latter Day Saints' Historian's Office, dated Salt Lake City, Utah, December 24, 1915, giving information as follows : "About the municipal government which obtained from 1846 till the creation of Pottawattamie County, the following is recorded in the Journal History of the 'Mormon Church': THE MORMONS 83 " 'July 21, 1846, a High Council was organized at Council Point, near Council Bluffs, to preside over the temporal and spiritual affairs of that camp and the other settlements organ ized since leaving Nauvoo. The following brethren were sus tained as a High Council : Isaac Morley, Geo. W. Harris, James Allred, Thos. Grover, Phineas Richards, Heman Hyde, Andrew H. Perkins, Wm. G. Perkins, Henry W. Miller, Daniel Spencer, Jonathan H. Hale, and John Murdock.' ' ' The personnel of this High Council was changed from time to time as members of the same migrated to Great Salt Lake Valley, and other men were chosen to fill the vacancies; and, after the organization of Pottawattamie County, the jurisdic tion of this High Council was confined to religious or spiritual affairs mainly. ' ' Relative to the first occupancy of any portion of what was the original town on the site of the present city of Council Bluffs, it is said, in the letter here mentioned, that: " ... in the advance company was Bishop Geo. Miller and also Henry W. Miller; the latter Miller soon afterwards settled in what some [time] afterwards became known as 'Miller's Hollow', while the other Miller crossed the river, traveled westward [ ?] and wintered among the Ponca Indians, 1846-47. "At an adjourned session of a general conference of the Church of Jesus Christ of Latter Day Saints, held in the log tabernacle, Miller's Hollow, April 8, 1848, Orson Hyde moved that 'the place hitherto known as Miller's Hollow be named Kanesville, in honor of Col. Thomas L. Kane.' " That motion was agreed to and the name Kanesville endured until after the final general exodus of the Mormons from the locality. The log tabernacle, referred to above, was erected in December, 1847, and stood on or near what is now known as Harmony Street, between Benton and Frank Streets. The residence of Henry W. Miller, from which the original name was acquired, was north of Broadway and not far from the present site of the Federal building, near Seventh Street. April 7, 1847, Brigham Young, at the head of an exploring party consisting of one hundred and forty-three picked men, embracing eight of the Twelve Apostles, set out from "Winter Quarters" in search of the "Promised Land". He returned on October 31st, having decided upon the Great Salt Lake Valley, and the site of the present 84 EARLY DAYS AT COUNCIL BLUFFS Salt Lake City, as the most desirable location, and established a colony there. During his absence difficulties arose between the Mormons and the Omaha Indians, resulting in a request by the Indian department of the Government for the abandonment of "Winter Quarters" and other places in the Omaha country then occupied by the Saints. Ac cordingly, in the spring of 1848, the great body of Mormons then in Nebraska, Brigham at the head, departed on the journey to the newly- established Zion, their train comprising six hundred wagons. Those left behind removed to various places on the Iowa side of the river, as hereinbefore stated, and "Winter Quarters", as such, ceased to exist, though it was for many years afterward used as temporary camping ground for Mormon emigrants en route to the Great Salt Lake Valley. In the meantime, however, occurred at Kanesville one of the most important events connected with the history of the church. By those familiar with that history it will be recalled that, after the death of Joseph Smith (the prophet), the then existing organization was aban doned and the affairs temporal and spiritual were vested in a council. On page 114 of the work entitled "Route from Liverpool to Great Salt Lake City", is found the following: "They returned to Winter Quarters, Council Bluffs, where they arrived on the 31st of October, and an Epistle was issued on the 23d of December, by the Twelve Apostles, noticing the principal events which had befallen the Saints since the ex pulsion from Nauvoo, and the discovery of G. S. L. Valley. It is also stated that it is in contemplation to reorganize the Church, according to the original pattern, with First Presi dency and Patriarch. Accordingly, on the 24th, the day follow ing, at a conference held at the 'Log Tabernacle' in Kanesville, State of Iowa, the suggestion was brought before the Saints who 'hailed it as an action which the state of the work at present demanded', and 'Brigham Young was nominated to be the First President of the Church, and he nominated Heber C. Kimball and Willard Richards to be his two counsellors, which nominations were seconded and carried without a dissentient voice'. The appointment was afterwards acknowledged at a General Conference on the 6th of April, 1848, at the same place at which the appointment was made. ' ' Upon the abandonment of "Winter Quarters" Kanesville became the church official headquarters for the Missouri river country. On THE MORMONS 85 page 648 of "The History of Salt Lake City and its Founders, by Edward W. Tullidge", published by authority of the organization at Salt Lake City, from which work have been gleaned many of the facts set forth herein, appears the following: "Before the return of the Pioneers to the mountains, they appointed Orson Pratt to preside over the mission in Great Britain, and to push emigration to the fullest extent, while Orson Hyde, George A. Smith and E. T. Benson were stationed at Council Bluffs to receive the emigrants from abroad, and to promote their speedy removal to the Valley, as well as the re moval of those of the community who had concentrated there after the exodus from Nauvoo." In the letter from the Latter Day Saints Historian's Office, to which reference has hereinbefore been made, it is said : " ... After the evacuation of Winter Quarters (now Florence), in 1848, nearly all of the Mormons who did not migrate to the 'Valley' that year settled in and near Potta wattamie County, with headquarters at Kanesville, and at one time there were about forty branches of the Church on that side of the Missouri river. Apostle Orson Hyde presided almost continuouly from 1848 to 1852." Upon petitions submitted by Brigham Young, the Iowa legislature provided for the temporary organization ' ' into a county, by the name of Pottawattamie", of "the country embraced within the limits of what is called the 'Pottawattamie Purchase', the act being approved February 24, 1847; and the Government of the United States es tablished a postoffice at "Miller's Hollow", to be known as "Kane", January 17, 1848, and Evan M. Greene was appointed postmaster February 7, 1848. Shortly afterward (precise date not officially shown, nor location given, ) another postoffice was established in Potta wattamie County, known as "Nebraska", as the postmaster for which Joseph T. Pendleton was named, May 30, 1849. Inasmuch as it is within the knowledge of the writer that Mr. Pendleton resided at Trader's Point; that the name of the Office is shown by official records to have been changed to Council Bluffs May 30, 1850, and to Trader's Point on December 10, 1852; that on a map published in 1851 the latter-named place was borne as Council Bluffs; that the name of Kane postoffice was changed to Council Bluffs on December 10, 1852, it would seem reasonable to believe that the postoffice of Nebraska was 86 EARLY DAYS AT COUNCIL BLUFFS located at Trader's Point. On March 11, 1850, a postoffice was estab lished at Macedonia. All of these resulted from Mormon effort. February 7, 1849, was issued the first number of the publication called the Frontier Guardian, not precisely a newspaper though in the form of one ; an organ of the Saints, published by Apostle Orson Hyde. Still, it did publish items that might be termed news, but per taining almost exclusively to church matters. Of course these char acteristics were in a measure unavoidable, even had the inclination to make them otherwise existed, because of the isolation of the community on the extreme frontier beyond the lines of ordinary communication. In one of the early issues it was said : "It affords unmeasured pleasure to see the favorable results of some limited exertions, not long since made, in favor of education. Two flourishing schools in our little town, of about eighty scholars each, conducted by a principal and assistant to each one, with many others in various parts of the country that have sprung into existence." Its issue of June 12, 1850, estimates the number of teams crossing the river during the season, up to that date, at about four thousand five hundred, with probably thirteen thousand five hundred men and about twenty-two thousand horses, mules, oxen and cows; and states that Orson Hyde 's own train would probably consist of seven hundred wagons, with two carding machines and other valuable machinery; also four thousand sheep and five thousand cattle, and added : "We have attended the organization of three hundred and fifty wagons of Salt Lake emigrants up to Saturday the 8th inst. We left them at Council Grove, twelve miles from Bethle hem, west of the Missouri river. ' ' Mr. Kane, in the paper from which quotation has been made herein before, referring to means of crossing the river, said : ' ' Our nearest ferry was that over the Missouri. Nearly op posite the Pull Point, or Point aux Poules, a trading post of the American Fur Company, and village of the Pottawatta mies. ' ' The ferry referred to by him was owned and operated by Peter A. Sarpy — "Colonel Peter A. Sarpy, by-gad, sir," — as he was wont himself to say, who was what our English friends would term the American Fur Company's "Factor" at Bellevue, nearly opposite Trader's Point, and he had established such exorbitant rates for THE MORMONS 87 ferriage that an opposition establishment was set up a short distance below, at the mouth of the Platte river below the mouth of which was its western landing. James A. Little, in his book entitled "From Kirtland to Salt Lake", to which the present writer is under obliga tions, referring to the year 1852, says : "For some reason the most of the Mormon emigration traveled the south side of the Platte. They crossed the Missouri river eighteen miles below Kanesville at an insignificant hamlet called Bethlehem." (Page 240.) Mr. Little visited Council Bluffs in 1854 and spent some days there renewing old acquaintance. In describing the place as then seen he said, among other things, that : "Through the western part of the town ran Indian (alias Lousey) creek. . . . Running along its western bank about half a mile was Greene Street, so named in honor of Mr. Evan Greene, who was one of the first residents in the locality. He was an early pioneer and the first postmaster of the place, then called Kanesville, in honor of Col. Thos. L. Kane, the philan thropist. ' ' He had his points of the compass slightly mixed as any one ac quainted with the place will readily perceive. At the time of which he wrote Indian creek scarcely touched the western part of the town. It ran through the northern part, for about the distance mentioned by him, turning to the north at the western edge of the town as it then existed, and, skirting the foot of the bluffs for a short way, lost itself in a swamp at the site of Dagger's Mill. But, this is digressing slightly from Mormon days, extending beyond the period of actual Mormon occupancy. Dagger 's Mill was erected by Madison Dagger, about 1848, originally a grist mill exclusively; but later a saw was added. Its power was derived from the waters of Indian creek poured upon an overshot wheel. The dam was at Benton street, and the water was carried in a ditch along the north bank of the original stream to the edge of the bluff under which the mill was situated. This ditch followed along the south side of the western part of Greene street, which, for that reason was called Race street (now Washington Avenue), and was no doubt the stream which Mr. Little supposed to be the creek itself. Almon W. Babbitt, an elder of the Mormon Church and a man of strong personality and combative instincts, never in very high favor 88 EARLY DAYS AT COUNCIL BLUFFS with the ruling powers, seems to have disliked Apostle Hyde 's methods of conducting the Frontier Guardian, and, therefore, in 1850, he founded an opposition publication named the Weekly Western Bugle. It was the fashion" among newspapers at that time to carry below the main head line some kind of a motto, and Brother Babbitt seems to have received inspiration for his from the well-known lines of "The Battle Field", by William Cullen Bryant: "Truth crushed to earth shall rise again, — The eternal years of God are hers; But error, wounded, writhes in pain, And dies among her worshippers". So, the motto adopted for the Bugle was, ' ' Truth, tho ' crushed, shall rise again. ' ' With the departure of Apostle Hyde for Salt Lake City, in 1852, his publication was absorbed by that of Babbitt and the title became the Weekly Western Bugle and Frontier Guardian, under which the paper continued so long as the existing advertising contracts of the Guardian remained in force, when, the name of the town having been changed, the title of the paper became Weekly Council Bluffs Bugle. By this time the concern had passed into the ownership of Joseph E. Johnson and L. 0. Littlefield, the former, an elder of the Mormon church, being editor, and the latter, a layman printer, the publisher. But this was after the almost exclusive occupancy and complete control of the town, which had existed for upward of six years, had passed from the church. No evidence has been found to indicate that newspapers or any periodical publications other than the two mentioned, were issued at Kanesville or in the vicinity during the official occupancy by the Mormons. It is believed that there were none. Although the "Stakes of Zion" — (such as Garden Grove, Mount Pisgah, and Winter Quarters) — established by the "Camps of Israel" along the line of march from Nauvoo to Great Salt Lake City were intended merely to be temporary camps, or way stations, fairly per manent improvements were made at each. Tabernacles were erected mills built, and business houses established, as indicated by the extract above made from "Route from Liverpool to Great Salt Lake City" descriptive of Winter Quarters; though that was by far the largest and most important of them all. True, no buildings were constructed of brick or stone, nor does it appear that bricks were at any of them manufactured under the direction of the church authorities ; but Rev. THE MORMONS 89 Henry De Long, who has been hereinbefore quoted, under date of March 24, 1916, has informed the writer that : "In 1849, a man by the name of Roberts started a pottery in 'Duck Hollow', what is now Harrison Street, a short distance north of the junction of Harrison and Harmony Streets. In connection with the pottery, a man whose name I have forgotten, burned a brick kiln, and these brick were used in the construc tion of the little powder magazine that stood on the hill back of the Ogden House." Inasmuch as the surrounding adjacent country was devoid of coal of any kind, the blacksmiths and other workers in metal were de pendent for fuel supplies upon the steamboats of the American Fur Company, which passed up and down the river once or twice each season, and upon charcoal manufactured in the locality, consequently there were numerous charcoal pits or kilns in and about Kanesville. When the exodus from Winter Quarters occurred, in May, 1848, the more important of the business concerns of the place removed to Great Salt Lake City, and a number of the smaller estabbshments reerossed the Missouri river and located at Kanesville and adjacent small towns. Many of these became fixtures and grew into the leading business con cerns in the early life of Council Bluffs. Mormon control in Western Iowa, especially at Kanesville, ceased in the spring of 1852, when Apostle Orson Hyde departed, bag and baggage, with all the Saints whom he could by any means induce to accompany him. 90 EARLY DAYS AT COUNCIL BLUFFS THE MORMONS 91 A STREET SCENE IN COUNCIL BLUFFS. This is a picture of the Phoenix Block, north side of Broadway at the corner of what was originally Hyde, subsequently Madison, now North First Street. It was one among the first brick business buildings erected in the city. At the extreme right is seen the weatherhoarded side of the old log store of Cornelius Voorhis, a portion of the sign being shown. The "prairie schooner" is drawn by a typical Mormon team — three yoke of oxen and one of cows. In the foreground is a calf. The emigration authorities of the Church of Latter Day Saints required that each team should comprise not less than three yoke of cattle, one of which must be cows. The owner of the team here depicted more than fulfilled the terms prescribed. It will be observed that, in addi tion to the full team, he has an additional bovine of some description on the off-side of one of the pairs in the team. The drawing from which the cut here shown was produced is from a photograph now in the possession of Mrs. L. S. Hills, of Salt Lake City, Utah, whose husband (Lewis S. Hills) was the last democratic Register of the United States Land Office at Council Bluffs, and who emigrated to Salt Lake in 1861, where he died, July 21, 1915. POTTAWATTAMIE COUNTY. Much confusion and many conflicting statements regarding the or ganization of Pottawattamie County, Iowa, are found in outstanding histories, reference to each and all of which in this work is not deemed necessary inasmuch as the purpose of its publication is to present facts pertaining almost exclusively to the immediate vicinity of the city of Council Bluffs. However, the organization of the county is intimately connected with the selection and history of its capital city, respecting which selection very little, if anything, has been heretofore published. In a "History of Pottawattamie County, Iowa, from the Earliest His toric Times to 1907", by Homer H. Field and Hon. Joseph R. Reed, I have found only two references to the organization of the county, viz. .- "Although Pottawattamie County was not organized until as late as September, 1848, its real history begins at a much earlier date." (See page 1 ; Volume 1.) On page 10 of the same work, referring to a later date, it is said : "With the end of Mormon supremacy the people began to look about to see where they were. The county, which was much larger than now, was reduced to its present size, an election was held, and A. H. Perkins, David D. Yearsly and George Coulson were elected the first Commissioners. The first clerk was James Sloan, and its first County Judge was T. Burdick, elected in 1851." ' ' The Historical Record, a Monthly Periodical, Devoted Exclusively to Historical, Biographical, Chronological and Statistical Matters", is the title of a Salt Lake City, Utah, publication, edited and published by Andrew Jensen, of the Latter Day Saints Historian's Office. On page 899 of Volume 8 of that work is found the following : "At Kanesville the people were anxious to have a postoffice established and a county organization extended over the land on which they had settled. At some meetings held in January, 1848, a petition to the legislature of Iowa was numerously signed, and Andrew H. Perkins and Henry W. Miller were chosen delegates to carry and present said petition. They attended to this business and learned that the legislature had POTTAWATTAMIE COUNTY 93 made provision for the organization whenever the judge of the 4th judicial district of Iowa should decree that the 'public good requires such organization'. They waited upon Judge Carrolton at Iowa City, who informed them that he had ap pointed a Mr. Townsend to organize said County. ' ' On page 900 of the work last cited, reference is made to the county organization, as follows : "In March (1848) a postoffice was established at Kanesville, and Brother Evan M. Greene received the appointment of postmaster. A county organization was also obtained, the county being called Pottawattamie. The officers were : Isaac Clark, judge of probate; George Coulson, Andrew H. Perkins and David D. Yearsley, county commissioners; Thomas Bur- dick, county clerk; John D. Parker, sheriff; James Sloan, dis trict clerk ; Evan M. Greene, recorder and treasurer ; Jacob G. Bigler, William Snow, Levi Bracken and Jonathan C. Wright, magistrates. ' ' Each of the foregoing extracts speaks for itself. Those referring to efforts made to secure a county organization, as well as those which mention such organization as a fact accomplished in 1848, have refer ence to a temporary organization of Pottawattamie County, pursuant to an act of the State Legislature approved February 24, 1847, which provided that: "The country embraced within the limits of what is called the Pottawattamie purchase, on the Missouri river, in this State, be, and the same may be, temporarily organized into a county, by the name of Pottawattamie, at any time when, in the opinion of the judge of the fourth judicial district, the public good may require such organization." (Laws of Iowa, 1st General As sembly of the State, Chapter lxxxiv, page 115.) Thus the county was to embrace, and when organized did embrace, all of the territory ceded to the United States by the treaty of June 5, and 17, 1846, which had theretofore been occupied by the Potta wattamie Indians. As said in the portion of this work relating to the Pottawattamies, the eastern part of the northern boundary of this territory was never delimitated. It was to extend from a point on the western boundary of the "lands of the Sac and Fox Indians" from which a west line "would strike the sources" of the Little Sioux river, which initial point was never exactly ascertained ; nor were the "sources" of the Little Sioux river ever determmed in connection 94 EARLY DAYS AT COUNCIL BLUFFS with the treaty of 1833, at Chicago, by which the Pottawattamie boundary was prescribed. Assuming, however, that the "Second Correction Line", established by the United States surveys in Iowa, approximates the "west line" prescribed by the treaty, which would, with the other lines mentioned, mark out an area of about five million acres, the quantity the Indians were to occupy, it will be seen that. beginning at the southwest corner of Iowa and proceeding eastward by tiers of counties, the Pottawattamie County authorized by the act of 1848 comprised territory within the present counties, viz. : "All of Fremont, Page, Taylor, and part of Ringgold; All of Mills, Montgomery, Adams, and part of Union ; All of Potta wattamie, and parts of Cass and Adair ; All of Harrison, Shelby, Audubon, and part of Guthrie ; Part of Monona, AU of Craw ford, and part of Carroll ; Part of Woodbury, All of Ida, and part of Sac." The area of the county was reduced to its present size and form by the legislative act approved January 15, 1851. (Laws of Iowa, Regu lar Session, 3d General Assembly, Chapter ix, pages 27-28.) By an act of January 23, 1851 (Chapter xxvi, Laws of Iowa, 3d General Assembly, Regular Session, page 56), provision was made for the selection of a county seat for Pottawattamie County, the County Commissioners being directed to designate two places to be voted for as such, and order an election for the purpose. Notices of the places for holding the election were to be posted in each township in the county and published in the "Frontier Guardian". The following is a copy of the published notice : "NOTICE OF ELECTION. "Notice is hereby given that on the first Monday, the 7th day, of April next, at the Warehouse of F. J. Wheeling, in the pre cinct of Council Bluffs, in the County of Pottawattamie, and at William H. Gooch & Brother's Warehouse, on Hyde Street, in Kanesville, in the precinct of Kanesville, in said County, an election will be held to establish the Seat of Justice of said County ; that Kanesville is one of the places to be ballotted for, for said Seat of Justice, the other is at the residence of John D. Parker, at Pleasant Grove, about eight miles above Kanesville, on the south side of Big Mosquito, and about five miles from the Indian Mill. Also to be elected, or ballotted for, at said election: one District Judge for the 6th Judicial District of the State of Iowa; one School Fund Commissioner, for said POTTAWATTAMIE COUNTY 95 County; one Supervisor of Highways, for each of said pre cincts; and as many Justices of the Peace and Constables for each of said precincts as it lacks of two of each. "Which said election is to be opened at nine o'clock in the morning and continue open until six o'clock in the afternoon of the same day. T. Burdick, Clerk of the Board of County Commissioners. "Kanesville, March 7, 1851. "N. B. — By a late Act of the Legislature, the County of Pottawattamie, as nearly as can now be determined, extends about thirteen miles north, eleven south, and twenty-eight east of Kanesville. Voters within these limits are entitled to vote for the county seat." (Frontier Guardian, March 7, 1851; page 2.) The result of the election thus provided for was reported in the Frontier Guardian of April 18, 1851 (page 2), as follows: "ELECTION ' ' The first Monday of April, inst., was the most disagreeable and stormy day that we have ever witnessed in this country. It began to rain on Sunday night, and continued to rain in cessantly until about 12 o 'clock on Monday ; then it snowed and froze severely ; and, consequently, we had a very light vote to what would have been given if the day had been fine ; yet, un favorable as the day was, quite a goodly number turned out at the election, the final result of which is officially given below. "Pottawattamie County and Precincts, or dependencies: For Judge of the Sixth Judicial District ; for James Sloan, 406 ; for Christopher P. Brown, 71 ; ' ' Fremont County : "For James Sloan, 7; for Christopher P. Brown, 91; for Burton, 2. "No returns from any other county. "E. M. Greene, Esq., was elected County Clerk without op position, in place of James Sloan, resigned. "Calvin R. Clark was elected School Fund Commissioner. "Kanesville elected Seat of Justice; only seven votes cast against it. "William Vanosdale and Jacob Degraw elected Justices of the Peace for Kanesville Precinct. "William H. Gooch and Roswell Ferry, Constables for Kanes ville Precinct. 96 EARLY DAYS AT COUNCIL BLUFFS "For Superintendent of Public Instruction: William G. Woodward, 397; Thomas H. Benton, Jr., 51; William W. Spencer, 5. " In so far as the writer of this work is informed the information rela- ' tive to the county-seat election, and election of officers mentioned, has never been recorded in any of the numerous histories of Iowa, or of Pottawattamie County, heretofore published. A discrepancy respecting the temporary organization of the county under the act of 1848 appears between the statements made in the Field and Reed History and those of the "Historical Record", above cited. The former places it in September and the latter in March, 1848. The office of the County Clerk of Pottawattamie County was destroyed by fire sometime in the "fifties", and practically all of its records went up in smoke. Inasmuch as the matter published in the "Historical Record" is based upon records kept at the time by officials of the Mormon Church, who were on the ground, it would appear that the information contained in it is the more reliable of the conflicting allegations. ¦;,;!M I iii I lliliiillllilll : ii:!il !!!! Iplj Ijj II ¦:\:>.i,i Hill lllj 1 I ! I il 11 n l; III!